Everything posted by Nick Nelson
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Myers has a .735 OPS. It's a huge stretch to think his presence was going to turn around their scuffling offense. And without Shields their pitching staff would be pretty mediocre too. Look, I wasn't a fan of the trade and it's not something I would have done. But it's easy to keep saying, "Let's hold onto these prospects and wait until the time is right." The Royals have been saying that for like 20 years. And frankly it's an example that scares me when it comes to the Twins.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
A cautionary tale indeed. Kansas City's big moves have actually worked out quite well; Shields has been incredible and Santana has also been fantastic. Their pitching staff is massively improved. Yet all those young hitters that they expected to power their offense have collectively fizzled. With so many people simply assuming that the Twins will make a few big moves when the time is right to build around an upcoming core that will surely lead them back to contention, it's worth thinking about. That's always been my issue with this whole notion of making no effort to compete during the rebuilding process. You're forcing the fans to go through 3-4 years of hopeless misery with no guaranteed payoff down the road.
-
Reusse: Twins and timid intersect too often
Sadly, that doesn't seem like a remotely safe assumption.
- Teams showing interest in Morneau, Perkins
- Teams showing interest in Morneau, Perkins
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
This is pretty much how I view it. Absolutely the Twins need to get at least one premium prospect back in return for Perkins, but I guess I differentiate a bit between high-caliber prospects and guys like Archie Bradley and Allen Webster, who IMO are two of the best near-MLB-ready pitching prospects in the game. I think that's a tad too high to aim. Someone like Zach Lee might be more realistic and is certainly the type of piece I'd target.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
None of those quotes fit what you said. Who's saying that the Twins "can't get much" for Perkins but should do it anyway? There's a large difference between not getting much and getting a blue-chip prospect. People are trying to be realistic. But I think the general assumption is that the return would be quite good, given his contract and the demand for his services. Multiple high-quality prospects at positions of need. I just don't think it's realistic to expect to get back a high-end pitching talent that is close to the majors. As Terry Ryan has frequently said, teams rarely part with that kind of asset, and I can't see anyone doing it for a reliever. I'd love to be wrong.
-
Article: Trade Talk: Cleveland Indians
You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=2089-Trade-Talk-Cleveland-Indians
-
Trade Talk: Cleveland Indians
Buyers or Sellers Just 1.5 games behind Detroit in the Central and three out in the Wild Card race, Cleveland has been the American League's biggest surprise. Staring up at a stacked Tigers squad that last year pulled away with a 44-32 record in the second half en route to a World Series berth, you'd better believe that the Indians are looking to add at the deadline. [PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] What They Need The Indians could use some help at the top of the rotation, where the talented yet inconsistent Justin Masterson currently leads the way, and have been linked to Matt Garza, among others. The Twins obviously can't offer anything in the way of high-end starting pitching. Cleveland may not be prepared to make the kind of aggressive moves necessary to garner that kind of talent, anyway. Although in the thick of things presently, this is a flawed team that is still in the midst of a rebuilding project geared toward fielding a title contender once Trevor Bauer (hopefully) figures things out and top prospects like Francisco Lindor and Danny Salazar are prepared to make an impact. It would be short-sighted to part with any premium prospect talent in the -- probably futile -- hope of catching the Tigers, but smaller deals aimed at improving, say, a bullpen that ranks 23rd in the majors in ERA make more sense. This is where the Tribe might find a match in the Twins. What Might Work Intra-divisional trades are somewhat rare but Cleveland and Minnesota have hooked up on minor post-deadline deals in recent years, with one sending Carl Pavano to the Twins and another sending Jim Thome to the Indians. If the two clubs were to connect again this year, I'd expect a similar non-blockbuster swap. Cleveland has been a little weak at DH, where 42-year-old Jason Giambi has been the principal recipient of at-bats. Ryan Doumit could be a fit there, although with Mark Reynolds and Nick Swisher on hand, the Indians are already pretty well stocked on 1B/DH types. In the bullpen, any one of the Jared Burton/Casey Fien/Brian Duensing group is a candidate. Chris Perez is firmly locked in as the closer and is controlled through next year, essentially ruling Cleveland out as a Glen Perkins destination. But beyond Perez the Indians only have a couple reliable relief options. Vinnie Pestano, a bullpen ace over the last two years, was recently demoted from the setup role. Sleeper Targets Mitch Brown - RHP - Rookie League - 19 years old A second-round draft pick in 2012 out of Century High School in Minnesota, Brown enjoyed a solid pro debut last year but has had a tough follow-up in 2013. He started out in Low-A, pitched poorly, landed on the DL for six weeks, and has since been pitching (poorly) in the Arizona Rookie League. Potential buy-low guy with added appeal thanks to the local ties. Might not be in play for anything the Twins have to offer, even with the poor results this season. Jesus Aguilar - 1B - AA - 23 years old If the Twins are looking to add more depth to their future first base equation, Aguilar would be a worthwhile name to look at. Right-handed hitter with a little pop and the ability to draw a walk. He currently has a .760 OPS in Double-A. Tony Wolters - 2B/C - High A - 21 years old Mired behind four superior middle infield prospects in Cleveland's system (Lindor, Dorssys Paulino, Ronny Rodriguez and Jose Ramirez) Wolters has transitioned this year to catcher. Opposing teams have run wild on him, attempting a whopping 51 steals in 31 games, so who knows how long that experiment will last. The Twins have no such concerns about overloaded infield depth, and Wolters has shown some decent offensive ability in four pro seasons. Austin Adams - RHP - AA - 26 years old Interesting case, this one. A former shortstop in college who converted to pitching in the pros, Adams performed well as a starter in the low levels of the minors with a big fastball that ranked as the best in Cleveland's system. A shoulder injury cost him the entire 2012 season, but this year Adams is back pitching out of the bullpen, where he has racked up tons of strikeouts (49 in 34 innings) while registering a 2.65 ERA. His control is iffy and he's pretty old for a prospect (he'll turn 27 in August) but if the Twins were going to give up an established relief arm he'd be an interesting one to bring back. Dream Target Dorssys Paulino - SS - Low A - 18 years old Lindor, who is backing up his top prospect status with a great season at High-A, isn't going anywhere. Paulino, another shortstop prospect playing in the Midwest League as a teenager, might be a more realistic possibility, if the Twins could package enough talent. He's a long way from the majors and he's hitting just .238 this season, but Paulino has big upside and would instantly give the Twins a viable prospect at shortstop, something they have lacked for a long, long time.
-
Trade Talk: Cleveland Indians
- Trade Talk: Cleveland Indians
Buyers or Sellers Just 1.5 games behind Detroit in the Central and three out in the Wild Card race, Cleveland has been the American League's biggest surprise. Staring up at a stacked Tigers squad that last year pulled away with a 44-32 record in the second half en route to a World Series berth, you'd better believe that the Indians are looking to add at the deadline. [ATTACH=CONFIG]4821[/ATTACH] What They Need The Indians could use some help at the top of the rotation, where the talented yet inconsistent Justin Masterson currently leads the way, and have been linked to Matt Garza among others. The Twins obviously can't offer anything in the way of high-end starting pitching. Cleveland may not be prepared to make the kind of aggressive moves necessary to garner that kind of talent, anyway. Although in the thick of things presently, this is a flawed team that is still in the midst of a rebuilding project geared toward fielding a title contender once Trevor Bauer (hopefully) figures things out and top prospects like Francisco Lindor and Danny Salazar are prepared to make an impact. It would be short-sighted to part with any premium prospect talent in the -- probably futile -- hope of catching the Tigers, but smaller deals aimed at improving, say, a bullpen that ranks 23rd in the majors in ERA would make more sense. This is where the Tribe might find a match in the Twins. What Might Work Intra-divisional trades are somewhat rare but Cleveland and Minnesota have hooked up on minor post-deadline deals in recent years, one sending Carl Pavano to the Twins and another sending Jim Thome to the Indians. If the two clubs were to connect again this year, I'd expect a similar non-blockbuster swap. Cleveland has been a little weak at DH, where 42-year-old Jason Giambi has been the principal recipient of at-bats. Ryan Doumit could be a fit there, although with Mark Reynolds and Nick Swisher on hand, the Indians are already pretty well stocked on 1B/DH types. In the bullpen, any one of the Jared Burton/Casey Fien/Brian Duensing group is a candidate. Chris Perez is firmly locked in as the closer and is controlled through next year, essentially ruling Cleveland out as a Glen Perkins destination, but beyond Perez the Indians only have a couple reliable relief options. Vinnie Pestano, a bullpen ace over the last two years, was recently demoted from the setup role. Sleeper Targets Mitch Brown - RHP - Rookie League - 19 years old A second-round draft pick in 2012 out of Century High School in Minnesota, Brown enjoyed a solid pro debut last year but has had a tough follow-up in 2013. He started out in Low-A, pitched poorly, landed on the DL for six weeks, and has since been pitching (poorly) in the Arizona Rookie League. Potential buy-low guy with added appeal thanks to the local ties. Might not be in play for anything the Twins have to offer, even with the poor results this season. Jesus Aguilar - 1B - AA - 23 years old If the Twins are looking to add more depth to their future first base equation, Aguilar would be a worthwhile name to look at. Right-handed hitter with a little pop and the ability to draw a walk. He currently has a .760 OPS in Double-A. Tony Wolters - 2B/C - High A - 21 years old Mired behind four superior middle infield prospects in Cleveland's system (Lindor, Dorssys Paulino, Ronny Rodriguez and Jose Ramirez) Wolters has transitioned this year to catcher. Opposing teams have run wild on him, attempting a whopping 51 steals in 31 games, so who knows how long that experiment will last. The Twins have no such concerns about overloaded infield depth, and Wolters has shown some decent offensive ability in four pro seasons. Austin Adams - RHP - AA - 26 years old Interesting case, this one. A former shortstop in college who converted to pitching in the pros, Adams performed well as a starter in the low levels of the minors with a big fastball that ranked as the best in Cleveland's system. A shoulder injury cost him the entire 2012 season, but this year Adams is back pitching out of the bullpen, where he has racked up tons of strikeouts (49 in 34 innings) while registering a 2.65 ERA. His control is iffy and he's pretty old for a prospect (he'll turn 27 in August) but if the Twins were going to give up an established relief arm he'd be an interesting one to bring back. Dream Target Dorssys Paulino - SS - Low A - 18 years old Lindor, who is backing up his top prospect status with a great season at High-A, isn't going anywhere. Paulino, another shortstop prospect playing in the Midwest League as a teenager, might be a more realistic possibility, if the Twins could package enough talent. He's a long way from the majors and he's hitting just .238 this season, but Paulino has big upside and would instantly give the Twins a viable prospect at shortstop, something they have lacked for a long, long time.- FSN interview with Terry Ryan [July 15, 2013]
This is always amusing to me. People come up with some extreme scenario that would never actually occur in real life, then use it to prove that the statistic is "completely worthless."- Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Has anyone said anything remotely resembling this?- Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Disagree. He was ranked No. 49 prior to this season by Baseball America and he's having maybe his best season as a pro (handful of clunkers in Boston notwithstanding).- Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
Some of the names being thrown around here are not in the realm of realism. If anyone's expecting to get Archie Bradley or Allen Webster for Perkins, you're going to be pretty disappointed if/when a trade actually occurs. But the key point here is that teams aren't trading just for Perkins, but for his contract, which runs through 2016 at a very good price. I can't remember when the Twins have had such an appealing chip to dangle. This isn't a situation like Liriano where they're trying to unload a pitcher with mediocre numbers who's got two months left on his deal. With lockdown closers being coveted around the league and the prices of such players escalating in free agency, the Twins could create a bit of a bidding war for Perk. That will drive a nice return, and while it's not going to be a potential No. 1/2 starter who's close to the majors, I do think you can get multiple quality pieces.- FSN interview with Terry Ryan [July 15, 2013]
And what good does that do the Twins? He still has the third-worst ERA in the majors, he has no trade value, and he's on a one-year deal. Pelfrey might have a solid second half for a team with no hope but the only thing that does is ramp up his market value going forward and take away opportunities from a younger guy who might be part of the future. The problem with Pelfrey was always that, as a guy 11 months removed from TJ, his best case scenario was "bad in the first half, better in the second half." On a one-year deal, that just wasn't going to do the non-competitive Twins any good. Now, if they had gone over someone with a little first-half upside (e.g. Scott Feldman) they could have possibly flipped him for something useful. I'm actually going to disagree with you here. I think the QS is a fine shorthand stat. Obviously it's imperfect (5 ER & 0 ER or 9 IP & 4 ER > 6 IP & 3 ER) but in the long run the 6IP/3ER barometer generally does a decent job of separating the good starts from the bad starts. It shouldn't be treated as gospel but it tends to give you a pretty accurate portrayal of how often the guy in question has pitched deep and given his team a solid chance to win.- FSN interview with Terry Ryan [July 15, 2013]
Kevin Correia is being paid to be a No. 4-5 starter. In that context, he's been pretty good. League-average ERA and he's on pace for 200 innings. It's not his fault that those modestly decent stats make him the team's best starter. There is really no ground for ripping him at this point unless your expectations were totally out of whack. Pelfrey, on the other hand, was a horrible signing.- Pohlads Willing to Spend?
We do discuss it. Very frequently. Probably too frequently. Here's the thing: it's easy to assess the performances of middle infielders, starting pitchers and corner outfielders because we watch them do their jobs on a daily basis. Not so easy to assess the performance of a GM who does most of his work behind the scenes. I was irked by Ryan's approach this offseason and I think his overly conservative approach is being reflected now by the team's record, but no one really expected the team to win this year and there's no denying that overall he and his staff have the organization on the right track.- Dream Trade Candidate: Profar
I'd love to get Profar but honestly I doubt it's possible without giving up Buxton or Sano.- Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
I actually asked him about this on Twitter a while back, because I'm so irritated by how little usage he gets and was curious to know if he thought better health + gained knowledge might lead to better results as a starter. His response was pretty blunt: "Didn't work last time, why would it now?"- Article: Monday Morning Madness: July 15, 2013
You bring up an important point about Duensing. The idea that he hasn't been effective against LH batters this year is an unfounded myth. I put a lot more stock into the excellent peripherals than the unsustainable .400 BABIP.- Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
You can view the page at http://twinsdaily.com/content.php?r=2080-Trading-Perkins-Makes-Too-Much-Sense- Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
- Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
[ATTACH=CONFIG]4809[/ATTACH]I've tried to rationalize my way out of it. I've tried reconciling the deep divide between my heart and my brain. Truly, it has been one of the most difficult instances of my emotions as a fan clashing with my insights as an analyst. But at the end of the day, I can't escape from what I know deep down to be true: The Twins ought to trade Glen Perkins. And passing on the opportunity to do so could go down as a critical mistake. It was an excellent article from Dave Cameron on FanGraphs last week that served as the tipping point. In discussing the stated commitments of the Twins and Mets to build around their talented young closers, Cameron points to Joakim Soria as a cautionary tale. The Royals repeatedly refused to shop their elite closer when they had a chance, and ended up getting bitten. Soria never pitched for a good team in Kansas City and the Royals got nothing in return for him when he left because he got hurt. Soria is hardly the lone example; Cameron also points to the top ten under-30 closers from the 2010 season (as ranked by WAR) and finds that -- without exception -- every single one has since lost his hold on the closer role due to performance or injury. Every. Single. One. Even before I came across this column, I was having difficulty convincing myself that trading Perkins isn't the most logical course of action for this rebuilding Twins franchise. The southpaw has emerged as one of the most dominant relievers in the game and his value has never been higher. In addition to carrying the vaunted "proven closer" label, Perkins ranks 14th among MLB relievers in ERA (one spot ahead of Mariano Rivera), seventh in xFIP and 15th in K/9 rate. His contract is extremely team-friendly -- perhaps the best in baseball for a high-end closer. In addition to his flat-out dominance on the mound, Perkins appeals to me as a Twins fan for a variety of other reasons. He's a local guy who grew up in Stillwater and attended college at my alma mater, the University of Minnesota. He's friendly to bloggers and fans. He's hilarious and forward-thinking. He gives back to the community. In many ways, Perkins is the perfect fit in a Twins uniform, which makes this such a sticky issue. But with his value at an all-time high, and numerous contenders in serious need of a lockdown reliever for the ninth, it stands to reason that he could bring in a sizable haul that may supplement multiple areas of need for this retooling Minnesota franchise. How does that weigh against the value that Perkins provides to the team? Right now he's closing out meaningless games for a club headed toward 90-plus losses. When the Twins return to a competitive state -- hopefully within the next year or two -- the closer's innings will obviously become far more important, but we're still talking about a guy who will end up throwing around 65 innings per year if he stays healthy. As we're seeing this season, Perkins is a victim to the institutional suppression of closers, limited to pitching in very specific situations and therefore restricted from helping the team in many times of need. Despite the fact that he is easily the Twins' best pitcher, he ranks seventh among relievers in innings pitched. He also ranks 101st in the majors. Perk is as good as it gets but his impact is severely lessened by Ron Gardenhire's stringent adherence to traditional closer usage (not that this differentiates Gardy from the rest of the league's managers). Obviously, it all comes down to what offers are out there. But if Terry Ryan has a chance to add multiple quality prospects in exchange for a reliever, he may very well regret saying no. History shows that, as phenomenal as Perkins is right now, there's significant risk tied to his future. History also shows that contending teams have a tendency to overpay for closers at the deadline -- look no further than the Twins for a recent example. I'd hate to lose Perkins, and I'm sure Ryan would too. Because of this, I know that a trade won't occur unless an offer really knocks the GM's socks off. If that offer comes, though, Ryan must pull the trigger. It will be the biggest bummer of a season that's been full of them, but this 2013 campaign has been all about present sacrifices for future gains.- Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
I've tried to rationalize my way out of it. I've tried reconciling the deep divide between my heart and my brain. Truly, it has been one of the most difficult instances of my emotions as a fan clashing with my insights as an analyst. But at the end of the day, I can't escape from what I know deep down to be true: The Twins ought to trade Glen Perkins. And passing on the opportunity to do so could go down as a critical mistake. [PRBREAK][/PRBREAK] It was an excellent article from Dave Cameron on FanGraphs last week that served as the tipping point. In discussing the stated commitments of the Twins and Mets to build around their talented young closers, Cameron points to Joakim Soria as a cautionary tale. The Royals repeatedly refused to shop their elite closer when they had a chance, and ended up getting bitten. Soria never pitched for a good team in Kansas City and the Royals got nothing in return for him when he left because he got hurt. Soria is hardly the lone example; Cameron also points to the top ten under-30 closers from the 2010 season (as ranked by WAR) and finds that -- without exception -- every single one has since lost his hold on the closer role due to performance or injury. Every. Single. One. Even before I came across this column, I was having difficulty convincing myself that trading Perkins isn't the most logical course of action for this rebuilding Twins franchise. The southpaw has emerged as one of the most dominant relievers in the game and his value has never been higher. In addition to carrying the vaunted "proven closer" label, Perkins ranks 14th among MLB relievers in ERA (one spot ahead of Mariano Rivera), seventh in xFIP and 15th in K/9 rate. His contract is extremely team-friendly -- perhaps the best in baseball for a high-end closer. In addition to his flat-out dominance on the mound, Perkins appeals to me as a Twins fan for a variety of other reasons. He's a local guy who grew up in Stillwater and attended college at my alma mater, the University of Minnesota. He's friendly to bloggers and fans. He's hilarious and forward-thinking. He gives back to the community. In many ways, Perkins is the perfect fit in a Twins uniform, which makes this such a sticky issue. But with his value at an all-time high, and numerous contenders in serious need of a lockdown reliever for the ninth, it stands to reason that he could bring in a sizable haul that may supplement multiple areas of need for this retooling Minnesota franchise. How does that weigh against the value that Perkins provides to the team? Right now he's closing out meaningless games for a club headed toward 90-plus losses. When the Twins return to a competitive state -- hopefully within the next year or two -- the closer's innings will obviously become far more important, but we're still talking about a guy who will end up throwing around 65 innings per year if he stays healthy. As we're seeing this season, Perkins is a victim of the institutional suppression of closers, limited to pitching in very specific situations and therefore restricted from helping the team in many times of need. Despite the fact that he is easily the Twins' best pitcher, he ranks seventh among Twins relievers in innings pitched. He also ranks 101st in the majors. Perk is as good as it gets but his impact is severely lessened by Ron Gardenhire's stringent adherence to traditional closer usage (not that this differentiates Gardy from the rest of the league's managers). Obviously, it all comes down to what offers are out there. But if Terry Ryan has a chance to add multiple quality prospects in exchange for a reliever, he may very well regret saying no. History shows that, as phenomenal as Perkins is right now, there's significant risk tied to his future. History also shows that contending teams have a tendency to overpay for closers at the deadline -- look no further than the Twins for a recent example. I'd hate to lose Perkins, and I'm sure Ryan would too. Because of this, I know that a trade won't occur unless an offer really knocks the GM's socks off. If that offer comes, though, Ryan must pull the trigger. It will be the biggest bummer of a season that's been full of them, but this 2013 campaign has been all about present sacrifices for future gains. - Trade Talk: Cleveland Indians