Everything posted by TheLeviathan
-
José Berríos Traded to Blue Jays
That's different than the last four months....how? I guess we can just stay with a bad team and just hope that we magically become not bad? I don't understand this mentality. The disappointment is already a reality, no reason to double down out of obstinance.
-
José Berríos Traded to Blue Jays
Martin is exactly the guy I was eye-balling if the Jays were the team that landed him. I preferred San Diego's SS, but I'll take this return!
-
If Berrios is dealt, what does the 2022 rotation look like?
Hopefully, by the all-star game next year, younger and much more promising with guys like Duran, Balazovic, Ryan, etc. If not the conversations get a lot more difficult across the organization.
-
Miller: Several teams pursuing Berríos
I dig that the Blue Jays are still in this. They have some nice pitching and infield options that fit well with this team. Not a pure shortstop, but some dudes that are appealing. But a deal to San Diego with Abrams as the centerpiece is my favorite option.
-
Current TV, regardless the year
I'd be curious how you feel about Lovecraft after you finish it. We haven't started it, but I've been wary to because I've heard it fell off the cliff midway through the season.
-
2021 Off-Season Thread
I don't think it's wise to trade an OL with experience for a 7th rounder.
-
2021 Offseason
With FA netting us Goligoski, Kulikov, and other filler parts it seems pretty obvious to me that Guerin wants to change the locker room culture and take a run at a cup in about 3 years. 2024 the dead cap is gone in time to start extending the young players they are banking on. This team is clearing the decks so that Rossi, Khusnutdinov, Boldy, Khovanov, O'Rourke, Addison, and Wallstedt are the future of the team and have a chance to get big minutes. I expect a fun team, but probably not a Cup contender for a few years.
-
2021 MLB Trade Deadline Tracker
Gallo will be launching in New York.
-
Trade Deadline: GM For A Day
Vital? No, but he's not being paid like he's vital. He's being vastly underpaid for how useful, versatile, and good he is. Plus, we've seen the upside there too. I think all you'll get for Kepler is people trying to steal an undervalued asset, you won't get someone to pony up.
-
Trade Deadline: GM For A Day
Maybe they are ok with that. They shouldn't be.
-
Pohlad: Twins "Absolutely Not" Having a Firesale
I really don't understand the reasoning here for preferences. I'm not in the boat that thinks we have to deal Donaldson to acquire pitching (though...it wouldn't hurt), but in order of preference I can't see any good reason to keep Donaldson over either of those guys. Kepler is younger, cheaper, healthier (most of the time), and a necessary piece to have around as Buxton insurance. Rogers is the only part of our bullpen that isn't god awful and he's also cheaper, younger, and healthier. Donaldson is a good hitter, he wasn't a bad signing, but he has a chance to fetch us something interesting before his legs make that contract look ugly. Now is the time to move him IMO.
-
Trade Deadline: GM For A Day
I think Kiriloff is a 1B, not an OF. The team still has a spot for Kepler and, let's face it, if Buxton is our CFer we better damn sure have a guy that can slide over too.
-
Letting Byron Buxton Walk Will Haunt
I appreciate the sobering reality you provided on Buxton. I think it's too pessimistic, but a lot of folks here at TD also are way too far off the deep end the other way. If you read a lot of these comments you'd think they've built churches to Buxton and his baseball career. So if nothing else, you're trying to balance the boat and I appreciate that. But contracts are not just given based on what a player has done, but the potential reward they provide as well. There is very clear risk to Buxton as you lay out, but there is obviously so much reward too. The Twins can't offer 3/35, it's not enough guarantees. If they cut the term down that far, they have to bump the AAV or it isn't worth it for Buck. By adding more years they've been able to cut down on the AAV, which I think is the better way to go in balancing this risk vs. reward.
-
Letting Byron Buxton Walk Will Haunt
Yeah, I agree it wasn't a good example, but there are good examples of contracts that hamstrung a team. Dexter Fowler, Albert Pujols, etc. It can have a demonstrably bad outcome for your team to sign someone who takes a big chunk of your budget and adds nothing. Which is why it's absolute nonsense for some in these threads to suggest 150M guaranteed is the low end of what he'd be offered. No one wants to get Pujols'd. Byron and his agent seem to understand this, which is why we seem to be in a battle of 80M vs. 110M with at least one side expressing optimism we can get a deal done. The Twins are in the ballpark of a fair offer, let's hope they are willing to bridge the gap, even if the risk is high.
-
Letting Byron Buxton Walk Will Haunt
I can get behind almost all of this. He is valuable when on the field and I do think the Twins would be making a worthy gamble to give him 100M plus incentives. Where I will disagree is the idea that 15/20M in dead money isn't a problem, it almost certainly would be. But I believe it is a gamble worth taking if you can keep the guarantees around 15M per year. Even then, I wouldn't put good odds on us looking back at the contract in 2026 and feeling good about it.
-
Letting Byron Buxton Walk Will Haunt
I'd be guaranteeing 52M. If Byron Buxton thought he could guarantee himself a lot more than what the Twins are offering.....they wouldn't be actively negotiating around the known offers. As Hayes implied in his story, the team and Byron agree on large components of the contract the team offered. That alone should tell people what the actual market might pay. Turning down close to 100M has a very high risk of being the last time that much money is on the table for him.
-
Letting Byron Buxton Walk Will Haunt
I think we are negotiating against our own difficult situation more than the rest of the league. Mike's 3/45 idea seems right for the market so if I'm the Twins I offer 7/91 with easy incentives to double that by PAs. But I also demand a 4th year opt out as safety against his risks. The Twins would basically be offering double what anyone else would guarantee for his risk level so I feel like that is a fair compromise.
- Three 'Combination' Minnesota Twins Trade Packages
- Trade Candidate Profile: Max Kepler
- THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
-
It’s time for the front office to step up and ink some deals
I guess I'm coming at this differently than most of you. I would prefer we sign Jose Berrios. He's durable, reliable, consistent, our pitching is an organizational weak point, and I love the kid's approach. That said....I don't believe we could offer anything to Berrios that would have him ink a contract. I really don't. I think he wants to field the market. When he does, I think it'll take 7/140 or 5/125 to be in the conversation, but I don't believe he wants an extension. And good on him, he earned the right to choose where he plays from the best offers available. Buxton? It really depends on the incentives, but I'm ok with something around 7/100 with some significant protections for the team against injury in exchange for incentives for Buck if he's healthy. I think that deal is far riskier and likely to implode on the team. It's also the one that appears doable. So I'd like them to try and bridge that gap and hope the guy can be healthy, but fire them for walking away from a guy who has played 30-40% of his possible games? How on earth is that fair either? If you're firing them, fire them for the failure to build the farm.
- THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
- THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
-
THE ATHLETIC: Buxton, Twins Cannot Come to Terms on an Extension
Well, we know they went from 7/73 to 7/80 right? Sounds like they guaranteed another 1M per season. We don't know what the offers and incentives were and that makes a huge difference in evaluating things. Where I disagree with you is what the market will yield. Buxton will not get 7 years unless he takes a huge hit in guarantees (much like the offer structure we see). If he takes short term deals he might get a good AAV, but if the injuries persist he may not get another deal. That's the risk, but I guarantee you that Buxton will not get 150M guaranteed. No chance. Too many posters here seem to be too close to the situation for an objective analysis.
-
Sign Byron Buxton! (Buxton rejects initial extension offer)
I totally understand why Buck would reject the deal. I'm pushing back more on the mythical pedestal/non-accurate understanding of the market the negotiations are happening in.