Everything posted by launchingthrees
-
Minnesota Twins 2nd Round Pick RHP Ryan Eades
So you "ding ding ding" a post saying this pick is full of players that never contributed then go on to name a ton of really good players to come from that spot. ok? It's hard to tell what you're arguing at this point. I'm not gonna touch the lol analysis of naming specific players to analyze the value of a pick. If i remember correctly the pick is worth less than 4war lifetime. Taking a a safe player in the context of the 43rd pick is a laughable strategy. The only time to even consider taking a safe pick is when there is actually expected value to sacrifice by going risky.
-
Minnesota Twins 2nd Round Pick RHP Ryan Eades
The post you're responding to speaks to the opposite of your point. There is no such thing as a safe pick at 43. No 10war players are available. The best strategy is to swing for the fences when it costs you nothing.
-
Minnesota Twins 2nd Round Pick RHP Ryan Eades
The twins are never short of bottom of the rotation pitchers. This pick makes no sense to me.
-
Article: Joe Benson claimed off waivers by Rangers
I would love to see what Butera would fetch on the trade market. I think they could probably fill the pop machine, and maybe if they find a sucker thow in pizza party for the locker room.
-
Mayo's updated top 100
Sano-Power: 5/7 This guy is paid to write these?
-
Gardy Needs a Refresher Course in Lineup Construction
Maybe start a thread and plug all your articles in it? Seem over the top to start a new thread every time you write an article for a non-twinsdaily site.
-
Article: Joe Benson claimed off waivers by Rangers
Nah man the Twins have some secret player evaluation tools and no one else in the world understands them. TRUST THEM. It has NOTHING to do with his father. War, ops, woba, WRC+ can't show a man's heart.
-
Article: Joe Benson claimed off waivers by Rangers
Butera is historically awful, and has an upside of replacement level player. Using the word impact in the same sentence as Drew Butera is a travesty. I'd prefer the Twins are mocked for keeping Butera on the 40 man in every single post on every single forum.
-
Souhan: Free Agent Pitchers Not The Answer
This isn't exactly what I would do but clearly one of many strategies vastly superior to how the team is run now. I think we can disagree on the best ways to rebuild but I would be excited if the Twins had executed what you outlined here.
-
Is it time to call the Red Sox?
- BA prospect hot sheet April 12 and tyler duffey
"Trying to resist doing an analysis here" Good impulse.- Walters
Yeah because a 23 year old player without a plate appearance at AAA is the same as a 25 year old player with quite a bit of AAA experience.- Walters
Both of these are likely to happen regardless of this decision.- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
Science!- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
You also think "ERA, won-loss record and even quality starts tell you a lot more than xFIP" So yeah- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
You should work for the twin's front office. Use 2 counter examples to a 2500 player study. Brilliant.- Twins Miss Golden Opportunity to Promote Top Prospect
- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
Agreed, but the twins are long past caring about their credibility They're spending about 1/3 of their revenue on payroll this year. Expecting ownership to be competitive with other major league teams in spending/revenue is a pipe-dream. "And the teams that repeatedly draft in the top 5 picks are generally the same ones, year after year, only Tampa Bay and Washington have been able to escape from your "optimal strategy", and they still look years away from legitimately being considered World Series contenders" It's not easy to be competitive for an extended period of time with a low payroll. That being said, in 3 years the Twins, Astros, and Nationals will be at the top of their divisions due to hoarding elite prospects. http://www.grantland.com/story/_/id/9273233/hoarding-prospects-being-horrible-houston-astros- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
Reread the exchange. Yes, the career WAR value of a given pick has essentially been solved. You won't see more work on it because the study was exhaustive and the confidence interval was high. Also it's not a fangraphs original. The Baseball Analysts: Draft Picks and Expected Wins Above Replacement- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
Yeah you're right. edited. And an example?- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
I'm simply asking you to give an example with a payroll comparable to the twins. If there are other ways there should be an example.- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
So you can't name a single team? eh...St Louis has a 116m payroll this year and has kept an above average payroll for the last decade.- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
"just that the argument that you need to be terrible to acquire good young talent is false" Of course you don't "need" to be terrible to get some young talent. Could a team technically draft in the bottom half of the first round, have a 74m dollar payroll, and field a competitive team? Possibly, but it's unlikely based on quantifiable expected value. If they refuse to sign costly free-agents, don't draft in the top 5 then they will be likely be terrible forever. Washington and Tampa Bay have done it the right way. Can you name any teams over the last 10 years with below average payrolls that have won consistently without rebuilding through the top of the draft?- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
May and Meyer were acquired by trading former 1st round picks who turned into good players. Either way, this isn't subjective. It's already been solved and getting the top pick will generate about 16 more wins than the 30th pick on average. Later round picks have little value Bottoming out for 2-3 years is now more than ever the optimal strategy for rebuilding. The Changing Value of Draft Picks | FanGraphs Baseball The first pick in any given draft is insanely valuable. The next few picks are pretty great too. It falls off in a hurry, though. When Sky Andrecheck (now with the Indians, by the way) did this analysis back in 2009, he had the #1 pick producing an average of +20 WAR, but the #10 pick was just at +6 WAR, while the #30 pick was only +4 WAR, and then every pick after that leveled off pretty substantially,- First quarter over...on pace for 89 losses
You're using a list dominated by 1st round picks, and players acquired by trading 1st round picks to illustrate that you don't need high draft picks to succeed? Yeah that makes sense. - BA prospect hot sheet April 12 and tyler duffey