Everything posted by beckmt
-
40-man roster decisions, part 1: position players
First of all, St. Paul should have a great pitching staff to start next year, as I don't see the Twins bringing any of the prospects to Minneapolis to start the year, Position players are not hard. 3 catchers if you do not trade Garver, Sano and Kirlloff at 1B (also Kirloff in the outfield), Polonco at 2B, or SS. Gordon, Miranda, arraez and Donaldson (if not traded) at SS and 3B. Lewis on the 40 man, but not in consideration to start, Palacios I might add as SS depth. Buxton, Kepler, Rooker, Laurach (will probably expect him to start in St. Paul), Celastino and maybe a free agent depth outfielder, that gets me to 18 which is what I expect to have. Only thing that would change if I were bowled over by an offer for Buxton or Polonco for what I felt was a pitcher with a #2 floor and other prospects. You win with pitching. Cleveland has been competitive with their good pitching (even without much hitting).
-
40-man roster decisions, part 1: position players
I can see keeping Rooker, since he still has options if not traded. Buxton seems to be OK with long term, let's get it done. Pohlads have always stepped up for long term face of franchise assets, that is how I view Buxton. If we sign Buxton, can see Kepler and Garver packaged for pitching. Too many holes to fill there. Gordon and Arraez and fine for utility players and should be kept and see plenty of AB's. Cave should be gone. Can see starting Kirlloff in left field and give Laurach some more AAA time until ready. He was rushed this year. If you don't resign Buxton this list is going to look a lot different.
-
End of the Line for Brent Rooker?
There are other players stated about like Cave and the Turtle, I would move on from first, plus a lot of the injured 40 man roster people Garlick, Refsynder, and other marginal players on the 40 man. He does have an option, which has value, but a trade after the rule 5 draft for pitching is probably the best we can hope for (As a minor part of a package for a mid-level starter.
-
How do you define "ace" and is Jose Berríos one?
A lot of pitchers carry the cavet 'when healthy'. You could add Strasburg and Thor to that category. If you add 10 or more years, you find very few pitchers who qualify now, because most of them don't reach the majors until about 25, and 10 years is a long time. That may be the push for the Twins, when not good, get the youngsters up here, don't waste there bullets in the minor leagues. But service time issues play into this a lot, which is too bad. If you only go by world series, remember you need pitchers to get you there. Big Don Newcome was an example of this, won 20 games almost every year, never won a world series game. Right now there is a very small number of aces. Someone earlier counting, 10 was about right.
- 3 Twins Players Set to Bounce Back in 2022
- Three Starting Pitchers to Trade for this Winter
-
Who is your top position player FA target?
I would rather see if Martin is ready and role multiple players thru SS. That will get us another year to Lewis or Palacous, We need to spend money on pitching. To me we have to extend Buxton or we might as well go to a 3 year plan. I am more in a trade mode to identify a pitcher (Marlins, Cleveland, TB) and send Kepler and others for a decent starting pitcher. Most players on the Twins are decent moneywise, so it could work. For the SS if you are going to buy one, I would look higher up the list, Baez might just get a QO and accept it.
-
Who is in your 2022 Opening Day Lineup?
This is all based on whether or not the Twins are able to extend Buxton. I believe they will, because of the PR hit if they cannot. So C - Jeffers, Rortvedt 1B Kirloff, Sano 2nd - Polonco ss - Martin 3B - Arraez LF - Miranda/Laurach CF - Buxton RF - Kepler DH - Sano/ host of others Garver is traded if we can get value, Donaldson is traded to get money for pitching down the road Martin may not be the answer at SS, but I like the idea of pest hitters. Players that make you throw strikes and a host of pitches. This club would seem to do that and become a problem with the bulk of players creating high pitch counts, which will ruin pitching staffs for days after a series with the Twins. This club will not require a huge payroll for the position players. I would funnel that money into really upgrading the pitching staff and running a host of near ready pitchers through to see what we have. Kepler will be here because he has little value at this time. Cleveland, which fits well as a trade partner, is not going to give up a good starter for a package headlined by Kepler.
-
OPINION: The ‘Fire Falvine’ talk should stop (for now)
That would be hard to do, but they are supposed to be the pitching gurus . And some of that was Gardy's one size fits all hitting approach for the Twins. Not playing to the hitter's strengths
- Game Score: Yankees 6, Twins 5
-
OPINION: The ‘Fire Falvine’ talk should stop (for now)
Do the names, Gil, Nick Anderson, Badaoo, john Curtiss, and another reliever or two ring bells. Under TR, Twins almost never lost players like this. This is a much higher rate than almost any in the major leagues. That is my issue, they were unable to identify talent from the prior regime. Most of those pitchers would have made a quality bullpen this year. I am concerned this offseaon, they will be unable to tell the good from the bad, and we will have more cases of this.
-
Has Minnesota’s Defense Improved or Declined in the Second Half?
Was surprised by Arraez. Twins will need a shortstop, and maybe depending on how they feel, move on from Donaldson and move Sano to DH. Buxton is the other factor to extend or trade. A lot to be determined here, but the Twins if Buxton stays and they have an average SS, rate to have at least an average defense next year.
-
Garcia outrighted to St Paul
Or Ryan to start tomorrow.
-
Game Thread "Heads", Twins vs. Brewers 1:10pm cdt 8/29/2021 ad
Is there any reason Jax should be on this club next year? We need to find many pitchers , so almost all should get a look.
- Game Score: Twins 6, Brewers 4
- Game Score: Twins 6, Brewers 4
-
Minor League Report 8/28 Offensive Explosions and A Curfew-ed Game
pitching seems to be hit and miss these days. Coming off a year with no games at this time probably to be expected.
-
Twins Minor League Report (8/24): Saints Begin Battle For Division Lead
Not quite, if there is a floor (possible, not certain), the injury would reduce Maeda's number to $3 million. Twins would need to extend Buxton and sign a couple of more players to get anywhere near $100 payroll. Donaldson would be the only player over $10 million and most of the rest are on long term (Sano, Kepler, Polonco) or not even to arbitration yet.
-
A conversation Baldelli and the FO need to have, and I want to mediate.
That might be this year, I mean going forward next year.
-
A conversation Baldelli and the FO need to have, and I want to mediate.
Sometimes with players like Gant, Garcia, and Garza you need a different voice. Gant has major league stuff and possibly the other ones also. I don't mind that. However Smeltzer and Thorpe and no more than long relievers at best, so let's move forward from them.
- Twins Minor League Week in Review: Debuts, Promotions and Lots of Wins
-
A conversation Baldelli and the FO need to have, and I want to mediate.
At lot we do not know. First what is the new CBA, but you may have to make decisions before that. If you are sure there is going to be a floor, you have to resign Buxton, because otherwise you are not getting there. Keeping Gordon around is a possibility to backup center along with other positions. 3 players who have no future here are Cave, Simmons and the Turtle. Several of the lower rung pitchers can be jettisoned also. Along with about 3 players on the 60 day DL list. FO has to do a better job on talent evaluation. Under Terry Ryan you rarely saw a released player have a big impact (David Ortiz, but not many others). This FO has several relief pitchers and maybe 1 starter (Gil) who could carve out decent major league careers, while the Twins bullpen suffers. Donaldson is a issue, but I would trade him (as a sunk cost) for whatever I could get (salary relief and lottery tickets are most likely) to open up positions for the next wave. Most of them will not be here until next spring or summer, but we need to move forward. This also includes buying 1 front line starter to stabilize the rotation and also if a floor to help get us there. Baldelli needs to play the younger players, and if he will not (except when we are facing playoff contenders), we need to release those players so he cannot use them. Next year could be bad, but it is the only way forward to find out what we have.
-
Miranda Mania: 3 Ways To Get Him To Minneapolis
Saints will probably make the AAA playoffs. Miranda will stay there until that run if over (may be about the same time the twins are done). This winter they have many roster decisions to make. Expect a lot of the part timers who do not have an upside to be gone. Cave for sure and probably Rooker.
-
When will we see Joe Ryan pitch for the Twins?
I feel with Wichita and probably St. Paul in the playoffs, we will not see any top prospects until the minor league playoffs are done, if then. Plus with the 40 man crunch, it is unlikely we will see any this year. Guess maybe the return of Dobnak will come first.
-
75% of the season is complete, how do the Twins finish?
I voted 15 - 26, with the loss of Maeda today, maybe for the year and the FO not willing to bring up the talented starters in the minors, the last stretch will be brutal. It could be worse.