Everything posted by TheLeviathan
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
You don't have to keep having the same part of your body getting hurt to be injury prone. Some people are just more durable than others. It's not his fault. He's not doing anything wrong necessarily. But you don't have a list like that and look forward to a pristine career in your 30s of picture perfect health.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
I didn't realize that alone explained the hundreds of games he has missed since we drafted him. Yeah, some of the injuries might just be terrible luck. Some weren't. Some were sliding. Or running. Or catching the ball. Not bad luck, hurt during routine baseball activities. Over and over and over again.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
Yes, it can happen.....but is Robert Smith the exception or the rule? People keep suggesting Buxton's injuries are bad luck, but people who get hurt often don't have to have it happen to the same area all the time. Some human bodies are more or less durable. It's also worth mentioning on this example: Robert Smith was on the field for the Vikings at a better rate than Buxton in a more physical game for the time period he was labeled as injury prone. He also retired at age 28. I'm not sure that example is a good one for a Buxton extension,
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
I guess I might caution that the Twins sending over an offer for him isn't necessarily a "negotiation". And I say that because I'm not sure Byron Buxton is eager to negotiate. It would give me some optimism if that gets reported though!
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
On what do you base the 70M value the last three years? Much of this extension talk is based on a comparison with the Aaron Hicks deal. Well....how's that one looking? And Aaron had nowhere near the history.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
There is absolutely upside he could be an MVP and make that contract worth every penny. But my pessimism is born out of some really tough facts, but facts nonetheless. Every GM out there has access to those facts too: counting on Byron Buxton is a dicey proposition. Counting on 34 year old Buxton? Woof.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
At this point, 40 games doesn't feel like a given and I don't agree he's worth that value. Any GM inking him to a long term is taking a significant risk they just created an albatross that will be hung over their head.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
7/70 seemed to be the speculation but that wasn't reported. In honesty, I can't imagine he gets a 7 year deal for a higher AAV than 10M. That is a ton of risk the team is taking on with that term.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
Someone will pay him a lot of money. No one will give him more than 3 years. I don't think Buxton signs this because the AAV is too low. But if he bets on himself he may not get to 100M on one or two year deals before his body and value give out. That's the gambit here.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
Interesting. I ask because I got the sense from the twitter comments that it was a base 7/70M offer with incentives. 10M AAV sounds like the team has absolutely no confidence in his health and, I'd argue, much confidence in him staying here to make that valuation their last ditch offer.
-
Ken Rosenthal: Twins Trying to Sign Buxton Long Term
What is the extensions length?
-
Cashing In at the Deadline Will Require Painful Decisions for Twins
I think one year is his most likely deal. A fat one year contract with some GM hoping to ride a lucky year of health to value. I don't think any GM who wants to retain their job gives him more than three years. Once you start getting past that point contracts can look like an albatross. Especially when the known track record is as bad as it is.
-
Cashing In at the Deadline Will Require Painful Decisions for Twins
They will for sure take a shot at him, but what people are getting wrong around here (IMO) is that they think he'll get a long contract. Teams will blow a wad of cash in a short term deal, but no one is locking in to him for anything beyond that. A 6 year contract to Byron Buxton is the kind of thing that gets you fired in a few years.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
Until Richardson was signed I was really skeptical that would happen. Now I have significantly more confidence it will. You can shift a 3-4 look in and out of an effective 4-3 with over/under adjustments. Stunting and blitzing is then a 5 man operation with the three big guys and Hunter and Barr and Wonnum moving all over. My hesitation is that linebacker is our weakest group.
- The Trade Deadline - Who Stays, Who Goes?
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
I'm pretty bullish on them as well. I like the investments they've made and I think the team is much deeper than it was in the past.
-
Nick Gordon
What Gleeman/Gordon conversation are you guys circling around for reference?
-
Avoiding disaster
I completely agree with your thesis, but I will note that I think TV ratings are a bad way to judge popularity. TV viewership is simply not what it was 5 years ago much less 20. I don't know if I know a better measurement, just that TV ratings are in a really dicey place right now.
-
Loki - SPOILERS
I understand frustration and a lack of satisfaction. What I'd like to see is less bitterness from a "you either fail or you succeed" sort of mindset. You can't be everything to everyone and some recognition of that would be nice. As you said, clearly strides are being made. Loki tried....maybe it failed....but trying something heretofore untried is something to be appreciated. Other elements of their efforts on representation also deserve appreciation. Perhaps sharing that dissatisfaction along with a genuine appreciation for the effort would help the criticism feel constructive rather than impossible. But that requires nuance and social media sucks at that. And that is where the battle is waged unfortunately.
-
Loki - SPOILERS
I feel like, had they said nothing about their goals, we'd be celebrating today about how the MCU just hitched their next decade to a brilliant black actor to carry the franchise as the binding force. Instead we're trying to figure out if the show was everything for everyone because they acknowledged the character's gender fluidity in the comics. The response seems to not only miss the best parts of the show, but be counterproductive to the next group of producers and talents who want to broaden representation. If the same people are always outraged and upset, it seems defeatist to keep going down that path. Whether the story ending landed with you or not, Jonathan Majors was ****ing incredible. It's exciting to think about what he'll bring. That should be the celebration. Instead the Vulture articles and the one Mike posted are just bitter and unfair. It sucks.
-
Loki - SPOILERS
Definitely and I agree with what you said about non-readers in struggling to understand what they saw with him. That missed the mark just a little bit. They should've given a short glimpse at the kind of variant of himself he was worried about. We got introduced to Thanos in bits and pieces too, I wonder if this scene will look better when we have more context as the future goes on. Not that it helps now for those that didn't quite connect with the character.
- The Trade Deadline - Who Stays, Who Goes?
-
Loki - SPOILERS
I can see why the criticisms with Sylvie and the other side characters being undeveloped are valid. Many in the TVA were underdeveloped because their nature was kept as a mystery for much of the show. I'd say to that.....six hours isn't a lot of time to develop those characters if they are meant to be mysterious. Still, I get it. Where they lose me is in calling Loki a six hour Kang reveal. There was very real, very well done development of Loki's personality and motivations. He started the show as the Loki from the battle of New York and ended it a very much changed person. I don't think that criticism had any validity at all. And the last thing in that review I take away is that if I'm a producer or actor in hollywood I would never mention my intentions about representation on the front end. It is abundantly clear in a variety of reviews for this show that it merely opened the door for critics that have zero intention of ever being satisfied to launch into nonsensical soapboxes. I believe strongly in representation and telling stories that will help everyone feel a part of the fictional worlds of entertainment, but the vocal crowd that opines is simply unreasonable. And their unreasonable nature will influence the experiences of many unfairly and, I worry, influence the willingness of entertainment to take chances and be bold representing all walks of people.
-
The Great Resignation - US Labor Force
Sorry for burying this under Loki! It'll be interesting to see how this shakes out in the coming years. I am not in or near a situation lile this so I don't have much to contribute beyond this bump.
-
Avoiding disaster
I'm not sure it's fair to use the dysfunctional Wolves as any example, but you can't just wave a wand and build a winning culture. Nor is "culture" an achievement you build once and then just have in your back pocket. First you have to identify and acquire talent able to win and give them opportunity to develop. A few wins can be the difference between Anthony Edwards and Jarrett Culver. No amount of buzzing about culture is going to save you with that talent disparity. Of course you have to eventually worry more about wins, but not in a season that is already a disaster.