Everything posted by PseudoSABR
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
No worries. In a conversation like this, it's easy to talk passed one another. There's nothing that Grienke has done specifically, but certainly taking that position is way to drive up your price. I mean there's lots of reasons for professional athletes to disassemble about something like that. Maybe we can take Grienke at his word, but it's hard for me to imagine him going to Houston or Minnesota if they marginally outbid a competitive, big market franchise. If the Twins could have signed Grienke by substantially outbidding competitors, well, I'm not sure that's so wise--at least when we were so far from actually competing. I'd rather sign a Grienke (not that there is going to be one) next offseason or the following one, when the core begins to emerge. I know that's too long for some fans, but I'd rather concentrate our assets to optimize the fantastic minor league talent and depth.
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
Dude, I specifically mention critiquing TR for not signing "such-and-such pitchers" (i.e. the good ones) in what you quoted. (I didn't intentionally leave it out of the sentence before that, if that's what you thought). My point is that you can't have it both ways. And more than that, crediting and critiquing TR is spurious business, because in my opinion (and I think supported by the short and cheap contracts so many pitchers signed) is that beyond the first tier the FA pitching pool was a crap shoot. I'm implying no such thing. I don't know what Grienke thinks nor do you. All we have is something he said to the media. I tend to be pretty cynical about what any professional athlete says about contracts and where they want to play. And as RP, points out LA would certainly help with his branding and outside baseball income. I doubt he'd eliminate that from the equation, in spite of what he outwardly said.
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
Right, too many are assuming they have as much information as the FO does. I think many are relying too heavily on stastical analysis (because that's all they have to work with). I wonder how the various prognosticating metrics (Zips etc) did in predicting how all of these free agent pitchers would do. My guess is that they did no better than the ML GMs... It would be an interesting exercise.
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
Your framing the Corriea signing to make TR look as foolish as possible. It just seems intellectually dishonest, especially when you really have no idea what KC's trade value is (likely more than next to nothing). Ryan didn't do a good job, but in my mind, a good job wasn't really possible. Evaluating TR is based not only the pitchers he acquired, but also the ones he avoided. It's dishonest to continue to critique TR for not signing such-and-such pitchers and not to credit him for avoiding such-and-such pitchers. It's a wash.
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
And you don't know his level of sincerity, lip-service, and media sweet-nothings. You can go on believe that if the Twins would have paid Grienke one more dollar than the Dodgers did he would come here, but I really doubt his decision was so simple.
-
International Talk: Miguel Alfredo Gonzalez
If money-dumping Dodgers have lost interest, I wonder if there's some serious redflags (injury/age/peds)...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Angels 7/22 9:05PM
What with his eyes? I'm an out-stater, mlb.tv sucker, so I'm deprived/privileged from seeing the postgame show.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Angels 7/22 9:05PM
That was a fun game to watch, honestly. Thanks everyone for the company.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Angels 7/22 9:05PM
His facial expression is so boyishly surprised.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Angels 7/22 9:05PM
What the heck is the closer doing in there? You just can't use your best reliever in the highest leverage situation if it's not the ninth. They get the jitterypanics!
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
Spy, I really don't want to respond to you piecemeal, but I do want to respond to your one quote and try to address all your points in earnest. It doesn't. That's my point (what the heck do we know, right?). We're working with incomplete knowledge and many of us are deriving a haughty sort of certitude. Look, I'm not so sheepish as to use an internet message board group think as some sort of grand baseball wisdom--I'm looking at the short and rather inexpensive contracts each pitcher received (as well as so many of the ones that didn't worked out)--the material market value of these pitchers as dictated by people in baseball paid to priceout that market. I just don't think there's meaningful scouting or statistical evidence to separate the group of Saunders/Villenueva/Haren/Blaton/McCarthy/Marcum/Baker/etc--yes, some have more obvious warts than other, but largely as the result of the contracts they received are viewed as risky endeavors. Only a few teams are celebrating their offseason pitching acquisitions. Again, you're expecting the ideal scenario. To the suggest that Twins didn't buy low on Correia, Pelfry, Harden, Worley is to ignore the context of each acquisition. Not all these buy lows worked out, but they certainly cost lest than Santana. Villenueva never topped 120 innings and has average around 100 for his career--there's not substantial statistical evidence that he could withstand as a starter--it would have been a good signing for the Twins, but that it was an obvious one is hardly a given. I concede on Saunders, but really he's a mid-rotation starter in his mid thirties (which, yes we have so few of). My point on Saunders is that we can't be certain about the nature of his failure to sign. You assume the Twins messed up rather than got screwed. And on Colon, no one offered him enough to pry him away from Oakland, the guy has obvious question marks, and he's known cheater who probably will end his career in suspension. You mentioned quite a few names, and as we parse out each case, it's pretty understandable why the Twins took a pass (or didn't desire to overpay). Really, as I've said, I believe beyond the first tier of pitching, the market was a crap shoot (as demonstrated by the contracts such pitchers received), and you don't. Yes, the Twins should have positioned themselves to acquire another of the questionable commodities, but the one they acquired could (maybe likely) have been just as bad. And again, there's more spots open in the rotation because of the epic failure of Diamond and Worley (and yes, there's applicable criticism to be levied against the Front Office for counting on these two).
-
Game Thread: Twins@Angels 7/22 9:05PM
Dick acts like his viewers don't watch the Twins often (heck, even occasional)..we know about the two-strike Mauer thing, because you tell us about it every time Mauer has two-strikes. Jesus.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Angels 7/22 9:05PM
Well, that's a heck of lineup, anyways.
-
The Dominos begin to fall
Is that the general sentiment among Brewers fans? Is there a viable/non-rube message board for the Brewers?
-
The Dominos begin to fall
Peter Gammons was just talking about (on the MLB Network) how there's been a shift in players attitudes, to the point where the Player's Union no longer seeks to defend cheaters in the same capacity. I'd like to hear from more current players decrying what Braun has done. I wonder how the Diamondbacks (at least those on the 2011 playoff team) are gioing to react when the face Braun next.
-
July 22nd
Rosario didn't play in either game today. Hmm. Walker with another homer, Sano too. Berrios and Duffy with nice nights. Baxendale did pretty well as well.
-
The Dominos begin to fall
Todd Sutton @toddsutton @AaronRodgers12 you really believe he didn't you PED's???? #delusional Aaron Rodgers ✔ @AaronRodgers12 @toddsutton ya I'd put my salary next year on it. #ponyup#exonerated 5:47 PM - 23 Feb 2012
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
I also want to note that the relative short deals so many pitchers received this offseason is an acknowledgment by baseball front offices what a crap shoot (beyond the top tier) free agency pitching was last year (and probably is in most years).
-
Houston's Bud Norris on Twins' radar?
I agree, but I'm happy to see that they are looking for pitchers in all capacities.
-
Zimmerman trial
I cleaned it up a little, while you were quoting it. But yeah, I stand by that you treat reasonable liberals* far different than you do reasonable conservatives. *I suppose this opens up to how unreasonable and crazy I am, and how liberalism itself is some exercise in illogic.
-
Zimmerman trial
Like I said rare. I can't imagine anyone whose watched you debate with others over the years would disagree. It's fine dude, you're conservative, but you're reasonable, so it's interesting to debate with you. (And really calling out the crazies from either side, does nothing to diminish one's own bias). Dude, you're coming at me! You trying to call me out for being rude and dismissive of other points of view, and you're doing exactly that. You consistently use the word Lefty as a pejorative and rudely try to frame my thinking as some liberal heathen hell bent on finding racism in everyone. I think my tone and my reasoning has been pretty diplomatic, even if you don't agree with them. Honestly, you haven't showed me the same courtesy. And really, do you think I'm so dull-witted to let the media shape my point view so thoroughly, I can see through the media sensationalism and still believe this is an incident of racial injustice--and that race played a role, as you said. (Certainty, aside, which as I said, was more a figure of speech about the the confidence in my opinion). Like Smerf said, which I agreed with! That doesn't mean that race wasn't involved in what happened that night and the following days. And to say the 'real' source of the problem is exactly the kind of rhetoric that should bother you. There is no one 'real' problem; it's absurd to rank the problems in terms of realness. I realize that your use of real is a colloquial as my use of certainly; but the irony here is palatable. It's fine that you disagree about whether or not race was involved that night (and I'm not even sure that you do), but to suggest I am trying to shape the terms (by using the term 'certainly' as opposed to 'real) so the debate favors me is totally false and does me a disservice. And if I remember correctly you thought Zimmerman was going to be found guilty of manslaughter--now that he wasn't you don't see some injustice in that? I just don't really understand why you're coming at me so hard.
-
The Dominos begin to fall
Don't get me wrong, Arod is a total punk.
-
The Dominos begin to fall
Ryan Braun is a piece of ****. The Lance of Armstrong of baseball. Even Arod has more class.
-
Zimmerman trial
Dude, I'd have a lot more respect for your point if you showed the same investment in policing conservative assumptions/terms (which are littered throughout this thread and the forum in general), which you rarely do if at all. I mean you're acting like your approaching the conversation from objective point of view. You're not. No, it got national intention because of public outcry--the sensationalism came later. And, no, I didn't ignore the facts of the case I drew different conclusions from those facts. I don't want to get into arguing about the case again. And how the heck to did I "come after" Smerf--who was pretty aggressive in his response to Shane for pete's sake. The first sentence of my post responding to Smerf was "I agree with this."
-
Article: Grading Last Year's Free Agent Pitching Market
I think that's pretty fair, and it's why I'm not so worked up about this issue. While they could have done better than Pelfry and Harden and while it stinks to suck now--I think there's a better time to invest a lot of money in pitching, when we're actually about to compete--which could be next year if the Twins are aggressive with their prospects.