Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • 2016 Twins Bust Candidates


    Cody Christie

    Every year there are surprises and disappointments on any big league roster. Poor play and mounting injuries can impact any number of players. That's one of the reasons teams try to build a deep 40-man roster so they are able to stay in contention even when players don't perform up to expectations.

    Going into any season it can be tough to predict who is set up to play poorly and maybe it is an exercise in futility. When the end of the season comes around, feel free to shout me out on Twitter and tell me how wrong I was in relation to this year's "Twins Bust Candidates."

    Image courtesy of Ken Blaze- USA Today Sports

    Twins Video

    Tyler Duffey, RHP

    Duffey pitched well for the while the Twins were still in the postseason hunt. He finished the year boasting a 5-1 record with a very respectable 3.10 ERA and a 1.31 WHIP. Call it the "Scott Diamond Effect" but it seems unlikely for him to keep up this pace into the 2016 campaign. He was never considered one the organization's top pitching prospects, as he averaged 7.4 SO/9 and a 3.73 ERA over four minor league seasons.

    Can the Twins get by with Duffey as a back of the rotation starter? Sure, he can fit into this role. Baseball Reference projects him to compile a 3.64 ERA and a 1.28 WHIP in just under 90 innings of work. Both of these totals would be better than his minor league track record and he hasn't exactly been lights out this spring as he works on his change-up. With top pitching prospect Jose Berrios in the wings, it seems likely that Duffey could find himself out of a starting spot at some point this season.

    Glen Perkins, LHP

    Perkins has made the All-Star Game in each of the last three seasons and he's even been asked to close out the game for the AL each of the last two years. However, the end of last season was a little rough for the Twins closer as he tried to play through an injury and posted some poor numbers along the way. World Series legend Jack Morris even hinted that Perkins might not exactly be in shape in a Twin Cities radio interview last year.

    While Perkins has been able to accumulate over 30 saves in each of the last three seasons, his other numbers have been on the decline. His first three years in the bullpen he posted a 2.45 ERA with a 1.06 WHIP and 10.2 SO/9. The last two years those numbers have declined to a 3.49 ERA, a 1.19 WHIP, and 9.1 SO/9. Perkins turned 33 at the beginning of March and the organization has a young core of bullpen arms working their way toward Target Field. If the recent trend continues, the team might have to look at other options.

    Kurt Suzuki, C

    Suzuki has been on the decline for most of the last year and a half so to say he will be a bust at this point in his career might not be too big of a stretch. After hitting .309/.365/.396 in his first 65 games with the Twins, he went on to hit .259/.323/.339 in the second half of 2014. Last season was even worse as he finished the year hitting .240/.296/.314 while taking a beating behind the plate. He had the lowest caught stealing percentage (15%) of any AL catcher with at least 600 innings behind the dish.

    The Twins had to add some depth to the catching ranks and they were able to do that this offseason. Minnesota has been clear that Suzuki is their starter and he should be to reward him for his work with the pitching staff over the last couple of years. However, John Ryan Murphy will likely start to play more frequently as the season progresses. This could help Suzuki's performance if he isn't out there for over 130 games but it's hard to know how much he has left in the tank. His days as a starting catcher could be coming to an end

    Who do you think is set-up to bust this season? Leave a COMMENT and start the discussion.

    MORE FROM TWINS DAILY
    — Latest Twins coverage from our writers
    — Recent Twins discussion in our forums
    — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email
    — Become a Twins Daily Caretaker

     Share


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments



    Featured Comments

    I think that you got this 100%.

     

    When your out of shape "proven closer" takes home brewing as a new hobby during the off-season and loses 5-7 mph off his peak FB and SL velocity, the writing is on the wall...

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I think that you got this 100%.

     

    When your out of shape "proven closer" takes home brewing as a new hobby during the off-season and loses 5-7 mph off his peak FB and SL velocity, the writing is on the wall...

    Come on man, you can claim Perkins can be a "bust" or that he has struggled, but I believe there was another thread that proved that Perkins didn't "lose" anything close to 5-7 MPH

     

    As far as the home brewing bit, come on now. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that whatsoever. You might be shocked to learn that 80%+ of MLB players enjoy a beer now and then (or even more often!) Claiming that being a home brewer is a reason for him "busting" is just silly.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    Come on man, you can claim Perkins can be a "bust" or that he has struggled, but I believe there was another thread that proved that Perkins didn't "lose" anything close to 5-7 MPH

     

    As far as the home brewing bit, come on now. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that whatsoever. You might be shocked to learn that 80%+ of MLB players enjoy a beer now and then (or even more often!) Claiming that being a home brewer is a reason for him "busting" is just silly.

     

    I was there this Spring.  His FB was 88-91 mph and Slider 79-83 mph.  Proof or not.  I know what the radar readings I read were.  And some of them on the fast Hammond Stadium gun.

     

    Beer is fine.  If you are not overweight and ineffective as a pro athlete and if you do not chronic back issues from being overweight as a pro athlete. 

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I was there this Spring. His FB was 88-91 mph and Slider 79-83 mph. Proof or not. I know what the radar readings I read were. And some of them on the fast Hammond Stadium gun.

     

    Beer is fine. If you are not overweight and ineffective as a pro athlete and if you do not chronic back issues from being overweight as a pro athlete.

    Come on you are better than this.
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Ask this question again in late June when it can be more based In facts than axe-grinding.

    I don't see a whole lot of axe grinding going on personally, and don't see an issue with the thread, but to each his own I suppose.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    So I think enough has been said about that trade being so terrible for the Twins.

     

    I still don't like the rationale behind the trade, but the result hasn't been as painful as it could have been.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Hmmmm.....

     

    I have always liked Rosario as a prospect, but I have this irrational (imo) fear that this year is not going to go well for him. Well, I guess there are signs.....but for some reason I'm nervous about him.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Interesting to read back toward the end of a miserable season.  I looked at this and the "Regression Candidates" thread to see just how foreseeable this season's struggles have been.

     

    Interestingly, the number 1 regression candidate, Eddie Rosario has slashed almost the same line as last season.  .267 .289 .459 to .262 .289 .421.  His slugging is down because he doesn't lead the league in triples. 

     

    Many predicted a regression from Dozier and Perkins because of their 2nd half swoons.  Perkins was way right, Dozier way wrong.

     

    Willinghammer predicted Jepsen's demise.  DaveW listed most of the team, and therefore was the most right.

     

    Sano was somewhat debated, depending on expectations.  Arcia was mentioned as a bust candidate.

     

    Duffey was commonly brought up and regressed badly.

     

    Nolasco, Park, Suzuki and Murphy were all considered top candidates to bust, and really only Murphy busted.

     

    Looking back, this is my top 5 busts of 2016:

     

    Honorable Mentions: Tommy Milone - Was maybe one of our best overall starters last season, but ended up DFA and looking more AAAA than ever.  Lack of stuff finally caught up.  But he was a 5th starter so expectations are somewhat tempered...

     

    5) Trevor May - He's been ok, but injuries and wildness give pause as to where he belongs and if he'll be good in either role.  Was supposed to be part of a solid back end.

     

    4) Kyle Gibson has been bad after posting his best year and appearing to have turned a corner.  Incredibly disappointing year from Gibson thus far.

     

    3) Tyler Duffey - Predicted by many, never developed a working change up.  Predictably, his superb feel for his breaking ball which allowed him to throw it on the corners at 2 speeds was not sustainable.  Recently sent down.

     

    2) Glen Perkins/ Phil Hughes - Tough to put guys on because of injury, but these two were counted on to perform at a high level.  Both face very uncertain futures.  Both arguably contributed to their own issues with poor fitness and over-tinkering.

     

    1) Byron Buxton - After nearly a full season, Buxton does not look any closer to being a MLB regular than he did at the end of last season.  Scary proposition for perhaps the most important player in the entire organization.

    That's my top 5.  I'm sure I'm missing some from this awful season that seemingly won't end.  Most interesting thing in my book is that we were mostly wrong on our regression and bust predictions, and we're still a thousand games out of contention. 

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

     

    That's my top 5.  I'm sure I'm missing some from this awful season that seemingly won't end.  Most interesting thing in my book is that we were mostly wrong on our regression and bust predictions, and we're still a thousand games out of contention. 

    The fact that they've gotten unexpectedly good to really good seasons from guys like Nunez, Dozier, Kepler, and Polanco (smaller example) makes that whole paragraph even more interesting.  Strange game, this baseball.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    Interestingly, the number 1 regression candidate, Eddie Rosario has slashed almost the same line as last season. .267 .289 .459 to .262 .289 .421. His slugging is down because he doesn't lead the league in triples.

     

     

    The triples were kinda the main reason folks expected Rosario to regress, no?

     

    Also, how is Park not a bust? Maybe not top 5, but he has to be a considered a bust for 2016. Even if you think the wrist was a factor, you considered other injury cases as busts.

     

    Also, Nolasco only failed to bust because he set expectations so low in 2014-2015. I have to imagine anyone picking him to bust were predicting a continuation of his 2014-2015 performances, which was mostly true.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    The triples were kinda the main reason folks expected Rosario to regress, no?

    Also, how is Park not a bust? Maybe not top 5, but he has to be a considered a bust for 2016. Even if you think the wrist was a factor, you considered other injury cases as busts.

    Also, Nolasco only failed to bust because he set expectations so low in 2014-2015. I have to imagine anyone picking him to bust were predicting a continuation of his 2014-2015 performances, which was mostly true.

    The only reason that I don't consider Park a bust is because I didn't expect much to begin with.  In some ways, he actually surpassed my expectations given how long he was with the big club.  I felt that he should have started in AAA and earned his way up, salary be damned.  

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    The triples were kinda the main reason folks expected Rosario to regress, no?

    Also, how is Park not a bust? Maybe not top 5, but he has to be a considered a bust for 2016. Even if you think the wrist was a factor, you considered other injury cases as busts.

    Also, Nolasco only failed to bust because he set expectations so low in 2014-2015. I have to imagine anyone picking him to bust were predicting a continuation of his 2014-2015 performances, which was mostly true.

    Park should be a bust, considering most of us predicted good things from him in the off-season... Most predictions on that thread were 20+ HRs. 

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    The triples were kinda the main reason folks expected Rosario to regress, no?

    Also, how is Park not a bust? Maybe not top 5, but he has to be a considered a bust for 2016. Even if you think the wrist was a factor, you considered other injury cases as busts.

    Also, Nolasco only failed to bust because he set expectations so low in 2014-2015. I have to imagine anyone picking him to bust were predicting a continuation of his 2014-2015 performances, which was mostly true.

    On Rosario, probably.  I guess I don't see his OPS as that much of a regression.  He's been up and down, but I don't think it's fair to say he regressed this season.  He's been alright.

     

    Park was listed as a bust candidate and he did bust, but I wouldn't consider him top 5.  He showed glimpses.  We've debated whether he was a high risk expensive signing or a low-risk high upside signing.  Intelligent minds disagree so, yeah, a bust, but not a giant bust yet.  Next season I think we should expect more...

    Nolasco was a pleasant surprise for me.  He was not so bad we couldn't put him out there or trade him, which is actually more than I expected.  Nolasco, to me was a pleasant surprise by eating innings as a horrible starting pitcher with ok peripherals.
     

    Edited by Jham
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    I had Duffey (on the linked thread) and Gibson on this one but I also said we didn't really have the kind of talent on this team where playing poorly would be considered a bust.

     

     

    'I'm not sure that this team has the quality of players where one could have such high expectations they would be considered busts if they perform poorly. 

    Sano has high expectations.  Some have high expectations for Buxton for this year. 

    Maybe Gibson?  Hear a lot of people talking about him taking the next step.'

     

    Additionally, I didn't have Rosario as a bust candidate because, well, I didn't expect much from him based on the his BABIP and the triple boosting his slg%.

     

    Edited by jimmer
    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

    It might be a character flaw of mine (among many) but I really don't look for regression. 

     

    I'm hopelessly attached to the thought of fix problem X and it can get better.

     

    At least until Problem Y comes along. 

     

     

     

     

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites

     

    I had Duffey (on the linked thread) and Gibson on this one but I also said we didn't really have the kind of talent on this team where playing poorly would be considered a bust.

     

     

    'I'm not sure that this team has the quality of players where one could have such high expectations they would be considered busts if they perform poorly. 

    Sano has high expectations.  Some have high expectations for Buxton for this year. 

    Maybe Gibson?  Hear a lot of people talking about him taking the next step.'

     

    Additionally, I didn't have Rosario as a bust candidate because, well, I didn't expect much from him based on the his BABIP and the triple boosting his slg%.

     

    Showoff. You could have at least saved us some time by reminding us sooner than late August that you had written a brutal one-sentence season preview that accurately foretold the ugliness to come.

    Link to comment
    Share on other sites




    Join the conversation

    You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.
    Note: Your post will require moderator approval before it will be visible.

    Guest
    Add a comment...

    ×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

      Only 75 emoji are allowed.

    ×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

    ×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

    ×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

    Loading...

×
×
  • Create New...