Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Linus

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Linus

  1. I think there are two interesting aspects to this situation (Ryan's answer not being one of them): First, Gardy apparently had more pull with personnel decisions than appeared on the surface. And when you got on the wrong side of Gardy, you tended to stay that way. Maybe he basically told the front office to get him out of here because he didn't like the attitude or whatever. Second, I don't think the Twins necessarily should get blamed because of the turnaround as that happens, pretty frequently, actually. The part that was a massive mistake was not keeping him around just in case. He wasn't taking up a 40 man spot and it would have cost them nothing to take a longer look. I actually think the real reason for all of this has nothing to do with the Twins coaching or the Pirates coaching. Rather, he had the "elbow cleanout" procedure and likely wasn't the same pitcher. When he got by that, the old movement, etc. came back. The big mystery technical change he quoted was that he was "flying open". Well, that's as basic as "keep your left arm straight" in golf.
  2. Ok, I'm going to try and be polite: he has shown nothing to deserve all the bouquets being thrown at him. Counting on guys like May, Millone, Pelfrey, Pino, et all are how you end up with AAAA starters getting a bunch of starts. Don't get me wrong: I hope the guy is lights out. I'm just saying that the failure rate for a pitcher with his pedigree is approaching 50%, and the Twins have a chance to win next year if they don't roll the dice on guys like this. If he turns out great, there will be plenty of ways to get him into the rotation.
  3. Close to zero. When Gardy had players and Maddon didn't, the shoe was completely on the other foot Don't get me wrong; I'm not defending Gardy, rather I am just clearly not proposing that Maddon as our manager holds much of a difference in win-loss record going forward.
  4. This. Sending him would have been a hail mary attempt. Would have helped if Gordon had run hard out of the box.....
  5. I believe all of these injuries can be easily explained. Its Dick Martin's fault............. (long time Twins trainer in the Kelly era and before)
  6. Big dog, c'mon - you missed the key piece, Swarzy. No irrational trade thread is complete without both Swarzy and Duensing.
  7. Wonderful. He went from bad to sub - par and you want to hand him a job next year. If he is one of the five best in spring training next year, fine. My guess is that there is 50-50 chance he never sticks in the big leagues and any good team is not going to be handing out starting jobs to guys with May's numbers, unless he proves better.
  8. If Alex Meyer had Bumgarner's control, he would have been in the majors five years ago
  9. Wow. That's crazy.
  10. Um...that's kind of the point. The quality of the players is a lot more important to manager's win - loss records than the other way around. I seem to remember the Rays losing a lot, before their minor league system starting producing a bounty of quality players, especially pitching. I would have been perfectly fine with Maddon as a manager, or not. What I care about is adding another good starter because that is going to matter a whole lot more in the short and long run.
  11. Well in this case he laid out some very straight forward observations about how critical pitching is in the overall record of a given manager, which is far less subjective to most of the "facts" posted here and elsewhere. Go ahead and ignore it and you are the one fitting facts to the story. Sorry.
  12. I think you've got your names mixed up but no matter. You would have to be blind to see anything in May's September to hand him a spot next year out of spring training unless you are OK with another flawed lineup.
  13. Well if my opinion doesn't resonate consider Reusse ' blog post. When they had good pitching Maddon's record was the same as the guy we just fired. The Maddon love is overblown.
  14. One thing being assumed here is that somehow Maddon's bona fides are without question. I think there is a very real possibility that TR wasn't nearly as impressed with Maddon as everyone on this board. My own take is this is way overblown. Take the money that would have been required to get Maddon and put it towards a free agent pitching offer.
  15. He is the secondary piece - what will get them to .500 is the Hughes level pitcher they need to add.
  16. I guess this is my point. The core isn't emerging - it has emerged, albeit without Buxton and Sano. There is nothing wrong with winning next regardless whether Buxton and Sano are there or are ever there. Go get a Hughes level pitcher and colby Rasmus and we are at .500 or better which puts us in the second wild card race most of the year.
  17. I disagree that Buxton, Sano, and Rosario have to lead the turnaround. Their offense is fine and their two main problems: starting pitching and outfield defense can be basically fixed or made acceptable with a couple key additions. It will be great when those guys get here but we don't have to wait until then for the winning to start.
  18. We just need to get better in the starting rotation and the winning can start next year. At this point, I don't care about age, I just care about ability. We've got other starters coming up to take the place of the older guys. We don't have to wait any longer if we add some pitching; we will be waiting longer if we count on Meyer and May both making it and nobody else getting hurt.
  19. This. We were 6th in runs scored and had solid infield defense. We don't have to be rebuilding anymore - we just need to add a pitcher in the 1-3 slot and an outfielder who can catch the ball and provide adequate offense. I think people are assuming a lot to think that somehow May is a lock next year or any year. There was nothing in his performance that woud indicate that; same with Milone, especially Darnell. My bet is that Meyer is the one that makes the rotation and we setting aside Milone, May and Pelfrey for spot duty. Not only do I not have a problem with this, I endorse this.
  20. Except it was hardly cutting edge. Every team (every manager) was playing Mauer that way. Most managers are very knowledgeable which is why they tend to cancel each other out, IMO. I think the biggest factor is when you get a guy that is a real jerk, then they can do some damage ala Bobby Valentine.
  21. I doubt this falls within TR area of responsibility.
  22. Don't know about the methodology but I agree with the conclusion. Managers just don't make that much difference - players do. Spend the money on a pitcher.
  23. I'm sure answering the same question for 7534th time may have had something to do with it.
  24. AS LONG AS WE DON'T SAY DOUGIE BASEBALL!!!!!!! I guess that is one of my pet peeves......
  25. Wow - the hyperbole is flying even for TD standards. The part I love best is that TR is getting blamed for stuff already - might be a new TD record. We'd be better taking the money and putting it towards the best FA starting pitcher.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.