Everything posted by stringer bell
- Article: Did The Twins Give Up On Hicks Too Soon?
- What do we know about John Ryan Murphy?
-
Article: Did The Twins Give Up On Hicks Too Soon?
You're right to a degree, but what changes if Hicks is considered a corner OF is that there will be different people who are capable of playing the outfield corners competing for playing time there. On the Twins, it would be Arcia, AB Walker and probably Kepler. None of those guys are projected as center fielders, but all could man left or right (maybe not Arcia). If Hicks were moved to a corner, he would have to better than those guys and I don't think he would be.
- Article: Twins Trade Aaron Hicks To Yankees For Catcher
-
The Twins On Base Problem
That was the most disconcerting thing about trading Hicks, whose on-base skills are pretty advanced.
-
Article: Twins Roster Projection: Where Are We Now Version
From the OP, I don't agree with Logan Darnell being on the Opening Day roster, many better options including Rogers. I think Plouffe will be traded, otherwise pretty much what was laid out there.
-
So what does the outfield look like now?
There's really no need or purpose for Vargas in your scenario and with Sano being unproven at third, I think the Twins keep Eduardo Nuñez. I think Buxton becomes the biggest question mark in Spring Training. It seems very apparent to me that the Twins believe he's on the cusp of really breaking through. It's a gamble, but I think they're right. I think Plouffe is gone too, but they aren't going to give him away.
-
So what does the outfield look like now?
Plouffe is slow, really slow, and when he played in the outfield, he was unsure of himself and hesitant. At this point Sano has a chance of being the better outfielder, but I don't think he should be there. If Opening Day were tomorrow, I'd have Rosario, Buxton, Arcia left to right. Arcia is out of options. It is his last chance. He showed enough in the previous two years to merit another chance despite last season's failure. Danny Santana can be a fourth OF. By the end of 2014, I thought his defense was adequate. With more experience, he could be decent or even better. Kepler, barring injuries, starts 2016 in Rochester, but either he or Walker could be a call-up if someone is injured or struggles. I don't see any point in signing a veteran outfielder. I'm pretty sure Buxton will be up fairly early. Kepler or Walker need someone to falter or to dominate AAA.
-
The Front Office and Settling For Mediocrity
OK, I've probably been as harsh a critic of Aaron Hicks as anyone, but all season he looked better up there than he did in his first two seasons. He had a hot month, but even when he wasn't hot, he took better at-bats as a whole. I think he can at least repeat his success of 2015. A couple of posters have noted he should do better in Yankee Stadium, which is a good hitter's park. Target Field is a good hitter's park, too.
-
Article: Twins Trade Aaron Hicks To Yankees For Catcher
Here's my take: Aaron Hicks was a different player last year. He hit and fielded like a major league center fielder, but his overall numbers were not quite league average. As noted by many, his LH numbers were below average and every year hitter will face between 2/3 and 3/4 right handed pitchers. If one thinks Aaron Hicks is a top 15 center fielder (offense and defense) the Twins got fleeced. I think Hicks is a marginal starter and would have been replaced by Byron Buxton early in the 2016 season. If Hicks isn't a regular in center, he just doesn't hit enough (especially left handed) to be a regular on an outfield corner. Hicks had more value than a year ago, so Ryan didn't sell low. I'd much rather see Buxton, Rosario, Kepler in the future. For now, the window is open for Arcia to get another shot as a corner outfielder and when his trial is done, perhaps Kepler or maybe even ABW will get a shot. I think that is better than going with Hicks in right or left field. John Ryan Murphy: He's young, he's cheap, and he's a catcher. Probably the most disturbing thing about Murphy is that he doesn't have All-Star upside. There are no 80 tools, but he profiles to at least get more plate appearances than Herrmann/Fryer and perhaps will be sharing the job or more by midseason. It won't be fair to look at Murphy's numbers compared to Hicks. Look at Murphy's numbers compared to Herrmann/Fryer and Buxton's compared to Hicks.
- Article: Twins Trade Aaron Hicks To Yankees For Catcher
-
Hicks will be traded
Two thoughts: The Twins continue to add right handed bats and seem willing to sacrifice defense on at least one of the outfield corners. Murphy for Herrmann is a step up, I think, but he's another right handed hitter. Hicks' at bats will go to ????--I think Buxton, but it is possible that the Twins will have only Mauer and Rosario from the left side with Escobar as a switch hitter. They have a crying need for left handed hitters who can get on base, like Joe Mauer used to. It does open the door wider for Kepler and makes it easier to see Arcia getting at bats to start the season. Second thought is that the Twins believe in Byron Buxton (so do I) and saw Hicks as really viable only as a center fielder (so do I). Hicks restored some value with his decent season this year and maybe the time was right to deal him.
-
What do we know about John Ryan Murphy?
In another thread I admitted knowing next to nothing about John Ryan Murphy. I checked his bio in BB Reference and he certainly looks to be an upgrade over Chris Herrmann, that bar is pretty low. One of the Yankee fan articles said that he had a positive defensive rating, but BB Ref doesn't indicate this (often Fan Graphs and BB Ref come out differently by their use of different formulas). I hope he is sound defensively and hits close to league average. If so, the Twins did OK.
-
Hicks will be traded
I admit I know very little about Murphy other than he homered off Perkins to win a game for the Evil Empire. I never saw that hit and I don't believe I've ever seen him play. It looks like he throws OK, but I don't know about his defense although the number of passed balls and wild pitches allowed looks pretty high.
-
Hicks will be traded
The odds that Byron Buxton will make the team out of spring training just increased dramatically. Sugar Shane will probably be re-signed in short order, as well.
-
Hicks will be traded
Wow. Let's never criticize Ryan for doing nothing! Big move early in the off-season. Good luck, Aaron Hicks. Those of us who were thinking there would be a Rosario, Buxton, Hicks OF for years saw it for what? 15 innings.
-
Twins Trade Chris Herrmann
Also, they cleared a spot on the 40-man. I think that is big, especially since Herrmann would have to have been DFAed to be sent to the minors.
-
Twins Trade Chris Herrmann
So, to summarize, the Twins traded catcher/outfielder Chris Herrmann to Arizona for OF/1B Daniel Palka.
-
Hicks will be traded
Some conclusions if Park is in fact signed--there isn't room for Vargas and Arcia unless someone is moved. Secondly, the power on the 2016 Twins will come almost exclusively from the right side. IMHO, it makes no sense to move Sano to the outfield unless the plan is for him to be out there for several seasons. This year would be a learning experience, not what you want to have on a contending team. If acquiring Park means that the Twins are really going for it in 2016, any other trade should be for assets that will help the team win in the coming season. Don't trade Plouffe, Hicks, Rosario etc. for prospects. The Twins offense was lousy and extremely disappointing in 2015. There is room for much improvement, but the improvement should be focused on guys that get on base. I'm very much puzzled about what will happen going forward, although I do like the idea of adding talent, which is how I see the move to add Park.
-
Hicks will be traded
Hicks appeared to turn a corner last year, but IMHO he isn't proven. The team is at a different place and Buxton is a different prospect than Hicks in 2013. I just don't think Hicks will ever hit enough from the left side to be an everyday corner outfielder.
-
Article: AFL Recap Week 4: Fall Stars Fizzle
It looks like all of the Twins farmhands are doing pretty well. I'm especially pulling for two who I think could help the club in 2016--no not ABW, but Rogers and Turner. Rogers has pitched pretty well as a starter, but I hope the Twins consider him for the bullpen. Turner is getting on base, with a really high percentage of walks and earlier reports have highlighted his throwing. It would be nice to have a catcher (even a backup) who can get on base more than 30% of the time and can throw out more than 20% of attempted base stealers.
-
AFL Recap Week 4 (Nov 2-8): Fall Stars Fizzle
It looks like all of the Twins farmhands are doing pretty well. I'm especially pulling for two who I think could help the club in 2016--no not ABW, but Rogers and Turner. Rogers has pitched pretty well as a starter, but I hope the Twins consider him for the bullpen. Turner is getting on base, with a really high percentage of walks and earlier reports have highlighted his throwing. It would be nice to have a catcher (even a backup) who can get on base more than 30% of the time and can throw out more than 20% of attempted base stealers.
-
2016 Election Thread
I just finished reading through this thread for the first time in weeks. Here is what I think: While Trump and Carson have led in the polling, we all know it won't last. The most viable candidate to win is Rubio--he's from a key state, he's good on the stump and the generational difference between Clinton and him favors the younger candidate. I think the last two candidates standing will be Cruz and Rubio. If Republicans want to make a statement they pick Cruz and lose the general election, if they want to have a chance a year from now they choose Rubio. Personally, I would abhor Republicans running both the executive and legislative branch, but they have a real chance because voters see changing the party in the White House as changing the direction of the country and most of us want to see a change of direction. Again, personally, I would like to see a legislative change. I am amazed how fast our nation's perception of two social issues has changed--gay marriage and marijuana legalization--and it makes most liberals and Democrats look like political weathervanes, changing positions on those issues. I suspect they previously wouldn't have felt safe backing SSM and legal pot, but seeing that it was acceptable to a majority of voters, they now take these positions, which fit a liberal profile. Hillary is Exhibit A. Clinton looks like the certain nominee to me. She has some assets--she is smart, experienced, has access to lots of money, and before things become politicized, she was lauded as a good Senator and Secretary of State. She doesn't excite people the way both Obama and her husband did, but she probably won't have to. She would bring the novelty of being the first female to head a major party ticket and a coalition of left-leaners, non-whites and economically disadvantaged might be enough to win the White House. Also included in her coalition would be people like me who believe the Republican party has gone off the rails and has a platform full of really bad ideas on both social issues (especially) and domestic issues. Bill Clinton might be the wild card in the next election. I think on balance his record and his popularity help Hillary.
-
Dozier to the Yankees for a Catcher?
I like Brian Dozier and I like his game. He has already exceeded most scout's predictions for his career. How many would have predicted that Dozier would hit 69 homers in a three-year span and lead the Twins in homers all three years? Not many, I'm sure. Dozier made adjustments to add extra-base power to his game and it has served him well. However, the league and it's pitchers have adjusted to Dozier. He now must make further adjustments if he wants to improve. It appears that Mauer couldn't, but a player like Torii Hunter continued to make adjustments and became a better hitter later in his career. I don't think it is out of the question that Dozier could continue to improve. Polanco looks to me to be the anti-Dozier. If his minor league record is to be believed, he might be able to come to the majors and hit an empty .270. The two things that Dozier has provided--extra-base hits and free passes-are the two things pretty much lacking in Polanco's MiLB resumé. Polanco is young enough to develop both power and better on-base skills, but I don't think they are there yet.
-
Dozier to the Yankees for a Catcher?
My problem with moving Dozier and/or Plouffe this offseason is that there is so much unproveness amongst the position players. In my book, over the last three years Dozier and Plouffe have proven themselves to be capable major league regulars. We had Sano, Hicks, and Rosario perform capably last year, but the year before Arcia, Santana and Vargas were all to some degree "breaking out" and all three ended up in the minors. Dozier put up a fine two and a half years, of near elite play at his position and had a bad 70-game stretch. Does it foretell his permanent decline? I don't think so. If he is close to the .840 OPS he had at the break, his value is a lot more than a good catching prospect.