Everything posted by LaBombo
-
The Return of Nishi
The only sane motive for this must be to embarrass Nish into accepting a lowball 2013 buyout.
-
Jose Lopez DFA'd by the Indians
Are you aware of the fact that Tsuyoshi Nishioka played second base for the Minnesota Twins last night?
-
Hypothetical
I submit Brandon McCarthy for consideration as the new "cheap ace" example, even though he's maybe more of a #2, even after his 'breakthrough' 2011 season. Sore shoulder discount may entice the Twins. There's speculation he'll be waived, since he's a free agent after 2012 anyway. Flame away. Btw, does anybody else wonder if the Twins are probably one of Lee's 20+ no-trade teams? It's certainly possible he'd waive that, but what evidence would he have that the Twins will spend what it takes to compete in 2014/15, other than that they claimed or traded for Cliff Lee? In addition to Lee's huge impact on the overall payroll, I'd imagine the Twins would be worried about the huge risk that his contract represents. It's hard to see the Twins gambling on mega-contract like Lee's when they've spun the wheel of fortune once already with Mauer, and are probably still sour on the way Morneau's contract has played out.
-
Should Butera start at Catcher?
Also, from an Occam's Razor angle, what's more likely... that Butera's defensive value is being inflated by a tiny sample of a shaky stat or two... or that he's found a new ability to handle pitchers that produces overwhelming, repeatable results, but he's refusing to even explain the breakthrough, let alone teach the new ability set to Mauer and Doumit, all with the apparent total disregard of on- and off-field management?
-
Should Butera start at Catcher?
How about a breakdown of the quality of lineups that Butera's pitchers have faced? He seems to get the 'day game after night game' starts fairly often, along with the other scrubs of both the Twins and their opponents. Maybe it's just me. As for being useful as Liriano's personal catcher, well, the idea that Liriano needs a replacement-level catcher to be effective sounds like another reason to trade Liriano, not elevate Butera to near-everyday status. That leaves the 10 starts with non-Liriano pitchers. Given that CERA is already suspect at best for career-sized samples, those 10 starts represent no discernible analytical value to me. I agree with you the Twins are out of it. I even agree with you that Butera should catch more, though not for the reason you suggest, and not nearly to the same extent. I'd just like to see Butera out there a little more just to save wear and tear on Mauer and even Doumit. That being said, the idea that there's no risk to elevating Butera to near-regular status isn't really true. The Twins still need to put butts in the seats, and it's not going well. Selling already disenchanted fans on Butera catching more than Mauer based on what's likely no more than a statistical anomaly would be an ugly PR undertaking. But let's say you throw attendance caution to the winds, keep running Butera out there the rest of the season, and get similar non-Liriano numbers. Now you're going to dump Morneau, convert an already-expensive Mauer to a much less valuable position , and insert a replacement-level bat into the starting lineup based on what's still a microscopic sample size of one of the weakest predictive stats in baseball? Pass.
-
The Quickie Response Thread to the Question: Should the Twins Trade Liriano?
Yes, trade him for a good prospect. His hot streak is another mirage, because he's been healthy and good exactly one time in six years since his debut. And even despite his hot streak his 2012 walk rate is the highest it's ever been, 5+ BB/9. The difference between bringing him back for one or, say, three years is the difference between taking one bad risk or three.
-
Article: Twins Must Decide When, Not If, Glen Perkins & Jared Burton Are Available
That's the spirit, Lloyd!
-
Article: Twins Must Decide When, Not If, Glen Perkins & Jared Burton Are Available
What Twins am I watching? I'm watching the ones that are still tied for dead last in MLB in run differential. I'm watching the ones whose above-average June offense has been predicated almost entirely on getting nearly a bomb per game from Trevor freakin' Plouffe (1 HR/6 AB in June). I'm watching the ones who rank dead last in MLB in bullpen K's per 9 (sustainable success, anyone?). And since you asked, starting May 10th I began watching a Twins team that's played .500 ball against a group of opponents who are a collective 40 games under .500. Look, they're obviously not the historically awful goon squad we saw in April, and they clearly will have money coming off the books as you pointed out. But the idea that the Pohlads will start, rather than finish, building a contender with high-priced FA starters seems terribly optimistic. There's the modest spending history of the Twins in free agency, and then there's the high probability that the recent surge to respectability has a pretty substantial mirage content to it. Or maybe we're thinking more alike than we know, and it's just that you're much more excited than I am about what the Twins can do next year with a rotation headlined by a show-stopper like Joe Blanton, Jeremy Guthrie, or Derek Lowe.
-
Article: Twins Must Decide When, Not If, Glen Perkins & Jared Burton Are Available
Hey, Jim. You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. The Twins will not write giant checks for "FA starters" next year and suddenly transform from crap into contenders. Frugality aside, their rotation currently boasts exactly zero reliable starters who can be counted on in 2013. Zero. Jim, this is still for you. Are you with me? Zero. That leaves the lineup and bullpen. Which of those two (both?) were you going to hang your hat on in 2013 to make up for an absolute vacuum of starting pitching? An offense that's been dreadful despite healthy, productive seasons from M/M/S and a nice shot in the arm from Willingham? Or a bullpen that, despite you bizarre assertions to the contrary, possesses nearly all the smart, quick turn-around tradable assets in the entire organization? Once again, Jim, pretty much everything you said was wrong. Other than that, it was an enjoyable read.
-
Who is NOT Hot in the Twins minors? 2012 version 2
Hicks easily makes the conversation for disappointing outfielders. He's batting just .239/.325/.384 with 41 K's to 19 BB's in 138 AB's. It's his first go at AA pitching, so it's not time to panic, but if he's still struggling against righties later in the season, then the Twins need to scrap the switch hitting and have him start batting right-handed.
-
Brett Lawrie Suspension Poll
Where's the poll for how many games the umpire should be suspended without pay for his embarrassing incompetence and his ridiculous Frank Drebin theatrics? Love the conspiracy theory that it was a deliberate bank shot off the ground. Which Lawrie no doubt practices every day in the off-season.
-
Doumit to the DL, Ben Revere's Coming Back
I'm unsurprised. Revere is a replacement-level player at the moment. It's unsurprising that a front office that looks good mostly because the previous GM destroyed the franchise would call up a player who is better served by playing every day in AAA where he's not consistently overmatched.
-
The move the Twins need to make....RIGHT NOW!
Ben Revere cannot get on base. Ben Revere cannot drive the ball. Ben Revere cannot throw. He can run fast and he has great range. There is a very specific name for a skill set that limits a player to being a defensive sub and pinch runner. It's called '5th outfielder'. Revere may still develop. He's approaching the point in his career that's comparable to where Span was when the light came on for him. That happened for Span in AAA. I hope it happens for Revere, too. He still may become something more than a 5th OF. And if that happens, it will probably be in Rochester.
-
Article: Sleeping on Slama
He's not hitting enough bats. And at 28, his bat-hitting skills are unlikely to improve any time soon. He'll probably end up missing bats for several years in one of those foolish organizations who believe in pitchers getting hitters out that way.
-
Article: Changing Focus: The Danny Valencia & Francisco Liriano Moves
Yep, and Coomer had quite a bit more success than Disco Danny in the minors before finally getting a crack at the majors. Maybe a better comparison to Valencia's offensive ceiling is Scott Leius. He was a nice little piece of the puzzle in '91, posting a .795 OPS while platooning at third against lefties. Pressed into service as a near-everyday player in '92, he went down in flames with a .626 OPS. Now the Twins just need Burroughs to get his Pagliarulo on...
-
Article: Contact Kings
I'm surprised that somebody who wrote an article this good would have anything positive to say about Brackin's blatant propaganda piece about pitching to contact. The lack of (true) supporting evidence in it was unforgivable, even for a second-rate rag like the Strib.
-
Twins Claim Erik Komatsu, DFA Clete Thomas
Komatsu takes Clete's role, which is placeholder for Revere so Ben can play every day and possibly develop into a poor man's Denard Span. Then we can trade Span for the next Jeff Diamond and the next Clete Thomas...
-
Article: Just Better Than Awful
How is finishing 15 or more games behind the typical win total of the Central Division winner over the past decade "competing", other than just not losing as often as they are now?
-
Article: Just Better Than Awful
Yes, the Twins made the playoffs in 2009 with below-average pitching. And all it took was career seasons from Mauer, Cuddyer, Kubel, and Span, plus a solid year from a mostly-healthy Morneau. The rest of the hitters were similar to the awful supporting cast we have now, but certainly not markedly worse. And that 2009 starting rotation was repeatedly bailed out by an infinitely better bullpen than the 2012 edition. Their high-leverage work contributed much more to winning than is reflected in their effect on overall ERA.
-
Article: Twins Drop Burroughs. But Why?
Burroughs/Thomas/Hughes/Butera ===> deck chairs. 2012 Twins ===>Titanic.
-
Article: Three Wishes
Why release Capps? He's got "Saves". Somebody out there will be dumb enough to give us a prospect because he's a "closer".
-
Article: Three Wishes
I wouldn't change a thing. My wish would be to have them continue to run it into the ground with their pitch-to-contact, go-the-other-way nonsense. Then, after the carnage of another 90 plus loss season, maybe I'll get my real wish that the OP won't allow: new leadership in the front office and in the dugout...
-
Terry Ryan/Scott Baker 4:00 Press Conference
...and AGAIN, if that kind of player were easy for the Twins to find, they would've found one in 2011. They didn't. They used two roster spots on Jeff Bailey and Aaron Bates instead. They're not only not the hitter that Rizzo probably is, they're also older. In Bailey's case, much older. If making a Rizzo appear out of thin air were so easy, why didn't they do so in 2011? Was it because there could be no possible need for him, what with Morneau being unavailable or awful the entire season, Thome being 102 years old and likely to be shipped out in a trade, a ton of other guys passing through the Twins' revolving door DL, and zero power-hitting prospects in the high minors? Is that why? Also, there's a difference between not adding value in the field and not being able to play the field. Since Rizzotti falls into the former group, it's not accurate to call him a "DH guy". But even if he were just a DH, he'd still have some potential value at the major league level since he can hit and, in a shocking development, it turns out that the Twins play in a DH league. That's a fact that even the Twins seemed to have overlooked (with the brief, flyer-ish exception of Thome) since they banished David Ortiz to Boston for the crimes of being a DH guy and hitting too many home runs. So I can't blame you for overlooking it as well. One more thing. Baseball Prospectus ironically (and unfortunately for you and your weak argument) characterized Rizzotti as a guy who "might be a good trade chip for second-division team". They also pointed out that his value to the Philly organization was heavily diminished by their farm system being far too left-handed, which explains much of their lack of interest in retaining him. Remember how you glibly dismissed every contrary opinion about the possible role of the Twins' medical and training staff in the Baker injury because those critics weren't doctors? Well, here's a medical analogy for your arguments re: Rizzo. Baseball Prospectus is the Mayo Clinic of baseball performance evaluation and prediction. You're a guy sleeping on a steam grate behind the Mayo Clinic of baseball knowledge. I'm going with the Mayo's opinion instead of yours, steam grate vodka man.
-
Terry Ryan/Scott Baker 4:00 Press Conference
The inevitable hindsight 20/20 charge. You're missing the point, which is that Baker was apparently retained with the false hope of contention. If his risk of injury was so high that he had no trade value, then it's safe to say that a) the Twins should've planned on a rotation fronted by Liriano/Pavano/Blackburn the Twins should've planned on at least 90-95 losses with a rotation like that, and not bothered with Carroll and Marquis, and arguably not even Zumaya. Willingham is still Willingham, and can probably be cashed in at some point.
-
Terry Ryan/Scott Baker 4:00 Press Conference
Void? How about players who can hit for power, or even hit, for that matter? If AAA guys who can hit are so easy to find, why didn't Rochester have a single g*dd@mned one of them last year? Except for Plouffe, their two top homer guys were Dustin Martin, who they cut, and Jeff Bailey, who had 15 "bombs" and is 34 freaking years old. VOID! What's silly is that you don't get that Rizotti has value to the Twins, and cost nothing, and that Baker was worth more than nothing in the offseason. Nothing < Rizotti < Guy you get for Baker.