Everything posted by Linus
-
Winter Meeting Discussions: Improving the Twins
Why do people think we can kick our garbage to the curb and have it magically replaced with something of value? Is it that we have a generation of people commenting here that have played MLB video games their whole lives and think the trade market actually works the same way?
-
MUST READ TWEET: Span Disses Twins?
I propose that we just ignore convenient comments from players about their former teams. All of that stuff is worth nothing unless you were dreaming of span playing center for the twins
- Article: The Real Brian Dozier?
-
So....May...what now?
I'm advocating for adding only pitching that is better than they have now. If we can sign Shields I will worry about the rest later. People are talking like Gibson, May and Meyer are locks. Odds are one of the three is never going to make it and one will just be ok. Given that there is nothing wrong about pursuing a pitcher that none of the three will ever equal
- Santana's Season
-
FA Pitching Targets
Very interesting observation and a weakness of TR (who I like). I remember in his first stint we had Rondell White, Tony Bautista and a couple other fill in veteran free agents who did absolutely nothing. However, when you added up their salaries, it came out to $10+ million per year which is the equivalent of a good player, especially back then.
-
So....May...what now?
I actually agree with your assessment and timeframe which is why I don't want to wait any longer. By the time the rotation is anchored with effective performances from Berrios, Stewart, etc. we are talking 2016 at the earliest and maybe 2017. That's simply too long to wait. For the record, I concur with the risk associated with such a move and believe improving the outfield defense will really help. Outfield defense can and should be improved regardless and could be cheap enough that it doesn't have to be an either / or proposition. Hell, Hicks in center and Schafer in left would save them 50 runs (I'm not advocating that, just using it as an example). The Twins will never be in a better position financially to go get a stud pitcher than they are right now. In a few years when are rising young players are arb. eligible, we won't be signing any free agents.
-
So....May...what now?
Interesting take but I am not talking about veteran mediocrity - I'm talking about somebody who will leapfrog the whole group. I am not at all interested in Johnson, Pelfrey and Milone. That means for next year we are counting on Meyer and May being effective and everyone else being healthy. The odds of both those things happening are not particularly high, which is how you end up having Kris Johnson getting 10 starts. Starting pitching is the best trade currency - if by some chance we end up with a surplus, then we can deal it.
-
So....May...what now?
When I referred to "higher levels" I was including the big league club. I have no difficulty whatsoever calling starting pitching at the higher levels weak. I am excited about Meyer and Berrios just like everyone else. I will be really excited when they are getting big league hitters out - until then, more pitching please.
-
So....May...what now?
My guess is that it would only put more pressure on them when they are already feeling the weight of the world on their shoulders, trying desperately to make it in the bigs. It seems pretty clear to me that May's initial struggles were from nerves which would only be worse if they games actually meant something.
-
External OF Options
This makes a bunch of sense. Whoever they sign needs to be a possible safety net in CF. That way, if Hicks finally makes it, this guy can play left; if Hicks doesn't make it, this guy can slide over and cover center. I hate to say it but Schafer is starting to grow on me. The fact that he could play either spot is valuable. The reason I say "hate to say it" is that he might be the most likely regression candidate of all time.
-
So....May...what now?
Doesn't change a thing for me - I still want a quality FA starter for next year. I'm done waiting around for guys to "hopefully" develop - especially considering the org is still weak in starting pitching at the highest levels. If May continues this progression next spring they can easily find a spot for him. I'm looking forward to the problem of having 6 quality starters for 5 spots (as in I'll believe it when I see it).
-
How Concerned are You?
I'm not concerned about him per se, because, in my book, he is an elite fielder on a team that desperately needs defense. He's already a strong contributor in the field and on the bases so his inconsistency with the bat is less concerning. I am a lot more worried about the rest of the roster who are generally poor in the field and inconsistent with the stick.
-
Article: "We've Got to, Otherwise We're Dead"
As I've posted in several other threads, the ability level of the roster is the determining factor in wins and losses, with everything else being periphery. I get as frustrated with Gardy as anybody (his mantra of "I want to play Santana at short" but never doing it is the latest thing to drive me nuts) but I don't believe the Twins will suddenly make a quantum leap forward from switching managers. I will say he deserves heat for his idiotic roster construction at the beginning of the year. My greatest concern about keeping him is his absolute faith in veterans at the expense of younger players who may be our future. That alone might make him the wrong person to manage us during this transition to younger players. Making changes to appeal to the fanbase is a poor way to run a franchise and should have no bearing on important decisions. Make decisions that give you the best chance to win and all the rest will take care of itself.
-
FA Pitching Targets
This is a complete non-factor - his contract isn't that much. They can just release him like they did with Marquies. With his arm troubles of the last couple years, I bet the Twins aren't even counting on him for next year.
-
Santana's Season
I am a fan of Escobar and he was solid on both sides of the ball this year. However, given the potential upside to Santana, its worth it to let him play short and see if we have something special here. Knowing Escobar is waiting in the wings if Santana fails leaves the Twins in a pretty good position for the next couple of years. I also like the idea of keeping Nunez - he swings the bat pretty well and plays acceptable defense at several different positions.
-
How long does a rebuild take?
I don't think Terry Ryan believes in the concept of a "rebuild". I've never heard him endorse the concept even conceptually. Rather, he has always stated that he is continually trying to make the team better position by position using multiple avenues (farm system, trades, waiver claims, free agency). In other words, if he believes there to be a need to improve a position, he is going to not necessarily going with a young player if he has a better option in some other fashion. I think this is what led to a lot of frustration on the part of some fans who kept clamoring for a full "rebuild" and it wasn't happening. If asked, I bet he would still say he is not in a "rebuild" rather he finally is able to find better talent from the farm system that he can't find in the other avenues.
-
FA Pitching Targets
I am firmly in the camp of, if you sign somebody, they better be quality and not another depth move. I like Shields the best because he has been so reliable. I think an understated factor in this discussion is the possible wear on Scherzer's arm - that would have me a little leary. Definitely would go hard after Lester and Shields; Santana not so much. I am not at all worried about a logjam of pitchers. If we end up with more than 5 effective starters we can trade one and what a nice problem to have. I also think Pelfrey is a non-factor. His contract is small enough they can just eat it if they have to.
-
Nice Story about Plouffe's Defense
I've never been a big believer in Plouffe but I really give him credit for getting better in all facets of the game when it looked like he might play himself out of the league. The thing I've noticed is that his throwing is so much better than it was before. If he can continue to improve (and at his age it certainly is possible) he could be a valuable commodity if / when Sano needs a spot. While he is never going to hit homers like he did for that month a couple years ago, he certainly looks like a guy who can hit close to 20 homers, a bunch of doulbles and get on base at an acceptable level.
- Article: Minnesota Twins Minor League Hitter of 2014
-
Article: Who Should Be Gone From the Coaching Staff?
I would disagree with this assertion. The information required to make this type of decision is not available to TD posters - sorry. His actual working knowledge of pitching mechanics, his ability to relate to players, ability to communicate his thoughts effectively would all be the most important factors in a decision like this. We don't know this stuff and never will. Twins Daily is great - I visit every day but let's be honest. All of the this stuff (including mine) is speculation, pure and simple.
-
Article: Who Should Be Gone From the Coaching Staff?
This. The act of firing someone is not akin to cleaning out your garage and should not be taken lightly. If he is truly deficient at his job, he should go but none of us has the information required to make that assesment. I get the whole "bottom line" argument but its not that simple. He's had horrible pitchers to work with over the last 4 years. For all we know, he might actually be really good at his job but there is only so much that coaches and managers can do. I wonder if the pitching coach in NY is getting ripped because he couldn't get the best out of Phil Hughes like the pitching coach in Minnesota?
-
Article: Could Mientkiewicz Be The Next Twins Manager?
I have several thoughts here.... Reason I don't want him here: if everyone keeps up with this "Dougie Baseball" bit I'm going to go nuts. Its old already and he is still in Ft. Myers. Reason I want him here: his wife is defintely worth a camera shot or 10. On a serious note: do we know he is any more forward thinking about sabrmetrics, etc. than Gardy? Just because he's younger doesn't necessarily mean anything. What we know for sure is that he's won but he has also really good players. My guess is that Jeff Smith is suddenly going to turn into a managerial genius the next year or so in New Britain.
-
Article: Who Should Be Gone From the Coaching Staff?
What's holdin this team back is a lack of good players. I understand the frustration and I couldn't care less if they fire them all or bring them back. I just think we all have to be realistic about how much of an impact the manager and coaches really make. I can't find much of anything to defend Gardy and Andy. I am also ready to say that you could have hand picked your manager and pitching coach at the beginning of the year and the results would essentially be the same.
-
Article: Who Should Be Gone From the Coaching Staff?
Actually, I don't believe coaching plays a "major" part. The Twins have had fundamentally sound teams and good pitching under this regime at certain points in the past. What it really shows is that the Twins just haven't had many good players lately. Fire them all if you want, just don't think coaching will take this starting rotation and turn it into gold. I'm not advocating for keeping them either but it is way more important to go get a couple of pitchers than a couple new coaches.