Everything posted by chopper0080
-
Terry Ryan interview on Fangraphs
My issue is with their approach at the plate, not their plate discipline. My issue is that Twins players consistently struggle to work opposing pitchers into fastball situations, and when they do, they either miss it or take it to progress the count. I have never thought the Twins taught a free swinging approach, but I do feel they have failed to instill the desire and ability to crush mistake fastballs in hitter's counts.
-
Hicks
Doumit being our starting catcher in 2 years is a bit of a stretch IMO.
-
Terry Ryan interview on Fangraphs
My biggest issue with the Twins hitting has been their approach. The Twins seem to develop hitters who aren't great at working counts to their favor and then making the most of their opportunities. Maybe this is because for a while now, the Twins have never stacked a lineup with solid hitters, top to bottom, like the Yankess. It always frustrates me when our players "miss" mistake pitches and foul them off or hit short fly balls. Even Mauer takes a ton of fastball strikes that I believe he could crush, but he is a good enough hitter to be effective with two strikes and not a lot of hitters are.
-
Action Plan for the Second Half of 2012--Part 3
I don't see clearing an outfield position as a NEED, but if the Twins can improve their middle infield or starting pitching by trading a current outfielder, they have to consider it. I find it hilarious that people think the Twins HAVE to trade an outfielder when in fact, they should only do so if they get a solid offer which improves some key areas of this team that are lacking.
-
Article: What Would It Take To Come Back?
In reality, all it will take is good, consistent pitching and timely hitting which we haven't had all year. We do play enough division games for it to at least be a possibility.
-
Article: Trade Target Team Profile: The Pittsburgh Pirates
Span becomes more and more of an option as long as Pedro Alvarez keeps raking. If Alvarez keeps hitting, I would look for the Pirates to pursue options that have more long term value rather than short term fixes. Putting a legit lead off hitter with team control for the next few years in front of McCutchen and Alvarez will be a more attractive option for the team as it will almost have to give up pitching prospects to gain a player.
-
Article: What Would It Take To Come Back?
The issue I have with trading Willingham is it would create a huge hole in the 4 spot of the lineup and deprive the Twins of the RH power bat they really need in Target Field. Being able to hit home runs is so key for teams these days and Willingham is the one player, outside of the unbelieveable year from Plouffe, that provides this. In my opinion, if we did need to compete and thus keep Liriano, the only viable option would be to trade Span or Revere, and then call up Hicks. He is ready defensively and has been improving at AA. He also brings a similar skill set to the table. I don't see us contending as a real possibility, but who knows.
- AA and AAA
-
AA and AAA
What is interesting is I agree, but think Arcia is probably the most ready of your aformentioned prospects to make the jump to the majors from a hitting standpoint. Where I would hesitate in promoting everyone but Arcia is that leaves him little protection in that lineup. Pitchers won't have to pitch to him which could hurt his development in commanding the strike zone as a hitter. All premier players want to help their team, and to put a young hitter who seems to command the strike zone in a situation where teams don't have to throw him strikes could very well lead to him expanding his strike zone in order to try an make an impact in the game as is expected of him. It might be a bit far fetched, but I have seen it happen. I am curious to see what Hicks does if promoted to AAA where there are less talented pitchers but ones who are more technically sound. In my opinion he either struggles because pitchers can bait him to chasing pitches outside of the zone or he blows up because he is able to crush more balls coming into the zone. All in all, I guess I would prefer to see the Twins move these guys up sooner if they aren't comfortable allowing them to make the jump from AA to the Majors. I understand the Twins don't want to call guys up to sit the bench, but it isn't like we are fielding a hugely competitive major league club right now. If the Twins do trade Span, I would love to see what Arcia could do in RF if the Twins think he can consistently lay off pitches outside the strike zone.
-
Liriano .... 4 more starts???
My question is why would Liriano take a deal like this when he is in the prime of his career. He will hold out for a long term deal which I would say would probably be 3 years WITH an option or 4 to 5 years without. Make no mistake about it, Liriano is looking to sign the biggest deal of his career while he is still young. This is pretty much it for him. When he hits the market, if he continues his current production, he will probably command 13 - 15 million per year for 3-5 years.
-
Liriano .... 4 more starts???
This is the main reason I believe the Twins have to trade him. Re-signing Liriano now is more than just paying him market value, it is about paying him enough to forgo exploring what he feels he is worth on the open market. If the Twins were to trade him, they could add a prospect and then wait to see what Liriano's market value turns out to be. If the market for him is shallow, they can always offer the 9 or 10 million per year that most would like to sign him more. If not, they can explore other options knowing they at least got some value for him leaving. If the Twins keep him this year, they are stuck. Either he is successful and signs a big contract with another team, or he regresses again and they didn't get anything for him when his value was at it's highest.
-
Reasoning on starting pitching rotation
Worst case, the Twins can roll out a 6 man rotation of Pavano, Blackburn, Diamond, De Vries, Hendriks, and Walters (if he comes back) and use Deduno as a long reliever or to fill in if Walters/Pavano doesn't come back. The Twins do have options, but I have to think they will think to 2013 and try to determine what options they have on roster and what holes they will need to fill via free agency. I believe this will be expecially true for Blackburn, De Vries, Walters and Hendriks. Blackburn to see if he can regain his sinker, De Vries if he can continue to provide 5-7 quality innings, Walters the same, and if Hendriks can make the leap as he seems to be able to dominate AAA. 3-4 inhouse options coudl put the Twins into the market of Grienke, but if not, I would look for them to consider multiple, lower costs alternatives because there is a huge lack of #1's available in our system.
-
Added Pressure.
The Twins could sign Anibal Sanchez and Colby Lewis for about 21 mil which will be about what Hamels and Greinke get per year.
-
AA and AAA
My biggest belief between the two would be pitchers need work at AAA because it is critical for them to prove they can get outs while throwing in the strike zone. In AA, many of the hitters are less disciplined and chase more pitches. This is why I feel AA is the top proving ground for hitting prospects. If they are successful at AA, it shows they can force top talent level pitchers to pitch in the zone which is critical to make the jump to the majors. It is also the reason I think pitching prospects need to go to AAA where they will face less talented hitters, but those who are more disciplined and will force them to develop "out pitches" in the strike zone.
-
Sano vs Harrison
I don't see a need to move either of them from 3B in the near future. They are young and can hit so even if they end up needing to move, their bats will keep them moving up through the system. Playing time can always be found in the minors so I can't see either of them blocking the other.
- Justin Morneau--Part of the Solution or Part of the Problem?
-
The Revere Experiment: Range vs Arm
I am an out of town Twins fan so I don't see many games and would rather pose a question to consistent viewers than make too many guesses. To my knowledge, the ball in target field carries further to left field than it does to right field. Using this assumption, this would mean there are more playable balls hit to right field vs left field ala more balls travel over the fence in left field and more plays are made at the warning track in right field. Because of this, it would make more sense to me to have a player with better range in right field because he will able to get to more balls as there are more playable balls hit to that area. My question to those on the board is, is this true? If it is, my thoughts would be why isn't Revere in CF and Span in RF? Both have plus range and Span has the better arm, so why wouldn't you flip the two? You would not be sacrificing as much in range as you would by moving Willingham over, and would benefit from having the better arm in RF. Honestly, I don't think it will matter too much longer as I see Span being traded either this season or during next offseason for an arm for the bullpen which would move Revere to CF. If a trade like this happened, I wouldn't be shocked to see the Twins pursue a player like Nate Schierholtz from SF who has the reputation of being a plus outfielder but has been made expendable by the Giants moves lately.
-
Article: What Would A Francisco Liriano Contract Extension Look Like?
Shanewahl, Nick Nelson, sbknudson, and Musk21 have it right. Make a trade now that Liriano's value is high, and get something in return. If he makes it to the open market the TWins can always pursue him at that point. If the market was depleted of starting pitching talent then I could see trying to extend him, but it is flush and the Twins would be doing themselves a disservice by not trading him. Potential is just that, potential. Liriano may have it, but his track record shows it is a pipe dream. I alos think Anibal Sanchez would be a great signing, but I wonder if he would bite on a Twins offer. I would guess he will command around 13mil on the open market.
-
Article: Are Span's Days in Minnesota Numbered?
You make a deal that improves your organizations pitching or middle infield depth. If you can't upgrade either of those areas, you hold onto Span until next year and shop him again. We hold all the cards to get the best deal possible.
-
Article: What Would a Francisco Liriano Trade Look Like?
The definition of insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting a different result. That is what not trading and re-signing Liriano would be. He has always been inconsistent, why you would want to invest more money into a car that may or may not start on any given day is beyond me.
-
Nick Blackburn and Sunk Costs
You probably have to try him in the bullpen to see if you can salavage any value from him in the future. I think he is done as a starter, and was last year as well. I wouldn't be crushed if they DFA him however.
-
Article: What Would a Francisco Liriano Trade Look Like?
A couple of points... 1: I highly doubt Liriano or his agent would accept an extention by the Twins. They see his value as rising right now, and pitchers tend to do very well in the free agent marketplace. Also, they know if the Twins don't trade him they are planning to make him a qualifying offer, so it's really a no lose situation from his standpoint. 2: As far as the return for Liriano, I think we have to realize the most likely option is probably a high end, low A pitcher or a mid range AA/AAA pitcher. I would be fine with either. We are rebuilding, and the last thing a rebuilding team should do is take a high doller risk on an inconsistant player rather than upgrading their minor league talent pool.
-
Article: Liriano Rediscovers the Slider
At some point you have to stop chasing the pipe dream of Liriano and his "ace potential" and move on, hopefully while also adding some sort of prospect that could develop into a contributor. I would rather pay Anibal Sanchez 12.5 million than Liriano any day of the week. I get the "potential" and "upside" of Liriano, but not trading him when his contract is nearly up and letting him walk for nothing is stupid.
-
Daniel Bard to Sign?
Good job by the Twins.
-
How to Fix the Starting Rotation.
This give us time, while also putting a competitive product on the field. It's not really likely for the Twins to make a total turn around in the offseason. What Sanchez and Marcum give us is quality pitchers who can keep us in games, hoping Mauer, Morneau, Willingham and Plouffe can bang us in enough runs. Both of these guys can give us 3 quality years so develop Hendriks, Gibson and Wimmers, and improve our overall pitching depth.