Everything posted by Thrylos
-
Free Justin Haley.....more importantly Free-up a roster spot!
This is a huge fallacy Yes, Les Straker ended up being the Twins' third best pitcher there but, if you remember, they started the season, in addition to Viola and Blyleven, with a veteran workhorse who pitched 198+ innings the 4 previous seasons, named Mike Smithson (who fell apart during the season) and a former top prospect who had a very promising 1986 season Mark Portugal (who also fell apart during the season) as their 3rd and 4th starters, with Straker rounding up as the 5th (occasional back then) starter. When Portugal and Smithson bombed, MacPhail replaced them with a future Hall of Famer (Steve Carlton) and a veteran of 20 years who had a 3.50 ERA with the Yankees in 1987 (and ended up winning 221 games), Joe Niekro who gave one of the most memorable performances of a Twin ever (in the David Letterman show.) Not remembering Smithson and Portugal is excusable. Not remembering Carlton and Niekro, is not...
-
Trade or stand pat
Depends on the trade. If it will bring back a younger controllable pitcher, like Sean Manaea or Aaron Nola, I would not mind if they trade any prospect in the organization, other than Jay and Burdi who can help potentially this season and Fernando Romero who I think can be special. If they want to go after someone like Dan Straily or Clayton Richard or Yovani Gallardo, then the prospects I would be willing to include would be lesser... (Disclaimer: the names are for indicative purposes - I don't see the Philies trading Nola, for example. Just examples of pitcher types...)
-
Time for Duffey at SP?
Yes, it is mental. He is afraid to hammer the zone. Same with Berrios last season. Totally mental and hopefully fixable.
-
Trade or stand pat
Someone like Stewart's prospect level, not injury level. Gee. And Stewart has knee issues and when healthy he is treadable. I think that you are missing and/or ignoring the point here...
-
Article: Kernels Ben Rortvedt Is Catching On
Good stuff, and he has great potential, but he has issues adjusting to hitting with wood, which need to be addressed. He is hitting .153/.210/.194 this season, after hitting .222/.306/.253 last season. One cannot continue to be sub-Buterean with the bat, and expect to be a major leaguer, no matter how good the glove is. He needs help and I hope that they realize that he needs help and they give it to him.
-
Trade or stand pat
Agreed, esp. on Dozier. You deal from a position of strength, and unlike starting pitching, middle infield has been a strength in the organization. However, I would not hesitate to add a prospect like Stewart, to a deal for a better return. Makes no sense hording prospects until they become non-prospects or goners. Case in point Adam Walker. Would the Twins be better of trading him or adding him to a package than what they got from him, of course they would. At some point you got to let go, esp. those in-betweeners...
-
Time for Duffey at SP?
So you take an accomplished College closer and try to turn him into a starter, but he becomes a failed starter, then get him back in the pen where he is on his way of shining again, and want to repeat that failed experiment? No Way. The Twins do need one, maybe two starters, but they should not break what is not broken (and, mind you very fragile) to fix that. I hope that Gibson rebounds. The thing with him is mental. They might have to go outside the organization for an extra starting arm
-
Cuban Luis Robert is a FA
Comparing the Twins' market with that of the Pirates and the Royals makes zero sense. Data: Twin Cities: Population 3,615,902. Median Household income: $54,304 Kansas City, MO/KS: 1,776,062 & $46,193 Pittsburgh: 2,358,695 & 20,935 So: Population x MHI / 2 = (approximate market size) Twin Cities: $98,178 M KC: $41,021 M Pittsburgh: $24,690 M So about 2.5 x the market size of KC and 4 x the market size of Pittsburgh. and if you look at the other markets in the AL Central, spare Chicago, there are smaller than the Twins' Cleveland: 2,945,831, $42,215 ($62,179M, ~2/3 of Twins') Detroit: 5,270,909, $22,319 ($58,821M ~2/3 of Twins') And they have been pretty relevant, pretty fast and for longer periods than the Twins. Enough excuses about "small" and "mid" market, because the Twins' is right on top of the division.
- Cuban Luis Robert is a FA
-
Hughes to the DL
That's one of the worst things that can happen for the Twins. They tooked a failed starter and turned him into a decent reliever. No reason to go back there again. I think that it is time for Gibson to show that he can step up.
-
Cuban Luis Robert is a FA
The TR administrations were spendthrift. They would rather throw away $50 million among 6 mediocre players than sign one or two difference makers. Case in point: Ryan's moves when he got re-hired after the 99 loss 2011 season: 3y/ $6.2M Jared Burton 2y/ $6M Jamey Carroll 3y/ 10M Ryan Doumit 1y/ $4.75M Matt Capps 3y/ $21M Josh Willingham 1y/ $3M Jason Marquis 6 players $51 million in contracts, instead of 2 difference makers. They did spent
- Article: Keith Law On The Twins And The 2017 Draft
-
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
The words "Turley" and "prospect" do not belong in the same sentence. He will be 28 in 3 months or so...
- Article: Lewis Thorpe's Return To The Mound
-
Article: Jose Berrios Flashes Something Special
The fact is that at the major league level in 2016, his 8.02 ERA, 1.869 WHIP, 6.20 FIP was below Santana, Gibson, Duffey, Nolasco, Milone, Dean, Santiago, Hughes, and Albers (other than the WHIP on the latter). That would make him their worst pitcher (as far as starters go) in 2016. Dunno what other facts there are, but that's the fact. Potential has nothing to do with performance. Hopefully he got it and will stay at the same level for a decade. Or more.
- Article: Jose Berrios Flashes Something Special
- Article: Jose Berrios Flashes Something Special
-
Article: Keith Law On The Twins And The 2017 Draft
This might be correct, but the Twins took a similar risk in Stewart and seems that it did not pan out. I just don't trust that group to draft high school pitchers. There is another issue also: A College player would a. be able to help the Twins in 1-2 seasons and b. he would be about the same age as the good young core of the team, and with Sano 4 seasons away from free agency, this core might not have the time together to allow a High School kid to be MLB-ready; especially one with one only pitch who might never get MLB-ready, if he does not get at least a couple other plus pitches. McKay is almost there. Greene might not be ready before the opportunity passes for these Twins. Got to look at the big picture here. If Greene had 2 pitches and was putting video game numbers it would have been a different story; and I don't care whether he looks like Adrian Peterson or like Bartolo Colon.
-
Article: Sam Carlson: A MLB Draft Prospect From Minnesota
The same Nick Hanson who had a 9.18 ERA and 2.400 WHIP his first season as a Pro?
-
Article: Regression For Twins Is Likely, But Not Inevitable
Which dropped down to .739 with 2 outs and RISP, .672 in high leverage situations, and .532 in "Late and close" situations. That's what "we people" are talking about... And BTW, Here is the big one about his HR last season: Men on: 12 HR / 248 AB (20.7 AB/HR) . Nobody on: 30 HR / 367 AB (11.5 AB/HR) His career numbers: Men on 35 HR in 1104 AB (31.5 AB/HR), nobody on: 87 HR in 1732 AB (19.9 AB/HR) Numbers do not lie.
- Article: Regression For Twins Is Likely, But Not Inevitable
- Article: Keith Law On The Twins And The 2017 Draft
-
Article: Regression For Twins Is Likely, But Not Inevitable
And that should really be the "All-Star second baseman" who was supposedly worth more in trade than the Dodgers offered. Unfortunately he sucks on big time situations, like today, when he came up with 2 on and 2 out twice and left all 4 on base. But he has been great in hitting solo HRs when the game is not on line. About addition by subtraction time as far as Dozier is concerned...
-
Article: Keith Law On The Twins And The 2017 Draft
One more thing because it is getting to be a pet peeve: How many "generational talents" can you have in a generation? 1, 2, 5, 50? I'd take Kershaw, Trout, Harper (and potentially a few more, with Sano knocking on the door) in this conversation for the current generation. If that number gets to how many, some of them are not "generational talents"?
-
Article: Regression For Twins Is Likely, But Not Inevitable
When I am looking at term like "regression", I'd like to look at data that might so deviation to begin with. Here is some of that for the Twins, and their closest AL Central opponents: Pitching: Twins: 4.80 FIP - 4.31 ERA, Indians: 3.52 FIP - 3.98 ERA, Tigers: 4.57 FIP - 4.77 ERA Twins: 72/7% LOB, 12.2% HR/FB, .269 BABIP Indians: 73.9% LOB, 14.3% HR/FB, .308 BABIP Tigers: 71.2% LOB, 12.3% HR/FB, .306 BABIP Hitting: Twins: .282 BABIP, Tigers: .294 BABIP, Indians: .278 How I would interpret that? Regression as far as hitting is not much of an issue (if anything players like Polanco and Buxton are likely to improve.) As far as pitching goes, it is obvious that Santana and Santiaga (other than his last outing) have been playing over their heads, the bullpen is made out of band-aides and spit and Kintzler has a pact with the devil (or something.) But, I hope that Berrios continuous where he starts to provide a serviceable number 2 behind Santana (at this point) and the one of Mejia (.360 BABIP) or Gibson (.359) rebounds (regresses? ) . That is hopeful likely possible. The pen is a bigger story and the Twins need 2-3 late inning arms to keep it up, whether they come within the organization (Bard, Burdi, Chargois, Melotakis, etc) or outside. But, I'd take first place any day