Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

TwinsDr2021

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by TwinsDr2021

  1. Dyson started one game in the majors in 2013 and pitched in 376 total games.
  2. I am guessing there is little to no chance is in the majors next year. He has a ERA of 5.38 in high A, he will be 23 when next season starts and is averaging less than 5 innings per start.
  3. Because Correa isn't going to return what you think he would.
  4. Spending 35 million dollars to get into first place, then trading said guy for a couple of minor league fillers at the deadline, or keep said guy thus not pissing on the team and the fans and continue to push for the division title. Yup can't see anything wrong with the first option. If the Twins decide to trade CC then Gray, Kepler, Polanco, Urshela should be traded as well. Then beg the fans for a few more years to get this prospect pipeline figured out, because 6 just isn't enough. Sure there will be fans that quit on the team (Me being one) but don't worry they have all those young fans coming to replace us, oh wait....
  5. traded for a 2 time all star at catcher, former all star at 1st coming off a 30 homer season after hitting 13 in 53 games and 34 in 105 games, a second baseman with a WAR of 4.9 in 21 also former all star at SS, All world SS (some could argue the best SS in the game) that cost 35 million dollars, A solid vet at 3B with your 3rd best non pitching prospect biting at his heals. Your 100 million dollar center fielder, A solid two plus WAR right fielder, a former 1st round pick and all world prospect fighting for left. Traded a first round pitcher and top 10 prospect for former all star and top (ish) of the rotation starter. All world Rookie Joe Ryan starting opening day, Bailey Ober as the third start after coming off a 1.2 WAR in his rookie season of 20 starts. Traded for another starter in Paddock, signed two vets and had a slew of pitching prospects just waiting to break though. Yes, I can totally can see how this team wasn't built for winning this year. Going into next year, they will be replacing Sano with Arraez at first, and somebody for Correa and instead of Ober coming back from a strong season he will be coming back from another injured season. As will Maeda and Paddock, and those pitching prospects waiting to break though, it will be a different group trying to break though. So anybody that thinks 23 is a different plan than 22 is dreaming.
  6. Sorry I thought the topic was - My evolving opinion on where the Twins stand I thought it relevant to point out I didn't and don't think the Twins should got get a top pitcher. I also thought it relevant to say my opinion on the FO has evolved from letting them build a consistent team with a pipeline of prospects and trades to I evolving into thinking they haven't and if they can't turn it around this year replacing them might be more on important than letting them continue down the path they have taken us.(Which I thought was looking like a good path and last year was a speed bump, but maybe isn't looking so rosy anymore. And I used examples of way I think that.) I mean it isn't like I was talking about starting pitchers or trades that happened.?‍♂️
  7. I have never been on the Twins need to trade for a stud starting pitcher this year, I just don't believe they would use the pitcher that way. Unless of course they decide they need to to drive up the trading price (IE - what they did with Berrios before trading him last year). They seem pretty consistent on allowing starters pitch to 18-22 batters and that is it. I also don't believe they will sign any stud this off season if there is any left to sign. So sure maybe they will be as good on the offensive/defensive side next year with the same question marks, but having most of the rotation being on innings limit next year, leaves me to believe next year is more of the same as this year. Personally if the Twins fold down the stretch I think it is time for this FO to go. Who have they brought in the last 7 years that will be starting pieces next year? Currently guys on the 40 man this front office: Laranach, Garlick, Contreras, Celestiono, Urshela, Correa, Beckham, Jeffers, Sanchez, Winder, Thielbar, Strotman, Smith, Smeltzer, Sands, Ryan, Romero, Pagan, Paddack, Ober, Megill, Maeda, Jax, Henriquez, Gray, Enlow, Duran, Dobnak, Coulombe, Cotton, Cano, Bundy, Archer, Alcala. Maeda, Smeltzer, Alcala, Duran came from trading guys from the previous regime. ( This FO should get credit for trading for these guys) Does this group give you confidence that this front office are the guys for the job? the top offensive prospect is the guy they took first overall in 2017 draft, the top pitching prospect (Balazovic) is from the previous regime, and the next two guys Martin and SWR are from trading the best pitcher from the previous regime.
  8. So go into next year with the same question marks as this year, Is Larnach the the guy that has had a couple of good stretches or the guy that has a couple of horrible stretches? Is AK the star we all expected or the guy that has been hurt every year since 2018, Can Jeffers be a starting Catcher, and two guys that have never played in the majors (Steer and Wallner), So basically the center field (Buxton), 2B (Arraez) and 3b set (Miranda), and question marks everywhere else, I guess beside having decent utility guys (Celestino and Gordon). Or maybe Kepler stays in RF and Polanco stays and moves Arraez to 1st. Lewis also is a question mark since he has 12 total major league games. Then the starters Gray in the last year of his deal and is a 5/6 inning pitcher an Ryan a good 5 or 6 inning pitcher, Maeda and Paddack coming back from TJ surgery and will be on a innings limit. Then Ober and Winder who also have a injury past and who I assume will also be on inning limits based on the amount of innings they will have pitched this year. This doesn't include the bullpen. This would all be OK IMO if 21 didn't happen or if this team ends up winning the division. But if they fall out of contention this year after last year and NOT going for it when they were good in 19 and 20 (with mostly a team from the previous FO) when they were good, and the reason they didn't go for it was because they were building for a team to be competitive going forward, and then us fans have to deal with this, it should be unacceptable. I mean it isn't like they have a stud pitcher in the minors ready to blow up next year or even a position player (unless we count Lewis who will be 24 in June next year)
  9. To be honest I was never on the get a top end starter, mostly because I don't think the Twins would change their philosophy of around 21/22 batters faced on average a game. Maybe they could try for Rodon and abuse the crap out of him the rest of the year (think Brewers with CC) and let him walk, but I don't think they would do that either. I have been on the need relief pitchers and need them fast and would have been willing to overpay the last few weeks, still think they need relief pitchers but waiting until the last second wasn't the right play IMO because if they get another Dyson situation there is no fixing that, but if they got a guy a few weeks ago, well then they still have the deadline. As for the prospects, it is somewhat depressing they have no real top end type talent close, and I am guessing people are going to be saying that is because they graduated some many guys which I would agree with if those guys would have been top end talents unless I am wrong only Lewis and AK were considered top 50-100 guys, I mean Martin and SWR were but lets not go there.
  10. I would rather the Twins get into the playoffs then not, but I totally get what you are saying. The question I have for everybody is who are the prospects in the minors that are going to help this team be great and when realistically is great? could the Twins trade 5 guys in their stop 30 and still be OK or is that the end of building? For me next year looks quite a bit like this year, hope the starting pitchers stay healthy, hope the younger guys get better (Larnach, Miranda, Jeffers, AK), Lewis is healthy and wins a starting spot (somewhere), and maybe have a couple of pitching prospects step up. To me I see the 23 Twins in a similiar situation next year as they are this year, by this I mean in first or fighting for first with all three teams being a little better than this year. With that said I am not trading Lewis (unless it is for Othani or Soto) but anybody else could be traded for the right deal. There are plenty I would trade for a guy for 2 months, but most would require some team control.
  11. The only prospect I am offering for 2 months, is somebody that projects to be a 1B or DH type that is striking out a bunch in the minors, or maybe a utility type player, but no way and I offering an athlete for 2 months.
  12. Before today this team was 1 and 3 (now 1 and 4) and prior to that they were 3 and 3, with two of the wins against the Tigers and the 3 loses to the White Sox. That is is 4 - 7 in the last 11, but 2-7 against anybody not named the Tigers. So I can excuse people for their complaints when generally things haven't changed.
  13. Based on these stats, Gray shouldn't even be allowed to come out for the 5th, but if they do he should go 7?
  14. I agree with not wearing out your starters, look at what the Padres did last night they are so dumb, Musgrove pitched 6 innings and 96 pitches and faced 23 batters, that kind of crazy usage will end up with him getting hurt and not being able to pitch in the playoffs, and not be 100% for his next start. /s
  15. I do love reading the trade offers where the Twins get rid of junk for other teams stars. Why in the world would Boston want that package? What good is Urshela and Sano to them besides two guys required to be on their 40? Sure they could keep Kepler and Steer and cut Sano and not offer Urshela a contract next year, but then why take them in the first place. Also as of right now Martin, SWR, Enlow and Jordan B aren't getting you the top guys, maybe even if you offered them all up in the same trade. And probably nobody would want to take on that many guys required to be on the 40 this year and next.
  16. I trade AK and his 5 years of control for 1 year and 2months of unbelievable talent like Ohtani every time. Don't like adding Lewis but if that is what it takes so be it. I am all in on this not likely to happen trade. I am sick of waiting for potential when this trade would make us instant contenders this year and if things go well next year as well (and if not next year they could always trade him, sure they wouldn't get back as much as the gave but the return should still be pretty good)
  17. I defiantly think that trade option would get a signed Soto's cap, jersey and bat and a National's prospect with the first name Juan. ?
  18. That would be a perfect contract for the Twins, I agree they Twins wouldn't do it, and I am not sure they have the prospect capital to pull it off without including Ryan and a AK/Miranda/Lewis and others . Yesterday I would have probably said Winder or Ober instead of Ryan but I am not sure those two have that trade value today as they did a week ago.
  19. I think you missed my point/sarcasm on that one, There is little to no chance any of the teams would make one of those trades, (Maybe Boston would make the trade, maybe) But the rest of the trades are the Twins trading garbage or less than other teams would offer for those guys, so yes if you can basically steal other team's players for your garbage you make those trades. For example it doesn't matter if the Twins are in first or last if you can get a major league player for Cave, Archer and #30 prospect, make the trade, or if you can trade failed (at this time could he be valued any lower?) first round pick and Smith for Bard, they could trade him next week for way more than they paid do it in a heart beat. If the Marlins are willing to do that trade again you have to do it. If the Diamondbacks are going to give you a pitcher you have control over though 25 for those two prospect, again you do that.
  20. This started out with you answer Mike Sixel's following question - "How will next year be better? They likely have no SS.... And need to replace Bundy and Archer. They won't have a built in lead in the division. I'm genuinely curious why anyone thinks next year is likely to be better. ? ' And you laid out a scenario (which by the way I hope happens which I mentioned) where a lot things have to go right and you didn't answer the question on the built in lead. I pointed out all the things that have to go right including Cleveland and Chicago being as mediocre as they are this year and the Twins FO have to sign a top tier starting pitcher (which they haven't ever done). And your response is we could paint any scenario in a negative light, then use a multiple examples of things to the best of my knowledge didn't happen like signing Corbin, Clevinger and Rendon. Then also use some crazy example of what others thought of the Donaldson trade and how the Twins are going to spend $20 on pitching, which may or may not happen. So yes if all or maybe all of these things happen the Twins might be in a better position next year, but as I was pointing out that is truly based on faith and hope only. I will say some of things you said are very, very likely to happen, but what I know is as of July 28th 2002 the Twins are in first place, and I can't say with any certainty that July 28 2023 they will be.
  21. You are correct everybody has an option. I basically was going off the 63 million you said they would have to spend. Do you know the amount they spent this past offseason? Correa 35.1, Gray 10.7, Bundy 4, Archer 2.75 and Smith, which is a total of 55.05 and then they subtracted a bit from the Donaldson and Rogers trades, the difference between the money to spend next year which is only 8 less than your projected 63 and they didn't sign one top rotation guy, Plus they have to replace Sanchez, Urshela and Sano so unless those guys are replaced by prospects that will bring down your 63 to less or about the same as last year. IMO the Twins have a philosophy on starting pitchers and that is pretty consistently allowing their starters to pitch to 21 or 22 guys, you don't and can not pay the price of a top end starter and limit him to this and I don't see them changing that philosophy for one or two guys when they haven't done that for Gray or Ryan. IMO this front office will pay higher salaries for the offensive guys and let the pipeline, trades and Bundy's of the world fill out a rotation. Now I hope I am wrong and they go out and sign a stud starter and they let him pitch to the best of his abilities and not stick to their starting pitching philosophy, but I have little hope and faith that they do.
  22. If the Twins could pull this off it would be the miracle of all miracles and I would be all for it. They basically would 2 starters, 2 relief pitchers , a outfielder, a catcher and a utility guy for Kepler, Urbina and clear out a bunch of minor leagues players that most likely won't amount to a whole lot.
  23. So the same team minus Correa and a few other vets and the hope (fingers crossed) the Twins go out and do something they have never done before and are going to do it Twice (Sign a high end starting pitcher)? Free Agents next year, Price, Sale, Rodon, Syndergaard, Morton, Wainwright, Eovaldi, Kersahw, Greinke, Nola, Severino, Manaea, Gibson, Bassitt and Musgrove are the top guys available. I can assume we can count out Price, Morton, Wainwright, Greinke, Gibson and Kershaw from the list. That leaves Sale, Rodon, Syndergaard, Eovaldi, Nola, Severino, Manaea, Bassitt and Musgrove. Sale and Bassitt are both over 33, so probably can assume if they were to be brought in, it would be for a 1 or 2 contract, maybe 3, but do we really see the Twins pay 20 million a year for these two. Are Syndergaard, Eovaldi and Manaea top end pitchers? Down to Rodon, Nola, Severino and Musgrove. (and the Twins are going to outbid everybody for not just 1 of those guys but 2 of them?, sorry I don't see that happening) Then they are going to go out and get a bat for the bench because there is no room for a starter and two expensive relief pitchers. Man I wish I could live in a world where I would believe those things could happen. In my world they try to get Correa back (or sign Swanson to a deal similiar to what they did with Correa if he doesn't have the interest he wants), maybe get Wilson Contreras, bring in a relief pitcher like a Joe Smith and sign a starting pitcher like Jose Quintana or something like that. Also the team you envision is no more a contender then the team they have this year is.
  24. Urshela, Sanchez, Duffey, Smith Garlick, Bundy, Cotton, Archer, Cano and Sano are all on the 26 man roster. (Also you understand that removing Dobnak doesn't open up a spot correct? taking him off the 60 day DL takes a spot away but cutting him or whatever doesn't free up a spot) I am very confused how you take 10 guys off the major league roster and replace them with minor league prospects that need to be added to the 40 and since the 40 is full now some or all them will need to be added to the 26 man and how that wouldn't completely be considered another rebuilding year? Not sure you understand but for every guy that is removed from the 40 and is on the 26 will need to be replaced with another player capable of playing in the majors. For example Urshela is removed the Twins need a major league guy to replace him, ok in this cases it is Steer, Garlick can be replaced by Wallner but the talk is next year is going to be better and the solution is replacing major leagues not only with prospects but prospects that just now need to be added to the 40. To me this is complete crazy talk.
  25. Hope that injured Pitchers come back as good or better than they were, Hope pitchers that have been hurt in the past don't continue to get hurt. Hope the Twins sign a top starting pitcher and change their starting pitching philosophy for said guy. Hope the Twins sign a really good bullpen guy. Hope that that is no regress from Miranda. Hope a 26 year old minor league SS (not even currently on the 40 man) gets us to the SS of the future in Lewis and hope Lewis is what he showed this year in 41 plate appearances. Hope they sign a catcher and Jeffers come back and is better than he was this year. Hope Buxton is at least as healthy as he is this year and that Arraez is in the top 5 in batting average and on base percentage. Hope that Jax and Moran do what they have done so far this year. Hope that two rookies in Sisk and Schulfer are viable bullpen arms. Hope that the following players are at their best Larnach (Pre-June), AK (Post April but with some power), Celestino (pre-July) and Gordon (pre-July) and are healthy. And hope both Cleveland and Chicago play like they did in 22 or at least close to as bad as they played. First I would like to say I hope everyone of those things happen, But lets be honest that is a lot of things that need to fall into place (Now I understand they don't need all that to happen to compete for a division title next year, but if most of it doesn't happen we could be sitting in the same spot next year claiming that 24 is the real year to compete)

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.