Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

PseudoSABR

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by PseudoSABR

  1. So if Bernie beats the Republicans by 10 to 20 points, you really are maintaining that won't have an effect down-ticket. (And can we get some support/links for some of these assertions; both you and Dave are generalizing and making broad statements of fact without making the effort to support it. The things you are assuming are true, I'm not sure actually are. You're discounting the value of having a mandate from the voting public; this notion that Democratic Congress would impede Bernie's agenda is absurd, and if it were the case, well, we need new democrats. And the notion that Clinton would have an easy time dealing with a Republican Congress is also absurd. The Republicans will equally impede who ever the nominee is. Sure Clinton might be more willing to appease them (but that's not necessarily a good thing). Honestly, this line of thinking is the same one that gets liberals negotiating at the 50 yard-line. I'm sick of it.
  2. Actually they do. I haven't seen one poll that has Clinton doing better than Sanders in the general. (And seriously, why wouldn't you check something like that before (incorrectly) correcting my post? If you're going to tell someone how it really is, might want to make sure you're right.)
  3. It's clearly not making any difference? Although I think he cannot win the nomination, his recent success has made significant difference in the polls (for the first time nation wide polls show him leading, and he's closing in California and to some extent in New York). It's probably too little too late. But I don't think Sanders' 'unqualified' remarks are made out desperation, but from poor judgement resulting from that WaPo article I mentioned above.
  4. The polls suggest he would fair much better against the Republican candidates--my suggestion is should that occur, it would, indeed, help elections down-ticket. If he were the nominee do you doubt that he wouldn't stump for other candidate or help fund them? I'm sure the primary season has chilled Hillary's efforts to do the same. (Again, this whole party v. Bernie thing is so...oddly establishment politics, as if loyalty to the party should inform our voting preference.) And you mistook my mirroring values comment; I'd suggest that either Democratic candidate reflects liberal values, even if they aren't our preferred candidate. I didn't mean mirror as a perfect reflection, but rather to simply emphasize voting on values and not on the candidate is far more important.
  5. I'm not sure how my post elicited this response. I don't doubt that Bernie-or-bust people exist and are loud and annoying, but I think they are full of hot-air and will come to their senses. Let's not be such people. I just don't get the point of drawing a line; or trying to make the 'unqualified' statement some undermining their 'friendship.' I see it as unfortunate politics; Bernie's campaign and himself responded hastily to a shoddy-sourced WaPo article titled, “Clinton questions whether Sanders is qualified to be president.” It's too bad Bernie went tit-for-tat and did so aggressively, but I don't get why you drew the line here. It just seems arbitrary and hasty and replicates precisely what annoys you about Bernie-or-bust people.
  6. I know they exist; but I don't know any personally, and no one here posts to that affect. True Bernie-or-bust supporters, in my mind, probably wouldn't be inclined to vote at all, if not for Bernie. The all-in Bernie supporters I know would definitely vote to keep the Republicans out, no matter the candidate. Like I said before, I think this my-candidate-or-nothing attitude is a lot of posturing and I think people will come to their senses and, if nothing else, vote against the Republican's candidate.
  7. How about leader of the United States and off-shore tax havens? Narrows the necessary qualifications, a bit.
  8. Do a set of qualification even exist for the leader of the free world? The job requires a skill-set beyond any one person, experience only gained through a disqualifying career.
  9. That's some stomach-turning logic right there. I'm just surprised.
  10. He'd have a liberal mandate for the first time since 1920, and if he brings a host of democrats into Congress with him; well, it would seem that Sanders helped redefined what it means to be Democrat. And really the party-loyalty thing from supposed liberals is well anti-progressive/liberal. It's not about what team wins, and about getting people that mirror our values into the right office.
  11. I don't know any Bernie-or-bust supporters. But I guess I know some Hilary-or-bust supporters. And I think your very wrong on Bernie running against Hillary if he loses the nomination. He said yesterday that he would support her. I know there's lots of never-would-vote-for-Hillary people, and they drive me nuts, but their attitude isn't rooted in loyalty to Bernie, rather it's (unfairly) adverse to Clinton. Let's not be either of these people. I honestly don't get your attitude towards Bernie; I don't like his comments about Hillary being unqualified (even as a retort to similar comments she may have made), but campaigns can get ugly, and largely he's been very classy towards Clinton with some media-emboldened exceptions. You've said in the past that issues like the Supreme Court and women's right are tantamount to you, are they less important than how they candidates are treating each other late in the primary? It just doesn't make sense from the values are more important than any candidate point of view. Honestly, this feels like a bit of hot-air, as Bernie is unlikely to win the nomination, and you really won't face a choice of voting for Bernie or benefiting Republican.
  12. So you'd really let a Republican benefit from your non-vote? Goodness.
  13. As I've said a few times in this thread, this evidence wouldn't result in a new trial, because it was available to the defense at the time of the original trial. They would need other grounds for a new trial, but this evidence would be useful (if true/reliable), no doubt.
  14. All that's just speculation. Like I said we can all invent scenarios to match the facts. The prosecution, however, would need a specific narrative that is believable beyond a reasonable doubt. (Again if what the data suggests is true,) you may find it more likely that murderer went parading around town with the cellphone, I find it more likely that the victim left with her own cellphone before whoever murdered her. In any case, if the murderer or the victim left the property it creates doubt to the prosecution's version of the truth.
  15. Oh I know. And I made the point that I don't even think this evidence will satisfy the test for a new trial as it was available to the defense at the time of trial, not necessarily because of the questions about the data's reliability. They will need other grounds for a retrial other than this, and they might have such grounds, though this evidence might be more useful to their overall defense. In retrial, if granted, the burden, of course, falls back on the prosecution to make it's case beyond a reasonable doubt.
  16. Why the heck would the murderer kill her and then go do something with the cellphone yet hide the Rav4 on Avery's property? That doesn't make much sense (and probably defies the time-frame). If Avery really did do it, and the cell phone data is credible, I'd find it more likely he followed her after she left, and then killed her somewhere off property. (Still I think this has time problems and witness problems). We might be able to invent some sort of reality where the facts still fit the prosecution's case, but reasonable doubt begins to creep in pretty quickly when we start generalizing our explanations to what frantic murderers usually do... If you want to argue that she wasn't killed on the Avery property, the placement of the cellphone is evidence towards making that case. Therefore it has value in the court room. The cellphone data does not need to by-itself unravel the prosecution's case; it's simply part of a larger defense to create reasonable doubt. I think people are overlooking the fact that the burden of proof is on the prosecution, not the defense.
  17. It doesn't suggest that she was alive - that's not why it would be useful as evidence. It suggests that the cellphone left the property, which is a fact the prosecution's version of events would have to account for. To use your Occam's Razor analysis, is it more assumptious to believe that Avery left the property with her cellphone even though he was about to murder her or already had; or is it more assumptious to believe that she left the property herself? It doesn't mean that Avery didn't murder her, but it certainly casts doubt on the prosecution's version of events and timeline. Although it's not smoking gun of innocence (which is silly concept anyway), if true, this evidence is unquestionably important. (I don't get the tendency to want to dismiss the evidence, honestly.) Could the data be unreliable? Sure. (And a judge ultimately decides this questions after arguments from each side - so it certainly might not get into "evidence," but it also could in few different ways). On the other hand, how much should such data be trusted and what does it really prove? Well, those questions go to weight; they would be litigated in the courtroom and the jury would ultimately decide how much to trust it and what it means as far as proving Avery's guilty or creating reasonable doubt.
  18. I'll just say this I find it highly problematic that this evidence is being dismissed without actually knowing what it consists of (all the probabilistic supposition notwithstanding). I also find it equally problematic to question Zellner's integrity. Thank god Occam's Razor isn't a legal doctrine.
  19. Fair enough (and your explanation makes sense, but...). Such data is still easily collected. I doubt Towers are sending pings out every second, whatever data they have collected may be sufficient to account for the error. The data might be fallible within a given range, but that range might still preclude the Avery property. For me, why I keep living with the possible fallibility of the data is that evidence need not show where Halbach was at, but where she couldn't be.
  20. So you doubt the data exists at all? What data do you think Zellner has? The cell tower information was probably collected in the days following Teresa Halbach disappearance; there was an immediate search. You may doubt that the cell company kept such simple ping-data for a matter of days, but I think it's very possible that in the search for Halbach, authorities were able to get such data from the cellphone companies. Of course, as Zellner indicates, the original defense may have blown it by overlooking the meaningfulness of such data.
  21. That they'd need any where near the amount of data you're supposing. The cellphone need not ping the cell tower every second, it could be a much larger time frame than that; and the cell tower need not record every ping. They need two pings from the same tower at even intervals from the outgoing phone, in order to indicate a radial distance. That's really - a minimum - of six data points for triangulation, and I imagine the data has much more than that. We don't know how much data they were collecting and in what intervals. That the cell towers need to receive the ping at the exact same time - (that really wouldn't make much sense if they did), rather the towers need to receive the same outgoing ping from the cell phone in order be validly compared. Receiving the pings at different times would account for the disparate distances between the differing towers and the source of the ping. Again, we don't know what the data precisely consists of and what auxiliary evidence would help ensure it's validity. That regardless of the imprecision, such data could exists that would foreclose the possibility that the cellphone was on Avery's property throughout the affair. Even if the area of the location is very large, Avery's property could lie outside of it, and that's the essential fact. The data already exists. It was accumulated during the lead up to the trial. The defense failed to 'discover' it. So I don't really understand your past tense point.
  22. And I hate cognitive bias and assumption-laden analysis. Cheers.
  23. Without seeing what data they have, I don't know how you can make a probabilistic determination like that. (For my part, I think you're overestimating the precision in data they'd actually need for that data to have evidentiary value, but I don't really want to argue that point any further). And where's the implication that Zellner is somehow incompetent or grandstanding coming from? I guess I just can't dismiss what she's saying about the 12 miles away from the property as an obvious falsehood or overstatement.
  24. And if Avery's property falls outside the hypothetical 100 square mile area, it has evidentiary value. (The evidence is not where precisely she is, but rather where the data indicates she could not be.) It seems like you're suggesting there's some technological impasse that prevents the possibility of the ping data being meaningful -- that's not the case. The requisite data might actually exist.
  25. You don't need the cell companies to triangulate; all they'd need is the ping data from more than three cellular towers over a period of time, and from that data they could 'triangulate' a location. Though that being said, they tried this method to locate that plane that went missing that one time, I don't think they found it.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.