Everything posted by LaBombo
-
The Twins don't use advanced metrics
Your snide, dismissive, wrong comment aside, what are the really compelling moments in the article that made it clear that the Twins are relying on every cutting-edge resource available? Is it the first few paragraphs, where 'stat guy' is an apparent organizational outsider who gets laughed out of the room by the 'baseball guys'? In front of media? Is it the resume of Goin, where we find that he's a business degree guy who started in the call center and whose admin jobs had nothing to do with player evaluation until two years ago? Is it the refusal of Goin to be interviewed due to "competitive advantage", which sounds almost as silly as the Top Gun "I could tell you, but then I'd have to kill you" thing? Is it the profound non-effect Goin has had on organizational culture that still has Gardenhire chuckling over and over at his own dumb joke about "cybermetrics". Or is it Ryan coming off as a pleasant, well-meaning, but slightly addled grandpa at the end of the article, where he tried to talk about specifics of statistical analysis, and... well, 'struggled' is the most generous interpretation that come to mind? On the other hand, if you're on board with the Twins' blueprint going forward mostly because you and Goin are both Packer fans, well, you're a better man than I am, Gunga Din.
-
Article: What's the Plan: Miguel Sano
Of course Sano's other stats have value in deciding his future. But he lags well behind the names you mentioned in terms of his ability to make contact, and that will probably get worse in the majors, especially if he skips AAA. Only a handful of MLB hitters are able to be consistently valuable with strikeout rates over 25%. Sano has the potential to be one of those guys, but why rush him when there is a glaring weakness in his game? And while I think the Twins organization is a little too wrapped up in 'play the game the right way' (especially Sano's silly multigame sit after the home run trot), I'd rather see Sano take as many of those lumps as possible in the minors instead of the majors. Not sure I ever raised an objection to a September callup for Sano. In a developmental vacuum it's relatively harmless at worst, and somewhat beneficial at best. My concern would be that a fluky-good September and a Hicksian spring training would lead the Twins to make the same mistake with Sano that they did with Hicks. Then again, maybe they'll make that mistake based on a good spring alone. Hard to say. At any rate, we're not going to see eye to eye on Sano's 2014 anyway, because most of what I've read leads me to believe that service time really is a critical issue. For that reason alone it looks to me like it would be a big mistake to start Sano in the majors next year.
-
Article: What's the Plan: Miguel Sano
And? So will Sano's, assuming they call him up in September. If they don't, and the explanation is that he's not ready, then we should have our answer about whether they should trot him out there on opening day.
-
Article: What's the Plan: Miguel Sano
Sano is striking out in 28 percent of his AA plate appearances. Not a single one of the players on your list was anywhere near that rate in AA. In fact, nearly all of them had K rates about 10 percentage points lower than Sano. And as much as you don't want to compare Sano to Hicks, the latter struck out at a significantly lower rate than Sano in AA, just over 20%, and still struggled to make contact in the majors. Also, it's odd that you should bring up Trout's name at all. He started 2012 in triple A, just like many people are hoping Sano will. If the Angels can do that with a guy who owned double A even more than Sano has, is there really anything keeping the Twins from doing it?
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Pretty exciting, and Detroit didn't exactly take them lightly with that lineup in a day game... And with that, glunn, chitown, adios, amigos, perhaps we shall ride together again soon. http://www.susansheu.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/09/three-amigos-web.jpg PS Thanks for doubling my career like total. 2377 more and I'll have enough for the stuffed panda!
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Not really sure whether to be awed at your powers of perception or bitter about jinxing Perk...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
A younger, cheaper Doumit would be nice, at least until the minor league catching situation sorts itself out.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
WhoaWhoaWhoa there, chief. Some of us prefer to think of ourselves as cretins.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
That's cool, as long as you sit in the same section but don't identify yourself so we can spend the whole game guessing...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
How about height-to-mass ratio?
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Whichever you decide, keep the truth a secret. Mystery will only heighten the appeal.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
If the Mini Cooper in your old avatar is your ride, you couldn't be more than about a buck twenty five...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
A new avatar possibility beckons...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Don't forget zombies.... ooh, alien invasion too. Better go see how many rolls of see-through, restroom-grade Scott are left in my garage.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Posting some of your plus-sized paintings occasionally should help keep tempers in check...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Yeah. Used to naively hope that Wins and Saves either be revised to make them relevant, or at least completely ignored. Kinda gave up on that.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Was going to post a simple "You're fired", but then remembered that I was thinking the same thing. Kid pitched well is still my takeaway, but only because I'm forced to because of my stupid 'however the game turns out' qualifier in my earlier compliment to AA.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
On the contrary, it proved that Glunn is unafraid to share his feelings, and our image of him as a man is the richer for it... http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/7/70/Bob_at_Easel.jpg
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Thanks, but it was really just a no-brainer after the Morneau/trade/salary debate.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Got an autographed picture of Doumit at Twinsfest laying around somewhere. Had trouble framing it for some reaason...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Ryan already turned 'em down. Tigers wouldn't eat enough of Cabby's contract...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Looks like you were right to test him by putting runners on with the jinx. Kid did a great job of digging himself out of the hole. Got Cabrera again. However the game turns out, that has to be a confidence builder.
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Not another word...
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Going Up North is generally regarded as a good thing in Minnesota, at least on summer weekends and holidays. Does that count?
-
Game Thread: Twins@Tigers 8/22 12:08PM
Looks like the second v should be capitalized after Doumsie's shot.