Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Richie the Rally Goat

    Community Moderator
    Points
    8,324
    Posts
  2. chpettit19

    Community Leader
    Points
    3,028
    Posts
  3. mikelink45

    Verified Member
    Points
    7,531
    Posts
  4. DocBauer

    Verified Member
    Points
    9,187
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 02/11/2023 in all areas

  1. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    Melissa and 10 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic

    11 points
    Not over rated, it just meant that they showed us great ball for the regular season and then we were bounced. The trouble was that we then expected this to continue, but the team and the ball both changed. In baseball you just celebrate each good year.
  2. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    Fatbat and 10 others reacted to MMMordabito for a post in a topic

    11 points
    Who cares? That was a fun year.
  3. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    Melissa and 9 others reacted to miracleb for a post in a topic

    10 points
    Seem to be mixing two different things here. Bomba Squad overated (title to the article) combined with how it affected the Twin's team moving forward. I don't think they were overated. Nelson Cruz had a 1961 Harmon Killebrew type of season.....101 wins is firmly on Cruz's back! Getting rentals to "make a run" also doesn't have any long term affects. Giving up PROSPECTS to "make a run" is where the front office can get in trouble (with me.) The risk for the front office is giving up prospects to "make a run at a title" and then fall short. Now you have weakened your farm system and the longer term future of the team is poor. Those front office people end up being "former" front office people.
  4. 9 points
    Exactly. The article missed the mark… the problem with the Bomba Squad wasn’t the rentals. The problem was they didn’t have enough pitching. getting bounced by the Yankees again in ‘19 was getting beaten by a team that hit the second most home runs in the league AND had much better pitching. frankly I wish the FO would sign more rentals. While I hate the Gallo signing, if I’m proven wrong and he actually can hit a Manfred Ball, that rental could prove to be a huge difference maker on a team that looks poised to prevent runs at a much improved rate, and struggle to score.
  5. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    goulik and 7 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic

    8 points
    They didn't have enough pitching to make up for Pineda getting suspended, Gibson getting sick, and Dyson being hurt. Their overall pitching that year was actually really good, but fell apart going into the playoffs due to their lack of depth. They had the 9th best ERA in baseball. 4th most pitching fWAR, allowed the 5th fewest HR/9, were 4th in FIP, and 5th in xFIP. It's one of the biggest "what if" seasons I can remember for the Twins. What if their pitching was healthy, and not suspended, going into the playoffs? Could've been a different story. Note: I'm not saying you weren't just meaning depth when you say "didn't have enough pitching," but I like to point out how good their pitching actually was that year because so many people put that entire season on the 307 HRs, and pretend they had a bottom 10 pitching staff or something. That was a complete team when it was all together. Just wasn't all together going into the playoffs, unfortunately.
  6. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    tarheeltwinsfan and 7 others reacted to RJA for a post in a topic

    8 points
    I think you need to judge each team based on the results of that particular year. The Bomba Squad won 101 games and set a major league homerun record. Yes, the ball was juiced, but it was juiced for everyone else as well. Every other team faced the exact same conditions as the Twins. For the conditions of that particular year, the Bomba Squad was not overrated. They had some success in 2020, but then the roof caved in. Just because the team did not become a dynasty, does not mean they were not exceptional in that particular year. Let's forget the 3 game sweep by the Yanks in the playoffs as that is the obvious result of some kind of curse:).
  7. Why assume Gordon won’t be the everyday left fielder? Gallo and Kepler need to earn their spot in the lineup just like Gordon and Larnach
  8. 7 points
    No doubt, the Twins are counting on Alex Kirilloff to step into a starting role at first base and hit. I don't think Arraez is traded if AK was not going to be ready this season. Like many, I am looking for a big season from Kirilloff. He is a key answer for both first base and the middle of the lineup.
  9. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    miracleb and 6 others reacted to rwilfong86 for a post in a topic

    7 points
    All the homeruns didn't equal any postseason success. I would lean yes but it sure was fun to watch.
  10. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    wsnydes and 5 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    6 points
    The team wasn’t overrated, they just didn’t have any good healthy players left by the time they reached the postseason.
  11. 6 points
    I don’t get why Nick has to “earn” his starts but Gallo and Kepler don’t. Play the best players.
  12. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    Melissa and 5 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic

    6 points
    That data is since 2019, not just 2019. The Dodgers didn't accrue 86 pitching fWAR in 1 season. Here's 2019: Twins 4, Yankees 10 in pitching WAR. Twins beat them in ERA, FIP, xFIP, HR/9, and BB/9. The Twins had a good pitching staff in 2019.
  13. Don't sleep on Julien playing some 1B this year.
  14. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    Melissa and 5 others reacted to RJA for a post in a topic

    6 points
    Good point on home run record, however I disagree with your historically overrated take. As for being historically overrated, the 2019 team had the second best winning percentage, .623, in the Twins 60 plus year history, with only the 1965 Twins winning percentage of .630 being better. In fact, if you add the Senators history to ours, in the 120 year plus history of the franchise, 2019 winning percentage rates the 4th best. How can a team with the 4th best record in the 120 plus year history of the franchise be historically overrated?
  15. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    ashbury and 5 others reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic

    6 points
    I read a yelp review on a restaurant once where the reviewer gave a restaurant two stars because they were handed 3 menus when the party of 4 was seated. Some folks... just search for a negative to hang on to.
  16. The AL Central is expected to be very tight and, according to projections and betting lines, the Twins are projected to finish second or third. For the Twins to make up the ground on Cleveland and Chicago, they'll need to get production on the margins, whether on defense, in the bullpen, or off the bench. Kyle Farmer and Nick Gordon's platoon pairing as utility players could be an excellent way for the Twins to score crucial extra runs. Left-handed hitting Gordon will play most days when righties are pitching, and right-handed hitting Farmer will play most days when lefties are pitching, which will give the Twins lineup added length in either platoon situation. Kyle Farmer When the Twins brought in Kyle Farmer from the Reds via trade, Twins fans hoped he would serve as a platoon bat in a utility role. Farmer can fill in all around the infield and corner outfield and, if necessary, at catcher. Farmer playing a utility role hinged on the Twins bringing in a big-name shortstop, and for a while, it appeared the Reds 2022 starting shortstop would be the Twins' Opening Day shortstop in 2023. When Carlos Correa signed with the Twins for at least six years, Farmer was thrust back into that utility role for which he is well-suited. Being able to target lefty pitchers for him to match up with could be a massive advantage for the Twins. In 2022, he obliterated left-handed pitchers with a 157 wRC+, which indicates he was a 57% above-average hitter, fueled by a .568 SLG. Farmer will move around the diamond for the Twins to hunt lefty matchups. Considering that two righties, a switch-hitter, and just one lefty make up the Twins' Opening Day infield, they may shuffle things around when lefties are on the bump. Farmer could slot in at left field, as the Twins have suggested, although he's only played four innings in the outfield in his major league career. Alternatively, they could move Jose Miranda to first base and slot Farmer, the superior defensive third baseman, at third. Wherever he slots in, the Twins hope that he will continue his dominance in those platoon matchups and provide much more versatility than their 2022 right-handed platoon bat, Kyle Garlick. Nick Gordon Nick Gordon put together his first full season at the major-league level in 2022. To the surprise of many, the 2014 first round pick was excellent. Gordon showed a surprising bit of power at the plate, especially against right-handed pitching. He put up a 111 wRC+ overall, and a 125 wRC+ against righties. He also showed that there might even be another level when he had a phenomenal 141 wRC+ against righties from July 1st to the end of the season. Due to his health, Gordon has a minimal track record of success at the upper minors or major-league level, so it's reasonable to question whether his production is sustainable. However, the batted ball data indicates that it was not just a flash in the pan. Gordon graded out in the 86th percentile for xSLG based on the quality of his contact. That could improve if he faces fewer left-handed pitchers, against whom he had a horrible 58 wRC+ against. Beyond roughing up righties, Gordon provided tremendous defensive flexibility. He played at least 17 games at left field, second base, shortstop and center field. He wasn't good at any position and was below average in the infield, but he was about average at both left field and center field. His ability to be somewhat competent at many positions will enable the Twins to get his bat into the lineup against righties as they get regulars off their feet. If you ask the average fan in any market outside of Cincinnati or Minnesota, they probably don't know Nick Gordon or Kyle Farmer. But these can be the type of bench players that make the difference between winning the division and coming up just short, especially when injuries pop up. Depending on the matchup, having one of Farmer or Gordon in the lineup just about every day will be a tremendous asset for the Twins in 2023.
  17. 5 points
    In 2019, the Twins put together one of the greatest seasons in franchise history. They won 101 games - second-best in Twins history - and cruised to a division win. Known as the Bomba Squad, the team broke numerous home run records, including MLB’s team record of 307, and they had five players hit 30 or more home runs. It looked like a youth movement was leading the way, but sustained success eluded them, both in the postseason and in subsequent years. In the postseason, the Yankees swept the Twins. pushing their playoff losing streak to 16 games. People look back at that team as one of the few times the Twins could be considered "true contenders," but in reality, they are blinded by nostalgia. The failures of the team all come down to sustained success. Sustained success is something that has been echoed time and time again since Derek Falvey and Thad Levine took over the team in 2016. The reasoning behind it is simple: anything can happen in the playoffs. The more times you make the playoffs, the more chances you have to go on a World Series run. The primary way to achieve this level of success is through team control. When trading at the deadline, players are often acquired as rentals. But trading for players with a year or two of team control gives the receiving team much more value. The same goes for signing team-friendly contract extensions. The Twins have committed to this philosophy in recent years through multiple moves. Pablo Lopez - traded for with two years of team control Chris Paddack - traded for with three years of team control and then a contract extension Tyler Mahle - traded for with 1.5 years of team control Jorge Lopez - traded for with 2.5 years of team control Gio Urshela - trade for with two years of team control Controlling players for multiple years solidifies parts of the team while also giving the organization the financial freedom to build around these players. In 2019, however, the organization ditched this idea. 2018 was a disappointing year, and in the following offseason, the Twins decided to fill their gaps with one-year rentals. It started in November when the Twins filled their first base gap by picking up CJ Cron off of waivers. Then they signed Jonathan Schoop to a one-year deal at second base, followed up by a one-year deal (plus a team option) to aging slugger Nelson Cruz. In February 2019, the Twins acquired Marwin Gonzalez for a two-year deal. To "fix" their issues in the rotation, they signed Martin Perez to a one-year deal. Notice the pattern here? It would have been easy to write off the season, except all those rentals started off hot and propelled the team into playoff contention. It became even more complicated as the season went on. By midseason, the one-year rentals were already starting to decline. Cron got hurt and had a bad second half. Perez had a hot start but got rocked the rest of the season. Schoop had a bad month in June and was mostly replaced by the up-and-coming Luis Arraez. Only Cruz continued to shine and was awarded the team MVP as a 39-year-old. By the time the trade deadline rolled around, either the front office felt that the early season success truly was sustainable despite warning signs, or they felt pressured to make a move to push the team further into contention. They added Sergio Romo and Sam Dyson. Romo was decent to finish the year, and the Dyson trade is arguably one of the worst of Derek Falvey's time. In the end, the acquisitions didn't matter enough, and the Twins fell short of the Yankees in the ALDS. The 2019 team produced great memories but had a lack of substance behind them. When one takes a step back and looks at the whole picture, one realizes how deceptive the year was in evaluating the Twins' future. The 2019 Twins were entertaining to watch, but when it comes to their effect on the franchise, people are blinded by nostalgia.
  18. Really interesting take - Polanco at 1B if Kiriloff is a no go. At the moment, even if Kiriloff can make it back, Miranda should get lots of frames at 1B. If Miranda ends up being a more dependable, higher producing player than Kiriloff this season, then next year when Lee, Lewis and Julien show up, Miranda would be the everyday 1B and Kiriloff (with Kepler and Gallo gone) would be a corner OF (with some combo of Larnach, Gordon, Wallner and Martin), backup 1B, and DH. I literally cannot believe we are going to be starting an OF of Gallo, Kepler and Taylor (when Buxton is inevitably out). Yes, the defense is there in spades, but what a snooze fest at the plate. And all essentially one year rentals. Back to Polanco. I actually think his year at the plate is going to be the key to the Twin’s offense this season. How Polanco goes is how this team will go..
  19. Good take - agreed Kirilloff producing and holding down 1B could be central to a successful season.
  20. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    old nurse and 4 others reacted to Whitey333 for a post in a topic

    5 points
    Pretty sad that you have to rip a very fun team to watch in the Bomba squad. They were at least fun to watch that year. The team the past couple of seasons have been totally boring. And everyone touts the prospects. Yes they are very important but if they were so great wouldn't they be on the major league roster now? Even the FO must realize we don't have very many major league ready prospects or the wouldn't have need to throw 11 million at a lifetime .199 hitter that whiffs more than Sano and Buxton.
  21. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    wsnydes and 4 others reacted to D.C Twins for a post in a topic

    5 points
    Juiced ball year and outlier so.... I'll go with yes
  22. How Close Is Sonny Gray to Ace Status?

    weitz41 and 4 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic

    5 points
    ACE seems to be a term we apply to those on a HOF track - those who just seem like the will win no matter the game or the opponent. That is not Grey. His experience with the Yankees might demonstrate that the big lights are not for him. Can he be our number one - sure, I expect him to be, but I think the only thing that settles ACE debates is performance on the field. 10 years - 24.9 WAR. An average of 2.5 - last year he was 2.4. That is who he is and I am content with that.
  23. 4 points
    The narrative about third time through the order is beyond tiresome. Chris Archer rarely saw the lead of hitter a third time. Joe Ryan saw the lead off hitter the third time every game. Sonny Gray? There were 5 games he did not see the top of the line up the third time. April 16 - pulled for injury May 7 - first game back from 1st IL trip. June 15 - first game back after 2nd IL trip September 2 - exited tightness right hamstring September 19 - pitched his last game of season. Placed on IL He saw the top of the line up every other start. Another thing that is tiresome is the misunderstanding of the skew in the data the third time through. Most of the data for the third time through is from facing the top of the line up. Starters rarely see the bottom of the line up a third time. Unusually Gray’s OPS against third time through happened to be better than second time through last year. It was not a meaningful difference or sample size. I don’t believe the data supports the persistent statement that Baldelli pulls pitchers before the third time through. He did pull Archer and Bundy frequently before the third time through, he managed many pitchers returning from injury and they often had a shorter first start back. He did not pull Ryan or Gray before the third time seeing the line up. I also don’t believe data supports a significant change in pitcher skill the third time through. It is true that most starters over their career have poorer numbers the third time through. Most of that drop is simply because the data is heavily skewed to the top of the line up. Why don’t most hitters do best the third time through? Carlos Correa does better the first and second time than the third time. There is skew in the data too. He doesn’t get to face many Bundy’s and Archer’s a third time and is stuck facing the Gray’s and Ryan’s more often.
  24. Couldn’t agree more. Gordon is currently our second best overall (hitting, fielding and running) outfielder behind Buxton.
  25. I think both of these guys are great bench players. I wouldn't be opposed to Gordon starting, but he's got to earn that. And I think they can probably do better, but if he earned it I can't argue with that.
  26. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    Melissa and 3 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    4 points
    One person having to go home hungry is not a good outcome. The Bomba Squad went home hungry after a handful of games in the postseason. They should have asked for a menu.
  27. Both of these guys will be extremely valuable.
  28. https://www.mlb.com/world-baseball-classic/schedule/2023-03-21 It appears to be on FS1, FS2, Fox, and Tubi.
  29. 4 points
    Sure would be nice if he was finally healthy and we could see what he's capable of.
  30. Looking forward to be in Phoenix for 5 of the games: USA Canada England, GB Colombia Mexico Have tix to the game where the crowd will really rock, USA/Mexico. Sold out, 48,000. Anyone who has been to Dodger Stadium knows how those who are of Mexican descent bring an added spirit to the crowd. Loud and cheerful! ¡Viva Mexico!
  31. How Close Is Sonny Gray to Ace Status?

    Doctor Gast and 3 others reacted to roger for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Agree with the above comment and also don't care about who on the Twins staff may be or soon be an ACE. What I see is a staff of more than five starters who are very good. Give me five starters who are all likely #2 or #3 starters and the team is gonna win a lot of games. Also agree there aren't a lot of true ACES out there. Take Kershaw for example, he sure seems like one until the Dodgers get to the playoffs...then not so much. Like to think that Verlander is an ACE, yet, didn't he struggle in the playoffs/series last year? The only former Twin I would consider an ACE was Santana. Liriano could have been, had he not been injured. And personally, I am saddened with how the game is changing. Was looking at Spahn's career the other day. If memory serves, he had 68 shutouts. Not 68 complete games, that was several hundred, but 68 complete game shutouts. Would guess there weren't 68 complete games, forget them being shutouts, in all of baseball last year. Maybe its time for starting pitchers to make a little less cash and give it the shut down relievers, like Duran.
  32. 4 points
    So the season hasn't even started yet and the topic is Aces. An Ace to me is a Frontline starter who is consistently dominant. He's the guy you give the ball to in a must win game situation or the guy who puts an end to a 3 game skid. He's your opening day starter. Gets 30 plus starts and throws 200 innings. And does it year in and year out. Gray has been a solid starter since coming up with the A's. His first few years he looked like he could be one of those guys. Will the Twins give him the opportunity to be a so called Ace? I doubt it. The Twins want their starters to go 5 solid innings, and maybe start the 6th. But the 1st hit or walk and they're going to the bullpen.I like Sonny Gray. He's a solid 2 or 3 with many other clubs. On some clubs he'd be a 4 or 5. If there's a potential Ace on the Twins it's either Ryan or someone coming up
  33. Second to Team USA, Minnesotans might look at Puerto Rico fondly during this edition of the WBC, as seven of the ten current Twins, plus four former ones will be playing the event for the Borícua team. Relievers Emilio Pagán, Jorge López, José de León, Dereck Rodríguez and Jovani Morán, catcher Christian Vázquez, and infielder José Miranda are the current Twins on Team Puerto Rico. Former Twins José Berríos and Hector Santiago and outfielder Eddie Rosario are also on the squad. In addition, the team's pitching coach, Ricky Bones, who spent about five months in early 1998 in the Twins organization. Back-to-back runners-up, the Puerto Ricans could even have another Twin in Carlos Correa, but the superstar shortstop opted not to take part in this year’s edition as his wife is expected to give birth to the couple’s second child during the competition. But despite also having names like Francisco Lindor, Javier Báez, and Martín Maldonado, Puerto Rico won’t have an easy life in Pool D, as another team full of former Twins will fight them for one of the two spots in the quarterfinals. Venezuela is another strong team in the group, and despite having only one current Twin, he’s perhaps the team’s ace, Pablo López. Four former Twins will join him. Fan favorites Luis Arráez and Eduardo Escobar in the infield and Jhoulys Chacín (pitched in spring training 2020 before the pandemic and was cut in July, just before the season started) and Martín Pérez in the pitching staff. Also, the Venezuelan coaching staff includes Twins assistant pitching coach Luis Ramírez and long-time Twins minor-league manager, currently with the Wichita Wind Surge, Ramón Borrego. Former Twins minor-league pitching coach Ivan Arteaga is the team's pitching coach. With names like José Altuve, Ronald Acuña Jr., and Salvador Pérez, among others, Venezuela the main competition to Puerto Rico for the second spot in the group. I said “second” because one other team is considered by many to be the pool’s favorite. The Dominican Republic doesn’t have a single current Twin. However, former Minnesota sluggers Gary Sánchez and Nelson Cruz, who's also the team manager. Still, they’ll be one of the most exciting teams in the tournament, with players like Sandy Alcántara, Juan Soto, Vladimir Guerrero Jr., Rafael Devers, Manny Machado, and more. Only a tragedy would keep the Dominicans out of the quarterfinals. There are several other current Minnesota Twins (or Twins minor leaguers) in the competition. Newcomer Carlos Luna will be playing for Panama, and prized-prospect Édouard Julien, for Team Canada. Joining the latter is former Twins pitcher Andrew Albers. Seven other former Twins will also be fighting for the world title: pitchers Lance Lynn and Ryan Pressly will play for Team USA. In addition, reliever Brooks Raley spent much of the 2014 season on the Twins 40-man roster, and Jason Adam was the player acquired from the Royals for Josh Willingham in 2014. Two infielders who had short stints with Minnesota, Andrelton Simmons and Jonathan Schoop will represent The Kingdom of the Netherlands. So will former pitcher Shairon Martis. Former Twins first base/outfield prospect Zander Wiel will also be on the team. Their pitching coach will again be Hall of Famer Bert Blyleven. Last year’s fan favorite Gio Urshela will represent Colombia, alongside reliever Jhon Romero, who pitched in four games in a Twins uniform early last season. The Twins long had a pipeline in Australia. There are five former Twins minor leaguers on Team Australia including Aaron Whitefield who spent some time with the Twins in 2020. The others include infielder Logan Wade and pitchers Todd Van Steensel, Tim Atherton and Josh Guyer. Great Britain is in the tournament this year. On their roster include former Twins pitchers Ian Gibaut and Vance Worley. Tyler Viza pitched for Wichita and St. Paul early in the 2022 season before being released. In addition, Antoan Richardson stole 39 bases between New Britain and Rochester in 2013. He is the team's bench coach. Slugger ByungHo Park, who played for the Twins in 62 games during the 2016 season, will represent his home country of South Korea. Several former Twins minor leaguers will also be participating in Pool A or Pool B in the first round. For Chinese Taipei (Taiwan) pitchers Chi-Wei Hu and Kai-Wei Teng, as well as Saints infielder Tzu-Wei Lin will participate. The team representing China will include former minor leaguer Ray Chang. Team Israel will include former Twins third baseman Danny Valencia, along with pitcher Zack Weiss who spent a little time in Double-A and Triple-A in the Twins system in 2019. In maybe a fun story, 35-year-old Jakub Hajtmar is competing with the team from the Czech Republic. He played in 33 games for the GCL Twins in 2008. The WBC will take place from March 8 until March 21, with the four pools having a different host city: Taichung, Taiwan, for Pool A; Tokyo, Japan, for Pool B; Phoenix, USA, for Pool C; and Miami, USA, for Pool D. Below is a picture of the competition structure, with the four pools and the bracket all the way to the final. Who do you think is going to win it all?
  34. There aren't many left-handed starters but the Twins will still face a lefty starter ~40 times in 2023. Do we really want Kepler and Gallo starting those games? I sure don't, give me Kyle Farmer every time.
  35. Was the Bomba Squad Overrated?

    Blyleven2011 and 2 others reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic

    3 points
    This. With all due respect intended, the only thing that keeps this from being "click bait" is the use of the word "WAS" in the headline. First of all, isn't EVERY SINGLE SEASON a microcosm unto itself? The Twins were a very good team that won 101 games! They were wildly entertaining and fun while setting a HR record. And didn't EVERYONE use the juiced ball that season? SECONDLY, you DON'T win more games than you lose, even with a juiced ball, unless you score more than the opposition. The Twins had a really solid pitching staff in 2019 that allowed that to happen. Chpettit19 laid out the exact parameters of the Twins pitching that season. THIRDLY, why does having a couple "rental" players diminish the production and winning of games? If that were remotely true, then we'd better examine every playoff team that DIDN'T WIN a WS and admonish their results and dismiss their accomplishments in those years due to "rental" players being involved. Isn't it the job of the FO to add ballplayers to make the best team they can that year? Don't all teams add 1yr rentals at some point? FOURTH. in EVERY sport, only ONE TEAM wins it all. And when that happens, they take home trophies and hang banners. And the regular season fades in to memory, and that's true. But not every 96-102 regular season winning team actually finished on top, regardless of the franchise. So to say those teams, or the 2019 Twins, would qualify as "overated" is not only a misnomer, but the opposite would have to be true as well, wouldn't it? The '87 Twins should then be guilty of being "overated". Same with many other WS winning teams including the Royals and Braves in recent history. IF we want to continue the arguement of overated and talk about sustainability, it's a slightly different arguement. Despite some roster turnover, the 2020 Twins were on another 100 win pace...based on a full season...and ended on something around a 96 or 98 win pace. (I object to playing a select schedule because you simply can't extrapolate that for everyone and an entire league). And if we're going to do that, we'll then, we need to start talking about some Doger, Yankees, Giants, and a whole bunch of teams that didn't win it all, and thus, should be considered overated. Again, every season should be evaluated as to whether it was good or bad, not whether you were the team to come out on top. Three playoff teams, a couple back to back, in 6yrs for the current FO, with some stinkers mixed in, including 2022, where the team was in 1st place in the ALC from May to early August before a rash of injuries where even MASH 4077 couldn't have put the team back together again. There's a lot of mid and lower market teams that would call that successful, and might argue they've had sustainable success. Do I want more and think/expect our FO and ownership expects/wants more? Absolutely. But there is no rapid plunge to mediocrity going on here in 6yrs, despite disappointment. Rentals, and Cruz, and Rosario from the Bomba Squad SHOULD have been replaced by Correa, Kirilloff, Larnach, etc, even Donaldson. It didn't work out. The staff, right now, looks like one of the best and deepest we've had in some time. Injuries have played a huge part in sustainability, as they did for the finish to 2019 where the Twins were limping in to the playoffs that year. Rookie Randy Dobnack starting a playoff game against the Yankees? How far down the rabbit hole of disappontment or "overated" and sustainability do we want to go? Sustainability is an ongoing arguement, despite the current 6yr stretch. But 2019 was NOT an overated team. They were HISTORIC. They were FUN. They were DAMN GOOD. They also ran out of steam and didn't win it all. But they are NOT overated.
  36. One thing I would like to see is Larnach get some time at 1B at St. Paul. I don't think they have a 1B prospect their and his size is ideal. If he is not going to get regular time at Target Field why not increase his value to the team.
  37. Who should start in the OF against left-handed pitching, though?
  38. I need to see Gordon perform over time before I label him a starter, even though I'm a fan and have been supporter of his. But I like him in the OF and believe he will get better. He's OK at 2B and passable at SS. He's barely played 3B but I want to see him there in ST to see if he can play there once in a while. And his speed on the bases is outstanding. He just needs to be a little refined there. Farmer is a passable, decent starting SS, but an excellent reserve option. He can, and has, played across the entire infield and brings a pretty decent bat. He's even an emergency catcher! I don't know that I'm crazy about seeing him in LF, but I'd give it a try in ST. I think these two bring a lot to the table in regard to their versatility and solid offense But I like the whole bench. Taylor is an outstanding defensive OF who can hit a little, provide occasional pop, and still runs well even if he's not a big base stealer. Larnch as a backup OF and DH who plays almost every day with solid defense and a great arm? Yes please! (Still believe he's a full time starter sooner than later). Whether you like Jeffers and believe in his potential at a still young age, and only a little over 600 PA, or not, you have to love someone like him as the 2nd catcher, especially considering untapped potential. The Twins have, I believe, a very, very nice bench.
  39. In 2022 Kepler had 95 wRC+, Gallo had 85 wRC+, and Gordon had 111. Gallo’s overall OAA last year was 0, Keplers was 11(!) Gordon’s was -2. Gordon’s OAA in the outfield was 0, compared to Gallo’s 0 to -3. Maybe something went horribly right if Gordon is slotted to start in Left.
  40. 3 points
    It's not 2019 or 2020 or 2021 anymore. And 29 other teams have seen it the same way up to this point, concerning Miguel Sanó.
  41. Indeed both will be very valuable. But with a logjam of corner OFers, Farmer should be limited to the INF where we are hurting at the moment. And Gordon should be limited in the OF.
  42. 3 points
    In perusing Fangraphs, NYY was 4th in Pitching War for the ‘19 season, Twins were 14 in FWAR, 19 in FIP, 16 in ERA. The Twins were average pitching, including a all the injuries and what if’s.
  43. How Close Is Sonny Gray to Ace Status?

    Melissa and 2 others reacted to wabene for a post in a topic

    3 points
    After all this discussion of aces and innings pitched there is not one mention of how teams have their starters throw harder and with more effort than in the past. The days of starting pitchers pacing themselves for a deep run into the game are over. Players weren't tougher or more determined in the past. The expectations of how to go about their jobs is what has changed. Sure in any era you can find exceptions, but I venture this is the number one reason why pitchers don't go as long. The Twins and Rocco aren't doing anything the rest of the league isn't doing.
  44. 3 points
    Fun to watch , but you knew it wasn't gonna work in the playoffs.
  45. This is humor right? Is this Randball?
  46. This isn't a real post, right? You want him not to use his actual last name, why?
  47. How Close Is Sonny Gray to Ace Status?

    Melissa and 2 others reacted to mac098 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Personally, I believe that day of "Aces" are over. There just aren't those with the will or drive to finish the game when they start. There are a few players that have that drive anymore (Verlander, Scherzer, DeGrom). Those pitchers are literally game changers when they take the mound. The refuse to come out of the game, they make sure their team is in it all the way, and most importantly, they have that knack to be able to work out of jams when it comes to it. They're able to dig deep down and find that extra level when needed. But it's also extremely hard to define an "Ace" with words. It's more or less something that you can see (kind of like a balk). There really is no true definition, but more or less of a visual queue. Now onto Sonny. Is he Ace material? No. Is he a solid top of the of rotation starter? Yes. He seems like he has a safe ceiling of being a really good #2, with a floor of a #3. And if we had an entire rotation like that, I would take it in a heartbeat over having a true "Ace" and a rotation of #5's or middling arms. He just needs to step up and claim that head of the rotation for himself. Make it undisputed that he belongs there compared to the rest of our rotation.
  48. 3 points
    Sonny Gray is a good established MLB pitcher, respected across baseball. That is quite an accomplishment by itself. However, no baseball person has ever deemed Gray an outright ace. When he was building his career with the A's he was a budding ace, but that never fully blossomed. Ace is an overblown term, yet it is often apt and we should still reserve a status for Verlander and those few pitchers who have managed to deliver across time and in volume with consistently high results. Who is a full blown argument. Cole, Bieber, Ohtani, and Verlander in the AL with several others building a strong case (Valdez, Manoah, Gilbert, Cease, and McClanahan. Sonny Gray is such a fiery competitor and fun to watch. Let's hope he can stay healthy all year.
  49. How Close Is Sonny Gray to Ace Status?

    Minny505 and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Nice analysis.
  50. Keith Law's top 20 Minnesota Prospects

    Jack and one other reacted to Steve Lein for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Was just going to start a thread on this myself! Surprises for me are Martin at #4, Julien at #6, and Balazovic still at #7. These are guys I typically think Keith Law would be down on a lot more than this. That's encouraging, I think. I think I have a bias toward Salas, as I didn't really care he was added to the trade for Pablo Lopez. Lopez was the one pitcher from Miami I didn't want if Luis Arraez was the guy being traded. I still feel that way, but understand why the Twins would make the trade with Salas included.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.