Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

LaBombo

Verified Member
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by LaBombo

  1. My point was that the AAA or majors decision should be based on what Hicks has accomplished (and what he has not) in his 5 years and over 2000 plate appearances in the minors, not what Twins scouts thought of him in high school. Scout evaluations in 2012 and in 2013 ST have relevance, but even those are made less and less revealing as we increasingly see what Hicks is becoming by what he's actually done, as opposed to what the scouts think he'll be, much less what they thought 5 years ago.
  2. In fact the Twins have stated as much at times throughout the previous decade. Can't find the quote, but I believe Ryan described a given season's available payroll budget as something along the lines of 'use it or lose it'. No carryover to next season's roster. But that was before the nonsensical 'money isn't an issue' meme took the place of frank discussions about payroll and roster construction.
  3. Or how about... Lineup A: 1.00 slugging = everyone goes 1-4 with a homer, no walks = 9 runs. Lineup B: 1.00 OBP = everyone gets a hit or walk in every at bat = infinite number of runs.
  4. What on earth does the round he was picked in have to do with skipping a level for a player who's needed at least a full season at every level?
  5. The fact that he's in the majors at all instead of AAA pretty much ensured that patience would be out the window. Those look like very good comps for Hicks, minus some power. If he can maintain a low to mid-teens walk rate and average .250, his glove should make him a plus player, and with several years to improve his offensive skill set.
  6. You've raised an excellent point and made all the due diligence disclaimers. But the minute you speculate what to do if Hicks isn't ready, you're in for some flak on a board where the 2013 expectations for him frequently range from net average to RoY or even All Star. While I think the Twins shouldn't have rushed Hicks, I'm hoping he'll stick and we won't have to count on Mastro as an everyday guy. But if the Twins see Mastro as a quad A guy who will be so exposed as a starter that he can't sustain an OBP high enough to lead off for a non-contender, why didn't they someone who can? And if they DO think Mastro can start in CF if Hicks is sent down, who is the backup? I'm a little more optimistic than you about what Mastro might manage if Hicks isn't ready. Even so, I think it was wrong to enter ST without a realistic CF alternative to Hicks and Mastro. And no, I don't consider Benson a realistic alternative, although I'm still hoping he manages to turn things around. Oh, and don't worry about Floribar leading off. They'll be too busy battling Dozier for AB's in the two spot if/when the Mauer experiment is pronounced a failure, and probably whether it is or not.
  7. And if Hicks IS over-matched after a few weeks in the majors, let's hope there will be more applause in order for a board that is not overflowing with proof of the existence of a center fielder corollary to Nichols' Law of Catcher Defense.
  8. I think a strong lineup and potentially killer rotation get them to 93-95 wins, but a good closer maybe gets them close to 100. On the other hand, if KC and Cleveland are both as improved on the field as they are on paper, they may need to add a reliever just to get to the 94-ish win area. If it sounds like I'm going overboard with the idea of adding 4 or 5 wins with a good closer, here's an even more drastic appraisal: "All three [benoit/Coke/Al-Al] are quality relievers and can get the job done short term but are better as setup men. A potential 100-win club becomes a 90- to 92-win team without a closer. And as a team with aspirations of returning to the World Series, the Tigers need a designated closer, such as Street or Cishek. The Tigers have enough in the farm system to make a deal at the trade deadline." However you feel about Jim Bowden, he's been around baseball quite a bit, and he seems pretty fired up about how much butt the Tigers could kick if they add a good closer. My impression of the value of a good closer is lower, more in the BP/Bill James (made, not born, leverage vs. 'saves', etc.) camp than in Bowden's, but that being said, it looks like they could use one. Coke is a LOOGY. Dotel is a solid, often underrated reliever but nearly 40. Albuquerque has mad stuff and durability issues. Rondon will have to work on his command in AAA for a while. That leaves Benoit, who is a fine reliever, but he's been inconsistent throughout his career. And today highlighted their need for another quality reliever. Leyland stuck with Smyly (way too long, imho, especially with a day off tomorrow), a converted starter, when most teams with playoff aspirations would have a better option when everyone is rested. As a Twins fan,, I'm hoping the Tigers give up Rondon for a 'proven closer' who will be gone in a couple of years when the Twins have rebuilt and rebounded.
  9. To that I would add that he was facing what is widely considered in the non-TD baseball world to be one of the better offensive lineups in MLB. Pretty encouraging outing...
  10. Nope. A revoltin' development instead. But sweet bugs bunny ref.
  11. Could be wilkin's entire war contribution for the season on the line right here...
  12. In addition to jokin's comments, I would add that even if you set aside what 'type' of hitter a player is, the fact of the matter is that Gardenhire has a loooong history of wasting outs by usually placing one of the lineup's worst hitters in the two spot. So the argument isn't as much 'Mauer 2nd vs. Mauer 3rd', it's 'Mauer 2nd vs. crap hitter 2nd'. And the answer is 'Mauer 2nd'.
  13. Run expectancy matrix: With the exception of Revere last season, Gardenhire has almost always put a mediocre to poor OBP hitter (who, entirely by coincidence, has been a middle infielder over 90% of the time) in the two spot. By having one of the worst hitters on the team hitting in front of Mauer, they're making outs they don't need to in front of him. And each extra out generally reduces by 20% per out the chance the Twins will score a run in most situations when Mauer comes to the plate. Batting Mauer third gives him a small (barely above 30% with the crap hitters Gardy uses in the deuce) chance of an extra baserunner to bat in, in about a quarter of his at bats. But that comes at the unacceptable cost of a substantially reduced chance of the Twins scoring a run in ALL of Mauer's at bats, including the first time through the order. Mauer with 0 out > Mauer with 1 out. Mauer with 1 out > Mauer with 2 outs.
  14. To me, it seemed that the point of the WAR comparison was to refute the claim that Marcum/McCarthy in place of Correia/Pelfrey would make the rotation only "slightly more serviceable". And it does. Both M/M guys are risks, but the assertion that if healthy they are virtually indistinguishable from mediocrities like KC and MP is clearly unsound. And as for the process used to decide on Correia, it hasn't really been open to debate since Ryan said this: So Ryan is believing favorable scouting reports instead of 10 years of statistical evidence of mediocrity when evaluating a 32 year old pitcher. And it seems likely that at least a few other decisions are being made the same way, since Ryan said nothing to explain why Correia represented a unique case where stats don't apply.
  15. No, dude, he totally wins, because he actually said "Checkmate!" as he typed his ftw claim...
  16. Good points, here and in the one about relative platoon splits of CP vs. other LHB Twins. To that I would add that as roughly the 6th or 5th best hitter in a typical lineup, Parmelee shouldn't see a ton of LOOGY's. Some teams won't have enough of them available to waste one on him when there are the other guys you mentioned who are much more likely to punish a righthander than Parmy.
  17. Yup. Interesting that Rosenthal cites Gardenhire's record of reaching the postseason but not his utter futility there, and BP's acknowledgement of his intangible clubhouse value but not their scathing criticisms of his tactical failings in the playoffs. Gardy's a good guy and a decent manager, but the idea that retaining him is some sort of no-brainer strikes me as the kind of thing you end up saying when you depend on amicable access to an important source for your journalistic livelihood. That's not a knock on Ken in particular, just what seems to be a beat writer fact of life.
  18. Yeah. If I remember correctly, Bill James was referencing another star catcher, Mike Piazza, when noting that it's a pretty sure sign of a bad franchise when it blames its best players for the team not succeeding. To that I would add 'sign of a bad fan base'. Like a previous poster said, frustration with the play of the Puntos and Buteras of the world tends to ultimately be directed at the GM, while complaints about Mauer tend to be, well, directed at Mauer. Too passive at the plate, can't stay healthy, costs too much, not an outspoken leader, etc. If forced to choose between the two dead horse whippings of a potential Hall of Famer or a guy who can't hit his Newfoundland's weight let alone his own, I'm trending toward the latter.
  19. Yes. And to that I would add that at least some people who think the Correia signing stunk don't believe that he'll ruin the franchise, however he pitches. Instead, they believe that a front office that can't understand why signing Kevin Correia is a bad idea will ruin it eventually.
  20. An aggregate of the Hicks projections at Fangraphs, BP, and elsewhere looks something like this: .235/.320/.365, with a K rate of about 25% and 12 HR, 18 SB, 70 runs if he were to manage 600 PA's in 2013. Assuming that he puts up a line like that more or less consistently through April, does he stay up? Should he? Is the reputation he has for slow starts after promotions a cause for optimism that he's on the right track if he manages an April like that? And if he ends up with a line like that after a full season, will it have been worth it? Also, while I like your optimism regarding Dozier, it's hard to find any projection that shows him getting on base at a .300 or better clip, and most figure him for about a .285 obp.
  21. He was listed at 6'3", 190 in his pro debut. He's 6'4", 235-240 now. If he "fills out" much more, he may have to skip playing first and just go full-time DH. Interesting that Sano's one plus defensive tool, the arm, would be almost entirely wasted at first, and yet it looks like nobody in this thread has mentioned right field. At any rate, with another dreadful year on tap at the major league level and a growing amount of impatience among many of the faithful here, I'm sure there will be a hue and cry to move Sano to first to expedite his MLB debut unless his defense at 3rd improves drastically this year.
  22. Like the middle-aged goat guy said, excellent point(s). The Benson non-catch at the foul line looked even worse (better?) to me after seeing it again. The 'fence' along the left field foul line looks to be about 6 feet from the chalk. Also, it's not a fence in any way that I connect with normal boundaries in ball parks. Instead, at that height it looks like a medieval torture device designed to hand out either a broken femur or a punch in the wiener, depending on the leg length of the charging outfield victim.
  23. +1. It's been surprising and a little disappointing how quickly much of the media and fan base has treated Sano's possible move to first as a foregone conclusion. He's still pretty raw at third, but he's not the hopeless oaf he's been made out to be. He sure looks like he has the raw athletic ability to be better than some of the bruisers who've managed to man third in the majors.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.