Everything posted by TwinsDr2021
-
Bundy and the third time through
That makes sense and I don't disagree with that, but if what you are saying is true, shouldn't we see more guys being taken out in the 5th with less than say 65 pitches? Or 6 innings with lets say 75 pitches? But that isn't what the box scores are showing, they are showing if a pitcher is efficient they are usually given more outs/innings and if they aren't horribly efficient they are taken out (Example Winder last night 5/77, that seems very consistent across the league). That is my whole point, I feel like you are trying to say something I already agree with and have said absolutely true.
-
Bundy and the third time through
That is what I did Big Dog, I went though hundreds of box scorse, looking for something close to that, every start by the Yanks, Braves, Rays, Mets and daily box scores for the last few weeks, and I couldn't find a pitcher taken out in the 5th averaging less (besides the ones I mentioned above) than 12 pitches (60 pitchers) or 6 innings and less than 7 pitches. unless that pitcher was coming back from a injury, a rain delay, or the pitcher was terrible. So I guess your point was?
-
Bundy and the third time through
My argument was never about pitcher's pitching less innings, less pitches, favorable matchups, or any of the other things, my argument was simplify do teams take a starting pitcher out in 5 innings and around 58 , or really any other inning where a pitcher is averaging 10/11 pitches an inning? You say pitch count isn't the major factor, but with all the examples I provided it actually does seems to be a big factor? No?
-
Bundy and the third time through
I agree, I was reading some on facebook (not a good source) but it was pointing out that the 300 win club is pretty much done adding pitchers, none of the active one are really all that close, will 200 be the new standard and if so after the current projected HOF starting pitchers retire, will that be the end of Hall of Fame starting pitchers? The youngest guys with 100 wins are Bumgarner (32, 131), Cole (31, 124), The youngest guy with 90 is Carlos Carrasco( 35, 98), The youngest guy with 80 is Trevor Bauer (31, 83), but he might be done, so Sonny Gray (32, 86) The youngest guy with 70 is Aaron Nola (29,72) The youngest guy with 60 is Jose Berrios (28, 66) The youngest guy with 50 is German Marquez (27, 58) Even if you drop down to between 40 and 50 wins you have three guys younger than 28 years old. Giolito (27, 47), Walker Buehler (27, 46), Shane Bieber (27, 44), These pitchers would have to average at least 12 wins a year each and every year until they are 40 just to get around the 200 mark and that is for the youngest guys. Cole seems like a decent bet to get to 200, but would anybody bet on any of the others?
-
Bundy and the third time through
Got it everybody doing this means one playoff game three years ago, going forward I will be sure to remember that everybody doing somethings could mean a unique scenario three seasons ago. And yes it is lazy to make a broad statement that everybody is doing something, but then not being able to back it up or refusing to back it up. And again I am talking about Bundy's latest game. If this conversation was about Winder being pulled after 5 and 77 pitches and somebody complained it was too soon and you or me responded with too bad that is way the everybody is doing it, you know what that would be OK and not lazy, why? because we could point out numerous games every damn day by just about every team that it was happening. I have looked at hundreds of box scores in the last 24 hours and I found 2 similiar games to this one. Bundy's 6 inning 60 game (which he did give up the lead and his only run in the 6th, so maybe that is what the Twins were looking at, but that is vastly different than everybody is doing it), Archer's 5 inning 57 pitch game which the twins lost when Pagen blew a save to Detroit. Maybe I missed some, but if everybody is doing it, it shouldn't take hundreds of box scores to find 3?
-
Bundy and the third time through
This started out as My response was - "You always say that, but was there another team that pulled its starter after 58 pitchers, in just 5 innings yesterday, recently?" I pointed out that nobody did something similiar last weekend and in other messages pointed out 4 teams that haven't done anything similiar with their starters after their initial start or two. And has turned into I am not even sure what, but I know it hasn't turned into proving other teams do this on a regular basis or even much if any at all. Pointing out the average innings per start isn't lazy it is true when comparing the Twins to the league and backs up completely what the Twins and the league are doing with the pitching staff on average. And if this was a general discussion on how the Twins are managing their starters compared to the rest of the league, then it is great and all and I would have been pointing out all the stats you were to proving the Twins aren't much different than the rest of the league, and then would have compared the Twins starters to the other teams and we wouldn't be having this conversation because we would be on the same page. But it is lazy to throw out a statement like this when comparing ONE start, because not one person has even attempted to show another team has done this even once. 5 innings and 58 pitches. Now, maybe this is my fault for changing the initial conversation from Bundy and the third time through to pulling him from this game. You may want to save all the good research you did because it could come in handy later.
-
Bundy and the third time through
That is not at all what I am saying, I saying when pitcher pitches good and efficient their average inning per start is higher than you and others are expressing. I showed you example from 4 teams (that you listed) and didn't find any examples of a pitcher being pulled after 5 innings with 58 pitches (or something close to that), and this what you are saying everybody in baseball is doing, correct? taking pitchers out early and with low pitch counts because the math says there is a higher percent chance of winning? Is that not what you are saying every team in baseball is doing? And if it wasn't obvious I am not removing games to fit my narrative, I am saying when a guy pitches like crap they get pulled early or if it is early in the season and they haven't been stretched out., and if you remove those games, MOST of the time are getting pulled because of a high pitch count. Based on what I just pointed out some or more teams would have let a starter like Ryan start the 8th in his last game with only 89 pitches (Since he is a 90 - 100 pitch count type of pitcher) Now, I am not saying the Twins should have, I kind of thought it was a good idea with how inefficient he was the prior game and leaving on a good note was important. But based on what I posted above, for anybody to say well they had to take him out that is what all teams do, is a lazy statement.
-
Bundy and the third time through
As for Kluber you could say he might be similar because they don't like him run up his pitch count, but in his last starts were he hasn't been terrible, 5.1 (63 pitches), 6(92 pitches), 6(93 pitches), 5 (80 pitches), 6 (69 pitches), 6 (80 pitches), 6 (90 pitches), 6(64 pitches), 6 (71 pitches) In between those were 3 starts of 3 innings. Springs moved from the pen to the starter and has went 6 in three of his last 7, one he wasn't good 4.1 (4ER and 86 pitches), The other three were good 5.1 (94 pitches)and 5 inning (2ER 85 pitches), 5.2 (1 hit 80 pitches, but 4 walks) Baz is 23 and has 8 major league starts, 2 of his 5 starts he has went 6, one with 5.2(95 pitches), one was 4.2( 78 pitches) and the other was bad 2.1 (5 ER) Rasmussen has generally been up and down, if he is good and keeps his pitch count down he pitches longer, he isn't the most efficient pitcher out there. Yarbrough has an ERA of 5.82 so no surprise he doesn't average many innings per start, with that said he last four games are 5.1, 1.2, 6.2 and 5.1. So again, I am not sure your are proving your point, unless your argument is that bad starts bring down your average inning per start, or unless you are trying to say running up your pitch count can contribute to short starts.
-
Bundy and the third time through
I will just use the Yanks, I am only really seeing three starts that qualify for has been said, the three by Montgomery. James Taillon lowest pitch count for 5 innings was 72 (1st start), Lowest for 6 was 71 Luis Severino lowest pitch count for 5 innings was 83 (2nd start), Lowest for 6 was 77 Nestor Cortes lowest pitch count for 5 innings was 82 (4th start), Lowest for 6 was 91 Jordan Montgomery lowest pitch count for 5 innings was 71 (2nd start and 4th start), Lowest for 6 was 71 Gerrit Cole lowest pitch count for 5.2 innings was 85 (2nd start), Lowest for 6 was 91 All average over 5.5. The only reason Cole isn't over 6 is two terrible starts., Montgomery has two starts less than 5 and if you remove those he is a 6, Cortes has two games of 4.1 with 4 runs, without that he would be a rounding error at 6. They generally don't allow him to start an inning with over 85-90 pitches. Taillon is generally limited to less than 90 pitches but still is at 5.6, Severino is at 5.57 and has pitched in 7 games since the end of 2018 prior to this year and 8 of his 14 games he has pitched 6 inning, So using the Yanks as an example of everybody is doing it is not a good example at all, most are just a few bad starts from averaging 6 and besides a few early starts they generally are only limited by how efficient they are with pitches. Looked at the braves and the only reason Anderson isn't above 6 is because he has 4 short terrible games, when he is not bad he is over 5+ and in the 90 pitch count. Morton who is 38 is only below 6 because of the games he was bad (2) and not very efficient with his pitch count (102 in 5, 92 in 5, 95 in 5.1, 95 in 5) but in his last 5 games he has pitched 6, 7, 7, 5,2, 7. The rest of their games have been started by people I don't know, except the moved Strider from the pen to starting and 4 of his last stars are 6, 6, 3.2 (6 ER), 5.1 (106 pitches) Mets, Bassit is one bad game 3.1 (7 earned runs from 6), Carrasco (5.45) but 5 terrible games less than 5 innings (4.1, 2,1, 4.2, 4.1, 3.2), still under 6 but to 5 2/3. Taijuan Walker is under 6 but his last 11 starts have been 6, 7.1, 6, 6.2, 6, 6, 5.2 (94 pitches), 5 (88 pitches), 7, 5 (94 pitches, 7, And Scherzer only has 8 starts but 49.2 innings (That is over 6). So while you stats are 100% true, looking a little deeper kind of tells a different story.
-
Bundy and the third time through
To clarify I am calling the stat that no staff averages 6 inning a start as lazy. Because that doesn't take into account a team like the Rays (as one example) have had close to 25% of their stars being made by non-traditional starters.
-
Bundy and the third time through
Is there? I haven't ever seen anybody post examples of pitchers being pulled similiar to what the Twins have done but maybe I have missed that I don't read everything on here. Sure I have seen the lazy stat that pitching staff don't average 6 innings or X amount of pitchers average X amount of innings without context on how stretched out they are or if they were terrible in a few games thus bringing their average start down. And it isn't bad watching a guy dominant for 5 great innings that isn't the problem, it is that he is being pulled and not allowed to dominant for 6 or possibly more. Being a former pitcher and seeing a pitcher that is pitching that well being pulled and turning the game over to the unknown isn't great to me, but to each their own.
-
Bundy and the third time through
Well I guess I am looking at different box scores than the rest of people, because I am not seeing starters that aren't terrible, rain delay, injury or relief pitchers starting that aren't going 80 - 100+ plus pitches be it any inning amount, some 5, 6, 7, 8, The Red Sox on Sunday did pull Connor Seasbold after 4 innings and 74 pitches (3 major league game and second this year) It would be interesting if somebody (namely baseball reference or something) took out all the rain delay, relief pitchers starts, and injuries and figured out what the average start was by month. So we could quit using the lazy stat that no team averages 6 innings a start.
-
Bundy and the third time through
? I would also add that fans complaining about fans complaining because "the entire league is doing it" without backing that up with examples is the same possibly as "aren't well thought out, informed, accurate, and relevant "? NO?
-
Bundy and the third time through
I am asking you to show examples (which should be easy since the entire league has been doing it for years) I understand it does happen and it for sure happens early in the season quite a bit before the starters are stretched out. But I would argue by looking at the box scores the last month or so, teams aren't pulling starters with that low of pitch count that early in the game, unless they pitcher is terrible or a rain delay. The starting pitchers that the managers don't trust to pitch 80 plus innings are being inserted after a starter goes an inning or two and then pulled to give the fireballers in the pen the last inning or two.
-
Bundy and the third time through
You are correct, I typed a zero instead of an eight, and I missed the run in the 10th was unearned, I forgot the ghost runner doesn't count as earned. I would argue if Bundy can't be trusted to throw more than 5 unless it is a blow out one way or another(which he has at least 4 other times) a better philosophy would been for Jax to start and throw his two innings and then bring Bundy in, but whatever. It is terrible baseball to watch a starter dominating a lineup for 5 innings (58 pitches, 6 K's, 1 BB, and 3 hits) and being pulled and the bullpen blowing the lead within 2 innings, but that is just my opinion. I do find it laughable that if the offense save the team the philosophy works, but if the offense don't save the team it is on them. I also find it funny that a week ago bringing in Pagen was a terrible call, but bringing him in today was the right call.
-
Bundy and the third time through
You always say that, but was there another team that pulled its starter after 58 pitchers, in just 5 innings yesterday, recently? There wasn't any yesterday or Sunday, people could claim the Rays and Boston did something similiar yesterday, but both went with a starter and let the second pitcher go 5 inning and 82 and 93 pitches. Also, just because others "are doing it" does that mean that fans can't complain about it? Maybe the Twins told Bundy no matter what today the most innings you are going is 5, we need to get some work from Jax, Duffey, and Pagan; seems like kind of a weird plan and one that is almost conceding the game or the next days game, Which is confusing since the three previous starters went 6,5,7, but at least it would be a plan.
-
Bundy and the third time through
Did it work last night? the first pitcher that came in blew the lead, and the Twins won because of a 4 run tenth. The Starter's ERA was 1.00 and the Bullpen's ERA was 3.60. Sure they won the game, but was it in spite of the bullpen usage or because of the bullpen usage, we will never know.
-
Power Starters, Middle Relief Aces, oh my - how the Twins could manage their pitching
I wasn't saying the Rays wouldn't be managing Archers innings like the Twins are, I was saying they would be doing it differently. I am sick hearing about the Covid year, all the teams had to deal with it and pitchers that missed the year are pitching innings in the majors and minors;the problem with the Twins isn't so much about the Covid year, it is all their pitching prospects always getting hurt. Sure the Twins are managing their staff, but are they doing it well is the question on just about every thread.
-
Power Starters, Middle Relief Aces, oh my - how the Twins could manage their pitching
I would hope nobody thinks the STAFF should average 6 innings. Having a pitcher or two is not out of the question. Shane Mcclanahan of Tampa averages almost 6 1/3. (and he just turned 25) Corey Kluber has went at least 6 innings in 7 of his last 11 games. (He also plays for Tampa) Drew Rasmussen has pitched 5 or more innings every start he hasn't been terrible. (another Tampa starter) The Rays let good starting pitchers pitch (To a point they don't run up pitch counts over 100 very often, but Mcclanahan for example never really gives them less than 90 pitches) , The odds are they wouldn't treat Archer like the Twins do, they would probably use a starter for 1 or 2 innings and Bring in Archer for 3 - 7/8. That is the thing, that is misleading about this article and the thoughts people have on Tampa, it isn't so much a team philosophy on how pitching SHOULD be done, it is their flexibility and adapting to what they have that makes them good. If you gave Tampa the starters the Dodgers do people really think they would pitch them different than the dodgers do, heck no. The Twins on the other hand IMO don't seem all that flexible,
-
3 Injured Pitchers That Can Help the Twins in the Second Half
For his career Alcala has blown 5 of 17 hold/save opportunities and has pitched 2 1/3 innings this year, so lets hold off on the "Twins bullpen would take on a remarkably different view" until he proves he is worthy of it, which probably won't be until close to the end of this month at the earliest. I hope he comes back dominant but that is all it is as of now, hope. Ober has averaged less than 5 innings a start in his 27 starts, so thinking he will come back and do something he really hasn't ever done is asking a lot, he seems like the perfect guy to piggy back Archer's starts. Maeda is a complete unknown as of now and in likely hood won't be asked to pitch many innings this year whenever he comes back. I think they could all be good or better, but lets be realistic about how the Twins handle pitchers.
-
Power Starters, Middle Relief Aces, oh my - how the Twins could manage their pitching
The Twins are kind of stuck between a rock and a hard place. The starting pitching has been a little too good for this to work (Except Archer it has been perfect for him) and the relief pitching hasn't been good enough for it to work. The guys that it would be perfect for Duran, Jax, Smeltzer, Winder have been too good and moved to other roles, or not good Sands, Cotton, Cano, or injured. Also IMO this doesn't work when you actually have too many starters, you can't limit Gray and Ryan innings for example, when you are limiting their starts by having a 6 or 7 man rotation. Also you can't plan the 6-9 innings to be perfect, and sometimes that seems to be what the manager is looking for. On a side note this strategy is not a good game to watch and could possibly eliminate starting pitchers from the HOF. (Which I believe is already happening by limiting the amount of innings pitched, and thus bringing pitchers Wins down)
- Cole Sands Finding Success Through Consistency
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Guardians, noon:10 cdt, 0th July 2022ad
The Twins traded a minor league prospect for a player that was or should have helped the team for three years, I will NEVER complain about a trade like that. Don't care Maeda got hurt, it was the right thing to do.
-
Minnesota’s Return for Berrios Continues to Look Better
are people really not happy with the return or are they unhappy of the progress of the two? At the time it was two top 100 prospects which is great. Lots of people thought Martin could be the opening day left fielder and some thought SWR could be in MPLS this summer, now I thought both of those things weren't possible, mostly based on the 40 man. If Berrios was doing great this would like a slam dunk for Toronto, but with they way he has pitched and the extension he signed it looks good for MN regardless of how well the prospects have done so far. I expect Berrios to turn it around at some point and I think Martin is going to be more of a Gordon than a starter and SWR should at minimum see some time in the bullpen. So at this point I still grade this as a positive for the Twins.
-
Logic of not making a trade.
No starting pitching? 3.20, 3.14, 2.86, 2.17, 3.06, 4.71, 4.03 that is the ERA of the Twins starting pitchers. If you mean no starters that pitch more innings, then sadly you/we are going to be disappointed by all the Twins starters, the teams philosophy is the reason the innings pitched is less than we like, not the lack of talent of the pitchers. If people think the next group (Winder, Ober, Canterino, Balazovic, Sands, and Varland ) is going to pitch longer in games, you are crazy. Or even if they trade for a Montas type that they will come in and throw 7/8 innings and 100 pitches a game, it isn't happening.