Everything posted by PseudoSABR
-
POTUS Donald Trump
So an agenda of half-measures is the "good"/good-enough that will win? Again, I think that's what led to Democratic losses throughout the last thirty years. (Obama's brand of hope, identity politics, and mainstreamism not withstanding). I don't necessarily want Democrats to boycott anything but the most progressive policies. But I want them to be authentic, and I want them to stand for something. Yes the Democrats are fractured, but it's time for the moderate Dems to give a little on universal healthcare, universal education, and checks on corporate power and uber-wealth--I think these are issues the vast majority of Americans can get behind, esp. if Democrats can avoid being smug/sanctimonious when campaigning on them. However, I do think it's smart to stay away bringing in incendiary issues like guns, identity politics, abortion, etc. into the agenda, even though I feel passionately about those issues, and in that sense, I hope, liberals are willing to give up the perfect.
-
POTUS Donald Trump
Not that I am endorsing indignance but I think the left being pragmatic is how you ended up the Clintons, Gores and Kerrys as their candidates. I think the left should be authentic and not bend over backwards trying to appeal to everyone and thereby appealing to no one really. That said, the left should be wary of being righteous; showing authentic disgust with genuinely disgusting behavior I don't think comes off as sanctimonious as some seem to fear.
-
POTUS Donald Trump
I care. You should care. Let's not make it easy for them by shrugging our shoulders. There's plenty of Trump voters who regret their choice/candidate. Maybe we can't win them over but we can't allow them to assume the moral high ground ever again. Ever again.
-
POTUS Donald Trump
This whole revised his statement narrative is maddening. Though it's such a non-surprise that he was lying, it's not news at all. We live in the nether world.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Blue Jays, 4/30 @ 7:10pm CT
I just can't...
-
Fernando Romero Starting Wednesday
Niiice
-
Souhan on the Twins
I think Molitor needs to show more willingness to leave his starters out there even if they are giving up runs; we end up burning through the bullpen in games we are already likely to lose and we end up with a depleted bullpen in games we can actually win...
-
POTUS Donald Trump
It's okay to criticize people who do good things. It's also okay to admire people who sometimes do/say bad things. What's not okay is taking either the criticism/admiration and generalizing it to group of people/political party or personalizing it to a specific poster.
-
Current TV, regardless the year
I agree. But that said, Paker Posey does play a pretty unlikable character. I still think of her hazing days from Daze and Confused.
- Race and Rosario
-
Kinley's Magical Horseshoe Remains Intact
I don't fault the Twins for wanting to keep Kinley; I fault them for not working a trade, and having to guarantee him a roster spot in order to keep him.
-
Non-Twins in-season news, tidbits and transactions
Alex Cobb has gotten knocked around (and that's putting it lightly) in his first two starts. Did signing late lead, at least in part, to such results?
-
Race and Rosario
Right. The other side has been acknowledged and assured ad naseum that they aren't being accused, but they refuse to accept it, and it's gotten to the point where the solution they really seek is for there to be no discussion. I think the tone of the conversation has shifted because conciliatory measures got the discussion no where. And now we should acknowledge the feelings of those who aren't even accused? Give me a break. (Imagine if we suggested that we should be thinking about the feelings of Latino players? We'd get laughed off the message board!) And I just want to point out again, how problematic it is, and representative of the very issues we are getting at, when we are told to try to make it easier for white men to participate in the conversation. When there is literally a dearth of diversity contributing to it, nor is anyone advocating to make it easier for such distinct voices to say how they feel.
-
Race and Rosario
Look, you made an observation that the offended group is still participating in a conversation about race, they certainly are talking about either how we should shut up or about how offended they are and how they are entitled to it. It certainly seems like you're suggest we should acknowledge that as something good (hence my line about praise). Now, as far as not listening, that's blatantly not true. And if there's any truth to it at all, it applies to greater force with those who find offense. I certainly understand that no one wants to be accused of being a racist (said it many times early in the thread). But no one is calling any one a racist. (Listening?) Maybe there's an implication that some people might have racially informed implicit biases, but that's not accusation, and that implication is nothing that needs to be wondered about quietly. (Yes, someone actually asserted that we shouldn't even talk about it!) Again, if people can get offended by implication; they certainly accept the proposition that implicitly people of color may be legitimately offended by a general trend without any direct racism going on. (And hence no proof, no one person to blame.) Sounds like your use of "listening" is code for legitimizing their right to be offended, which I won't. It's privileged, snow-flakey, and self-important, and worse it refuses to allow even discussion of the issue.
-
Race and Rosario
They aren't participating on the merits. They are meta-discussing it; and centering on their own perceived offense. That's not worthy of praise.
-
Race and Rosario
If people here can feel accused wit out actually directly being accused, imagine how people of color might feel about systemic biases that don't manifest in direct "quotable" racism. Again, you don't get to demand direct proof of racism when the basis of your supposed offense is totally indirect and implicit. There's some irony for you. It's literally impossible to know what motivates each individual (to see inside someone's head and heart, to know whether they are truly racially motivated, even subconsciously)--so asking us to name to names and point figures is totally futile. Yet, what remains is a social phenomenon where specific derogatory language and criticism are levied disproportionately at people of certain races. Sure, it may be frustrating that we can't solve the systemic problem by calling out individuals--but it's totally pollyanneish to believe that a systemic problem can be solved by weeding out the real baddies. Part of the point some of us are making is that we may all be part of the problem (which Craig and Brock have willing implicated themselves). Why don't people of color post here? Why don't women post here? I couldn't possibly have anything to do it with it. Not me. And because I'm so innocent, I'll just ignore the obvious feature this very conversation has much less its subject matter.
-
Race and Rosario
Oh it closes off the conversation that we'd be having if I wondered quietly to myself? Give me a break. Basically you're saying shut up. It would be impossible to have any conversation about any social phenomenon that might be systemic or latent if all we can do is wonder about it fear of offending some white dudes.
-
Race and Rosario
I think this is simplification in favor of getting offended or the push back. In my mind, there's a meaningful distinction from "being racist" and having implicit biases that might be racial informed. The former is far more objectionable, and while the latter may be an uncomfortable proposition, it is totally forgivable given the systemic nature of the phenomenon which we're talking about. I think the nuance and the distinction matters, and it's only when we erase that nuance and distinction that the pushback is at all justifiable.
-
Race and Rosario
How can an accusation be implicit? Because if it is, wouldn't simply wondering about it on some level imply that some wrong doing by someone is happening? So then wondering wouldn't be fine, because it would imply an accusation? (I think part of the substance of an accusation is that it is direct and isn't made through implication).
-
Race and Rosario
Aside from being absurd and that racial bias often doesn't emerge as a preference (as opposed to an absence of criticism), it's not materially different. I think it's fine to wonder about what appears to be disproportionate treatment of players, and to ask the question about what might explain that uneven treatment. My point in what you quoted was that your criticism of Mauer has no bearing on the collective treatment of players of color. Again, I assume your criticisms of any player aren't racist because you've always appear to base your opinions on observable facts not on generalities; that said, I do think your stance throughout this thread has shown some snow-flake-white privilege in being offended/asking for evidence/demanding people to name to name names. I mean is it so hard to imagine that some people's (DEFINITELY NOT YOURS) criticism might be tainted by implicit biases that become more significant when viewed in the aggregate?
-
Race and Rosario
Is passive aggressive wisdom, still wisdom? When we implore others to be nice, isn't our criticism implicit? (No need to answer, I'm just being difficult.)
-
Race and Rosario
If a person doesn't have an actual factual basis for criticisms that go to a player's character or intelligence that person opens themselves up to valid criticism. We can't just call a person lazy or stupid without having specific facts that go beyond what we've all observed within the lines and not expect some flak. Assumptious and speculative criticisms that go to a person's character is worthy of being knocked down. Now does that necessarily open up a person to criticism about racial sensitivity, perhaps not; but it certainly doesn't preclude it. Sure, it might be that they are cynical or arrogant or just largely assumptious about nature of other people's effort and intelligence; it might not be racism, but whatever it is, it's not founded with facts. And more, when those criticisms in the aggregate get applied disproportionately to players of color, well, it'd be crazy not to at least ask the question. And really, are we such special snowflakes that asking people to consider if they might have implicit biases is some how offensive and accusatory? Honestly, there's no greater proof of privilege than finding offense in the mere questioning of implicit attitudes. (And the whole "I criticize Mauer too" angle uses the same logic that "I have Black friend" narrative does. The comparison makes me cringe, and again, focuses too much on the notion that any one person is being accused of anything, when people are going out of there way to say it's not the case.) And yes, all lives matters.
-
POTUS Donald Trump
I wonder what actual legal services Cohen provided Hannity. I doubt it was estate planning. Is the reason they wanted to hide this is to keep up the myth of Hannity's disinterestedness?
-
Race and Rosario
What kind of evidence of racism would satisfy those looking for it? No one is suggesting there's some overt hate letter, a smoking gun, a burning cross in Sano's front yard. In fact, many have gone out of their way to suggest that racism of this sort is latent, an implicit bias, systemic in operation, only detectable on the aggregate. There's unfortunately no direct evidence to provide (at least here on Twins Daily), but we can look at general trends, and disparate treatment between like players. Of course, we can't know with certainty whether the criticism levied at Sano or Rosario is tainted with an implicit bias, but it's not wrong (nor accusatory) to ask the question. I'd also like to point out, that while I can understand that it's insulting to suggest that one's criticism of a player may be, in part, tinged with racism. It's equally insulting to suggest one's notion of social justice is predicated on the nice feelings of righteousness one alleged gets from using the word racist. Indeed, a conversation like this, among largely white-males, maybe enacts some of that privilege.
-
Race and Rosario
Especially on the internet, I think condescension is easy to lapse into. This article reminded me of David Foster Wallace's Commencement speech at Kenyon years ago, a fantastic, important read if you haven't come across it before.