Everything posted by stringer bell
-
Article: Brian Dozier: Powerful Asset
You're missing the point. Both Uggla and Kent were hitters with plus power, especially for the middle infield. Kent was a good player until his early thirties and became a borderline Hall of Famer because he mashed well into his thirties. Uggla fell off a cliff. With Dozier also being a "power for his position" guy, I've wondered if he might fall off the map if he couldn't catch up with a good fastball or if he could adjust as Kent did. I do lean toward the sustained fine performance for Dozier, maybe not at the level of Kent, but certainly above average. Kent's top OPS+ season through the age of 29 (Dozier's age now) was 111 in less than full-time play. Starting in 1998 (age 30) he was an All-Star five times for three different teams with an OPS+ of 119 or better for each year for 10 years. I'd venture to guess that Dozier's OPS+ today is superior to Kent's at age 29, but I'm not that good at math to say for sure.
-
Article: Brian Dozier: Powerful Asset
Good take Nick. Both sides of the Dozier argument have been laid out for a long time, but his performance since June 1 has put BD back in elite territory. Any return for him should be more than substantial. I would say one "can't miss" or established player plus a couple of good to premium prospects. The team can build around him or build from what is returned for him. I lean toward keeping him, because he has shown he can make adjustments to keep improving and he is durable. Early in the season, I was contemplating whether his career would be more like Dan Uggla or if it would be more like Jeff Kent. I am now leaning to Kent.
-
2016 Election Thread
That was my impression as well. I know he had been ahead all the way in Iowa (was that a decade ago?) and held leads in other states and then didn't hold them. He always polled well in the jungle, when there were 5-10 candidates, but didn't really overperform vs. the polls that often.
-
May on DL, Chargois up
May pitched much better between DL stints. I wonder if it will be determined that bullpen duty doesn't jibe with his balky back. I confess to being all in on the "May as setup guy" early this year and I still like how his fastball plays up, but overall he's been a huge disappointment this year in the bullpen. Maybe this will convince the Twins brass to stretch May out and go with him as a starter. We can only hope. Saying this, I do want to say that I don't hold out hope that May becomes to topflight starter.
-
Why has Polanco seen no time at Short?
Polanco--both offensively and defensively has looked very good. His minor league numbers don't scream "call me up!". His hitting was good, but not dominant, his fielding, especially at short hasn't been of major league quality. Maybe it was exactly the right time to recall him, maybe he was bored in the majors. It is still a really small sample. He's young and he appears to have good on-base skills. It would be great if he could continue to hit and be an acceptable shortstop. Buxton--with his speed, he should bunt a lot more than 1% of the time, if only to bring the third baseman in, but also to lay down a sacrifice in the late innings. Rosario--a lot of great players never walked much and Eddie probably never will. Rosario needs to be selective enough to force people to give him pitches he can handle AKA strikes, rather than getting behind in the count and chasing neck-high fastballs and breaking balls in the dirt.
-
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Astros, 8/8 @ 7:10pm CT
Gomez is a shadow of his former self.
-
So what exactly do we do about the catcher spot?
I haven't had time to read the entire thread, but if the supposed answer is Ramos, let's be sure to know how big an outlier this is for the Nats catcher. He's never had an OPS of .800 and his currently sits at .932. His OPS+ was below 100 until this year. He's a good defensive catcher and he turns 29 this year, but as recently as last year he hit only .229 with a .616 OPS. He's been great this year, but the Twins once signed a catcher to an extension after his best season.
-
Byron Buxton
Except there's only three plus weeks remaining in the AAA season. The Twins are probably duty bound to recall Buxton on 9/1 or after Labor Day. Perhaps they would keep him down for the IL playoffs if the Red Wings make it.
-
Who gets Sent Down when Plouffe Returns? Official: It's Buxton
What the major league team has done with Buxton hasn't worked. Does everyone agree with that? I'm reading that he sat too much--gee, aside from injuries he got a lot of play for a guy who is hitting below the Mendoza Line. Pinch hitting? I remember only a few occasions, including Rosario's bomb on Friday night. Right now, offensively, Buxton is a mess. How much is mechanical and how much is confidence I don't know. I really haven't seen much improvement at all before or after his last promotion or before or after missing time for an injury. I thought the right play would be to continue to let BB try to figure it out at the major league level, but Buxton hasn't shown enough improvement that I can castigate the organization for sending him down.
-
Should Sano Get Demoted?
Yes, considering Sano's total body of work as a hitter says more All-Star than AAA. I do believe the Twins brass has a point about not taking defense seriously. I haven't counted his reps and probably none of us know exactly how much time and diligence Sano has for being a good defender. What we know is that he's never been very good in the minors as a third baseman, he was a (near) disaster when switched to right field, and he's been poor when switching back in midseason to third base. We've seen enough good plays at third to believe he has the skills to be satisfactory or better, but we've seen mistakes that would make an Appie League manager shake his head. Offensively, Sano was the team MVP last season in a half season of work. He's been pitched differently and better since September of last year and his numbers since then remind one of Dave Kingman or Mark Reynolds more than Big Papi or the Big Hurt. Would a trip to the minors help his offense? I think it could, but this young man is extremely talented and should do better than Kennys Vargas or Oswaldo Arcia. In summary, I think that since Sano has come off the DL and returned primarily to third base, we've seen a player with great talent either demonstrate he can't play a defensive position or not work hard enough to have one and we've seen someone regarded as one of the future great hitters be considerably less than great. He had a fine series in Tampa despite a couple key strikeouts in the middle game. Perhaps this talk of demotion has lit a fire under the big fella.
-
"They are who we thought they were!" - Denny Green Memoriam Thread
OK, to Brock's general point, I agree wholeheartedly. I was going to divide the season in thirds. Of the top of my head, the Twins were 16-38 in the first third, and 27-27 in the middle third. I don't believe a contender can have a 16-38 stretch, but plenty of contenders (who make post-season) have had long intervals of so-so baseball, such as that 27-27 stretch the Twins just completed. I don't think we can expect the team to contend next year without new faces on the pitching staff, but I believe there is enough fully developed talent amongst the position players for the 2017 team to contend. That is why I don't want their best player the past four years to be traded.
-
Who gets Sent Down when Plouffe Returns? Official: It's Buxton
Interesting to read all of these comments. I said at the very beginning that I think it will be Vargas and if I was making the decision I believe it still would be Vargas. IMHO, Vargas has put in his chit for consideration as a DH/1B going forward and his demotion would only be for three weeks. If I were the manager or GM, I'd tell him he's made progress and has a chance to figure in the team's future. Sending Vargas down would lessen the logjam of Polanco (3B), Sano, Plouffe, Mauer. I won't get my knickers in a twist if anyone sits a day or two going forward, No one has played well enough long enough to expect to play every day. There is enough talent among the position players, I'm convinced of that.
-
Who gets Sent Down when Plouffe Returns? Official: It's Buxton
A small injury may in fact become disabling at this point. I expect they will give Plouffe enough at-bats to show he's healthy and swinging at least OK.
-
Who gets Sent Down when Plouffe Returns? Official: It's Buxton
Mod note: There's already a thread about Sano. If you are talking about his weight, his attitude etc. make your thoughts known there.
-
Who gets Sent Down when Plouffe Returns? Official: It's Buxton
Sadly, this is the likely scenario, if no one wants Plouffe by the end of the month, I think. However if someone has an injury, he could be a good fit. Plouffe is an average or slightly better 3B when healthy, but I don't think he's been really healthy all year. It is too bad that the team is painted into a corner or moving him.
-
Who gets Sent Down when Plouffe Returns? Official: It's Buxton
Plouffe is out of options and probably has too much MLB service time, anyway. The Twins are currently carrying 12 pitchers (the new minimum), although they might be able to get creative and only carry four starters somehow.
-
Who gets Sent Down when Plouffe Returns? Official: It's Buxton
Trevor Plouffe was sent to Rochester when the Twins went to Cleveland. He DHed last night and was 1-4. In total, it appears he is 3-11. I would expect Plouffe to remain in Rochester through the weekend, but probably about August 8th or 9th, he should be ready to return. With the flexibility of the roster as is, the Twins could send out any position player. This late in the season, I would find it hard to believe that they would burn an option for any player who hasn't had his option used. Here are my candidates: Danny Santana (DFA), Kennys Vargas, Jorge Polanco, Byron Buxton, and Miguel Sano. Of course, a trade could open a spot, but except for Suzuki, who would have to be replaced by another catcher, there aren't many waiver trade options left. My bet would be Vargas. It is already crowded at 1B/3B/DH and his option was already used. What is the opinion of Twins Daily posters? Who should it be? Who will it be?
-
2016 Election Thread
I think it ends up Obama-Romney close. 5-7% margin for Hill, with her basically winning the same states that Obama did in 2012. If the margin widens, North Carolina, Georgia and Arizona turn blue. If it is really lopsided, I'd like to see Clinton make a run for Texas, the only reliably red large state.
-
Why has Polanco seen no time at Short?
Third base doesn't require as much arm strength as short and beside that shortstops also have to make a bigger variety of throws and angles with less time to set themselves.
-
Game Thread: Twins @ Indians 8/3 6:10pm
I DVRed the game and just finished watching. Several thoughts: Trevor May's glove looks like it should belong to a Little Leaguer. Everyone else's glove looks twice the size of their hand. May's doesn't look like it is big enough for Donald Trump. Just think how good the Twins offense would be going if their two most ballyhooed players (Sano and Buxton) were playing like All-Stars. It's not fair to expect those two guys to live up to the hype, but Buxton's offense and Sano's defense halve been pretty disappointing. Polanco looks pretty comfortable at third, despite limited experience. I like him there better than Sano already, and if I'm penciling in an infield for next year, it is Mauer, Dozier, Escobar, and Polanco, making Sano one of three DHs. More on Polanco--he looks really good at the plate. Good approach and good swing. Combined with being a switch hitter and having decent speed, I would think it would be hard for him to have a long slump. I'm really surprised his minor league numbers aren't even better. Speaking of Polanco, what we've seen of him he's really a good player, but he'll have to go some to be better than Dozier. The numbers for this year are almost elite despite a miserable start. He's hitting more and more balls with authority to right and right-center and his power as a middle infielder is pretty much the best in Twins history. He most likely will hit his 100th homer this year, almost all in the last four years. Unless Kepler continues to hit like Babe Ruth or Sano gets hot, Dozier will lead the club in homers for four consecutive years. The only guy to match or exceed that for the Twins is in Cooperstown. If Dozier is traded to make room for Polanco, the team better get a haul, because IMHO Dozier might have made the adjustments to be an elite hitter. Mauer and Kepler have had great series against the Tribe, but a lot of others are swinging good bats, it's tough to get ABs for Grossman and Vargas, who weren't slumping either, It will be interesting to see who sits tomorrow vs a rookie. Finally, 37 runs in three games! Wouldn't be fun to see a big number tomorrow afternoon? I suppose the rook will throw seven scoreless and the Twins will lose 2-1 or something, but this is a lot more fun than watching them lose game after game. Oh yeah, welcome to .400 baseball. For probably the first time all year, the Twins don't project to lose 100 games.
-
Why has Polanco seen no time at Short?
It would be great to get Dozier's production at short, but that's not happening either. It's pretty obvious that the team doesn't believe Polanco is a capable shortstop. I saw what Ash saw in ST. Way back when he was in Cedar Rapids, I talked to an Angels scout who said his arm was a little short and that he probably was a 2B. I haven't seen anything to change my mind.
-
Max Kepler
Two thoughts on Kepler: I pretty much expected lots of doubles and triples, but not many balls over the fence. It appears to me that he's a more complete player than the more publicized Buxton and Sano.
-
Max Kepler
With the season well underway (more than 100 games) and the Twins out of contention for anything but a high draft choice, I checked the stats for AL Rookie of the Year candidates. I found three who have been great: Kepler, the Tribe's Naquin and Michael Fulmer of the Tigers. Naquin vs. Kepler is interesting. Naquin is hitting well over .300 and has an OPS in excess of 1.000, that is superstar territory. Kepler has his OPS over .900, and leads all AL rookies in HR and RBI. Kepler has a slightly higher WAR. Bonus for Naquin--he's playing for a contender. Fulmer is a wild card. He's been great--9-2 with a 2.50 ERA, 84 Ks in 97+ innings. The Tigers have to be considered contenders, as well. Fulmer might make the "qualified" level for pitchers. He has averaged just over 6 IP per start and has probably 11 starts remaining, he'd had to average about 6 and a half innings per start. It doesn't appear Naquin or Kepler will get enough at-bats to qualify (FWIW). Neither hits on the top of the order and they both are at about 250 PAs.
-
Brian Dozier's Silent Asset
Pretty sure Dozier's best season for WAR (and just about everything else) was 2014. Brian tailed off dramatically in 2015 after being named to the All-Star team.
-
Abad to Red Sox
Ryan and Antony can get an "attaboy" for the deals for Abad. Minor league contract-solid performance-trade for some value. Well done former and current GM.