Everything posted by StormJH1
-
Article: Twins shut down Mauer for rest of season
Sensitivity to light, noise remain for Mauer | Star Tribune My favorite thing about that video is this exchange: Reporter: Joe, what are your symptoms? Mauer: Um, sensitivity to light... (As reporters shine a GIGANTIC HEAT LAMP directly in his face) I don't understand why anyone in the media or fanbase legitimately thought Mauer was playing again this year, or why you'd want him to. The team has shut him down in other years (such as the end of 2007, or intermittently in 2011) over situations far less career-threatening than this. Mauer was good this year, and I think most educated fans have come around on the type of player he is and his importance to the fans and franchise. But his future as a catcher is seriously in doubt, and we just have to hope that he heals from his bruised brain (because that's what it is) in time for next spring.
-
Top 34 Free Agent Starting Pitchers
Actually, when I looked at the full list, I think there's more halfway decent pitchers that could actually be in range for the Twins than last year's list. Last year had more high-end talent, but there's a lot of injury guys in there or guys that have aged (Halladay) or otherwise slipped from a higher level (Lincecum, Josh Johnson). I guess one thing that's concerning is that except for Lincecum and maybe a guy like Ervin Santana, there aren't a lot of guys on that list you could see being effective 3 or more years down the road, even in a best-case scenario. Paul Maholm certainly looks like a Twins pitcher, doesn't he? A lot of people will look at giving a guy like Phil Hughes a shot, but I was surprised when I looked at his numbers and realized that other than 2010 (which was by no means "elite") he never really put together a "good" full MLB season as a starter. I'd take Baker back, but are the Cubs really going to let him walk? He'll make all of 3 starts this year, what if he looks okay? (He went 5 and was okay in his first one).
-
Article: Why the Twins Will Spend This Offseason
I actually think I agree with Nick's underlying premise, which is that the Twins are more interested in spending than we think they are. But I think they had that same attitude LAST offseason, as well. The problem is that they show up to these negotiations with a late 90's perspective on what players should cost, and there's always at least one other team that's willing to overpay. That being said, of the "mid-tier" starting pitching options from last season, how many of them actually would've been a significant help? Anibal Sanchez re-signed fairly quickly, and ended up getting more "elite" money than people expected. I guess Jeremy Guthrie and Brandon McCarthy have been okay, but neither of them would've been a clear-cut "ace", even on this lackluster staff. The chances of at least one of Deduno, Gibson, Hendriks, etc. emerging and giving you that same exact production for FAR less money is always going to appeal to the Twins over free agency, and probably rightfully so. There's really no "half measure" solution to a bad pitching staff. Either you spend $80 million+ to buy a top-tier pitcher, or you wait until you develop them yourself. Otherwise, you're just perpetually adding replacement level crap.
-
Arcia to First & 2015 Opening Day
I'm of the same opinion. I don't know if I'd go as far as saying we've seen Mauer catch his last game (or even the end of him as a starting catcher), but that may be closer to the truth than people expecting business as usual for next year. Lemme get this straight, we don't want to "risk" Doumit catching mop-up games in September, but we'll throw Mauer behind the plate for some post-concussion meaningless "parade" games?! I don't think so... This organization has experienced concussions several times over and knows what they are capable of doing to a career. Even 5 years ago, the idea that foul tips to the mask could cause permanent brain damage would have been viewed as laughable to most. Now, if it's even an outside possibility, what really is the point of throwing $184 million behind the plate? The "positional scarcity" crowd is technically right when they say Mauer is more valuable at catcher, or that Arcia is less valuable at 1st base, but that argument presupposes that you're (a) a competitive baseball team where just a little bit more production could have postseason implications; and ( a potent lineup where you presumably have more than 9 quality hitters available to fill out a lineup card. In other words, if keeping Mauer at catcher is necessary to free up 1st base for...a platoon of Colabello and Parmelee, then you really aren't benefiting from Mauer's ability to catch. Mauer/Colabello may be slightly better than Pinto/Mauer, but it's not like it's the difference between Pinto/Mauer and Mauer/Prince Fielder or Mauer/Chris Davis.
-
Jason Kubel DFA'd by Arizona
There may well be a link between PED's and the popularity of the game. If individual longevity were correlated to the popularity of a sport, how do you explain the NFL, where star players burn out more quickly than any other sport? RB's have an avg life span of 3 years in the NFL. I think the ability to hit a round ball with a round bat at 90mph, and to do it with statistical consistency that we deem acceptable at an MLB level is just a very fleeting thing. Kubel can still play, but if he's not hitting .270 with power, his skill set is really quite limited. He can't run, and he's certainly not an asset in the field. It's easy to say "oh, he can just go to the AL and DH", but there's only 15 full-time DH jobs in the AL, and the expectations for a pure DH are higher than any other position.
-
Article: What's the Plan: Josmil Pinto
The Doumit re-signing was popular and I never understood why. People really thought he would play a lot of 1B to spell Mauer when he was first acquired, and it turns out that's his worst position. Though he plays RF now and then, I really can't remember a time when it was necessary to have Doumit as an OF option, especially now with guys like Colabello and Parmelee hanging around. My point is: he's a bad catcher and overrated as a "plus bat" pretty much anywhere he plays. He got extra-credit as a super-utility player, when that's really not the case. We would've been better off spending the money on a traditional backup catcher, or developing an internal option like Hermmann. All that in mind, if Pinto is still considered a project, we don't need to see him now. I suppose if the minor league season ends early, then calling him up to the MLB club is better than not playing at all, but it's not a priority yet. Kind of sad that fans had finally come to peace with Mauer as a slightly-more-than-part-time catcher (with good defense this year)...and now this concussion stuff may actually force our hand in moving him. It's just funny that with some players (Biggio), they get moved away from catcher VERY early in their careers, but now at Age 30, that decision may be made with Mauer...and Mauer was about as good a hitting prospect as anyone.
-
Aww, Morneau. Can we keep him?
To the extent we care about 1B defense, I watch the Twins pretty regularly and I still think of Morneau as an above-average 1B defender. I hear people like Bonnes casually refer to his declining defense, but there are guys around the league that can barely move that play 1st base (or they are former catchers or OF'ers that are just there to get a bat in the lineup). Morneau's range may be down, but I consider him "elite" at grabbing bad throws. MN fans are also spoiled because they've had over a decade of Dougie M. and Morneau playing there, and both were very good. But I agree that you let him go, unless he explores the market and is willing to come back for 1 or 2 years, and probably then for less than $5 million per. There are plenty of rostered players that can play 1B or learn it, or you could sign a cheap RH vet. People say "we have the money", but a 3-year deal spends money for this offseason, plus the 2014 and 2015 offseasons. The only meaningful FA spending that will impact our on-field success is a multi-year deal for some decent upside SP who is under 30. Obviously, we won't get the elite guys, but we just have too big of a hole to dig out of it by trading for AA prospects here and there.
-
Carroll Love vs. Punto Hate
It's an interesting point, but what really cemented it was the year that Gardy basically handed the 3rd base job to Punto. He had at least hit for average in years past, but a poor average that year coupled with the usual lack of extra-base hits rubbed people the wrong way. Still, as has been pointed out by others, Punto was a far more popular player with the fanbase than Carroll ever was. It's kind of similar to Mauer - Mauer gets far and away the most criticism, but he's also the most beloved player since Kirby. Actually, you could argue that Mauer's popularity is Kirby (plus) Hrbek's hometown appeal (minus) postseason relevance. Plus, Carroll had the (mis)fortune of playing for horrible Twins teams, and being viewed as an "alternative to Nishioka" in the middle infield. The stakes were much higher when Punto was being given at-bats as a regular, as opposed to being valued as a utility defender.
-
2014 Rotation and You Ain't Gonna Like It......
Nobody seriously thought Diamond was in our rotation plans in 2011, then he opened the year as "staff 'ace'" (I put "ace" in quotes twice to emphasize how much of a stretch that was). When Deduno came up in 2012, he wasn't considered any more realistic of a rotation option as DeVries, Walters, or anyone else...now he's this year's "ace". Point being, yes, I think Albers is smoke and mirrors, but it don't take much to stick with this rotation. As for free agency, I don't expect them to sign 4 guys, but I could see another Marquis-type signing. By 2014, really, both Meyer and Trevor May were supposed to be in the big league picture. Meyer pitched well, but is hurt. May has continued to strike guys out, but he's also getting hit. And neither of them can aim very well, which is of particular concern to THIS manager and pitching coach.
-
Gammons: Morneau placed on waivers
Can't we still eat up to like $3 million of the salary (or whatever the number is?). Also, the salary is pro-rated, so it's not like new team cuts a check for $14 million. They pay for whatever is left. Of course, I'd be relatively stunned to see the Twins make a deal where they pay for another team's player, even if that made it possible for them to get a better player in return.
-
Better than we thought?
I honestly don't think of this team as being any better than the 2011 or 2012 teams at this point in the season. Every time I glance at the standings, I'm amazed that we're only 9 games under .500. They have a 27-28 record at home. Still, that's pretty deceptive, IMO. It probably doesn't hurt that the AL added a total bottom-feeder (Houston), that Chicago has been even more terrible, and that Toronto decided to become the Florida Marlins North. Also, Twins teams with losing records tend to get even worse at the end of the season, so this may not be the best time to judge.
-
Holy crap! We got a good return for Butera!
It's really pretty amazing. Could you even imagine a lower-value "rental" than trading Butera at the deadline? I expected some 26-year old burnout at Triple A, not a kid at A-ball who actually has put up pretty good numbers. Crap, you could have said this was the return for MORNEAU and some people would have defended it.
-
Gammons: Morneau placed on waivers
I've heard he was an absolute punk when he showed (there's the famous story about Torii b%$&*-slapping him), but there's reason to believe he grew up. Or, at the very least, he matured to the point where whatever his personal flaws happen to be (and we all have them), they never shined through publicly to embarrass himself or the organization. From the perspective of a baseball fan, there's really no basis to think Mauer is any better of a guy than Morneau. He is one of my favorite Twins since I moved here in 2003, no doubt. Probably the favorite. But I'm also realistic about his decline, so yeah, flip him for a bag of balls if you can. If you don't though, it's not a big deal. It should kept in mind that the value of a Morneau "rental" as of 7/31 was two full months of Morneau. By the time a waiver trade would be completed, it's closer to one month. You'd have to be nuts to give up even a C+ prospect for one month of Justin Morneau at this point.
-
Gammons: Morneau placed on waivers
http://www.rotoworld.com/images/headshots/MLB/3602.jpg Peter Gammons of MLB Network reports that Justin Morneau has been placed on waivers. This is standard procedure in August, but Morneau could draw interest from contenders. The impending free agent has seven homers over his last 15 games. We should know more about his status later this week. (From Rotoworld) --- Standard procedure, but it sets a timetable for what we thought could potentially happen this month. Timing is good with his recent power surge.
-
Playing Rule forces Double Header
That's a tough call. 27 consecutive game days is pretty brutal, I'm sorry. I know these guys make craptons of money and blah blah blah, but they are still human beings with lives and families. And of course there's the whole wear and tear issue. I kind of agree with Spirit above about more double headers, except that's really rough on the bullpen. If your starter gets punted in the 3rd inning or something, you're going to burn up most of your pen in the first game. I think some managers have used relief pitchers in both games of a doubleheader, which blows my mind. Back when they used to play more doubleheaders, I feel like starting pitchers stayed in much longer, also. The "26th man" special rule at least helps.
-
Article: Mauer and the Monster
I think they are trying, but the farm system was poor, and you really can't do that in free agency quickly unless you WAY overspend on a Fielder-type player, in which case they probably are beyond what their budget allows. It's tough to fans to grasp, but their current struggles were caused by what they did in their drafts and developmental system from 2004-09, which happened to be years when the MLB product was quite good. Plenty of teams have tried to buy their way out of terribleness aggressively, and they usually fail the way the Royals and Mets have.
-
Article: Mauer and the Monster
Two things really summed up the enlightened fanbase coming full circle on Mauer and appreciating him as an all-time great talent, whose abilities are being wasted on this team. First, just watching Mauer in the 9th with 2 outs (I think). Team is down by multiple runs, there's no one on base. Mauer takes several pitches and then just laces one down the left field line for a single. Like Dick said, he swings one time and that's what happens. He can't hit a 3-run homer with nobody on-base, but did exactly what they needed, and of course the rally goes nowhere. Second was Perkins' tweet after the game. There was a hashtag meme about voicing unpopular opinions (could be about anything). Unsolicited, Perkins tweeted: Glen Perkins @glen_perkins 12h Joe Mauer doesn't need to hit home runs to be a great hitter. #ConfessYourUnpopularOpinions That contract was not looking great when Mauer had...whatever he had in 2011. Yet, agree or disagree with the wisdom of the deal, he really has become everything you realistically could have hoped for. It's sad watching him waste away on a terrible team, but less so because I don't think Mauer's the type of "Alpha Dog" competitor who is tearing himself up apart inside because he's not in the Playoffs every year. As the star of a basketball team, that lack of "killer instinct" and ego might be a problem. But as one of 9 guys in a lineup, he just shows up for work and does his job extremely well, probably enjoys playing in his hometown, and that may be enough for him.
-
Mauer on wrong side of pitchf/x framing leaderboard
Yes. And Willihammer's point about "respect" is a big one too. There are literally dozens of factors that go into this, and they include very subjective and situational things, like how long the game has been going, the mood of the umpire, home vs. away, respect for the pitcher, respect for the hitter. I'm sure anyone could add several others. I have zero doubt that pitch framing is a "thing". Obviously, there are visual tricks and cues as to how the ball is caught and then shown to an umpire that could make a difference in a tough ball/strike call. I also think if you're a catcher who is a total jerk and you're framing over and over again in an obvious fashion, that would piss the umpire off. And I've basically never seen anything from Mauer to suggest that he's anything but respectful to everyone in the game. It's an interesting thing to study, but much like any number of indirect baseball metrics, I'm just a not a big believer of its reliability and usefulness in creating general propositions, such as "Joe Mauer is good/bad at framing pitches".
-
Biogenesis suspensions: Bad for baseball, good for the Twins?
It's an interesting angle. Tough to say it's too far fetched when you look at the way the Tigers handled picking up Iglesias to respond to Peralta's suspension. Then again, that's a very aggressive front office with money to spend, and a history of reacting quickly to lost players (see: Fielder FA signing/V-Mart Injury).
-
The Silver Lining of Kyle Gibson
Agree with the posters thus far. I had kind of forgotten about the innings limit, but he's at nearly 130 innings between AAA/MLB now, so the end may be near. I'm not passing any judgment on Gibson's staying power in the majors based on his early returns. There's also the post-Tommy John effect that may be holding him back some. But what worries me the most about him as anything more than a middle-rotation guy is that he just doesn't miss bats all that much. It'd be easy for a Twins fan to miss this fact (Santana and '06 Liriano excepted), but strikeout pitchers who come up and struggle are still usually able to strikeout a good number of guys, even if their overall numbers are hampered by control problems or leaving mistakes over the plate and getting hit. This is a guy that even in Single-A and Double-A as a 22 year old (and pre-TJ surgery), was never really an elite strikeout pitcher. He profiles as more of a Baker/Slowey type, though I'd be thrilled if he ever strikes guys out at the rate Baker did in the majors (mid-to-high 7's in K/9 rate). Fans dump on Baker constantly for being hurt and for his rough stretches, but if you factor in all of Liriano's injuries and inconsistencies, Baker was pretty clearly the best starter for this team going back to 2006.
-
Twins send Diamond, Hicks down
Yeah, Hicks showed some flashes of what he could be, but he just isn't ready. Hopefully he wasn't too badly damaged coming to bat virtaully an entire season with a sub .200 batting average on the scoreboard. Suppose he could be back in September, but ideally, I wish he could stay down there until he's had extended success in AAA.
-
C'mon JR, Make a Move!
I agree with some of the earlier comments on Pelfrey - you think a 2-month rental for Liriano or Morneau would have crappy returns? A Pelfrey rental would be even more brutal. His last 4 starts have been pretty good. If he's turned a corner in his TJ recovery, and this is they type of pitcher he is, he might even be a guy you bring back next year as a mid-rotation guy. If not, that's fine too. I guess the point is that Morneau should be traded, but if the offers all suck, it's really not the end of the world that he plays another 2 months here.
-
Mauer on paternity leave until Tuesday
I just operate under the assumption nobody actually believes anything on TwinsDaily they post about - awkward hypotheticals are fun!
-
Top Destinations for Justin Morneau
I just want to make sure I come out aggressively with this comment so I can be proven badly wrong minutes or hours later: I still don't believe that Morneau will be traded. Gleeman and Bonnes seemed almost sure he would be gone because they're applying baseball logic to the front office. I think the Twins are very cautious about shooting themselves in the foot with their fans regarding players they actually care about. Trading Morneau isn't like dumping Luis Castillo or even Liriano at the deadline. This guy was an MVP and a face of the franchise. There are a ton of people who still believe he's a middle of the order hitter. They're wrong, but that doesn't mean their opinions don't "matter". If the return for a Morneau rental is Eduardo Escobar and a replacement level reliever, yes, that makes "baseball sense" by incrementally adding assets, but let's be real, they aren't getting anything of value. And if they have to pick up a portion of the salary to move him, I'm even less convinced that this front office will pay for a player they no longer employ, WHILE pissing off the fans for trading him in the first place.
-
Park Factors and Target Field
I never get tired of this one. I even named one of my fantasy baseball teams the "Cursed Batter's Eye Pines". I kid you not, every single time I see a game in Colorado, Anaheim, Detroit, or the probably dozen of ballparks that have some type of "distracting" green wavy branches in CF, my first thought is "we need an ugly black wall there WHY?" Getting back on topic, I think the perception on it is coming around to the point where it will be considered a "neutral" park. There is evidence that it is very good for RH power hitters and bad for LH power hitters (unless you're a Thome-type hitter that hits no-doubters). It doesn't have a particularly large amount of foul territory at all, which is another reason I don't consider it a pitcher's park.