Everything posted by StormJH1
-
Harden's release
Yeah....except that Part 1 of your statement doesn't really line up with Part 2. I agree that it's good of Terry Ryan to explore every possible avenue outside of the traditional routes of drafting, trading, and signing free agents to improve the Twins, but let's all keep in mind that the guys he found are still basically replacement-level guys to comprise a really terrible baseball team (for 3 years in a row now). The "top rated farm system" has nothing to do with taking a chance on injured players with minor league contracts, the waiver wire, or the Rule 5 draft. It is due, almost entirely, to: (1) The Twins being terrible enough to get elite level draft prospects; (2) The Twins allowing useful free agents to depart on purpose to receive compensatory picks; (3) The Twins being willing to part with MLB players of some value (Span and Revere) in exchange for prospects.
-
Mauer on paternity leave until Tuesday
I refuse to rip Mauer on this point, and I'm not even reading up on all of the gossip/opinions on it. Nothing is more important than your family, and this is a time that happens a few times in a lifetime. He can have a few days, a weeks, whatever, with his family away from this non-playoff team.
-
Reusse: Twins need a Latin American Coach
I've never been of the mind that the manager needs to be able to speak Spanish, but the grumblings you hear from fans and Reusse-types about the Twins not being very Latin-friendly or accepting of players of other backgrounds likely pales in comparisons to what actual Latin players think and say about the team with other Latin teams. I don't think the Twins organization is purposefully discriminatory or insensitive, I just feel like there's enough anecdotal evidence regarding the way black and Hispanic players are "discarded" (Ortiz, Castillo, Casilla, Hudson, Liriano, etc.) when you get the sense that a Caucasian player of the same demeanor and resume might have been treated differently. (Not including Delmon in there because he just isn't a good dude). Again, I think a lot of it is not purposeful discrimination, but comes from a like-mindedness and insularity of background from the whole organization. Managerial staffs have like, what, 10 people on them, and not a single black or Latin coach? And it's been that way for how long? This isn't about "affirmative action" or any broader moral/social topics. Baseball isn't like society - a law firm wouldn't hire a poor 16-year old from the Dominican Republic who doesn't speak any English to argue in Court. A 95 mph fastball works the same regardless if the arm that threw it is attached a dude that speaks English, Spanish, or Japanese. But there's also a human being with feelings attached to that arm. I worry a little bit about how this organization handles a Latin mega-star like Sano because I remember a lot of the issues they had with Liriano during his TJ rehab, and in general. At the same time, it's likely that we know 15% of what Sano said or did, and I have to think they wouldn't take a disciplinary action like this unless they really had to, so who knows.
-
Article: Minnesota Twins Prepare For Trade Deadline
There's probably no question that Perkins would get the most back now of the "candidates". If the Orioles would give up their #5 prospect for a 2-month rental of K-Rod, you would THINK Perkins would have more value than that because of his contract, age, and recent success. But I don't think they move him. I really don't think they move Morneau either. The guys who get moved at the deadline are never the "one of us" guys or players beloved by the fans. It's guys like Castillo or Liriano. Even Torii Hunter, who was beloved by most fans, but a problematic teammate/personality at times, wasn't moved. I just don't think they want to explain to the casual baseball family from Blaine why they traded Justin Morneau instead of trying to resign him, and all they got in return was the equivalent of Eduardo Escobar.
-
Braves eyeing Twins relievers
I'm almost baffled that the Twins could get a C-level prospect for Duensing, but let's make that trade yesterday if it's there. Duensing is 30 years old, was awful as a starter, and isn't much better as a reliever. I've already advocated shifting Diamond to the bullpen with the hopes he turns into a Perkins, but it's 20 times more likely he pitches like Duensing out of the pen.
-
Braves eyeing Twins relievers
I'm almost baffled that the Twins could get a C-level prospect for Duensing, but let's make that trade yesterday if it's there. Duensing is 30 years old, was awful as a starter, and isn't much better as a reliever. I've already advocated shifting Diamond to the bullpen with the hopes he turns into a Perkins, but it's 20 times more likely he pitches like Duensing out of the pen.
-
Scott Diamond to AAA?
They need move Scott Diamond to the bullpen, like, yesterday. You don't need any better example of how this could work than Glen Perkins. Perkins basically WAS Scott Diamond as a starter. His K/9 rates were 4.4 and 4.2 in the years he started. Yes, he got more velocity later, but there's no way he can pump 95 mph for 5 innings or longer, so there might be a chicken-and-the-egg thing going on with his success as a reliever. Diamond's stuff almost certainly isn't as dynamic as Perkins, but his problem seems to be the 2nd or 3rd time through a lineup. Reinventing him as a lefty specialist or one-inning reliever might be the best thing for the Twins, and for Diamond's career. He has no prolonged track record of success as a starter, and he doesn't miss enough bats to be effective long-term.
-
Article: Trading Perkins Makes Too Much Sense
I'll open this post (so it doesn't get locked for being off-topic) by saying I'm not adverse to the Twins keeping Perkins because he's a quality guy under a very reasonable contract. As for Myers/Shields, the fact that the Royals haven't been able to develop or keep front-line starters for years should not factor into whether that was a good trade. It was a horrible trade. Anybody checked Detroit's rotation (and lineup) recently? I have no idea what possessed Kansas City to think that Shields was that one piece that would make them compete for the division. KC is 6 games under .500 and that's WITH Shields pitching his butt off. When the guy you acquire does everything you expect him too and you're still 8 games out of 1st place....whoops. People try to justify Myers/Shields by saying that the Royals have had tons of blue chip hitting prospects and none of them panned out. Isn't that an argument for keeping MORE of your blue chip hitting prospects, since you might not be able to count on 30 HR and 100 RBI from Moustakas, Hosmer, and Gordon every year? Prospects fail - it happens more than it doesn't. The fact that Myers could fail doesn't justify the trade, since the relatively small chance that he becomes a gigantic star is infinitely more valuable than 50-70 starts from Shields on a losing team.
-
Official: Colabello recalled
Niiiice. Apart from a surprising return on a Morneau or Perkins trade (which either won't happen or is bound to underwhelm), about the only thing positive to look forward is some unexpected 10-15 HR outburst. Colabello is post-post-never-hyped-in-the-first-place, but he seems like the only guy around that could do that.
-
Morneau/Mauer Double Bobblehead: An Analysis
This thread easily exceeded my very modest expectations. Haha. Trying to get a free bobblehead featuring Joe Mauer in this state is like trying to get Hannah Montana tickets circa 4 or 5 years ago. Good luck. Wife (then girlfriend) was out of town one weekend, so I showed up like 2.5 hours before a game at the Dome, the Mauer bobbleheads were LONG gone by the time I got there. So I got to take in the "ambiance" of the Metrodome for a few hours while watching everybody except me catch a batting practice HR in my section. Good times!
-
Morneau/Mauer Double Bobblehead: An Analysis
The first 10,000 fans to Target Field on Friday get this beauty. Parker tweeted out that it looked like one of them was scoring from 1st base, but several people disagreed with him and he called it back. But it leads to the question, what is going on here? Are there any hidden messages (a fateful goodbye pending a Morneau trade)? Morneau has his batting gloves on and is standing on homeplate. Presumably, then, Morneau has just hit a two-run (or more) homer, which would have scored Mauer, and Mauer is now congratulating him. But in that scenario, Mauer should have scored first, and is now standing creepily inside the diamond, forcing Morneau to do a 180-degree turn for the high five. Also, Morneau needs eye blacks for the sun glare, but Baby Jesus doesn't? I find this hard to believe since Mauer (with an assist from Morneau and Cuddy) more or less single-handedly ordered the CF pines dug up because of batter's eye interference. Plus, as Josh Hamilton taught us, blue-eyed people are basically blind in the sunlight. Finally, their heads and feet are comically large, but such is the charm of a bobblehead. I might actually have gone to that game but for other plans with the wife. There's probably something better I could be doing right now, but such is the "Sports Abyss".
-
Article: Catching Up on Mauer's Catching
That's a fair point. We've seen Gardy be careful with Mauer in the past (2007) when the season was already lost. But the thing with that is that you have an elite all-around catcher in the prime of his career and to me, Mauer was paid to be Joe Mauer and suit up for the Twins, as opposed to being valued for his specific contribution to a World Series team. These past 3 seasons have basically become "lost" by June, so are we supposed to just stop using one of the best catchers of all-time for huge portions of the season because the team sucks? At some point, it needs to be remembered that this is still a product for the fans, and those fans by tickets in large numbers whether the team wins 90 or loses 90. I think we're already getting beyond the point in Mauer's career where he could be featured as a full-time catcher on World Series team. That ain't happening in the next few years unless some dramatic changes occur. By then, I think Mauer will still be a productive hitter, but he'll be a "catcher" in the sense that V-Mart or Mike Napoli is a "catcher" now.
-
Reusse: Let Gardy go
Gardy would find another job given his resume pretty easily. I guess I'm surprised how ambivalent I am about the coaching change issue. Gleeman's list of the only managers to not get fired after 3 straight 90-loss seasons is pretty telling, particularly since half of them managed expansion teams (and one was another Twins coach): Larry Rothschild Rays 1998-2000 Felipe Alou Expos 1998-2000 Tom Kelly Twins 1997-2000 Joe Torre Mets 1978-1980 Darrell Johnson Mariners 1977-1979 Preston Gomez Padres 1969-1971 Casey Stengel Mets 1962-1964 Zack Taylor Browns 1948-1951 But unlike a lot of fans, I don't really have a huge problem with Gardy's "style" as a manager. The issue that the Twins have been mired in, really for quite a long time, is that they have a culture that really dooms them from evolving beyond what they are. It scares me a bit to think that the new wave of (possibly great) Twins prospects will be exposed to this old school mentality of "always play when you're hurt" and "low risk, low reward" approaches to hitting. Sometimes you just need to shake it up. The sad truth is: how much worse could it really get? 110 losses instead of 95?
-
Reusse: Extending Morneau might be better than a trade
I'm not either, but I am fairly convinced that he can't sustain whatever the best he's capable for more than a week or two at a time. If you look at what's happening to Willingham right now, that's more likely to be the case for Morneau going forward. 2006 (his MVP year) was 7 years ago. In pretty much every year since then, he either struggled or broke down in the last 1/3 of the year. He's had a number of nagging injuries, any one of which could mess up his swing. And the concussion thing is not going away as an issue. I'll admit that trying the one-year qualifying offer thing seems more tempting that I would have thought, but he likely would accept it, and he's just not going to be in the plans going forward. We could probably spend $2 to $6 million and end up with a first baseman (even a right hander!) that has a pretty good chance of producing as much as Morneau would.
-
Gotta Listen on Perkins?
Perkins is almost like Mauer-lite in terms of his "Twins-iness" and fan appeal - I just can't see them shipping out a hometown guy like that unless they absolutely have to. And, as Gleeman and other posters here have noted, they really don't have to. It's not like a Nathan situation where he has this giant contract coupled with post-injury concerns and a lousy team. Plus, I don't feel like the return would be that great anyway. His production has been good, but some teams just don't like lefty closers, period, and Perkins doesn't have a long track record of domination. He'd likely be an elite 8th inning option for a team that already has a great closer, but you don't pay a deadline premium for that.
-
Article: Play at the plate angers Twins manager
Yeah, I think Parker had it right early in the article, but covered the rest of the "debate" because so many Twins-related quotes are whining about it. He should be sliding there, no question about it. Yes, you can get hurt sliding feet first into home (Robin Ventura comes to mind). But there's no way Gomes could have "tripped" Doumit unless he predicted a future where Doumit tries to tiptoe over he plate, instead of sliding to avoid a potential tag. Gomes was reacting to the throw being late and feeling like the plate was exposed. His priorities there were catching the ball and finding a tag, not tripping the runner. Following the Buster Posey injury, I'm sure Mauer probably has instructions to head to a bomb shelter if it looks like there's a possibility of a home plate collision, but I'm pretty sure Twins players do stuff like this from time to time and Gardy never calls them dirty.
-
Should Plouffe Be Shopped?
Yeah, I'm totally with this post. Has Plouffe even really had a good 2-month stretch as a starter yet where he was encumbered by injuries? Even so, the results haven't been that bad. But he would have virtually no trade value - his best asset in the eyes of other teams is that he's not old enough to be considered a confirmed "bust". Which, coincidentally, is exactly one of the main reasons we should keep him.
-
What is the Twins strategy this season?
It's kind of funny to me that there's been multiple occasions where a veteran was traded at the deadline for guys that it's assumed will basically never be major leaguers, and yet Drew Butera (Castillo trade, 2007), Eduardo Escobar and Pedro Hernandez (Liriano trade, 2012) have all gotten decent run on what happens to be one of the worst teams in baseball over the last three years. I only bring this up because even though the assumption is that we would get virtually nothing for Doumit or Willingham, recent history suggests there could be a role player coming back for them. Which might be better than nothing. Plus, it saves the front office some salary money, and (more importantly) frees up crowded corner outfield spots for young prospects to actually use. The Doumit re-signing was pretty universally popular, but I didn't quite understand it. It's almost like they resigned him because of what it did to help Mauer, but looking at how Chris Hermann played, you have to think they could've landed on a better-than-Butera option to spell Mauer without adding another veteran to the mix.
-
Article: Twin Terrors in the Twins System
Eddie Rosario is definitely the most overlooked prospect, relative to his value. While his numbers might be slightly skewed by the fact that he's still in High-A ball and will be 22 in September, a left-handed 2B who hits for power and average?! Middle infield prospects are rare, and even some of the good ones pan out, but while other teams are bringing up Jason Kipnis (pretty good) and Dustin Ackley (struggled, sent down), Rosario is the only guy of his kind in the organization for some time. Sano and Buxton go to show how just a few elite prospects can change the whole perception of the farm system.
-
Current Standings
The division is terrible with the exception of Detroit, which isn't exactly free of its own problems. Detroit didn't look great early last year either, then ended up in the World Series. Their starting pitching depth, barring injury, gives them a clear advantage. It was mentioned on G & G that while they're only "5 games under .500", they're not all that far from the worst teams in the league (except Houston and Miami), and Gardenhire clubs that aren't clearly in the pennant race after the ASB don't exactly tend to "finish strong".
-
Hicks to DL, Arcia recalled
I'll fully cop to not knowing who the heck Antoan Richardson was until last week, but he would have made more sense than Clete Thomas, let alone Arcia now. Not that I have a problem with Arcia getting at bats in the majors, but they probably should play Clete everyday now in CF (I really don't want to give Arcia the experience of screwing up CF in the majors when it isn't even his real position). Richardson could at least potentially hold down the leadoff spot for some time, Clete ain't doing that!
-
Article: What's The Point Of Clete Thomas?
That comment (originally noted by Seth) about the callup date is a HUGE point to make. After letting Benson walk, I don't see how anyone can be too annoyed that this team wants somebody on the 40-man who can actually back up in CF. If Hicks got injured, or even if he just goes on a 2 for 38 stretch or something (not too unrealistic), you can't Wilkin Ramirez, Escobar or Parmelee trolling around out there.
-
Article: Joe Benson claimed off waivers by Rangers
Gleeman's negative reaction to how they handled this (shared by many on this thread) is a valid complaint. They obviously lost a young "asset" when they could have exposed a number of replacement-level veterans instead. But let's keep this in context. Benson has been very hurt and very terrible for about 2 years. He's not THAT young. He had no trade value at the present time. So the entire potential "harm" to the Twins never comes to fruition unless Benson rehabilitates himself for some time in the minors, finds a spot in the majors, and is something better than Clete Thomas once he arrives. That's a lot of "ifs". Not to mention that this organization actually has quite a bit of top level depth in the minors at corner OF, plus Buxton in center, and that's assuming Hicks doesn't hold onto the job.
-
Rest In Peace
Wow, that really got to me. The fact that these guys make a lot of money doesn't change the fact that (most) of them really like doing what they do, that it's all they ever known, and that it can be taken from you in an instant. You'd have to be sub-human not to feel for him.
-
Aaron Hicks May
Totally agree. However, while he basically has the job out of sheer necessity right now, he should take note of what happened to Chris Parmelee, who is still relatively young, but never started hitting in the majors before he started to get steamrolled by other young players. Buxton is coming. Not this year, maybe not for most or all of next year, but Hicks can't wait until he's 27 to figure things out if he wants a job on this team.