Everything posted by LaBombo
-
Which pitcher gets sent down to Rochester today?
More deck chair movement. Too bad for Mansihp (sic). "Nice job out there today, kid. The traveling secretary has your ticket to Rochester".
-
Delmon Young traded one year ago today
Not sure where I implied otherwise, and it reinforces my point anyway. It's not like an army of Twins scouts scoured the Tigers system looking for a diamond in the rough. They pulled a name they liked less than probable bust Cole Nelson out of their collective @ss and may have actually gotten a pitcher out of it. Good for them. Your understanding of PTBNL looks about right. Here's the wiki link:http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Player_to_be_named_later.
-
Which pitcher gets sent down to Rochester today?
Jeff Gray making his case by allowing a leadoff double followed by RBI single. More proof that nobody in this organization has the slightest idea what they're doing...
-
Delmon Young traded one year ago today
stringer was referring to Delmon/Oliveros, not Delmon/Barza, is my guess. And that just makes the Delmon episode that much more painful. After all, the deal wasn't Delmon for Lester Oliveros. It was Delmon for Cole Nelson, who is now 22 and still getting his butt kicked in A ball. Oliveros was a PTBNL, for heaven's sake. And that, for me anyway, kills the notion that Bill Smith 'won' the trade with Detroit. If anything, it just shows that even the Twins' bizarre talent valuation was due to hit on a prospect out of sheer luck. Blind squirrel, meet nut.
-
Delmon Young traded one year ago today
If you missed it the first time, or just haven't seen it in a while, check out the best Delmon action photo ever:
-
Delmon Young traded one year ago today
Are you saying it's ok to sell a.........nevermind. The answer to your other question is yes... it is too soon.
-
Delmon Young traded one year ago today
That last sentence is one of the sweetest summaries of Bill Smith's reign of terror I've ever read.
-
Delmon Young traded one year ago today
Great. I was just thinking this morning, "What I could really use is another reminder of how the Twins were destroyed by one of the worst GM's in the history of baseball". And here's this awesome thread to do just that! Cool! Bartlett/Garza post-trade WAR: 18.6 Delmon Young post-trade WAR: -0.8 Other people may see this move as a failure, but I see it as an ingenious maneuver by Smith. It makes the +0.4 WAR received in return for a perennial Cy Young candidate look like an absolute haul. Is anybody else discouraged by the fact that the same people who let Bill Smith run the Twins for four years still own this team? Edit: Oops, forgot to include the 0.1 WAR that Lester Oliveros churned out for the Twins in return for Delmon. And DY's WAR total does not reflect today's home run. Still leaning Garza/Bartlett, though.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
Are we talking about the same thing? The OP was talking about how surprising the current state of the Twins rotation is relative to how locked in it seemed looking forward to this year from the 2010 offseason, not this past offseason. Following the 2010 season the only lineup issues were replacing Hudson and wondering how much of the team's offensive decline was Target-induced. On the other hand, the rotation was Liriano and question marks. You're right about the hindsight 20/20, dime a dozen on the internet thing. And yet I still reject the idea that a rotation like that of the opening day 2012 Twins built exclusively of guys with a history of falling apart...fell apart... is like being hit by lightning from a clear blue sky. No. It's more like being hit by lightning from a sky like the one that forms over the Nazis at the end of Raiders of the Lost Ark.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
Agree to disagree, I guess. If you can look at a kid with 15 innings of AAA, 3 veterans who had collectively managed consecutive healthy, above-average seasons zero times in their careers, and a guy who'd done it once in 13 years and was already in his mid-30's with a drastically dropping K rate... and see a promising, reliable rotation, well, you're more of a glass half full guy than I am. At any rate, you have every right to chalk it up to bad luck if you like. Instead, I see an organization that has shot itself in one foot with a misguided talent valuation philosophy that undervalues pitcher strikeouts (among other problems), and then shot itself in the other with sub-par diagnose and treatment of injuries. Ryan is a huge step up from BS in terms of trading players and signing free agents, but I'm waiting to see some signs that they're moving out of the Dark Ages of baseball before I start doing cartwheels.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
You were talking about the Twins front office and their best guess in 2010 what a 2012 rotation might look like. They obviously had no idea what Liriano would do in 2011 and 2012 or they would've traded him after the 2010 season. So your point about "1 good season in 4" is irrelevant. After the 2010 Liriano was 26, a fringe Cy candidate, and cheap through 2012. Alex Wimmers was a 21 year old with 15 innings of A ball under his belt. Suggesting that the front office projected Wimmers as a 2012 major league starter over Liriano at that point is absurd. So your predicted rotation becomes Liriano, Baker, Pavano, Blackburn, and Gibson. Your point was that unforeseeable injuries ruined that rotation. My contention is that even then it didn't look great, and by the end of 2011 it should've been obvious that NONE of those guys could be counted on in 2012. Setting aside that wildcard Liriano guy you forgot about, the 2010 winter meeting FO brain trust was rightly (according to you) counting on these guys to anchor the 2012 rotation: Baker: Almost as maddening as Liriano. Very good stuff, but zero previous seasons in which he wasn't either injured or mediocre. Pavano: Coming off a good season which also saw his K rate plummet by 2.5/9 innings. 36 years old at the start of the 2012 season. Blackburn. One of the most hittable pitchers in MLB, he got worse in 2010. Miniscule K rate went even lower. Gibson: A rapidly rising star, he finished his first year of pro ball in AAA. So Gibson was a promising but unknown quantity who suffered a serious injury. But how on earth can you say that any of the other three tanking was some sort of unforeseeable shock? None of the four pitchers had pitched 200+ innings more than once in the three preceding seasons. And at the end of 2011 it should've been obvious that not a single one of the guys in your projected rotation could be counted on. The Twins responded to their shattered rotation plan by signing Jason Marquis and conceding the 2012 season. That's no big deal if he's just a body while you rebuild, but the Twins haven't behaved much like a rebuilding team. If you think that an organization finds itself with a rotation full of castoffs because of bad luck, you've got to make a better case than that.
-
Is "Property of Twins" appropriate?
Probably a bad attempt at humor? If it isn't, then it's also NOT further proof that the mantle of racism in America continues to pass from the ugly, meaningful kind against minorities to the increasingly more common kind perpetrated by concern trolls like this imbecile trying to create an issue where there obviously isn't one.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
Fair enough. It was quality sarcasm; just seemed 180 off the P.T.C argument, ie. the Twins DON'T want them. And I lean heavily toward believing that an organization with a reputation for quality scouting cannot possibly fail so consistently to get strikeout pitchers if it's a priority. We'll have to see where Ryan takes the Twins in the next few years. Organizational emphasis on various kinds of ballplayers aside, Ryan simply exceeds Smith in terms of trading players and signing free agents in my view. It's not that Ryan is a genious; he's pretty good in my book, and looks twice as good as he is due to the blinding contrast between his recent years and the nightmare that was Bill Smith's tenure.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
Mauer was a signability pick. Santana was a great move that happened a dozen years ago. The Nathan/FL/BB trade was another great one that took place in 2004. Pavano has provided one ERA+ season above 100 at a cost of nearly $8 million per year. The last 4 are all BS's moves. If you want to make Ryan look better, how about Willingham and Doumit? That would hold more water. That said, I'm happy with Ryan the roster chess player. I'm ready to give up on Ryan the shaper of the franchise's future direction.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
Same straw man. More sarcastic clothes. The Twins have had an awful K rate the past three seasons, including distant, dead last in MLB twice. They've usually ranged from mediocre to bad in previous years. Other than that the Twins are a franchise that doesn't value strikeouts as much as other teams, or are plagued by an organization-wide ineptitude at finding guys who can miss bats (good luck with that one), what's the story? Let's hear your theory. And you're at the point where even your sarcasm doesn't make sense. Almost anybody who disagrees with you about the overall organizational pitching philosophy would expect Deron to be saying some shade of exactly the opposite of that. "Pitches to contact. Doesn't walk many. Perfect Twin! Let the defense worry about the high rate of balls put in play and the screaming line drives. It keeps them happy and engaged". Obscure FO non-player talent evaluator: "His K rate is low for a high pick". Radcliff: "Shut up and go get us more beer". There's the sarcastic version of the argument you're failing to put even a tiny dent in.
-
Article: Twins Must Erase Memories of Nishioka
Nice article, Nick, but there's one part I don't fully agree with. "Nishioka's $3 million salary is hardly a massive burden" Yes and no. You're referring to the 2013 sunk (suck?) cost and its relatively likely modest effect on what the 2013 payroll can buy . Agreed. But when you include the cost of the bidding rights and buyout, the Twins will have blown over $14 million on this guy. To paraphrase the immortal quote by Senator Everett Dirksen, "A million here, a million there, pretty soon you're talking about some real money". Amortizing waste and failure is a way to minimize and sometimes even ignore it. Most people at least acknowledge that Nishioka's utter collapse was unforeseeable, and Hardy's near-AS caliber 2011 was a bit of a surprise. I get that. But there are also plenty of people wondering why the Twins gambled by letting a proven above-average SS go for nothing, then signing a guy who'd never played an inning of American ball in his life to start for an alleged contender while only saving about $1.6 million per year over 3 years. Other risks are even harder to justify. Marquis, Blackburn's extension, Pavano's, Punto before that... the Twins are predictably, reliably p!ssing away a few million 'here and there' every year. It's adding up to "some real money", nearly enough to knock them out of the 2013 market for an ace and place them in the '2nd/3rd starter if you're lucky' market. That's unacceptable.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
I had heard Wimmers was the 'safe' and most league ready arm if I remember correctly. A two year ETA doesn't seem too out of reach with that being said. Unfortunately he's free fallen since the organization COMPLETELY screwed up his UCL tear. Too stupid to get the surgery done right away. I'm sorry, but if you seriously believe that the Twins FO in 2010 was counting on a guy with at BEST one full year of LOW minor league experience to hold a spot in the major league 2012 rotation, well, that's just crazy. When have they ever done that voluntarily, with either pitchers or position players? And the idea that Wimmers would take the place of a near-Cy Young candidate under contract through 2012 just indicates that you don't believe your own point about the 'woe is me' luck of the Twins with injuries. If you thought the point could stand on its own, you wouldn't have to rely on the rainbows and unicorns scenario you concocted to place Wimmers (darn the bad luck!) instead of Liriano (who sucked instead of getting injured and didn't fit your bad luck narrative) in the 2012 rotation. Agree with your assessment that the Twins multiplied their own bad luck with their handling of Wimmers' injury. It's an ugly, repeating theme in an organization that has several others as well. It's looking more and more like the Twins fear losing a bunch of games more than they fear not contending, and fear change even more than they fear losing. Twins Fear-o-meter summary: not contending < losing season(s) < change.
-
What's to Blame for the Rotation?
How many people are discussing the Twins' pitching philosophy purely in terms of velocity? Most people are talking in terms of "pitch to contact" and the low strikeout rate that goes with it. In Liriano's last good year, 2010, the Twins still managed to finish ahead of only perennial also-rans KC, Baltimore, Seattle, and Cleveland in K rate among all MLB teams. Last year, they were dead last, and will almost certainly finish 2012 in their current position, dead last. When an organization posts a dreadful strikeout rate and then lowers it in the following seasons despite spending more than the league average, then two things are apparent. 1. Blaming Ryan for this mess after less than a year on the job is beyond ridiculous. He was handed a bag of crap that started really stinking after Wild BS took over. 2. At least some, if not all, of the facets of the organization you insist are not bad... are pretty bleeping bad.
-
The Nishioka Story
I'm in. Pernell Roberts has checked out, so I hope Sally Struthers is available for a TV spot.
-
Worst Twin Ever?
+1, but ironically a reason to hate Tommy Herr even more. TH's failure led to the Twins trading for Backman. At least it was just prospects instead of a popular member of a WS winner like Brunansky/Herr.
-
Is it time to just release him?
thrylos98 - I won't say you're missing the point about Nishy, but you're maybe undervaluing it. Yes, it's true that short of maiming or murdering productive teammates, Nishy in a utility role won't affect the outcome of this throwaway season in any meaningful way. That's not the point. The point is that Nish isn't being played to avoid the appearance of sunk cost, he's playing because an injury to one infielder has left the Twins with no appreciably better option than an abject failure. This is a guy who barely looks like he's played any baseball before, let alone the major league kind. Just his presence on the roster is a powerful indictment of the failure of a business that has received an enormous public subsidy. Sure, that doesn't obligate the Twins to spend, let alone win. But short of Terry Ryan forcing the fans at home games to enter through a single gate and personally telling every one of them to go f#@% themselves, it's hard to see how he could cultivate more ill will than the kind generated by allowing a ballplayer who can't play ball to suit up every night. PS Thanks for posting the awesome Nishy Error photo...
-
Avian Flu > Jeff Gray
It's heavily dependent on exchange rates and the ability to self-administer antibiotics... > Crain Wreck > Gray Lady Down
-
Worst Twin Ever?
Or Jose Offerman. He's not even top 10 worst Twin material, but it's just so much fun to say 'Awfulman'.
-
Next Year's Needs Start With Outstanding Defensive SS and 2B
There's an idea. Instead of placing a high priority on acquiring defensive savants who can't hit, let's work on replacing our p.t.c. guys with real pitchers who can miss some bats! That way they won't need the savants, and would have the option to eventually pursue adequate defenders who can actually hit.
-
Jose Lopez DFA'd by the Indians
Last night? LAST F'!ING NIGHT? Unbelievable... And yes, the Twins are fairly stocked up on no-hit infielders. The difference between most of those guys and Nish is that he's no-field as well. Anybody who thinks that assessment is based on just "last night" hasn't watched a lick of Nish's 2011 fielding 'highlights'...