Brusdar has talent as his 7-0 record shows last year in AA and AAA. He made it to the majors in September and had a 4.66 ERA so I hope he does well this year. Maeda did better in August and September pitching out of the bullpen in September with a 3.45 ERA. Both hitting and pitching are important, as your stats of the 0-6 record indicate. If Maeda can continue as a starting pitcher I think his value over a relief role will give the Twins the better deal.