Everything posted by Thrylos
-
TwinsDaily Awards
I hate this logic. A team does not have to make the playoffs for a player to have been the most valuable to his team in the league. The Angels, Tigers, and Yankees could all miss the playoffs or could all make it going into the last four games of the season. So, each of them was the integral piece of a contender. That's what an MVP is. If they don't make the playoffs, that doesn't fall on any of those three players. Different strokes for different folks. If the Twins did not have Willingham for example they would have probably lost 115 games. Should he be the MVP? No. He is valuable, but not the MOST valuable (same thing with McCutchen and Wright in the NL.) It is not the "best" player, it is the most valuable player. And unless a team goes to the postseason any value any player gives to his team is bettered by another one. That's my opinion. Let's agree to disagree. And pitchers have won this award as well. I think that the game needs something analogous to the Cy Young award for the best hitter. Call it the "Babe Ruth". (in that case, my votes for the Babe Ruth award winners would have been Trout and David Wright.)
-
Article: Ryan and Gardenhire speak to season ticket holders
I cannot believe that he did not say the starting pitching was the most frustrating thing this season. 99% of the people who are following the Twins agree. He either is lying to protect his buddy Andy, or he is deluded. Regardless, he has to go. If he things that the biggest problem with this team and what made them lose 90+ after they lost 99 is "doing the little things right", I just don't believe he has what it takes to ID a root cause of the problem and try to fix it. Apparently he is part of the problem too.
-
TwinsDaily Awards
MVP - too early to tell before final regular season standings AL: Trout (Angels)/ Cabrera (Tigers) / Cano (Yankees) in that order depending who makes the post-season. eg. if the Angels and the Tigers do not make it, it is Cano. If all 3 make it, it is Trout NL: Posey (Giants) Cy Young: AL: Price (Rays) NL: Strasburg (Nats) Rolaids: AL: Chapman (Rays) NL: Kimbrel (Braves) ROY: AL: Trout (Angels) NL: Harper (Nats) Manager of the Year: AL: Showalter (Orioles) NL: Johnson (Nats)
-
2013 Twins with Salaries
Brandon Inge as an option? I see you have Span traded. I suspect that they will get an SP for him. At this point, in order to compete, I think that they need 3 SPs better than Diamond, so they can place Diamond at the 4th spot and let the 5th go to one of the rest who started this season. Assuming that Span + something brings one of those SPs + something, they got to get 2 more. You have them at 73M with Duensing at 3, but he will be closer to 1.5 in his first arbitration.So they got about $20M to spend in a $90M budget. They got to be creative with that. I think that Baker's upside at #2 is too good not to offer a $3-4M plus incentives if he is progressing, so they got to look at one more. I'd have zero issue with getting the other one via trading Morneau because a. it will add $14M to the $15 or so leftover to make it a robust $29 and b. there are no Aces in the FA market and would have to get one via trade. Ryan (assuming he still is the GM) kinda did that with the Lawton-Reed trade back when. Someone like Lester who has pitched better than his W-L record and ERA indicate, might be an option (and the Red Sox need a first baseman) Or even Halladay from the Phillies (I would not touch Lee and that contract with a 50 mile pole) but they do not need a first baseman (but they need OFs). The Twins GM has to be creative in fixing this thing.
-
RA Dickey becomes first Met since Frank Viola to win 20 games
Yes we all missed it. I missed it, you missed it we all missed it. But unlike the 4 you mention by name, a. we are not paid to not-miss it and b. we are kinda powerless to make any difference; unlike those 4. That is the difference. And also look at the names of the immortals who the Twins signed as MiLB FA Ps that season: Brad Hennessey, Yoslan Herrerra, Mike Maroth, Charlie Zink. Dickey's 2009 numbers in the majors: 4.62 ERA, 1.617 WHIP, 5.9 K/BB, 1.4 K/9. Not exactly earth shaking by any means but better than the four mentioned. Plus he made to the majors for a division winning team (remember those years? ) unlike the aforementioned. Also, here are Samuel Deduno's numbers so far this season: 4.44 ERA, 1.544 WHIP, 6.5 K/9, 1.08 K/BB . Not that much different and pretty much equivalent if you look at their relative BABIPs: .267 for Deduno this season vs. ,319 for Dickey in 2009. I suspect that the Twins (pretty much the same people who let Dickie go) will not learn Deduno go. Frankly, if you look at the differences between the Twins' Dickie and the Mets' Dickie are: - He was one more season removed (and now 3) from injury - He has been used as a starter with the Mets vs. as a reliever with the Twins - National League vs. American League - Different manager, coaches, trainers and staff. I suspect all 4 contributed to his suggest; what contributed more and what less, I cannot tell. And, interestingly enough, if you look at Jason Marquis this season and his resurgence after he left the Twins, the last 2 factors are there for him as well. So when there is enough smoke, there must be some fire, don't you think? The Twins seem to be overtly coddling the players they drafted and tend to keep them over players who they got in a trade or via minor league free agency. I guess it has to do with what they have invested into them and hope if they keep them longer they might get some return (Blackburn, Manship Perkins come to mind.) Perkins worked pretty well, I am not sure about the other 2... But, again, look at Dickey's numbers in 2009 vs those of the mentioned 3. There is a lot of frustration with the way the Twins have been performing the last 2 seasons.
-
Twins release Tsuyoshi Nishioka
How come this is Nishoka's fault. It is the fault of people who made the decision: Gardy who wanted more speed to his lineup and Smith who gave it the green light and executed it. People like Nishioka and Butera are who they are. They cannot control that. Others control whether they are in the majors and whether they play. That is where the blame should reside.
-
Twins' 2013 Bullpen
A few notes: Robertson is second in the team in K/9 and only Fien and Burton are less hittable. So he belongs in Group A, and I think that we will see him next season. Look at those WHIPs Capps was ok for a 7th inning type guy but not for the IPs and as a closer. So he will go. Perkins, Burton, Fien, Robertson, Duensing, Swarzak, and one more will be it next season barring trades, injuries and ST phenom appearances
-
Cleveland Fires Acta
Cleveland has been stable. Constantsuckage stable for a while. Same way the Twins have been the past couple seasons. I guess they do not like that stability so they try to find someone who can change that. And they were in the contention path for a while both of the 2 last seasons.
-
Mackey: Twins may make changes to field staff
Bruno is one thing but he has history with the Twins. Cuellar is not a spring chicken and I think might be close to retirement himself. That said I agree. I think if the only move after two 90+ loss season would be to replace Liddle, they better do nothing. They should clean house, but at least Anderson has to go. Cannot keep only the players accountable and call for no scholarships (and still hand one to the Drew) while you tenure your manager and your coaches. Glad to hear that the Pohlads do not like the product their staff (starting with the GM) put on the field. Time to see whether they will do the right thing...
-
RA Dickey becomes first Met since Frank Viola to win 20 games
Little inside dirt here (and this is kinda "common" knowledge: ) The same person who pushed for Dickie to come in is the same person who practically showed him the door.(and GardyNAndy gave the thumbs up.) Here goes the story: Since the early parts of last decade a certain General Manager was so obsessed to prove a point from his scouting days that a knuckleball is a formidable weapon indoors, which made him actually bid the sky for an average free agent knuckleballer and made his team match it in every opportunity he saw. Google "Twins" and "Wakefield" and you will find some interesting stuff about Terry Ryan's "love affair" with knuckleballs indoors. Wakefield re-signed with Boston (a couple of times), the opportunity arose. RA, Dickey was around... he can throw the knuckleball. So that happened. Then the new stadium happened. So the Twins did not play outdoors any more so a knuckleballer was not needed to prove the interim's theory. So bye bye RA, welcome Mr Marquis, (you know those outdoor stadiums have underground rodents so you need ground ball pitchers to kill them...) And, yes it bugs me, and I did lay out the math about knuckleballs 3-4 years ago, but I am still surprised how Mr Interim GM, the manager of the millennium and the pitching coach of the millennium can keep their tails clean of this
-
Ervin Santana-Twins Free Agent Target?
Santana is kind of an interesting guy. His xFIP has stayed pretty much constant all these years while his Fastball dropped 3-4 mph (but his breaking stuff and change stayed pretty much constant, so I think that this might be a mechanical issue thing maybe.) I don't know. He will be 31. He is a lefty. Here is my thinking about next season: a. for the Twins to compete they need at least 2 #1 #2 types in the rotation and a #3 (so you can let Diamond be a number 4 and deal with 5+). b. those guys are not to be found unless they get creative about trading and willing to trade prospects and they get lucky c. they are probably not willing to do b. (and there are like 3 ifs there), so they better trade the excess fat (Morneau/Span/Willingham/whatever else) for younger players and shoot for 2014-5
-
RA Dickey becomes first Met since Frank Viola to win 20 games
ok, Pin it on the Twins. But someone has to be accountable. Who would that be in your mind?
-
Offseason Trade Candidates
Let me put it this way: I've seen plenty of Kendrick in the minors and majors around here. And there is a very good Twins comparable: Anthony Swarzak. Matter of fact, I think Swarzak has better stuff. Kendrick would be a huge huge mistake.
-
RA Dickey becomes first Met since Frank Viola to win 20 games
I hope he does. There should be another question also: Should the Twins' manager and pitching coach be held accountable for letting R.A. Dickey go, while they were planning a season (2011) with Brian Duensing and Nick Blackburn as starters ahead of him?
-
Article: Twins Prospects in Review
Here is one of my gripes with some of those lists that are treated as holy grails: Wonder how many times has Sickel seen Rosario and Arcia play (either live or on TV?) And I am not picking on Sickel. Lot's of those lists are the results of bandwagon jumping from good and bad reviews. (Full disclosure: I saw Rosario about the equivalent of one game and Arcia for like 10 games or so.)
-
Byron Buxton Named Top Prospect in Appy League
BA is (and has always been) biased towards drafted players and against latin american free agents, unless they are can't miss types... So no wonder Pimental and Polanco are not in their lists... And frankly part of the bias here is because they spend a lot of time scouting the US guys as draft prospects and not so many the other guys as July FA signings... That's why they are biased. Seen them more. Plus they are scout-driven so if they went to 2-3 games for the E-Twins and some of these guys had bad days, they would not make their list.
-
Article: Twins Prospects in Review
If anything this sound indicate that inclusion in the BA top 100 prospect lists means absolutely nothing other that a nice status as a trade chip. Remember, the Twins were completing in '92. Wonder if they would have won a bit more before the strike that changed everything if they had traded a bunch of those "blue chip prospects" for some established players...
-
Cleveland Fires Acta
Lets see how long will take the Twins to follow suit
-
Deduno leaves start with "left eye irritation"
Any ideas if he is wearing contacts or something?
-
Article: Homer-Happy Hendriks
I think that there is domination and there is domination in the minors. Slowey had only one season with WHIP higher than 0.834 (and that was 0.958) And his highest full season ERA in the minor before that call up was 2.12. Slowey's worst seasons would be Hendriks' career seasons and Hendriks is pretty darn good. Small sample size to talk about HRs. ... A good comparable to Hendriks is Frankie Viola who made his debut (like Hendriks) at age 22 and had a full season at age 23. Both of those season were not remarkable and then Frankie got the changeup going and became Frankie. Hope that Hendriks follows that trajectory...
-
Article: Where Does Carroll Fit In?
I really think that the middle infield might go 2 ways in 2013: a. let the "kids" (Dozier, Escobar, Florimon,- alphabetical order) fight for 2 starting positions and trade Carroll b. hand Carroll a starting job (heck he is a 2.3 WAR MIF... they have not exactly grown on trees for the Twins) and try to get someone else for the other, while having the "kids" fight for a utility job assumptions: Nishioka is traded to Japan and Casilla is non-tendered (I don't like the latter much, but...) b. makes sense only if the Twins get 2-3 starting pitchers better than Diamond. a. makes sense otherwise.
-
Article: Matt Capps and his looming option year
I am sure that the Twins will look again in the heap pile and find another couple pitchers better than Capps next season (like they did with Burton and Fien this season) I just find it irritating that they are playing him in expense of a prospect or two...
-
Offseason Trade Candidates
Phillies and Span (and?) for Tyler Cloyd (and?). I wanted the Twins to make that trade in the deadline when Cloyd was still in AAA and flying well below the radar. Got to see him pitch the couple last seasons in Reading and at Lehigh Valley and the guy is legid and the Phillies did not value him because he does not throw 98. Maybe the Twins missed an opportunity here.
-
Article: What Would You Do? Jared Burton
Too much... What you are suggesting is a deal better than the one Perkins got. No way the Twins should do this.
-
Matt Capps activated from DL
Of course. Capps is a proven MLB-closer