Everything posted by Thrylos
-
Article: Drew Butera and Defensive Prowess
Yeah but you got to balance things: small advantage (and I take that, over Mauer and Doumit, but not as much as advertised) in fielding but huge disadvantage with the bat. The guy is below AA replacement level. So, is it worth it for the Twins to carry and play Butera over someone who can hit the ball? Not in my book.
-
Article: Drew Butera and Defensive Prowess
30 factual events are 6x the size of 5 hand-held stopwatch events, when they directly contradict each other. And it does not matter if a C can throw fast to second base if he overthrows the man who covers it and the ball ends up in CF. And Butera did that at least 3 times last season
-
Article: Drew Butera and Defensive Prowess
3 words about the analysis: Small Sample Size. All 3 Twins' Catchers are withing the standard deviation for this thing, and much within the standard error of a hand held stopwatch Some real numbers: 2012 Butera: 23% Caught Stealing. League Average: 25%. Butera's alleged "fielding ability" is a suburban legend that hopefully will go away with Gardy and his crew. Horrible move for the Twins, paying a guy below replacement level twice the replacement level salary. Butera's scholarship got upped to $700K. Way to go Mr Ryan. The only good thing I can find in this move is that Gardy will give Butera 300-400 PAs and will cost him his job.
-
SI: Twins Winter Report Card is a B-
I think that B- is fair. The trades were close to A, the Correia signing was an F, and the Harden and Pelfrey signings (if they regain their form and can be flipped for useful parts or extended mid-season) have a lot of potential with little risk.
-
KFFL: Four Burning Questions About The Twins
1. There are All-Stars and "All-Stars". Ron Coomer was an "All Star". There is high likelyhood that Morneau will be at that level. For the Twins to compete, he needs to be at the MVP level. 2. Perkins will handle it fine as long as he stops thinking too much 3. If his manager and general manager trust him and let him get his confidence up, Plouffe will be fine. 4. For the Twins to compete, they better get their best pitching from Harden, Pelfrey and Worley in that order. If Diamond is their "best" pitcher again, we are again in for a long summer.
-
Joe Saunders
I don't think that he is any better than Worley or Diamond right now. And I don't think that he is any better than a healthy Pelfrey. He is not better than a healthy Harden. And I don't think that he is any better than Meyer, Gibson, May or Hendriks once they got their act together. (and probably Gibson is better than him at this point) My point is that the Twins are not going anywhere this year. A #3 or #4 starter in a contender will not "save" them this season and very likely that 3 year contract will make him be like Blackburn was last season. I'd rather see them play the kids who do have a future. He will make the Twins a 75 from a 70 win team? Is that worth a 3 year contract and $24 M and blocking the kids? Not in my book. I'd rather see them save that money and spend it on someone who can take them over the top once they are competitive again.
-
Joe Saunders
That's why you have a crapload of AAAA pitchers along with some prospects. In case of injury. Look at the starters with MLB experience they already have this year (in no order) : Harden Pelfrey Worley Diamond Correia Hendriks Blackburn De Vries Deduno Walters Vasquez Elarton Martis Hernandez add some of the ones who signed as MiLB FAs this year (Jason Lane, Michael O'Connor, Bryan Augenstein, Virgil Vasquez) add the prospects Gibson, May and Meyer and you really need Sanders (who is about as good as Diamond - a #3-4 pitcher) in case of injury? For 3 years? That is enough to fill the rotations down to New Britain and beyond.
-
Joe Saunders
The way it is, with the likes of the Correia signing, Twins' prospects are not only blocked this season (I doubt that more than one of Hendriks or Gibson will see the majors this year with no injuries) but 2014 as well (Diamond, Correia, Worley, Gibson, Hendriks) . So Meyer and Mays and Wimmers and the rest will see action in 2015 unless people are traded/ineffective. Saunders' skills are no better or worse than Diamond's. And they are fine for a #3 or #4 pitcher in a contender. No thanks.
-
Butera, Duensing File for Arbitration
[video=youtube;yiJ9fy1qSFI]
-
Butera, Duensing File for Arbitration
I wish Butera filed for free agency
-
The Twins and Autographs
Sports memorabilia company X pays Rod Carew Y amount of $ for Z number of autographs with the inscription "HOF". Their contract includes the clause that he cannot sign autographs with that inscription for a certain number of years. Company X owns the market for Carew "HOF" autographs.
-
I can't believe it but I agree with Sid Hartman
About this Morris thing: people should let it rest. He does not belong to the Hall of Fame. Morris has a 39.3 career rWAR look at the following non-HOFers Dave Stieb: 53.5 David Wells: 49.4 Jimmy Key: 46.1 Doc Gooden: 45.1 and here is the kicker: Frank Viola: 43.7 so if Twins' fans want to lobby after a former P to be in the Hall, it should be Frankie V (who had a Cy Young award and a WS MVP as well) or even Brad Radke: 42.6 (but from another era)
-
Hall of Fame: Nobody elected
Because of the spitball? (which was legal until practically the '30s and was the main pitch of another Hall of Famer - Ed Walsh...) Hard to start those witch hunts...
-
TwinsDaily 2013 Hall of Fame Ballot
Mine (and the explanation is here) Hall of Fame Ballot: Bonds, Clemens, Bagwell, Schilling. Since players like Larkin, Alomar and Dawson have been recently elected, got to add: (hall of very good) Walker, Trammell, Raines, Palmeiro, Lofton, Martinez Biggio (even though better than Dawson) is the 11th man and loses by a hair.
-
Hall of Fame: Nobody elected
Here is part of the issue I have with this: - Amphetamines are PEDs and now verboten like steroids - Hank Aaron is on the record in a televised interview with Bob Costas (this one) admitting that he has used amphetamines (i.e. PEDs) - Several of the guys who were not voted today were never convicted or admitted to taking PEDs; a couple of them actually proven innocent in courts of law. So the writers are going on a crusade based on I don't know what, forgetting the "innocent until proven guilty" including the ones who were proven innocent, while a. ignoring admitted PED users already in the Hall (Hank Aaron) and b. (one idiot) voting for Aaron Sele the same time. Hypocrites if you ask me. Do I like Clemens and Bonds? No. They are A%$Iols. Ty Cobb was probably a bigger one than them. Do they all deserve to be in the Hall? Heck yeah.
-
Mackey: Twins Likely Done Making Significant Moves this Year
turn the "how" into "because" (i.e. dealing players like Hunter, Cuddyer, Morneau, Willingham at their highest value before they become too expensive to keep or too bad to get anything in return - eg. Liriano) and you got 50% of your answer. The rest would be not about a quarter not signing oldies but not goodies because you need proven "inning eaters" (Correia, Blackburn, Pavano), "closers" (Crapps), "infielders" (Punto, Carroll) or keep horrible players around (Butera) and about a quarter having an analytics department that is able to crunch numbers and identify targets based on performance and not on whether they can "spin the ball", "kill worms" or "battle their tails off"....
-
Hall of Fame: Nobody elected
Well, not exactly. Here is my take: (copying and pasting from the MLB HOF website, bold for emphasis is mine : ) Since 1936, the Baseball Writers' Association of America has held the exclusive voting privilege to consider recently retired players for the National Baseball Hall of Fame Who gets into the HOF is a matter and responsibility of the HOF board that delegated that privilege to the BBWAA and the Veterans' Committee. I think that if that idiocy with the writers' voting continues (a vote for Sele, really?) the HOF should and probably will revoke that privilege and find another way of inducting retired players. In 1936 there was barely TV and the writers were the only ones who had the ability to see the players in a regular basis. In 2013 this is not the case, so the need for the writers to be the ones voting should go the way of its (almost) co-current alcohol prohibition That simple.
-
Nick Blackburn - potential ace?
Blackburn has 2 young kids (and 2 more are on the burner.) That much for training
-
Brandon Inge and Yuniesky Betancourt
+1 Bret Boone, Tony Batista and Brian Buscher are also available and Ryan knows those guys pretty well too...
-
Prospect list in depth, Part Four: 21-30
Love your Burris placement btw Main reason is that he has a plus (soon to be plus plus curve) and there are not many pitchers around who can claim that. One can live with an average-plus FB and a change of pace change as long as he can control that FB and throw the nasty curve any time in the count for strikes.
-
Josh Burris
Been a while I will let you know about A in March after I come back from ST and not sure about B any more. He has had 3 pitches. Not sure how much the change has improved.
-
Jason Frasor
I have just a simple question: in a 99 + 96 loss team that has a 9th (Perkins) and 8th (Burton) inning guy, how much a priority should be a 7th inning guy? Given the 99+96 Ls (in my book, I wouldn't even waste $ extending Burton - he is 31 - trade him. Get the kids to pitch in relief and there are many college power arms coming in the pen from the recent drafts. But Ryan has millions to throw away to the likes of Correia and Burton)
-
Worst Twins of All-Time Series: Butch Huskey
Really? Huskey??? He was not even the worst player in that lineup that season. That would be Matt LeCroy. with an OPS+ of 46 that season vs. Huskey's 64. Huskey has a career 96 OPS+ in the majors. I can thing of many worse players to wear the Twins' uniform. He had a bad half season. So what? Are you going to include Steve Carlton in the series as well, because he really underperformed when with the Twins? Gee. If you want to do a father and son special, pick the Buteras. Neither of them can even dream to be half the players Huskey was.
-
Terry Ryan to receive award next week
Nope. But giving a lifetime achievement award to someone who already is in the Hall of Fame is somewhat silly. Like giving Babe Ruth a lifetime achievement award in Baseball.
-
Terry Ryan to receive award next week
Maybe a little known fact (at least to the ones who have not yet visited Hammond Stadium at Fort Myers.) : In addition to Hammond Stadium being the home of the Twins for Spring Training and the home of the Fort Myers Miracle in the Florida State League, it is the home of the Baseball Scouting Hall of Fame. A bit understated (a bunch of plaques on the wall), but Terry Ryan is already included among the other members. So: Terry Ryan is in the Baseball Scouting Hall of Fame. Why would a lifetime achievement award would top that?