Everything posted by AlwaysinModeration
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
Even in this hypothetical situation where he is OPSing under 600 in June, he will still be a 25 year old with 1600 ABs of 875 OPS in the minors and 1200 ABs of 665 OPS in the majors. Maybe he won't ever get up to 875 in the majors, but my money is on the likelihood he starts posting seasonal OPS of 750+ sooner rather than later, with >800 OPS well within his reach. I wouldn't say Hicks is a late bloomer, either - he reached his full potential in his age 27 and 28 seasons, right when he should have. Buxton is still two years away from hitting his prime.
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
I am sure the Yankees will be more than happy to take him off of the Twins' hands if he posts two months of sub 600 OPS next year. It would provide some nice parallel structure. On June 12, 2015, (after starting the year -- his age 25 season -- in Rochester, through May 12), Aaron Hicks was demoted. His OPS was .599. Then the Twins traded him at the end of the year...even though he OPSed 750+ down the stretch. With the Yankees as a 26 year old in 2016 he OPSed 617. Then 864 and 833 the last two seasons.
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
Quit the depression talk...happy birthday, diehard!
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
There are any number of articles detailing how the small sample size of spring training has almost no bearing on regular season performance. I’ve said this before, but let me try one more time. Buxton is 25. He posted overall minor league numbers of OPS 850+, with over 900OPS in AAA, en route to becoming the top prospect in all of baseball. He hasn’t achieved anywhere near those heights in the majors yet. But as we’ve seen from many, many players, it can take a while for hitters to put it together against MLB pitchers. I think we can all agree that we want Buxton to become a standout player, with the bat as well as his glove. I think that the best way for him to get there is to play CF for the Twins all year in 2019 - even if he has a lousy spring training. I also think it is very useful for the front office and new manager to give him a vote of confidence that he isn’t going to be immediately demoted if he has a bad start. (Which is apparently what many of the posters on TD would be prepared to do.)
-
Article: Reviewing 2018 Breakout Prospects
Interestingly, Tyler Wells isn’t on any of their breakouts lists for 2019, either. (Go buy the handbook to find out who is). He does get a nice long article as the organization’s pitcher of the year, and as he landed that award, it does seem fitting that he isn’t really a good breakout candidate. While he would technically fit the bill (top 30 with a chance to break into the top 10), it wouldn’t really be under the radar. I also found it noteworthy that Wells dropped 60 pounds over the last couple of years.
-
Article: Now Available! 2019 Minnesota Twins Prospect Handbook
Seth, Tom and Cody— I just bought the PDF version of the handbook. Not only have I been enjoying it, I am also very glad to support you guys for all of your work on this site. The handbook is extremely well done. Congratulations, and more importantly, thank you! Two things: 1. Was there a profile of Misael Urbina? If so I think I missed it. Saw his rankings in the top 20 for two of you. 2. I won’t give away all of the “breakouts” candidates you have all selected (people should go buy the handbook to find them; they are starred in the player profiles), but I will share one of them, with this great nugget, paraphrased: A scout said that if Blaine Enlow had gone to LSU (he had committed there and would have been a sophomore now), he would have easily landed in the top 15 picks of the draft after three years (2020 draft). So by getting him to sign as a high schooler, the Twins essentially stole a first round pick.
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
One interesting aspect of this situation is that there is a presumption by everyone involved (Buxton, the front office, the fine, obtuse and hypocritical Twins Daily posters alike) that the Twins’ adding another year of Buxton service time is costing him lots of money. I don’t necessarily think that is the case for Buck. First of all, if he were arbitration eligible this year, how much would he make? I don’t know exactly, but I am guessing around $3mm. Then he could have a good year, and jump to $6 or $7mm next year, and then $10-$12mm in two years, before becoming a free agent. However, if has a strong year this year, I think it is reasonable that he could get more in arbitration next year, say $5mm. He could make $9-10 the following year, and maybe $12-$15mm in three years. (Remember, Jonathan Schoop was set to make $10mm this year). So he will likely be making higher arbitration salaries by the delay. What about his first free agent contract? Obviously, being young when you hit FA is a bonus, so getting his big payday for his age 28 season would be better than age 29. However, it seems clear he hasn’t established himself as a superstar yet. (If he were a free agent, I wonder what he’d get on the open market right now?). I think it is more likely that he establishes himself in the next four years rather than the next three. So having four more years as a Twin before his first FA contract might actually help him have enough time to become one of the best players in the game. A lot of that is speculation, but I just thought I’d point out that it’s not 100% cut and dried that losing a year of service time absolutely hurts Buxton.
-
Article: What's the Plan with Tyler Austin?
Just to explore this a bit further, I went to look up the career splits for Kepler, Buxton, Rosario, and Sano. Adding in minor league and major league ABs: Kepler vs RHP.....PA: 2722....OPS: 803....vs LHP....PA: 860...OPS: 678 Rosario vs RHP.....PA: 2974....OPS: 838....vs LHP....PA: 1203...OPS: 732 Buxton vs RHP.....PA: 1977....OPS: 792....vs LHP....PA: 697...OPS: 801 Sano vs RHP.....PA: 2760....OPS: 870....vs LHP....PA: 887...OPS: 918 Copying the other numbers as well: Austin vs RHP.....PA: 2144....OPS: 834....vs LHP....PA: 927...OPS: 811 Cron vs RHP.....PA: 2716....OPS: 790....vs LHP....PA: 1030...OPS: 833 Cave vs RHP.....PA: 2355....OPS: 815....vs LHP....PA: 836...OPS: 632 Cruz vs RHP.....PA: 4651....OPS: 835....vs LHP....PA: 1767...OPS: 927 Certainly seems like Austin should be in the OF every time a lefty is on the mound, subbing in for either Kepler or Rosario. And he should start at 1B against righties.
-
Article: What's the Plan with Tyler Austin?
For both Cron and Austin, they had K/BB numbers in the minors of about 2.5 to 1. In the majors, Cron’s rate jumped to 4:1, whereas Austin’s has jumped to 5:1. For Nelson Cruz, he had a similar rate of 2.5 or so to 1 K/BB in the minors and also in the majors. I would assume that both Austin and Cron would improve their K/BB rates over time, gravitating towards their minor league rates. On a slightly different note, Justin Bour has an OPS of 853 against righties, better than Austin, Cron, Cave and Cruz!
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
Becoming a good or very good Major League baseball player is a long process, which clearly differs from player to player. If you look at Hicks, you can see the almost linear progression of his career: play at a level, perform at a pretty mediocre level, repeat the level, perform at a high level, get promoted, perform poorly, repeat. He was moved up slowly, getting to the bigs by 23. He didn’t do well in the majors at first, as we all remember. And it took him longer to adjust in the majors than at any other level. But he now seems to have arrived, putting up the numbers that were there from his minor league track record. Buxton has not had nearly such a linear path. Yet as a top pick and a top prospect, he was promoted aggressively, getting to the show when he was 21. Even with the quick promotions, he posted an .874 OPS for his minor league career over 1600 PAs, with the most ABs at AAA posting .901. In the majors, he has accumulated 1000 PAs and OPSed .674. To me, he has earned the chance to play every day in the majors, and we should look for progress from him this year, not a finished product. He won’t OPS .874 this year, but topping .750 would be a great step towards achieving his potential. When he puts it all together with the bat, we can expect him to post seasons topping 800 OPS. Combined with his all-world defense, that is going to generate all star nods and MVP votes. He needs to be in CF all year this year. That isn’t rewarding him unjustly, that is part of the process.
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
I’d say he’s closer to Aaron Hicks. Both were five-tool athletic high school outfielders drafted by the Twins in the first round, who were high on prospect lists. In Hicks’ first four seasons in the show, age 23-26, he posted three seasons on OPS’ in the 600s, including his age 26 season with the Yankees, after the Twins gave up on him and traded him for a marginal catcher who is no longer with the organization. In the last two years, Hicks has posted 800+ OPS each year, hitting 15 and 27 home runs respectively. In his first four seasons in the bigs, from age 21-24, Buxton has posted two seasons of OPS over 700, one in the 600s, and then last year (I won’t mention). He’s also already won a gold glove / platinum glove, and generally considered he best CF in the game. He is 25 this year, with two full seasons before he hits his prime. (And the Twins have him under team control for two of his three prime years, which are generally age 27-29). Incidentally, he also has 29 consecutive stolen bases, more than halfway to the MLB record. As for anyone arguing that the Twins should pull the plug on Buxton in April, I don’t even know where to start. (Perhaps at Cooperstown at David Ortiz’ HOF induction ceremony in a few years?)
- Article: What's the Plan with Tyler Austin?
-
Buxton: "Pissed" at Twins for No Call-Up Decision in 9/2018
I don't like that he gets interviewed at a charity and says that he doesn't want to talk about the situation, and winds up doing it anyway, and saying some things that can be spun as disgruntled and will likely cause him a headache. Everyone knows that the management did a business move by not calling him up. You can squint and see their justification base on the numbers and the play, but obviously it was all about having him as a Twin in 2022 as a 28 year old instead of hitting free agency. Buxton is a super-2. He's a Twin for 2019, 2020, 2021, and now also 2022. I think he is going to play CF full-time this year, hopefully getting ABs in the top part of the line-up sooner rather than later. I think he will win another gold glove, and improve all of the pitchers' performances. And I think he is going to start hitting this year, putting up a 750+ OPS (maybe 800+) with a bunch of homers and triples. Then next off-season, I hope the FO signs him to an extension (off the top of my head, 5 years, $60million, buying out two years of FA at $20mm per year?) that puts this whole issue to bed.
-
Article: What's the Plan with Tyler Austin?
Sorry for the weird formatting. In any event, the narrative that Austin can only hit LHP is based on his MLB numbers, which is a small sample, and is incorrect when you add in his minor league stats. So, in answer to the question, what do you do about Austin, I say "keep him!" He can play 1B full-time, or DH, or even play some OF. Even if they sign Cruz, I think there is plenty of reason to keep Austin around. (And don't forget, they gave up Lynn to get him.)
-
Article: What's the Plan with Tyler Austin?
I dug through the bbref pages to pull up the platoon splits for Austin, Cron, Cave and Cruz, including their minors numbers (but not Cruz' minors; plenty to go on from his MLB resume). Here are the results, which were somewhat surprising to me: Player PA vs RHP OPS vs RHP PA vs LHP OPS vs LHP Austin 2144 .... .834 .... 927 ... .811 Cron 2716 ... .790 ... 1030 ... .833 Cave 2355 ... .815 ... 836 ... .632 Cruz 4651 ... .835 .... 1767 ... .927 So Cruz, unsurprisingly, is the best player of the four, regardless of the starting pitcher. Signing him should help the team, depending, of course, on how much he declines. Note that Cruz OPSed over 850 in two of the past three years versus right handers. The second most valuable player from that group, in my view, is Austin. He has hit RHP just as well as Nelson Cruz over his career! Cave looks like the third most valuable, with an OPS north of 800 against RHP, which is more than 70% of the ABs. Of course, as a lefty with Kepler and Rosario, he doesn't have a good path to ABs in the OF, and he doesn't hit righties better than Austin or Cruz, either. And he is terrible versus lefties. Cron looks weakest from this group. Sure, he mashes lefties, but not much more than Austin, and definitely not more than Cruz.
- Article: Rundown: Cruz, Cahill, Soria and Ramos
- Article: Standing Pat as a Strategy
- Article: Twins Sign 2B Jonathan Schoop
-
Article: Twins Sign 2B Jonathan Schoop
Another guy who seems to be a preferred option to posters here is Jed Lowrie: 262/335/414, 17.6 career WAR, 35 years old. Six seasons (majors/minors) hitting 780+, Including the last two years hitting 800 plus. He might be better than Schoop, but it’s probably a toss-up at best, going into his 35-year old season, he’s likely to start declining pretty fast. Is he the guy you want to sign to a multi-year contract? To me, Daniel Murphy is the only clear upgrade over Schoop. And 1)I’m not sure Murphy would be a regular at 2B, and 2)they could still sign him (2b/1B/DH). Of course, he’s more expensive than Schoop, and that extra money could go towards relievers, for example.
-
Article: Twins Sign 2B Jonathan Schoop
I know there is a lot of clamoring for Marwin “Mr. Versatile” González around here. Just want to do a reality check. Career stats: Schoop: 256/294/444, 11.5 career WAR, 27 years old, six seasons (minors/majors) >780 OPS González: 264/318/419, 12 career WAR, 30 years old, three seasons (minors/majors) > 780 OPS Marwin also hit over .300 two years ago...during a season he hit .343 on balls in play. Maybe I’m reading the numbers wrong, but to me, I’d rather put my chips on Schoop having a better 2019 than Gonzalez.
-
Article: Is Mitch Garver Still a Catcher?
I think the answer is yes. In the last month of a lost season after suffering a September concussion, it seems very prudent to keep him away from the tools of ignorance. But I fully expect him to be sharing catching duties with Castro this year. As for Chirinos—perhaps the front office is considering either of the current catchers in trade packages? And yes, agree that catcher’s need better protection, better helmets. There should also be very serious penalties for batters hitting catchers on their follow-through swings. It one of the reasons I think batters should have to keep two hands on the bat during their swing.
-
Article: Twins Sign 2B Jonathan Schoop
Schoop’s batting average on balls in play in 2018 was 261, down from 330 in 2017 and down from his career average of 296. And yes, when a player has a down year, it is in fact very useful to look at his career numbers. This seems like an obvious thing to say, but players usually produce closer to their career numbers than outlier years, especially those skewed by low batting average on balls in play, which is flukey, but over time generally gravitates towards .300. Finally, and again feels somewhat obvious to say, players generally post their peak numbers during their prime age, which is generally, looking at the vast majority of players, during their age 27-29 seasons. Schoop is 27. Incidentally, Cron is 29. Garver is 28. Austin is 27. Rosario is 27. Kepler is 26. Sano is 26. Polanco is 25. Buxton is 25.
-
Article: Twins Sign 2B Jonathan Schoop
Career stats: Dozier: 246/324/444, 31 years old ($9mm in 2018) Schoop: 258/294/444, 27 years old (1yr/$7.5mm for 2019) Escobar: 257/308/417, 30 years old (3yrs/$20mm for 2019-2021) Murphy: 299/344/458, 34 years old ($17.5mm in 2018) I’d rather have Schoop that Dozier for 2019. Schoop is better than Escobar, especially for his 27year season instead of three years of Escobar’s 30s. Murphy is better, and will be a lot more expensive. The big key there is whether Murphy is actually able to play second. I think he would be a fine signing for a LH bat at 1B/DH, with maybe some games at 2B.
-
Article: Twins Sign 2B Jonathan Schoop
Here are career stats: Dozier: 246/324/444, 31 years old Schoop: 258/294/444, 27 years old Schoop hits for a bit better average, Dozier gets on base a decent amount more, they have the same exact power, and Schoop is four years younger. I’ll take the guy going into his 27 year old season for a one year $7.5mm year deal, sounds good to me.
-
Article: Twins Sign 2B Jonathan Schoop
I’ll repost what I wrote yesterday or two days ago on the “Schoop, Avisail non-tendered” thread: “Looking at Schoop’s track record, he has posted four seasons in the minors and two seasons in the majors of at least 780 OPS. He had a bad year last year, but he’s still very young and looks like an excellent bounce back candidate.” Like the move. Polanco-Schoop could make a very strong hitting MI. As for his low OBP, sure, it would be nice if he was at 350+. But I kind of like a 30HR, 800OPS 2B who is aggressive.