Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Nick Nelson

Administrator
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Nick Nelson

  1. You think you need to tell me, of all people, that the Twins' decision-makers are not infallible? They miss the mark, plenty often. And I call them on those mistakes, probably more so than any other writer on this site. But they are also not clueless morons. If they've kept Butera around for this long, and waived several players from the 40-man roster ahead of him, and are paying him $700K to play in the minors right now, then clearly they recognize an enduring value in his presence. Who am I as an outsider to authoritatively call them idiots? I personally do believe they overvalue Butera and I wish they'd move on, but I'm not unwilling to try and see things from their perspective and I guess that's where I differ. I try to remain objective and there's no objectivity here when it comes to the topic of Butera. He's an absolutely dreadful hitter and because of that people choose not to bother trying to understand what sort of positives he might actually bring to the table. No shock that we once again see him being tied to every one of the organization's problems... I'm sure since some international scout and/or Bill Smith once screwed up on Nishioka it means Ryan and Gardenhire have no clue what they're doing in assessing the necessity of a single defensive-minded catcher on the 40-man roster. Totally related situations. Anyway, I'm bowing out of this conversation. I'm tired of being put in the position of defending a player I don't even like. By all means, keep on with the ridiculous ranting over a guy who currently has absolutely nothing to do with this team's problems.
  2. Wonder if this is the same calf issue that was nagging at Plouffe in spring training. If so, that's pretty worrisome. Really bad timing. Offense could use a jolt and June has been the month where Plouffe has exploded the last two years.
  3. So your argument is that the Twins, a major-league baseball organization filled with professional talent evaluators, have a view on Butera that amounts to "Hey, this guy's a historically bad hitter so he must be a really great defender!" And that's the reason they've kept him around for the last three years and paid him $700K in arb this year. This is the reason I can't take a lot of these anti-Butera tirades seriously. No basis in reality.
  4. What I'm saying is that catcher defense is often one of those things better evaluated by the people on the field. There are many nuances to the position that can't be quantified. I certainly haven't seen anything substantive to convince me that he's not a plus defensive catcher, and I don't think there's anything objective about choosing SSS stats and presenting them as evidence of his decline. Joe Mauer's CS% was 14% last year, he must have the worst arm in league history, right? Could someone explain to me why Butera, who's been reputed as a top-notch defensive backstop throughout his career, would suddenly undergo a major decline in his late 20s? Has he been hurt? Is there anything to back up this viewpoint other than a couple insignificant statistics?
  5. I think people have generally been doing a good job of not only linking to their writing but also including some additional thoughts/comments to spark a conversation about a relevant topic. In this respect, it's not really different from any other thread starter. You certainly don't have to follow their blog links.
  6. They may be. But when you're basing your argument on his CS% and passed ball numbers compiled in a limited sample size while working with a preposterously bad pitching staff, perhaps we can acknowledge that they may have better insight on the matter? That's not meant as a dig, but the fact is that there really aren't any great metrics for evaluating catcher defense, especially when we're talking about a sample of 135 total games over the last two years.
  7. The fact that he's managed to rack up enough service time over the past three years to hit arbitration despite a sub-.500 OPS is a pretty good indicator. The whole notion that the people running the Twins are completely clueless morons isn't an especially compelling explanation to me. Obviously they recognize that he can't hit, but value other aspects of his game enough to keep him around and pay him $700K in Triple-A. Butera is not a good player and at times he's been way overexposed, no question about that. I just wish people would keep an open mind and make an effort to at least recognize the guy's strengths while doling out (very justifiable) criticism.
  8. I know people seem to think that premium defensive catchers who can't hit grow on trees, but the Twins don't share that opinion. They need to have someone around who can come up and hold things together behind the plate if Mauer or Doumit goes down. They apparently reached the conclusion that it will be more difficult to find that type of player in a pinch than a backup center fielder. They're probably correct. I don't think that's safe to say at all. Butera will be the first one called up if there's an injury to a catcher. Benson was undoubtedly behind several others in line for a call-up even as an injury replacement. He wasn't going to be around after this year.
  9. I think his point was that, like Kubel, Parmelee lacks footspeed but makes up for it with good routes and defensive fundamentals. I should follow up my previous question about whether it's wise to keep Parmelee up as a part-time player with the flip side of the argument: if they don't option him all year and his play doesn't drastically improve, they'll have the chance to start him back in Triple-A next season. He'd be a nice guy to have around as insurance behind Arcia et al.
  10. I would agree that he's been better than expected. He looks like an average defensive right fielder, which is impressive for a first baseman playing the outfield. But by no means is he a defensive asset. Still waiting for him to work out of the slump he's been in for the past two seasons... Do you think they should keep him around all year even if he continues to play only ~50% of the time? I don't see that as being positive for his development. As I recall, Doumit hit a pretty crucial two-run homer in the game, his fourth this month. Parmelee, meanwhile, is hitting .206 in May. At the end of the day, Gardenhire is interested in trying to win games and I can't blame him for that.
  11. You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1794-For-Parmelee-the-Clock-is-Ticking
  12. [ATTACH=CONFIG]4205[/ATTACH]Chris Parmelee offered Minnesota Twins fans a glimpse of his offensive ability on Monday in Milwaukee, when he launched a majestic, 420-foot home run to center field. Unfortunately, those glimpses have been entirely too rare for the 25-year-old. The solo shot was just his fourth homer – and seventh extra-base hit – of the season, leaving him with a .215/.293/.331 hitting line. That’s miserable production for a plodding right fielder whose value is tied almost entirely to his bat, and when combined with his similarly ugly .229/.290/.380 mark with the Twins last season, it paints a grim picture regarding Parmelee’s ability to hit major-league pitching. The Twins keep giving their former first-round pick chances to dig his way out, but Parmelee’s time to prove that he’s got more to offer may be running short, at least here in Minnesota. Surely this is a situation where the Twins would prefer to exercise patience. They have plenty invested in Parmelee, whose career minor-league track record suggests that he should ultimately be a competent hitter in the majors (maybe more if his small-sample Triple-A numbers are to be believed). Even though he has tripped over himself in two extended MLB chances now, he remains relatively young and inexperienced. But the window to make an evaluation may be shrinking. Parmelee was added to the 40-man roster following the 2010 season, so the Twins have already used up two of his three options (2011 and 2012). They haven’t used one this year, since he made the big-league roster out of spring training, but it’s hard to imagine he will stick much longer if his offense doesn’t pick up. With an OPS+ of 70 – third-worst on the team ahead of only Brian Dozier and Aaron Hicks, who both at least provide meaningful defensive value – Parmelee has been beyond brutal. Even a rebuilding team in a lost season can’t justify trotting that production out regularly, and if his playing time continues to wane (he’s started only 10 of the team’s last 20 games) it makes little sense to keep him on the roster. If he’s sent down, Parmelee will suddenly be headed toward a tough spot next spring. The Twins have numerous candidates to fill their outfield and probably would have some interest in retaining Justin Morneau if the cost isn’t exorbitant, so barring a turnaround in performance, Parmelee could be squeezed out. That’s not an ideal outcome for him or the Twins, who would enjoy having a usable inexpensive piece that they can plug in for a few years. I'm not quit ready to give up on Parmelee but his plate approach has been mostly ugly and, as his performance continues to deteriorate rather than improve, it seems like major-league pitchers are gradually figuring him out rather than the other way around. It's not time to cut bait yet, but he has already relegated himself to part-time duty and with Oswaldo Arcia lurking in the minors, his place on the roster is very much in danger. Should he find himself bumped to Triple-A, he'll have an uphill climb ahead of him in order to remain in this organization long-term.
  13. Chris Parmelee offered Minnesota Twins fans a glimpse of his offensive ability on Monday in Milwaukee, when he launched a majestic, 420-foot home run to center field. Unfortunately, those glimpses have been entirely too rare for the 25-year-old. The solo shot was just his fourth homer – and seventh extra-base hit – of the season, leaving him with a .215/.293/.331 hitting line.[PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] That’s miserable production for a plodding right fielder whose value is tied almost entirely to his bat, and when combined with his similarly ugly .229/.290/.380 mark with the Twins last season, it paints a grim picture regarding Parmelee’s ability to hit major-league pitching. The Twins keep giving their former first-round pick chances to dig his way out, but Parmelee’s time to prove that he’s got more to offer may be running short, at least here in Minnesota. Surely this is a situation where the Twins would prefer to exercise patience. They have plenty invested in Parmelee, whose career minor-league track record suggests that he should ultimately be a competent hitter in the majors (maybe more if his small-sample Triple-A numbers are to be believed). Even though he has tripped over himself in two extended MLB chances now, he remains relatively young and inexperienced. But the window to make an evaluation may be shrinking. Parmelee was added to the 40-man roster following the 2010 season, so the Twins have already used up two of his three options (2011 and 2012). They haven’t used one this year, since he made the big-league roster out of spring training, but it’s hard to imagine he will stick much longer if his offense doesn’t pick up. With an OPS+ of 70 – third-worst on the team ahead of only Brian Dozier and Aaron Hicks, who both at least provide meaningful defensive value – Parmelee has been beyond brutal. Even a rebuilding team in a lost season can’t justify trotting that production out regularly, and if his playing time continues to wane (he’s started only 10 of the team’s last 20 games) it makes little sense to keep him on the roster. If he’s sent down, Parmelee will suddenly be headed toward a tough spot next spring. The Twins have numerous candidates to fill their outfield and probably would have some interest in retaining Justin Morneau if the cost isn’t exorbitant, so barring a turnaround in performance, Parmelee could be squeezed out. That’s not an ideal outcome for him or the Twins, who would enjoy having a usable inexpensive piece that they can plug in for a few years. I'm not quit ready to give up on Parmelee but his plate approach has been mostly ugly and, as his results continue to deteriorate rather than improve, it seems like major-league pitchers are gradually figuring him out rather than the other way around. It's not time to cut bait yet, but he has already relegated himself to part-time duty and with Oswaldo Arcia lurking in the minors, his place on the roster is very much in danger. Should he find himself bumped to Triple-A, he'll have an uphill climb ahead of him in order to remain in this organization long-term.
  14. As opposed to center fielders who hit .187/.261/.297... in Triple-A. I understand that we all think Butera is disposable, fungible and easily replaced. You're misinterpreting if you think I'm disagreeing with that standpoint or defending the guy. The Twins, clearly, do not feel the same way. As they might not have one single quality defensive catcher in the entire organization outside of Mauer, they feel it's important to dedicate one of their 40 roster spots to keeping Butera around. From what I've heard, it seems likely he would be claimed fairly quickly if he went on waivers so there's a good chance they are not alone in valuing him to some extent. I may not agree but I've come to accept it. I wish others would do the same. Anti-Butera opinions are not wrong or meaningless, they just don't need to be regurgitated ad nauseum every single time the Twins make a 40-man roster decision. Especially when the guy who was dropped had far less chance of making any kind of impact for the big-league club.
  15. Considering that 20 teams just passed on the opportunity to add Benson for free, I doubt many would find him an appealing trade chip. How much was he really going to improve his numbers in two months, especially considering that he's demonstrated no ability whatsoever to hit high-level pitching? Again, for all this talk but his "talent" Benson has hit .199 with a 98/24 K/BB ratio between Triple-A and the majors, and he's about to be 26 and out of options in an organization with a loaded OF pipeline. He wouldn't have been my first choice to jettison but I'm truly baffled by all the fuss this is raising. FWIW, Jim Mandelaro, who covers the Red Wings for the Rochester Democrat and Chronicle, is fully on board with the decision.
  16. That very well may be true, but it's not necessarily something that goes away, especially within the time frame that the Twins need to make a decision on him. Seriously, take a look at the history of guys who have had microfracture knee surgery, it's not pretty. Grady Sizemore is a high-profile example. You seem fixated on the player he was prior to 2012. There's no evidence that player still exists. Benson has shown no ability to hit above Triple-A, and has only continued to deteriorate in Rochester. He was striking out in one out of every three trips to the dish. Brutal. The Twins had to be at the point where they were considering sending him down to New Britain, again. At that point, knowing he's out of options the next spring, is it really that big a deal to just cut him loose and wish him the best? I get that nobody likes Butera, but at some point we all just need to accept that the people running the team place a value on his presence, and it just is what it is. I am so bored with every single thread of discussion turning into a Butera bash fest. The guy can't even be stashed away in the minors without constantly becoming the focus of blame for every single one of the organization's ills.
  17. I wouldn't worry too much about it. One way or another, Morneau isn't going to bring in anything spectacular at the deadline. If he heats up, maybe you can flip him for a decent prospect; if not, you hold him and reevaluate at the end of the year. If Parmelee continues to show very little the rest of the way, I'd have no problem with extending the qualifying offer to Morneau, presuming he stays healthy.
  18. You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=1787-Three-Bagger-Worley-Correia-Florimon
  19. * Vance Worley made his first start for Class-AAA Rochester on Monday after being demoted last week. Facing Lehigh Valley, the Triple-A affiliate for his former organization, Worley delivered a five-hit shutout. Before we go making proclamations about the Twins' Opening Day starter's ills being miraculously cured, it bears noting that his peripherals were less than stellar; he threw only 74 of 119 pitches for strikes and issued four walks against four strikeouts. Really, the biggest change was that balls put into play were turning into outs rather than hits, which tends to happen against minor-league competition. Nevertheless, the shutdown effort undoubtedly provided some much-needed confidence for Worley, who has been battling through the most tumultuous stretch of his professional career. Hopefully he can continue to build on this success and work his way back up quickly. * The acquisition of Worley is one of many offseason decisions that haven't worked out especially well for the Twins thus far, but we also should recognize that a few of the team's moves have indeed paid dividends. One such example is the signing of Kevin Correia, who picked up his fifth win on Monday by holding the Brewers to three runs over six innings. [ATTACH=CONFIG]4189[/ATTACH] The Correia contract was widely panned when it was inked in December, and I was as vocal as anyone in my criticism. The right-hander brought over a poor track record from the National League and Terry Ryan's proclamations about Correia being "better than the numbers" were met with great skepticism given this club's past efforts in the free agent pitching arena. We're not quite a third of the way through the season yet, but to Ryan's credit, Correia has up to this point been as advertised (by the Twins, not the numbers). He's striking out fewer hitters than ever before -- unsurprising for a 32-year-old lifelong NL guy coming over to the Junior Circuit -- but still he's been the lone bright spot in an otherwise disastrous rotation, with a 3.96 ERA and 1.30 WHIP. On a staff whose members have frequently struggled to get through even five innings, Correia has completed six or more in seven of his 10 starts. Many of the veteran's past trends have remained constant but the biggest difference for him in a Twins uniform has been markedly improved control. He had previously averaged 3.4 walks per nine innings in his career, but this season he's handed out just 10 free passes in 63 2/3 innings for a 1.4 BB/9 rate. The Rick Anderson effect? Despite my lingering doubts regarding Correia -- and pitchers who allow tons of contact in general -- I have maintained an open mind and must admit that I enjoy watching him pitch. He works quickly on the mound and seems to have a good plan for each hitter. He's not afraid to show some emotion out there. He fails to execute on his pitches occasionally -- Monday's three-homer outing serving as a fine example -- but he bounces back and gets after it. In many ways, his game reminds me of Carl Pavano's. Those are the things that Ryan saw in Correia. Whether these strengths can continue to keep the the hurler afloat in spite of his extreme contact tendencies remains to be seen, but for now I'm happy to give the Twins' brass some props amidst the justifiable venom being doled out toward their handling of the rotation overall. * Another decision I had major doubts about was Minnesota's commitment to Pedro Florimon as starting shortstop this season. Here was a guy with a marginal track record who had been passed on by every organization in baseball less than a year ago, and now the Twins were plugging him in as their starter at a crucial position with no feasible backup plan. Through these first two months of the season, however, it hasn't been hard for me to see why the organization values him. Florimon's game is still raw in many respects, but he's an athletic ballplayer with an outstanding arm and some intriguing offensive abilities. This was all on display in Monday's win, when he went 2-for-4 with a double at the dish and started three double plays in the field. Florimon's hitting line stands at .255/.328/.368, which is hardly spectacular but perfectly adequate for a defensive specialist hitting toward the bottom of the lineup. His ability to make things happen on the bases (6-for-6 on steals) adds another dimension. He'll never be a true asset as a starter, but I've come around on the idea that Florimon could be a legitimately decent stopgap for a few years, which would be big for an organization that lacks short-term or long-term solutions at shortstop. As with Correia, it'd be no surprise if Florimon's flaws and history eventually caught up with him, but for now: kudos Twins.
  20. * Vance Worley made his first start for Class-AAA Rochester on Monday after being demoted last week. Facing Lehigh Valley, the Triple-A affiliate for his former organization, Worley delivered a five-hit shutout. Before we go making proclamations about the Twins' Opening Day starter's ills being miraculously cured, it bears noting that his peripherals were less than stellar; [PRBREAK][/PRBREAK]he threw only 74 of 119 pitches for strikes and issued four walks against four strikeouts. Really, the biggest change was that balls put into play were turning into outs rather than hits, which tends to happen against minor-league competition. Nevertheless, the shutdown effort undoubtedly provided some much-needed confidence for Worley, who has been battling through the most tumultuous stretch of his professional career. Hopefully he can continue to build on this success and quickly work his way back up. * The acquisition of Worley is one of many offseason decisions that haven't worked out especially well for the Twins thus far, but we also should recognize that a few of the team's moves have indeed paid dividends. One such example is the signing of Kevin Correia, who picked up his fifth win on Monday by holding the Brewers to three runs over six innings. The Correia contract was widely panned when it was inked in December, and I was as vocal as anyone in my criticism. The right-hander brought over a poor track record from the National League and Terry Ryan's insistence about Correia being "better than the numbers" was met with great skepticism given this club's past efforts in the free agent pitching arena. We're not quite a third of the way through the season yet, but to Ryan's credit, Correia has to this point been as advertised (by the Twins, not the numbers). He's striking out fewer hitters than ever -- unsurprising for a 32-year-old lifelong NL guy coming over to the Junior Circuit -- but still he's been the lone bright spot in an otherwise disastrous rotation, with a 3.96 ERA and 1.30 WHIP. On a staff whose members have frequently struggled to get through even five innings, Correia has completed six or more in seven of his 10 starts. Most of the veteran's past trends have remained in force; the biggest difference for him in a Twins uniform has been markedly improved control. In his career, he has averaged 3.4 walks per nine innings, but this season he's handed out just 10 free passes in 63 2/3 innings for a 1.4 BB/9 rate. The Rick Anderson effect? Despite my lingering doubts regarding Correia -- and pitchers who allow tons of contact in general -- I have maintained an open mind and must admit that I enjoy watching him pitch. He works quickly and seems to have a good plan for each hitter. He's not afraid to show some emotion out there. He fails to execute his pitches occasionally -- Monday's three-homer outing serves as a fine example -- but he bounces back and gets after it. In many ways, his game reminds me of Carl Pavano's. Those are the things that Ryan saw in Correia. Whether these strengths can continue to keep the the hurler afloat, in spite of his extreme contact tendencies, remains to be seen. For now I'm happy to give the Twins' brass some props amidst the justifiable venom being spewed toward their overall handling of the rotation. * Another decision I had major doubts about was Minnesota's commitment to Pedro Florimon as starting shortstop this season. Here was a guy with a marginal track record, passed on by every organization in baseball less than a year ago, and now the Twins were plugging him in as their starter at a crucial position with no feasible backup plan. Through these first two months of the season however, it hasn't been hard for me to see why the organization values him. Florimon's game is still raw in many respects, but he's an athletic ballplayer with an outstanding arm and some intriguing offensive abilities. This was all on display in Monday's win, when he went 2-for-4 with a double at the dish and started three double plays in the field. Florimon's hitting line stands at .255/.328/.368, which is hardly spectacular but perfectly adequate for a defensive specialist hitting toward the bottom of the lineup. His ability to make things happen on the bases (6-for-6 on steals) adds another dimension. He'll never be a big asset as a starter, but I've come around on the idea that Florimon could be a legitimately decent stopgap for a few years. This would be big for an organization that lacks both short- and long-term solutions at shortstop. As with Correia, it'd be no surprise if Florimon's flaws and history eventually caught up with him, but for now: kudos Twins.
  21. I've never been sold on his "potential" considering his total lack of strike zone judgment, and with his epic struggles above Double-A -- along with the microfracture knee surgery which few players successfully come back from -- there's less reason than ever to think he'll be an MLB asset. If it was going to happen, it would need to be in an organization that wasn't already loaded with quality outfield prospects.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.