Everything posted by LaBombo
-
Stephen Drew
Guess we can throw in the towel on Hicks. And at least a dozen other prospects. But hey, it'll make it a bit easier to keep track of the minors.
-
Even though Hicks is better than AP and DM......
He was terrible at the plate and took some routes on fly balls that would have baffled Magellan. And if he's not more worried about the crap season he had last year more than a 2014 'demotion' to the level above the one where he last had success, well, that's an argument against the probability that he'll help the Twins in a meaningful way. PS. Who his dad is? What his body looks like? Really?
-
Even though Hicks is better than AP and DM......
Hence the word "established" in my post. Pending good evidence to the contrary, you could substitute the words 'remotely valid'. And yes, Oliver's WAR thinks Hicksie's web gems will offset the continued struggle at the plate that it projects. But it's a small overall edge derived from the much less quantifiable variable of the Offense + Defense = WAR equation. Also, none of the projections account for the potential increase in offensive advantage for the Preslianni platoon as a result of them facing same-side pitching less often. That's not a given, with Presley having had some reverse platoon splits, but it's certainly worth noting. But we agree that it's not worth arguing over (as opposed to discussing?). The decision has been made, and center probably belongs to Hicksie until B^2 arrives. His projected progression and ceiling took a hit last year, but it looks like a setback instead of a wall. He should be a good player, and how the Twins handled the choice probably won't have a drastic effect on either the outcome of the season or his future as a baseball player.
-
Even though Hicks is better than AP and DM......
While I don't agree that wins are the most important goal of this season, I certainly understand that philosophy. But why can't we compare the idea of promoting of Meyer to the majors to the decision to re-promote Hicks? And why aren't/weren't Presley and Mastro viable options?
-
Even though Hicks is better than AP and DM......
Is everyone who wants Hicks to start in center because winning takes precedence over player development also in favor of putting Meyer into the rotation? Because that's essentially what you're asking for when you put Hicks back into the majors. The highest level that each player has succeeded in is AA. You could argue that Hicks was more ready because he played a full season in AA while Meyer played just under half a season. But you could also argue that Meyer is a lower risk than Hicks to fail if starting the season in the majors because he hasn't already failed once like Hicks. The fact is that Hicks didn't hit much in AAA either. Much has been made of the fact that he was playing through an injury that hampered his swing. That's certainly a strong possibility, but it's also a better argument for him to start the season in Rochester than it is to ignore his performance there and make him the opening day CF, isn't it? Whether his swing was messed up due to injury or not, the point is it was messed up. If it was due to the injury, he should be able to tear it up in AAA for a couple of months, regain confidence, and still have over 400 PA's to contribute to the big club. If his AAA struggles were not due mostly to the injury, then he'll need some more work down there. In any case, the fact that he struggled to make contact all of last year is a better indicator of his present ability level and what to expect at the beginning of the season than two dozen spring training AB's and a home run against a pitcher who may have washed out with the Nippon Ham Fighters. There's a reason why pretty much every established projection system has Hicks OPSing a good 30 or 40 points lower than Alex Presley. Hicks will very likely end up the better player, and he's certainly more fun to watch, but the Twins are making the same mistake twice by having him start the season in Minnesota.
-
Article: Glen Perkins Signs Extension With Twins
Yeah, it looks like a good deal to me too. There's a good chance they'd go too long and/or too much if they waited another year to extend. That or else lose him just as the Twins finally become competitive again and then be forced to audition middle relievers in the closer role while trying to win the division or worse, end up making a trade like the one for the guy whose name rhymed with Cat Naps. That being said, possibly the best part of the deal is that it could substantially increase his trade value should the Twins decide to move him if, by mid-season next year, it appears the rebuild will continue into 2016.
-
Article: Twins Roster Projection 2.0
It's interesting to me that even after the fiery crash of Aaron Hicks last year, there's still belief that a handful of spring training at bats is a pretty useful tool to decide who makes the Opening Day lineup and roster, including...Aaron Hicks. He was overmatched in both MLB and AAA last year, and he didn't play winter ball. It's hard to see how 5 hits in 20 AB's (or 15 in 45, for that matter) provides any meaningful counter to the relatively substantial evidence that he's not ready yet.
-
Is Pinto getting a fair shake?
Or until he gets conked in the melon by a stray round and the replacement level guy behind him coming down the ramp of the Higgins boat becomes the new squad leader. Sorry, over the top, I know, but after all the talk about PST and Wet Blanket Awards, I couldn't resist. Hope Pinto (and the rest of the organization!) stays healthy and sports medicine and equipment people figure out how to minimize the danger of concussion.
-
Bonnes for Preposterous Statement
KG's Ponder Gorgasm had my backing for #1. And personally I'd like to see them limit the field to quotes about sports, or least quotes from people in sports. Then you could eliminate obvious "winners" that are just too sad to fit the spirit of the tournament, like any entertainment person comparing the gravity of their field to military or EMS service, for example.
-
Is Pinto getting a fair shake?
The signing of Suzuki wasn't a terrible one to begin with, but it has a chance to turn out that way if Pinto ends up playing only once or twice a week all season. It would be better to let him work on his defense in AAA until he's ready to push Suzuki to the bench and start around two thirds of the games. And however it was phrased, the Antony comment about weight isn't a good sign with respect to how highly they regard him. If there's organizational concern about conditioning, and therefore possibly even work ethic, well, it's going to be hard to overcome in the near term in a franchise that considers Spring Training to be Spring Tryouts. As far as I can remember, at least that hasn't been a recurring theme in the scouting reports on him. It's still disappointing to know that Gardy hasn't overcome his bizarre, inexplicable phobia of 'losing the DH' for two or three at bats when one of two catchers DH's. But at least he's made it clear that he'd rather have two non-DHable catchers than pretend it's the '80's and carry three, which is pretty much a 24 man roster.
-
Article: Wilkin & The Kids: Twins 9, Orioles 2
Hey, a pleasant surprise for a change. Cool. Worley was sort of the forgotten man in the mainstream media coverage leading into spring, but even as bad as last year was it's encouraging to hear he's off to a good start. Gardy's postgame words gave me an idea for a Twins game promotion. When a weekend game in July or early August isn't selling well, promote it as Kill the Cliche Day. A Twins fan will be chosen at random and given the chance to designate a cliche that will be off limits for Gardenhire and Anderson to use in interviews for the rest of the season. Until recently for me it would be 'keep the ball down' without hesitation, but now the incessant gibberish about 'pitch angle' (not arm slot) and 'downward plane' is making a real run for the money.
-
New Catcher Framing Values
It's interesting that in a thread about quantifying what is essentially the skill of deceiving umpires, the only mention of umpires is that they are 'accounted for' in the methodology. If catcher framing is exerting a measurable (let alone significant) effect on ball and strike calls, then MLB either needs to either completely overhaul the umpire selection, training, and review process, or else take the primary responsibility for ball and strike calls away from them. I realize I'm in the unvast minority on this one, but I'd much rather know whether a pitch is actually a ball or a strike than what the vivid imagination of a Joe West or a C.B Bucknor happens to think of it.
-
Article: Who ARE You People?!?
http://31.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m8d9hgYfD61ryq77fo1_500.jpg "Sure thing, Giant Beer! (*belch*)"
-
The unofficial offseason trade idea dump
But think of how many lively debates about framing we'd miss out on...
-
Hypothetical: Would you have traded Joe Mauer for Fielder or Kinsler?
It's surprising how many people would at least consider the Fielder trade, thought I'd be in a tiny minority there. It might be interesting to re-frame a Kinsler deal with the caveat that such a trade would come with a hypothetical assurance that the Twins would use the surplus payroll from the deal to help them sign their first legit free agent 1/2 starter ever to a long-term deal. Also, does this thread get taken seriously or even created if Mauer is still catching? Gonna guess no.
-
Article: Should Twins Offer Bronson Arroyo A Third Year?
So when considering expensive upper-tier pitchers who are 30, we're told that Terry Ryan would be, in his own words, "very cautious". But when shopping for an affordable back of the rotation starters, a three year deal for a 37 year old with weak peripherals is Kool and the Gang? Lately Ryan has seemed bent on eroding his credibility, and in that sense a three year deal for Arroyo is a perfect fit.
-
Pirates Reacquire Duke Welker from Twins
http://dahayden.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/03/Titanic-Deck-Chairs.jpg
-
Article: Finding Mauer's Replacement: Part 2
Molina all the way. Let's get a guy who's the best in the game at manipulating the grossly inconsistent umpire strike zones to give the Twins' developing pitchers an edge they don't deserve and that pads their stats and egos, as well as further taxing the front office's already sketchy ability to evaluate pitching talent. Then in a couple of years, when his already 38-year-old butt is gone, and his Jedi umpire- mind-tricking skill with it, we can watch the whole staff collapse as they're forced to actually throw pitches inside the real, non-Jedi strike zone. Sarcasm aside, I'd rather see MLB fix the shameful state of strike zone consistency and accuracy than have the Twins buy into the one of the sleight-of-hand charlatans. Barring that, yeah, let's go after one of the guys who's best at exploiting a deeply flawed system. If he can teach the shell game to Pinto and add to the clubhouse quality of life as a bonus, I'm in.
-
Talks with Bronson Arroyo "heating up"
After three years of abject rotation failure, it's getting a little less likely to feel either excitement or frustration over possible FA starter signings. So "Talks with Bronson Arroyo heating up" sounds a tiny bit to me like an Onion story, along the lines of "Family's excitement over impending used minivan purchase approaching fever pitch with approval of car loan". Yes, 'heating up' refers to the increasing likelihood of a deal, not the desirability of it. Still, it's hard to see what Arroyo does on a two year deal other than maybe to help Gardenhire achieve the historical moral victory of becoming the first manager since WWII to avoid losing at least 93 games after three consecutive 90+ loss seasons.
-
Article: Finding Mauer's Replacement: Part 1
That, and Steinbach is coming back, right? Joe has caught most of the likely 2014 opening day pitchers, and I'm guessing Terry learned a thing or two in 1300+ games behind the plate As for the second part, entertainment value was also the reason to love The Great and Profaneful Oz during his tenure with the WS. But not too keen on bringing him in either.
-
Article: Finding Mauer's Replacement: Part 1
The first part is incredibly accurate. Doesn't that buy some slack on the credibility of the second part?
-
Article: Finding Mauer's Replacement: Part 1
Last year's visit to the solar system by Comet Bernier foretold the forthcoming Fryer Apocalypse. Remember... drinking water, canned foods, batteries, and '87 and '91 playoff runs on DVD.
-
Article: Finding Mauer's Replacement: Part 1
Not sure there's much cause for litigation here. The Twins have had a comprehensive, exhaustive acclimation/conditioning program in place over the past three seasons to minimize the danger and suffering fans are subjected to in the event of an apocalyptic disaster exactly like a potential Eric Fryer 2014 Opening Day start. If you've failed to adapt after three seasons of this, well, let's just say that if you're claiming damages, pain and suffering from seeing Fryer in the lineup after watching the 2013 Twins debuts of Worley, Gibson, Hicks, Colabello, etc, then you'd be facing an uphill battle convincing a jury of your peers if any of them are Twins fans.
-
A Veteran's Day Thank You
A day late but the thread is still up so I'll chip in my thanks as well.
-
Twins expressed interest in free-agent catcher Jarrod Saltalamacchia
If you asked 10 people on the street who the Dodgers gave up for Drew Butera, you'd get 3 'I dunno's, 2 'The Twins traded Drew Butera?'s, and 5 'Who's Drew Butera?'s.