Everything posted by PseudoSABR
-
Dozens killed by truck in France
Well, that's my issue, I don't think we are outlining it correctly. Again, I think the reality of terrorism emerging from Islamic culture has less to do with Islamic culture itself than it has to do with Western imperialism of the middle east. Islam may provide the basis for organizing and mechanizing hate and violence, but the current violence is not perpetuated on the basis of infidel, or cultural supremacy, its a direct reaction to Western meddling, wars, and occupation over nearly a century. For my part, suggesting that Islam should go fix itself, or that we somehow should fix or change Islam is a total nonstarter of a solution; I'd rather address what our culture has done to create the current violent climate.
-
Dozens killed by truck in France
The fact that many, many Muslims believe some really antiquated and oppressive things does not explain the recent phenomenon of radicalized Islam attacking Western societies. Sure, the oppressive dogma allows such hate and fanaticism to take root, but no more than Christianity allowed for the KKK to shroud itself in faux-religion. For my part, I think Western, esp. US and Israel, policy towards the Middle East in general since WWII provides a lot more meaningful basis for the emergence of Islamic Terrorism than the Quran or Sharia law. It took modernization, democracy, and the promotion of social welfare for Christian societies to shed many of their antiquated and oppressive regimes. I think focusing on what is wrong with Islamic belief is a mistake, rather focus on what is wrong with Muslim's people's quality of life, and I think we'll get better sense of the roots and motivations of Islamic terrorism/ISIS. In general you can't kill an idea, a belief, or even a religion; but you might be able to help foster a world were people are less likely to put stock in such ideas/beliefs/religions.
-
Trade Thoughts
Thanks. I mean that makes sense but for some reason the club option didn't occur to me. So much the better, as the option is an added attribute to Suzuki's trade value. (Gosh, if the Twins don't deal him, they're gonna exercise that option aren't they...)
-
Trade Thoughts
The unfortunate/fortunate thing about the Twins pieces that have some value--Nunez, Santana, Dozier, even Plouffe--is that they are under team control for at least another year. That gives the Twins leverage in not having to make a deal, but it also allows the foolhardy myth of being competitive next year to influence what the Twins may do. I fear that a team will have to overpay in terms of prospect-value to force the Twins hand. So my prediction is nothing much happens. Edit: I forgot about Suzuki who should definitely be on the block, and given his batting line this year, his vesting option might be desirable to an acquiring club--to give that vesting option value (i.e. so the acquiring team can give Suzuki enough PAs to trigger) the Twins should look to deal him sooner rather than later. The lack of credible major league catching, I also fear, may stay the Twins hand.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Is there a regular mounted police? What makes them Royal? Calling back to antiquity?
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
I was with the article until I came to this paragraph: If there is police discrimination at work, it would operate on both the initial encounter and the actual killing. To suggest that police discrimination isn't a big factor in the actual killing seems off-the-mark. The same discrimination that may lead to an unjustified arrest (or encounter) may also lead to the unreasonable use of lethal force. The author's explanation about why police encounter and arrest more African-Americans isn't data based, but rather arm-chair sociology, that seems bent on finding factors beyond race. Maybe I'm picking nits or I'm failing to grasp the author's point about the significance of the data, but the analysis seems titled towards the more compelling conclusion (that race isn't a factor).
-
Best Minor League Signings of 2016
Part of being really bad is that you have the opportunity to addition the best of minor league signees
-
Throw in Prospects
Ugh. Throwing in a prospect would work against the Twins' desired ends for a number of reasons: First, to a pennant-chasing team, that extra lower-grade prospect is virtually meaningless. At best, it would serve to outweigh extra added cost of the contract (which *sigh* Twins). Second, if the trading-team had a better prospect it was willing to part with, it would seek a better pitcher than we have to offer. Santana is a good asset, despite the word around hear, but he's not the game changer you give up a piece of the future (and that's what we seek in return, right?). Third, these are prospects, we shouldn't give up our 'prospect' in addition to a valued tradeable asset, to obtain another 'prospect' whom is more highly regarded. That's the strategy Delmon Young trades are made of.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
I apologize, that paragraph needed some unsaid conceits; I was speaking ideally, which can be righteous, so ugh. Yet, it's madness that it is a negotiation at all, given the supposed 'balance' of the relationship, one group being the other's employees. The charge--again--seems to be YOU SHOULD NEGOTIATE TO GET THE OTHERSIDE TO THE TABLE. I cannot concede that point. Nonetheless, negotiation, of course, inevitably, is required--not with those who represent the exclusive interest of police, as an end into itself (as the unions might), but with those good actors who seek to do the possible. And I mean good actors in the sense of willing to address the problem, that's really I want at this point. (And not just on this issue. Non-negotiation, of course, is a conscious tactic, no?)
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
That last paragraph is straw man. I'm totally willing to listen and understand other people's perspective on any issue. And really, I think you're putting my character out of context, there's plenty of incidents in the election thread, where I politely engage and seek to understand those who think differently. But when I post a link in this thread, I don't need to give "both sides equal due." I think I do just fine of leaving whatever link I post unadulterated by thieving liberalism (boo). There's bad actors on "both" sides, yes, yes, yes. But I'll continue to emphasize it, only one of those are paid by the people's taxes, have a duty to protect us from harm, and safeguard our constitutional rights. This isn't a negotiation. The police are our employees. The whole notion that we should grant something in return fails to acknowledge the absurdity of the balance of the two groups I spoke of in the previous post. All that said, whether it's Black Lives Matters or some dumbass internet poster, the fact that someone speaks without violence demonstrates one's willingness to engage. The whole 'treatment of both sides' issue is one that just delays assessing/fixing the problem.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
I just want to echo this. I hate grandstanding. I hate righteousness. I generally think protests are unhelpful; they pursue the wrong direction, when they should be assembling to hold a community forum as an alternative to what they are protesting. And, any impediment of actions by those not directly involved in that which is being protested is totally unhelpful to the cause. Don't block traffic, you're just being a dick.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Balance might be overvalued thanks to the Fox News channel. I try to be fair. I try not to editorialize when presenting articles and others' ideas. I tend to edit/fix my posts when I notice errors, oversights, biases, or when they're brought to my attention. And yet, still, I feel the need to hammer in one direction. That's not because of ideology, that's because of results, a result of that unwillingness to come to the table. Here, one group is a race who is composed of people who did not choose to be part of that group, on the other side, are public officers who are paid from tax revenue, which inevitably includes the former group. An error in balance is to suggest that each group has equal complaint or as much work to do to change the happenstance. It seems to me, by duty of public office, just one group is obligated to supply the most give....yet, we should some how leave blameless those who abdicate their second-job's duty because of some perceived offense? Give me a break. Why is the phenomenon of police brutality emerging in the twenty-teens? Because the power of the police is embedded, it's defenders from blame were infinite and powerful, and the law of land was written and construed to favor that authority in nearly all circumstances, with near immunity. Forgive me, and others, if we tend to be a bit unbalanced in our caricature of the phenomenon. Balance, so-called, has been part of the problem.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Right, Levi. I'm not going to pretend not to believe what I believe, or be from where I'm from, but I'm so there at the table, willing to listen, willing to be wrong, but in the face of defiance and obstinacy, it's very difficult to keep one's composure, which, in turn, makes it difficult to keep coming back to the table. I don't say this to chide anyone, but rather to implore a general of willingness to not ask 'why should I help out, why should I give up what I believe' but rather ask, 'what can I do to help fix the issue?', whether if it's their "place" to do so or not. People worry too much about blame, and who's really at fall, and who should carry the burden of making things better--when in reality, the problem is systemic, has no source, exists only in a latent state, shaping policy, discretion, and fear, never emerging as that hateful beast we call racism. It does not take racists to build a society where cops kill black people, it only takes do-nothings, and not-my-problems.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Link More from here.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
At some point you have to assess how much you want the "police pursuing armed criminals." Does Castile's look-like-ness constitute probable cause for a stop, probably not, hence the need for the "broken tail-light" rationale. At what point must person NOT LOOK LIKE the suspect for the police behavior to be unreasonable? If we value the lives of innocents more than we value seeking to punish those who MAY have committed crimes; well, this officers behavior is inappropriate. On Driver's licenses, etc. The second point is that Castille is NOT the perp and looking at his Driver's License may have provided enough information to rule him out as a suspect. Again we are looking for disengagement. Not Justification for the cop's actions. (The problem is not that the individual cop messed up but that the rules of engagement allow for latent racism and assumptions to guide such engagement). -- In any case, no matter how much Castille may have looked like this suspect; the officer's actions are unreasonable (whether they are predicated on bad procedure or individual negligence) and the result is unacceptable. The notion that somehow had Castille really been the suspect his death would have been more justified ENTIRELY MISSES the problem of how police over-use force.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Good stuff here on Black lives matter wearing law professor https://imgur.com/a/YkDVQ
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Indeed. If they ran the plates and found that it was registered to a person who fit the description of the person actual in control of the car; well, they've found another way to eliminate unnecessary engagement. Either 1) the person is actually the suspect and he registered the car under his name, and his identity can be corroborated through driver's license. (And more caution can be taken in engagement) 2) the person is not actually the suspect and he registered the car under his name, and his driver's license can be compared to the suspect's, and lack of identification can be confirmed. (And no engagement is necessary.) 3) the person in question is not the person the vehicle is registered to, and more caution can be taken to corroborate identity. Checking the plates and comparing suspect description to driver's license may not actually CATCH the bad guy, but it would corroborate an INNOCENT person. What really bothers me, is that you too, are starting with the presumption that person-is-the-suspect, rather than that the person-is-innocent. We should value protecting the rights and LIVES of innocent people, more than we should value attempts to catch supposed criminally-liable persons. The goal should be: how do we disencourage unnecessary engagement, rather than bending-over-backwards justifying that engagement. Even if the person was actually a suspect of the crime, he too, has not yet been found guilty, and deserves the presumption of innocence (i.e. not a cop death sentence).
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Well that's why you got to pull him over so you can check his nose? Heck we should have police check points where black people have to step out and get their nose measured, so we can really be sure to get this one suspect of this one crime days ago. (The crazy truth is that there's enough suspected persons out there that look like each and everyone else to provide justification for police engagement with each and everyone of us.)
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
This is all good stuff. But continuing on the whole no sense of urgency thing...if they have plate numbers, they can track the persons registration, and thereby his driver license and corroborate identification issues without the need of the officer ever interacting with the person. (My sense is again, that the 'suspect' stuff, along with the broken taillight are just 'excuses' and not 'reasons' for the pull over. The cop doesn't so much believe he's found a suspect as he is looking for a reason to meddle and hopefully detect some ticktable/arrestable offenses in the course of the meddling.)
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
So you're okay with pulling over everyone who matches however vague a suspect's description is? The value of catching robbers days after the crime does not supersede the fourth amendment rights that establish the need for probable cause/reasonable suspicion before pulling someone over. If wideset nose, or black guy, is enough to establish such probable cause, well that's a problem for me. The rights of look-a-likes should not be abrogated in the name of tracking criminals down. (I wonder what the statistics suggest about random pull-overs based on suspect descriptions days after a crime. My bet is such a strategy produces pretty low results.) Call me cynical, but I tend to believe cops look for 'excuses' to pull a person over, hoping to discover indications of other crimes than what initially led the cop to pull someone over. And such behavior is in part what predicates unnecessary police engagement.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Part of the police mentality that is so problematic is the notion that the Ends justifies the Means -- which you simply keep echoing without even assessing how problematic those Means really were. The notion, which you keep implying, is that these people some how deserve to get busted by law enforcement (and if death happens, well, its probably their fault because they are bad criminals) is EXACTLY the kind of dehumanization that breeds reckless police authority. We need to stop with this barbaric concept that some people are bad and deserve what's coming to them. That's predicated on a judgment without any due process of law, with scant facts, and lots of assumptions, which is a kind of mentality that is shared with bigots and racists. It's not simply not up to you, or the cop to make such a profound and life-affecting judgment.)
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Rangers, 7/10 @ 2:05pm CT
It took a while, but they made up the call on the pick off.
-
Castile shooting, police violence, race, etc side discussion
Excellent article from a black ex-cop.
-
Twins Player Power Rankings
I like the idea a lot, but I'm unclear of the standard, as there seems to be a mix of recent production, season production, potential future production, value as a trade asset, and hype. Explaining how you weigh each factor would go along way to putting them in context, and making them meaningful.
-
Tribute
Speaking of reform; Baltimore recently overhauled their use of deadly force policy, focusing on the 'sanctity of human life'. In reading about that policy reform, I came across the Peelian principles of policing, which I find very relevant and something to aspire to. The nine principals are: 1. To prevent crime and disorder, as an alternative to their repression by military force and severity of legal punishment. 2. To recognise always that the power of the police to fulfil their functions and duties is dependent on public approval of their existence, actions and behaviour, and on their ability to secure and maintain public respect. 3. To recognise always that to secure and maintain the respect and approval of the public means also the securing of the willing co-operation of the public in the task of securing observance of laws. 4. To recognise always that the extent to which the co-operation of the public can be secured diminishes proportionately the necessity of the use of physical force and compulsion for achieving police objectives. 5. To seek and preserve public favour, not by pandering to public opinion, but by constantly demonstrating absolutely impartial service to law, in complete independence of policy, and without regard to the justice or injustice of the substance of individual laws, by ready offering of individual service and friendship to all members of the public without regard to their wealth or social standing, by ready exercise of courtesy and friendly good humour, and by ready offering of individual sacrifice in protecting and preserving life. 6. To use physical force only when the exercise of persuasion, advice and warning is found to be insufficient to obtain public co-operation to an extent necessary to secure observance of law or to restore order, and to use only the minimum degree of physical force which is necessary on any particular occasion for achieving a police objective. 7. To maintain at all times a relationship with the public that gives reality to the historic tradition that the police are the public and that the public are the police, the police being only members of the public who are paid to give full-time attention to duties which are incumbent on every citizen in the interests of community welfare and existence. 8. To recognise always the need for strict adherence to police-executive functions, and to refrain from even seeming to usurp the powers of the judiciary of avenging individuals or the State, and of authoritatively judging guilt and punishing the guilty. 9. To recognise always that the test of police efficiency is the absence of crime and disorder, and not the visible evidence of police action in dealing with them.