Everything posted by Nick Nelson
-
Article: Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown
Well what exactly were you angry about? If it's the medical staff, then this article is aimed at you. If it's something else, then what? Who exactly is to blame for this repetitive pattern? To me, it seems like a few evenly distributed iffy decisions mixed with a whole lot of bad luck. I'm guessing the medical staff deserves some blame, is it the main problem? How would you know? By what standard? Who here follows another team closely enough to really make an accurate and objective baseline comparison? I really feel like a lot of people do not understand just how mysterious medicine is. Injuries and illnesses get misdiagnosed all the time, in sports and in life. Someone above cited the example of Morneau playing through an injury back in 2009... do you realize how common that is? Players hide injuries because they want to play. Managers defer too quickly because that's how clubhouses are run. Much of this stuff is just baseball, and has nothing to do with the team doctors. It's a complicated issue and, to me, a low priority. I feel like we should be focused a lot more on figuring out how to put together a decent roster than complaining about an injured player tying up a meaningless roster spot for a last-place team. Injuries are just part of the game, and they're rarely a tidy affair.
-
Article: Twins Promote Eduardo Escobar and Luis Perdomo as September Callups
Did I miss something here? He may be referring to the fact that Guerra will be out of options next year, although it seems like a rather ridiculous conclusion. There's a very good chance Guerra will break camp with the Twins next spring, which makes it all the more bizarre that they don't want to take a look at him now.
-
Article: Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown
Pretty sure my stance was directly in the middle of those two extremes. I'm not pinning anyone in any corner, I'm responding to the (very real) reaction I saw after the Span news dropped last week. I'm not responding to the frustration over funky injury situations – that's well warranted. I'm frustrated with them too. What I'm responding to is the tendency to immediately blame the medical staff in every situation that pops up without considering the number of variables in play. I see people calling for the entire medical staff to be cleared out... do those people really believe that every single doctor, trainer and med tech under the organization's employ is incompetent? Seems pretty far-fetched. This is a complicated issue and the kind of blanket critiques often being thrown out there simply don't fit.
-
Article: Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown
This is a common gripe, but I would suggest that it's less unusual than you think. Elbow injuries are extraordinarily common across the league and surgery is always considered a last resort. Most teams will prescribe rest & rehab before TJ, not just the Twins. Please elaborate, keeping in mind the points mentioned above.
-
Article: Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown
You can view the page at http://www.twinsdaily.com/content.php?999-Outrage-Over-Medical-Staff-is-Overblown
-
Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown
- Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown
[ATTACH=CONFIG]2229[/ATTACH]Last week, Denard Span finally landed on the disabled list one day before rosters expanded and 18 days after initially suffering a shoulder injury back in early August. Not the medical staff's finest hour, probably, but the uproar I saw amongst casual fans and hardcores alike sort of left me dumbfounded. My Twitter timeline exploded with rants against the team doctors. Commenters here at Twins Daily vented in similar fashion. Clearly folks are fed up with the strange injury situations that continue to arise with this club. That's understandable. Still, I'm wondering if we haven't reached a point where people are jumping the gun a bit to crucify the medical staff for every mishap. Here's a fact: medicine is an inexact science. Here's another: the members of the Twins' medical staff are highly trained experts who have reached an elite level in their profession. Most of them have been around for more than the past two years, yet the implication seems to be that since the start of 2011 they've just forgotten how to properly diagnose injuries. The truth is that this staff made mistakes before 2011 – as does every other staff in the league – and they went largely unnoticed because the Twins weren't one of the worst teams in baseball. My sense is that the higher incidence of injuries in the past two years and the club's struggles overall are causing a lot of people to exaggerate the role of the medical staff in lingering ailments and goofy DL management. It wouldn't be a unique case. As an example, let's look at this latest situation with Span. The fact that it took the doctors so long to properly diagnose his sprained sternoclavicular joint is concerning, but the outfielder didn't make their jobs easier by backing out of an MRI due to claustrophobia. Additionally, we simply don't know whether the Twins would have shown the same patience and deference to Span if the games actually mattered and they were legitimately hurting themselves by tying up that 25th roster spot. They weren't. Sure, there have been examples where the team's medical staff has pretty clearly erred. Those extend back past 2011. Like I said, it's an inexact science. But frustration seems to have some people believing that we're dealing with a bunch of quacks who have completely lost the ability to competently do their jobs, all while the numerous execs running the organization have failed to notice or care. Pretty ridiculous notion born out of a scapegoat mentality, if you ask me. To be clear, I'm not saying that the Twins' medical staff compares well to the rest of the league. They might even be among the worst. But I don't believe we have the evidence to make that assessment. Judging a doctor's performance isn't like judging a pitcher, or hitter, or manager, or GM. Each situation is unique and there are lot more factors in play than some would assume. Maybe after this season ends the front office will clear out the entire medical staff and bring in new faces across the board. I'd say that's unlikely, and I doubt it would meaningfully resolve any of the real problems plaguing this organization.- Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown
Last week, Denard Span finally landed on the disabled list one day before rosters expanded and 18 days after initially suffering a shoulder injury back in early August. Not the medical staff's finest hour, probably, but the uproar I saw amongst casual fans and hardcores alike sort of left me dumbfounded. [PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] My Twitter timeline exploded with rants against the team doctors. Commenters here at Twins Daily vented in similar fashion. Clearly folks are fed up with the strange injury situations that continue to arise with this club. That's understandable. Still, I'm wondering if we haven't reached a point where people are jumping the gun a bit to crucify the medical staff for every mishap. Here's a fact: medicine is an inexact science. Here's another: the members of the Twins' medical staff are highly trained experts who have reached an elite level in their profession. Most of them have been around for more than the past two years, yet the implication seems to be that since the start of 2011 they've just forgotten how to properly diagnose injuries. The truth is that this staff made mistakes before 2011 – as does every other staff in the league – and they went largely unnoticed because the Twins weren't one of the worst teams in baseball. My sense is that the higher incidence of injuries in the past two years and the club's struggles overall are causing a lot of people to exaggerate the role of the medical staff in lingering ailments and goofy DL management. It wouldn't be a unique case. As an example, let's look at this latest situation with Span. The fact that it took the doctors so long to properly diagnose his sprained sternoclavicular joint is concerning, but the outfielder didn't make their jobs easier by backing out of an MRI due to claustrophobia. Additionally, we simply don't know whether the Twins would have shown the same patience and deference to Span if the games actually mattered and they were legitimately hurting themselves by tying up that 25th roster spot. They weren't. Sure, there have been examples where the team's medical staff has pretty clearly erred. Those extend back past 2011. Like I said, it's an inexact science. But frustration seems to have some people believing that we're dealing with a bunch of quacks who have completely lost the ability to competently do their jobs, all while the numerous execs running the organization have failed to notice or care. Pretty ridiculous notion born out of a scapegoat mentality, if you ask me. To be clear, I'm not saying that the Twins' medical staff compares well to the rest of the league. They might even be among the worst. But I don't believe we have the evidence to make that assessment. Judging a doctor's performance isn't like judging a pitcher, or hitter, or manager, or GM. Each situation is unique and there are lot more factors in play than some would assume. Maybe after this season ends the front office will clear out the entire medical staff and bring in new faces across the board. I'd say that's unlikely, and I doubt it would meaningfully resolve any of the real problems plaguing this organization.- Article: What has happened to Joe Mauer's defense?
Because of the widely held definition provided on this very thread?- Article: What has happened to Joe Mauer's defense?
I don't really consider myself a "stat-head" by any definition of the term. I use stats to support my opinions, not as the basis for them. (I mean, come on, I was railing against WAR on another thread just yesterday.) I simply take exception to the whole "looks at box scores, doesn't watch the games, has never played baseball" mantra. I know plenty of fellow analysts who would be deemed "stat-heads" and the majority of them have played baseball before, watch tons of games and understand the intangible nuances of the sport. It's a vastly inaccurate stereotype.- Article: What has happened to Joe Mauer's defense?
I would call it an uninformed generalization, but either way.- Article: Minor signings make impact
Yes. No one is allowed to talk about anything positive. Nothing good matters.- Tommy John for Lester Oliveros?
Wasn't funny any of the last 18,742 times somebody's used that line. Isn't funny now. Intentional or not, that is pretty funny.- Span to DL after game
How much is it really going to matter in the long run? Parmelee is going to get plenty of at-bats here in the final weeks and he'll be ready to go at the outset of the 2013 season. The Twins' medical staff has had some annoying moments, but I think this situation is being overblown. We're talking about the 25th roster spot on a last-place team.- Mackey's notebook: Throwing Out Baserunners
Mauer has had some recurring shoulder issues that have largely been brushed under the rug. I wouldn't be surprised if that's a contributing factor.- Article: Mauer's Not Going Anywhere
Let me ask you this: do you trust UZR in partial-season samples? If you do, you're not using it right. If not, what reason is there to trust fWAR – a metric heavily influenced by UZR – in partial season samples? Also, focusing on any numbers he's posting this season overlooks the realities of his situation that are going to weigh heavily on any general manager's mind, namely the significant durability issues. Also, does the fact that Mauer will catch only ~75 games this year have more to do with the fact that the Twins are out of contention, or the fact that the last time he caught 100-plus games he broke down? I don't think you can say one or the other with confidence.- Article: Mauer's Not Going Anywhere
Do you seriously believe there's a bunch of GMs out there that are judging Mauer solely on the basis of his WAR? Sorry to break it to you, but I doubt that particular metric weighs very heavily on the minds of many front office execs. People using WAR in this sense, as a be-all end-all dictator of a player's value, is what's given it such a bad rep. It's a fun and sometimes telling little theoretical stat, nothing more. If you are determined to use WAR as the sole basis for your argument, though, why are we comparing Mauer to the 15 highest paid players in the game? That's irrelevant. A GM looking to improve his club would ask himself how Mauer stacks up against the entire league; he'd likely ask himself whether a guy who ranks 27th among MLB hitters in WHIP (in a good year) is worth being one of the four highest paid.- Article: Mauer's Not Going Anywhere
You can view the page at http://www.twinsdaily.com/content.php?985-Mauer-s-Not-Going-Anywhere- Mauer's Not Going Anywhere
Ask yourself this question, and be honest in your reply: If Joe Mauer were becoming a free agent this offseason, is there any chance – ANY chance, whatsoever – that he would fetch a six-year, $138 million contract? I think the answer is pretty clearly no.[PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] That's the prorated remaining portion of the eight-year contract Mauer signed with the Twins after a 2009 season in which he was arguably baseball's best player. He was 26, he was one of the game's most popular players and he was as healthy as he'd ever been. That was then, and this is now. In three seasons since, Mauer has hit .311/.393/.429 – impressive numbers but nowhere near the otherworldly stats he compiled in his MVP campaign. He has been besieged by injuries, missing a quarter of his team's games. And as he prepares to enter his 30s, he has already begun to transition away from catcher. Mauer is a great player and a tremendous asset. But any way you slice it, his value has declined pretty sharply over the past three seasons, which is largely a testament to how insanely high it was at the time he re-upped with the Twins. My point in all this is to say that no baseball team is going to give up quality prospects for the right to absorb Mauer's enormous and substantially risky contract. For all the hubbub about the catcher being put through waivers earlier this week – an extremely routine and procedural move that probably shouldn't have been reported in such provocative terms – the truth is that Terry Ryan would have been a fool not to expose Mauer to the league. He said as much himself. If some team were to go crazy like the Dodgers and offer up good young players to take on more than $100 million in salary commitments (extraordinarily unlikely since that bonanza was basically unprecedented), shouldn't the Twins at least hear them out? There is no downside to testing the waters, and certainly no player should be considered flat-out untradable by anyone when it comes to a rebuilding team. As you'd expect, Ryan got no bites. Because no team is in position to do what Los Angeles did. Had that wacky trade not gone down so recently, this "story" would have been a passing note rather than a daylong talking point. Mauer's oversized contract and full no-trade clause make it extremely improbable that he'll be moved, now or in the future. I mean extremely improbable – like Jim Carrey so-you're-telling-me-there's-a-chance improbable. It might be fun to daydream about what kind of impact such an outlandish move might have, but at the end of the day such thoughts are nothing more.- Mauer's Not Going Anywhere
- Mauer's Not Going Anywhere
[ATTACH=CONFIG]2196[/ATTACH]Ask yourself this question, and be honest in your reply: If Joe Mauer were becoming a free agent this offseason, is there any chance – ANY chance, whatsoever – that he would fetch a six-year, $138 million contract? I think the answer is pretty clearly no. That's the prorated remaining portion of the eight-year contract Mauer signed with the Twins after a 2009 season in which he was arguably baseball's best player. He was 26, he was one of the game's most popular players and he was as healthy as he'd ever been. That was then, and this is now. In three seasons since, Mauer has hit .311/.393/.429 – impressive numbers but nowhere near the otherworldly stats he compiled in his MVP campaign. He has been besieged by injuries, missing a quarter of his team's games. And as he prepares to enter his 30s, he has already begun to transition away from catcher. Mauer is a great player and a tremendous asset. But any way you slice it, his value has declined pretty sharply over the past three seasons, which is largely a testament to how insanely high it was at the time he re-upped with the Twins. My point in all this is to say that no baseball team is going to give up quality prospects for the right to absorb Mauer's enormous and substantially risky contract. For all the hubbub about the catcher being put through waivers earlier this week – an extremely routine and procedural move that probably shouldn't have been reported in such provocative terms – the truth is that Terry Ryan would have been a fool not to expose Mauer to the league. He said as much himself. If some team were to go crazy like the Dodgers and offer up good young players to take on more than $100 million in salary commitments (extraordinarily unlikely since that bonanza was basically unprecedented), shouldn't the Twins at least hear them out? There is no downside to testing the waters, and certainly no player should be considered flat-out untradable by anyone when it comes to a rebuilding team. As you'd expect, Ryan got no bites. Because no team is in position to do what Los Angeles did. Had that wacky trade not gone down so recently, this "story" would have been a passing note rather than a daylong talking point. Mauer's oversized contract and full no-trade clause make it extremely improbable that he'll be moved, now or in the future. I mean extremely improbable – like Jim Carrey so-you're-telling-me-there's-a-chance improbable. It might be fun to daydream about what kind of impact such an outlandish move might have, but at the end of the day such thoughts are nothing more.- Article: Beacons of Light
Did you miss the part where he indicted himself and took the blame? I don't think even he would disagree with your assessments of his actions (or lack thereof) within "all markets" up to this point, but that doesn't mean he can't get better. Last offseason he was guilty of being too confident in what he had. He won't make that same mistake again this winter.- Article: Back of the Napkin: How Far Are The 2013 Twins From Contention?
Blackburn over the past two years averaged 150 innings with a 4.98 ERA and 1.52 WHIP while being affected by injuries (which were, in both cases, purportedly corrected after the season). Certainly not good numbers, but borderline palatable for a fifth starter and far better than the muck we've seen this year. When you take into account how sharp he looked in spring training, I think it's pretty tough to make the case that anyone truly should have expected him to be anywhere near as bad as he's been.- Mauer placed on waivers
The basic fact of the matter is that if the Twins want an extra $23 million to spend on other things, they need to just spend it. There's no excuse for trading away their best player for nothing (and believe me, if they found a taker willing to absorb his entire contract, they'd get nothing in return) because they're unwilling to push payroll to $120M to get the players they feel they need to contend.- Article: Beacons of Light
You can view the page at http://www.twinsdaily.com/content.php?975-Beacons-of-Light - Outrage Over Medical Staff is Overblown