Narrative: Have the Twins Promoted College Pitchers Slowly?

Question: Were all these pitchers listed shut down as soon as they were drafted for the remainder of the year or did some of them go on to pitch some professionally in the year they were drafted?

Pleasantly surprised - when the pitcher was good the previous regime did move them quickly.  If only there had been more good ones. 

I’m not sure you can really compare all college pitchers.

Did they leave college at 19 or 22? Did they pitch at a high-end program or a community college in Alaska? Did they have a college program that ran them into the ground or is their “arm mileage” low?

There are other factors as well. Was the guy ever good enough to make it to the majors in the first place? Where were they drafted? Obviously, there is more pressure to advance a top 5 pick than a guy drafted in an obscure late round. Who’s ahead of them in the pecking order, both minors and majors? Is the major league team competitive?

Another input into the process: the developmental staff. A high end staff gets the player ready for advancement earlier. If you spend two decades teaching hitters to slap the ball into the opposite gap....of course you’re going to screw guys up (see Ortiz, David). It may look like they aren’t “ready” to advance, when really they’re being held back by poor coaching.

I don’t think there’s any doubt that the previous regime advanced all players, not only college pitchers, on a different timeline than some other clubs. It’s the nature of the small vs. large market salary cap-less system (poor developmental staff aside). When you’re small, you don’t want to burn a year for a marginal role. You know you’re not resigning the guy, so you want to hold off until the player is nearest his prime as possible. A year too early hurts the team....not the player.

On that note, speaking of narratives, I think this system has created one. It’s that players need lengthy periods of development. If they’re exposed too early, you’ll crack them like an egg destroying their career forever. There are parallel dimensions in which a player is a hall of famer if given adequate developmental time against 19 year olds, or a total bust if not cooked long enough. I’ve never bought any of that.

I don't ever recall someone complaining about someone not being promoted from the A+ level or higher ever panning out.

There is no doubt that the Twins have slowly promoted college pitchers.

From 2013 to 2019 there were 15 pitchers that the Twins drafted that made their MLB debut.  Of those 15 pitchers only 3 of them made their debut at age 24 (Duffey, Vasquez, Curtiss).

Most were 25 years old (Gibson, Rogers, Poppen, Sleger, Chargois, Acther, Darnell).  Hildenberger and Wheeler were 26.  Eades, Wimmer, and Dean 27.

While to a degree most of the names on here made the MLB level for just a quick show they did not have the talent to remain in the league, we have to also remember that the Twins pitching staff was pretty limited throughout most of this time frame.  The other factor is that despite having good minor league statistics a lot of these players were still slowly moved through the system.  

But, a guy like Hildenberger was virtually unhittable as a minor league player at every level.  When he got to the Twins in 2016 as a 26 year old player, he pitched very well with a 3.21 ERA and 9.4K/9.   His arm did not hold in after his rookie season with the Twins, but when you are moved so slowly it doesn't give you much of a chance for second chances either.

Whether they were promoted to fast, or not, what I took from this post is that only 7 of the 16 who did move fast made it to the big leagues for more than a few games.  So less than half of the best of the entire organization made it.  Of those 7 four had very good careers (five if you would include Gibson),  albeit there were no ACES.

Don't know if you are up north or in the Twin Cities, Seth, stay safe.  

There is doubt we have moved our college pitchers too slowly. Let's see how they compare to the other 29 teams before we draw any faulty conclusions. It's very common for fan bases to feel prospects are not moved quickly enough. Very common.

The Alaska Baseball League alumni includes:

Randy Johnson

Tom Seaver

Frankie Sweetmusic Viola

Jared Weaver

Dave Steib

C j Wilson

AND...

Josh Donaldson

Aaron Judge

Barry Bonds

Mark McGwire

They all played summer ball here.

The list is long.

Some of these examples kind of make my point. First, I will definitely agree that Hildenberger could have and should have moved up faster, but he was like a 22nd round pick who had one good college season, his fifth year, so the age thing doesn' matter in that case. 

 

Guys that get drafted at 21, if they're in the big leagues at 23, that's an exception.  

 

Of that group above that you mention, there are a lot of similarities that can explain why they weren't called up until 25 or older. Gibson was certainly on the fast track until Tommy John surgery. JT Chargois missed two years with injury. Many were late round picks, likely because they weren't as advanced at 21 and eventually did get it. Andrew Vasquez was a late-round pick who struggled to throw strikes the first two seasons of his pro career. Many of the guys that debuted at 27 maybe just didn't develop in the upper levels.  In some cases, the argument isn't so much if they were called up too late but if they should have been called up at all. 

 

My point is that they aren't afraid to push guys to AA which is generally where even the top college guys start to see some struggles. 

 

And ultimately, it is an individual's development. There is no cookie-cutter timeline. 

I dont think that the data supports your claims. 

If you look at the college pitchers drafted in the first rounds since 2009 (Gibson's year) here is the age they made their MLB debut:

2009

Strasboug  21

Minor 22

Leike  22

Storern  22

White  22

Jenkins  24

2010  

Pomeranz  22

Harvey  23

McGuire  28

Sale  21

2011

Cole  22

Bauer  21

Jungman  25

Bradley 26

reed   24

Barnes  24

Anderson  26

Meyer  25

Gilmartin  25

2012

gausman   22

Henry  23

Wacha  21

Stroman  23

2013

Gray  23

Shipley  24

Gonzalez  22

Gonzales  23

2014

Rodon  22

Nola  22

Freeland  24

Hoffman  23

Beede   25

Newcomb  24

Finnegan  21

Fedde  24

Weaver  22

2015

Tate  25

Fullmer  22

Buechler  22

2016

Quantill  24

Dunn  23

Zeuch  23

Lauer  23

While this is not a perfect study because MLB debut might not be a full measure and there may be typos and other issues in presenting the data, it is clear that the Twins have been slow to move college level pitchers.

Most of the college drafted pitchers who are relatively successful in the minors make the major leagues before the age of 24.  Some are held up, like Kyle Gibson was, with arm problems or minor league struggles, but those are rarer.  

And, as I point out many times over, the Twins throughout this period struggled with their pitching stagg.  Yet, they moved their college arms stepwise through the system that other organizations would no have.  

College pitchers drafted in the first round made it to The Show relatively young. We already knew that and it has nothing to do with the Twins.

Based on Seth's data, I don't see how people can say they moved college pitchers too slow, I think it points out how how bad the Twins were at drafting really good college to top end major league pitchers, or to give them the benefit of doubt, how they were too successful to draft a few of the top end pitchers.

On a side note, rushing pitchers that aren't great doesn't make them great.

This is an interesting topic, but the stats prompt what may be a far more important question: Why do so many young pitchers blow out their TJ ligament?

Are there examples of power pitchers that never had elbow trouble?

If so, what were they doing different?

Most likely they weren't pitchers in Little League.

Randy Dobnak undrafted college pitcher In 2017 moved pretty fast from independent ball to the majors.

I am confident now that if pitchers perform well and remain healthy they will move up.

The previous group was unable to provide the major league team with pitchers. It may have been an inability to recognize talent or an inability to develop talent. It doesn’t matter how fast or slow they move if they don’t have the talent or don’t know how to use it.