Leaderboard
-
-
Cody Pirkl
Twins Daily ContributorPoints758Posts -
-
Greggory Masterson
Verified MemberPoints86Posts
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 01/29/2023 in all areas
-
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
Twins_Fan_For_Life and 7 others reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
8 pointsJulien has to be on this list. He had a monster year at AA, his hit tool is advanced, he's likely to start the year in AAA and if he's crushing it there, then he'll be looked at as an injury replacement if any of the non-SS guys go down for an extended period of time.8 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Jeff D. and 6 others reacted to Cody Pirkl for an article
7 pointsThrough the end of May, Gilberto Celestino appeared to have turned a corner in 2022. The Twins backup center fielder was slashing .324/.398/.378, 50% above league average by wRC+.With little power to speak of, Celestino was a legitimate offensive contributor for a month or two. And then it all fell apart. From June 1 forward, Celestino slashed .211/.286/.278. The Twins clearly lost faith in him as they acquired Michael A. Taylor in a trade this last week, and he’s likely to fill the backup center field role. Celestino simply has too many questions left unanswered. Nothing demonstrates the Twins lack of trust in Celestino like them trading for a nearly identical player to fill the role he was in last season. Taylor is nearly a carbon copy in terms of raw skills. Both are elite defensive center fielders with little offensive value. It begs the question as to why the Twins traded for Taylor in the first place. There are two main considerations to take into account. First and foremost, the Twins likely have a lack of trust not only in Celestino’s performance, but in his ability to focus. Celestino regularly made awful decisions in the field and on the bases down the stretch in 2022, and in September it reached a breaking point. The offensive struggles were one thing, but it likely said a lot to the Twins brass that in a golden opportunity to prove himself with so many injuries, Celestino was losing focus in several aspects of the game that he had no reason not to be excelling at. It likely told the Twins that for 2023 on days when Byron Buxton is not in center field, Celestino was not a trustworthy replacement even to provide defensive value. A bigger reason for the Taylor trade is that Celestino may be the same zero offense, plus defense type player as Taylor now, but he doesn’t have to be forever. In 2021 Celestino was promoted straight from Double-A as a 22-year-old out of necessity. He was an average hitter there and didn’t have time to adjust before making a massive leap to the MLB. He predictably showed little offensive value, but went down to Triple-A to end the season and slashed a fantastic .290/.384/.443 in 49 games. It seems Celestino is headed back to Triple-A St. Paul to begin 2023, and he may spend significant time there. His unrefined plate approach became too obvious in 2022, and his plan of what to work on is pretty straightforward. He hit the ball to the opposite field more often than any other direction, and as the season went on, he was successfully challenged by pitches inside. He rarely made loud contact, as he appeared to just be trying to hang in there at the plate against MLB pitching. In Triple-A the Twins can work on him pulling the pitches he should be. Even developing some gap power would make him a much more serviceable fill-in. He has one minor league option remaining and won’t even be arbitration eligible until 2025, meaning the Twins have a solid timeline to develop Celestino just a bit more offensively. There is likely still a slight chance that the Twins could trade Celestino if a team calls them up and sees him as a legitimate piece in a trade for an impact player. The Twins would likely prefer however to turn the keys over to Celestino next season after Michael A Taylor departs in free agency. Even if Celestino doesn’t show the offensive upside he flashed in his brief AAA stint, he can play a valuable part in the Twins outfield mix the next few years. It’s obvious that Gilberto Celestino is the big loser in the Michael A Taylor trade, but the Twins have to ensure they don’t find themselves in the same spot as last year. Celestino was dealt a tough hand the day he was promoted directly from AA, and it likely set him back a bit. With Taylor, the Twins bought time for Celestino to develop into the player he’s capable of however, and now it’s up to him to make use of the development time he missed out on in AAA.7 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
DocBauer and 6 others reacted to Twins_Fan_For_Life for a post in a topic
7 pointsIt was pretty obvious last year that Gilberto needed more time at St. Paul. Having Taylor gives Celestino the AAA reps he needs to become a useful MLB player.7 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
milkytoast and 5 others reacted to jorgenswest for a post in a topic
6 pointsCelestino is 23 years old. He was born in 1999 and is one of the youngest on the 40 man roster. Larnach, Wallner and Kirilloff were born in 1997. He doesn’t even gave a full season of at bats in the minors since his time in A ball in 2019. If anything I think the deal for Taylor shows the twins belief in him. He needs that time in AAA. It might not go well at first as he makes adjustments but I expect he will have a good career in the majors with some years as a starter. Sometimes up the middle players are pushed up because of need. It happened to Eduardo Escobar. I am sure many has no hope for him with his poor batting performance through age 24. It could be the same with Celestino. Is it really obvious to all that he is the big loser in the Taylor trade? It seems like this time in the minors could help set him on a path to a lucrative major league career.6 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Paul Henkels and 5 others reacted to wabene for a post in a topic
6 pointsGood article and I agree with everything except Cele being the big loser in the Taylor trade. This is the best thing that could happen to him. He needs missed developmental time. The best medicine for his mental errors is a minor league paycheck.6 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Minny505 and 5 others reacted to Karbo for a post in a topic
6 pointsIMO the Twins made the right move. Going to AAA should help him regain his confidence I hope.6 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
PatPfund and 4 others reacted to Reptevia for a post in a topic
5 pointsThey are not the same player, and it’s not really close. The Twins needed a starting CF, and last year made it clear Celestino wasn’t ready physically or emotionally. I hope he has a great year and leads AAA in all categories. He should not step foot in the Bigs this year.5 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
DocBauer and 4 others reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
5 pointsI think he still has a future, but he's also showed that he needs work on his game, including the mental side of it. There's still a lot of talent there, but necessity pulled him up the majors long before he was really ready for it and the interruptions in developmental play probably didn't help him very much in his overall evolution as a player. With Taylor in place, there's unlikely to be any pressure for him to be in MLB this season unless he's playing his way up there. Hopefully that gives him the room to work on his swing and approach at the plate, cut down on the mental mistakes in the field and on the bases, and grow as a player. Celestino is still in the Twins plans, I think. A good year in AAA sets him up to be back as the 4th OF in 2024 (when Gallo & Kepler could be gone, Taylor could be gone, and there could be openings in the OF) or be a significant trade piece for a team needing a defender in the OF (maybe Royce Lewis or Austin Martin passes him in the CF ranks). While I'm not all that enthusiastic about Taylor...I can understand the move. It does send a message to Celestino that he has to improve and that's not a bad thing.5 points -
Twins Daily Winter Meltdown Returns with a Bang: Event Recap
Twins Daily Winter Meltdown Returns with a Bang: Event Recap
wsnydes and 3 others reacted to Richie the Rally Goat for a post in a topic
4 pointsHad a blast! Great event as usual!4 points -
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Who do I WANT to bat leadoff? That would be Julien almost literally replacing Arraez on the roster as a utility player and DH. While he fits best at 2B...and played there exclusively in 2022 when not as a DH...he has some experience at 1B and LF. While he'll never hit like Arraez, or SO at such an insanely low level, he will walk more and provides more power and speed. His ability to walk as much as he does tells me he can thrive early without being close to reaching his ceiling at the ML level. He beat up on AA ball and destroyed the AFL. But even with a strong ST, he probably won't be pushed that quickly. Also, unless Kepler is moved, or someone is hurt, I don't see room to begin the season with the Twins. What makes the most SENSE? Various combinations depending on the daily lineup and matchups. Buck is just not the leadoff hitter type everyone thought he would be when drafted. He's a dangerous power plant who should be hitting with runners OB, anywhere from 1-4 probably. Polanco could probably do the job quite well. But he's also been such a quality run producer where he's been at that I think it would be a mistake to place him there. IMO, that means a LH combination of Gordon and Larnach, with a splash of Gallo. You have to remember that if Gallo DOES revert back to his very recent Texas self, he's pretty good at OB and being a dangerous power option in that spot. And one out doesn't have to kill an inning he leads off. And...get ready for it...IF Kepler isn't moved, and IF he suddenly finds the ability to drive the ball again instead of soft contact, and with the changes in the shift helping him even a little, he's not a K machine, will take some walks, runs the bases well, and Rocco has used him there previously. From the RH side, I see Farmer and the catcher of the day, especially Jeffers, who rakes against LHP. Remember, the Twins used to play Garver a lot in the #1 spot. Getting OB at a decent clip is important. But the #1 hitter isn't guaranteed to actually lead off an inning but once a game. So what you're looking for is someone who can provide a "spark" in that spot between getting OB, advancing runners ANY WAY POSSIBLE, and knocking in runners on base ahead of you from the bottom of the order, or helping perpetuate an inning, which is much the same as advancing the runners. And that's why it isn't so crazy to play matchups until SOMEONE comes along to grab that #1 spot. For all the "absurdity" that someone like Gallo could be considered, his GOOD YEARS still has a low BA and high K rate, but he also has great power to produce and high BB numbers to give him a good OB%. Imagine him in that spot with a runner OB and he cranks a HR. Imagine he walks instead and now the likes of Buxton, Correa, Polanco, Miranda are up. Now, of course, he might whiff or hit a lazy fly ball. But isn't that true of anyone/everyone most of the time? I don't WANT Kepler at #1 unless he turns himself around. I'm not advocating Gallo in that spot, but I'd like him, or even Larnach, RIGHT NOW, over the Kepler from the past 2 seasons. I WANT someone like Julien or possibly Martin...who I don't think is as close to being READY...to provide all "all encompassing" offensive game for that spot. But as of RIGHT NOW, I say NO-ONE takes that spot and it will be a moving and matchup position. And that makes the most sense to me.4 points
-
The Falvey Philosophies, Part 3: One-Year Wonders
The Falvey Philosophies, Part 3: One-Year Wonders
nclahammer and 2 others reacted to Greggory Masterson for an article
3 pointsThis is where the group leaves the biggest footprint. In the Falvey-Levine era, most of the veteran fill-ins discussed in Part 2 have come in the form of one-year contracts, or contracts with vesting, team, or mutual options for the second year. Based on my research, the breakdown in the length of free agent contracts can be seen below, prior to the second Correa signing, sorted from most recent to least recent, again color-coded by position. One-year contracts are something of a default option for most clubs. No-harm-no-foul, small commitments have a short-term risk. However, this club has shown a special proclivity for the one-year deal. This pattern emphasizes the importance of the farm system producing fruit in this organization. If the decision-makers refuse to find longer-term pieces in free agency, they need to be sure that their internal options are enough to win more games than they lose. They have made a few longer-term commitments, but those situations were special exceptions, such as shoring up the catching position with Jason Castro in 2017 and Christian Vazquez in 2022. Carlos Correa's three-year deal was a one-year deal with insurance, should he suffer a significant injury or forget how to play baseball, a risk the club was willing to take given his talent and clubhouse presence. Although the Josh Donaldson contract does not reflect favorably on them in hindsight, like with Correa, they saw his off-field presence to be valuable (i.e., “He’ll bring intensity”) regardless of his performance, which was expected to be high as well. As can be seen in the table, they do often try to get a bit of extra value out of these one-year deals—especially for bounceback candidates—in the form of options. Most recently, in 2022, they added team options for the Dylan Bundy and Chris Archer signings. If either of them had regained their past form, the team could have brought them back for about $10MM each, The options, though, however, have rarely been exercised, suggesting more duds than bouncebacks. The only option exercised by the team was for the second year of Nelson Cruz ’s 2019 contract. The Cruz signing has been the best in the Falvey-Levine era, netting 6.3 fWAR for about $18.5 million over his first, two-year deal. Exercising that option was a no-brainer. The majority of those moves have not paid off anywhere close to as well as the Cruz signing. A few times each offseason, they make attempts at players on multi-year deals. Before Donaldson and Correa twice, those attempts have not borne fruit. However, their steadfast adherence to their strategy generally prohibits them from the biggest move. As with many of the one-year deals, the Twins' signings of Donaldson and Correa were due in large part to other clubs' wariness over injury concerns. They instead made their interest known and provided a lower offer as a fallback. They attempted the same to no avail, for instance, with Carlos Rodon, Zack Wheeler , and Yu Darvish. Those types of moves, though, would largely prohibit future moves of a similar magnitude. Without the Donaldson trade, they likely would not have been able to sign Correa the first time around. It is possible that spending more money to land Wheeler would have precluded them from future flexibility, so they likely see value in never overextending themselves, especially on pitchers. For this reason, it’s imperative that the Correa signing pays off, because they likely will not have the ability to sign even another Donaldson-like contract in the near future. Given that the chips have been pushed in on a player like Correa, I feel pretty good about the odds, but all that needs to happen is the spontaneous combustion of an ankle to sink the ship. What are your thoughts on the one-year approach with specific exceptions?3 points -
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
glunn and 2 others reacted to JD-TWINS for a post in a topic
3 pointsI’m a pro Gordon guy after 2022! He’s an OUTFIELDER! To me he’s got enough speed & hits with enough consistency against RH pitching to be as close as we can get to a prototype lead-off guy. He could be more selective and maybe walk 3-4 times more per month! With 575 AB’s this year he could be a 38 doubles guy. He won’t be cheated on swing. Vs. Left handed starters I think Michael Taylor makes sense. He can steal a base occasionally. He can run & his spilts against Lefties suggest he’ll start against all left handers. These guys are athletic & durable. I like Gallo 1st maybe 10-15 times per year if Gordon is sitting against a RH. He would be good against power arms or somebody that isn’t a great control guy early. With the former he might turn a fastball around & with the latter he can use his ability to walk. Julien’s gotta make the team before I speculate with him in any spot in order. Lewis could drop into the #1 spot after July & we probably shed ourselves of either Gallo or Kepler. LH opposition starter (30 games): Taylor - Buxton - Correa - Polanco - Miranda - Farmer - Gordon - Jeffers - Keppler RH opposition starter (130 games): Gordon - Kirilof - Correa - Larnach - Polanco - Vazquez - Kepler - Miranda - Gallo Obviously, Buxton will play 100 games or so against RH pitching and alternate with Larnach at DH & Gordon in CF. With LH pitching being a personal target for success and the fact that he’s spelling Miranda - CC - Polanco ……….Farmer will be playing 120 games this year……….maybe a surprise?3 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
joefish and 2 others reacted to MGM4706 for a post in a topic
3 pointsTwins coaches need to look in the mirror. Not one of their young Players know how to play an outfield wall. This includes Celistino!! That's on Gardenhire in St Paul and lower level managers!!3 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Lasorda_This_Out and 2 others reacted to miller761 for a post in a topic
3 pointsMaturation is the key word. It takes more than physical ability to play at the major league level. He has been delivered a wake up call. Now it is up to him what he does with it. Here is hoping he makes the best of it in St. Paul.3 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Lasorda_This_Out and 2 others reacted to JD-TWINS for a post in a topic
3 pointsTaylor upside v. Celestino: .257 BA & .722 OPS vs. Lefties for career (9 yrs) - at least solid. 32 yrs. old with World Series experience. Since beginning of 2021, HIGHEST graded outfielder in baseball!!! Big deal & contrast. Likelihood for mental errors are way low. Seems durable as well. Can steal a few bases as well in right situation…….he may bat lead-off against Lefties?3 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Barnacles and 2 others reacted to The Mad King for a post in a topic
3 pointsGreat take3 points -
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
TopGunn#22 and 2 others reacted to terrydactyls for a post in a topic
3 pointsI would like to see Ricky Henderson.3 points -
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
3 pointsI just want to see Royce, Kirilloff, and Larnach stay healthy and have a little success, and Miranda and Gordon repeat theirs. Not ready for these new guys yet! ...unless we trade Polanco.3 points
-
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
glunn and one other reacted to Greggory Masterson for a post in a topic
2 points#1 may surprise you. Image courtesy of © Jesse Johnson-USA TODAY Sports Last Friday, the Twins finally bit the bullet and shipped Luis Arráez off to Miami in return for Pablo Lopez and two exciting prospects. It’s a sensible move, but the Twins will need to replace Arráez’s production on the field after his 3.2 fWAR 2022 season. Alex Kirilloff appears to be the heir apparent at first base, which was likely to be Arráez’s primary position in the field, with Joey Gallo, Kyle Farmer, Jose Miranda, and Edouard Julien in line to get time at the spot as well. The team shouldn’t struggle to fill the designated hitter spot, either, with the number of players that would benefit from half-days at DH. However, there is a role that Arráez filled with no clear replacement—leadoff hitter. It’s the biggest question right now about the Twins lineup, and Ted Schwerzler has already mentioned a couple of top candidates. But let’s crunch some numbers and see if any new cream rises to the top (of the lineup). There is some debate about how much having a stereotypical leadoff hitter matters to team performance, with some adamant that having someone at the top of the lineup who gets on base consistently leads to more runs. Others believe that the sequencing doesn’t necessarily matter and that the top players should hit as many times as possible over the course of the season, no matter the style. I’m not here to settle that argument, though it makes good reading from analysts wiser than myself. Instead, I want to look at the current roster to see which players fit the mold best. The common idea of a prototypical leadoff hitter is a player who gets on base, can run the bases, and, as Patrick Reusse asserts, sees a lot of pitches. There probably isn’t a player who checks all those boxes on the current squad. Luis probably didn’t either, given that his footspeed leaves a lot to be desired, although he is a good baserunner. I was interested, though, in seeing which players might be the best fit, based on those criteria. I looked at every hitter projected to make the team out of Spring Training based on Fangraph’s Roster Resource. I then compiled select stats from A) 2021-2022 and A) Steamer projections for each player. The players were ranked 1-13 based on their OBP, Fangraphs baserunning runs per 550 plate appearances, and average pitches per plate appearance (there aren’t projections for P/PA, so I used career averages for the projections). These three stats measure the player’s ability to get on base, run the bases, and see many pitches. Let’s see who fits the bill. Unsurprisingly, among the top four in both past performance and 2023 projections were the three players widely believed to be the Twins’ best hitters. The other may surprise some people. #4 Byron Buxton (4th Past, t-4th Projection) Past Rankings: 3rd OBP (.327), 1st BsR (7.5), 8th P/PA (3.84) 2023 Projections: 8th OBP (.304), 1st BsR (1.2), 8th P/PA (3.78) Buxton’s elite speed very much buoys his score on this exercise. As a free-swinger, he doesn’t see a lot of pitches, and his OBP is dependent on his average with his lack of walks. If he hits for an average over .300, as he did in 2021, he’ll be on base a good amount. The team will probably slot him in a more stereotypical power spot, given his ability to hit for extra bases. Nonetheless, he may get some run at the top of the order, as he has in past years. #3 Carlos Correa (3rd Past, 3rd Projection) Past Rankings: 1st OBP (.366), 8th BsR (-3.0), 2nd P/PA (4.08) 2023 Projections: 1st OBP (.351), 12th BsR (-0.9), 2nd P/PA (4.05) Almost the polar opposite of Buxton, Correa’s scores are weighed down by his lack of baserunning—the only player projected to lose more runs on the basepaths is Christian Vazquez. If it weren’t for those abysmal scores, he easily would have come out on top. He will, like Buxton, probably bat second or third, but it’s not unreasonable to think he may hit leadoff a bit, especially against lefties. #2 Jorge Polanco (2nd Past, t-1st Projection) Past Rankings: 2nd OBP (.332), 4th BsR (2.0), 4th P/PA (4.03) 2023 Projections: 2nd OBP (.332), t-4th BsR (0.0), 5th P/PA (3.97) Polanco is probably the best bet to serve as the leadoff man, and he barely missed the top spot in this exercise. He gets on base, runs well, and turns in good at-bats—so long as his ankle pain doesn’t cause him to pirouette out of the box on a swing. Leaning even further into the stereotype of a leadoff man, he’s also a middle infielder. He probably would have hit cleanup in a lineup with Arráez, but he’s a dependable option to plug in at the top of any order, given his balanced skillset and approach. #1 Joey Gallo (1st Past, t-1st Projection) Past Rankings: 5th OBP (.323), 3rd BsR (2.5), 1st P/PA (4.23) 2023 Projections: 6th OBP (.313), t-4th BsR (0.0), 1st P/PA (4.22) Oh no. The spreadsheets have gone too far. It doesn’t sound right, but by this definition of a leadoff hitter, Joey Gallo, of all people, is the top option. He leads players in pitches seen by a wide margin. He actually runs the bases well, even with his large frame. He gets on base at a good clip, too—the past performance metric includes his miserable play from the last season and a half. It sounds absurd, but we’re only three seasons removed from Rocco running out another unconventional leadoff hitter in Max Kepler . I wouldn’t be shocked to see at least a trial run of Gallo hitting leadoff in 2023. It seems in line with this front office. Don’t say I didn’t warn you. Speaking of Kepler, he tied Buxton in this exercise for fourth in the projections, and Trevor Larnach , of all players, landed in fifth in past performance. Another option not included is Edouard Julien, because he has no past performance, and Fangraphs only projects him for 26 plate appearances. Julien, though, gets on base as well as anyone, and if he hits at the Major League level, he’s undoubtedly a leadoff candidate. Admittedly, the three categories here probably shouldn’t be given equal weight, but it was still a fun exercise, and Gallo falls to third if the weight of OBP is doubled. Who do you want to see batting leadoff in 2023? View full article2 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
wabene and one other reacted to Cody Pirkl for a post in a topic
2 pointsGilberto Celestino had a chance to cement himself as an MLB player in 2022 and couldn’t get the job done. After several outfield additions, it seems his future is unclear. Where does Celestino stand in the organization? Image courtesy of Jordan Johnson-USA TODAY Sports Through the end of May, Gilberto Celestino appeared to have turned a corner in 2022. The Twins backup center fielder was slashing .324/.398/.378, 50% above league average by wRC+.With little power to speak of, Celestino was a legitimate offensive contributor for a month or two. And then it all fell apart. From June 1 forward, Celestino slashed .211/.286/.278. The Twins clearly lost faith in him as they acquired Michael A. Taylor in a trade this last week, and he’s likely to fill the backup center field role. Celestino simply has too many questions left unanswered. Nothing demonstrates the Twins lack of trust in Celestino like them trading for a nearly identical player to fill the role he was in last season. Taylor is nearly a carbon copy in terms of raw skills. Both are elite defensive center fielders with little offensive value. It begs the question as to why the Twins traded for Taylor in the first place. There are two main considerations to take into account. First and foremost, the Twins likely have a lack of trust not only in Celestino’s performance, but in his ability to focus. Celestino regularly made awful decisions in the field and on the bases down the stretch in 2022, and in September it reached a breaking point. The offensive struggles were one thing, but it likely said a lot to the Twins brass that in a golden opportunity to prove himself with so many injuries, Celestino was losing focus in several aspects of the game that he had no reason not to be excelling at. It likely told the Twins that for 2023 on days when Byron Buxton is not in center field, Celestino was not a trustworthy replacement even to provide defensive value. A bigger reason for the Taylor trade is that Celestino may be the same zero offense, plus defense type player as Taylor now, but he doesn’t have to be forever. In 2021 Celestino was promoted straight from Double-A as a 22-year-old out of necessity. He was an average hitter there and didn’t have time to adjust before making a massive leap to the MLB. He predictably showed little offensive value, but went down to Triple-A to end the season and slashed a fantastic .290/.384/.443 in 49 games. It seems Celestino is headed back to Triple-A St. Paul to begin 2023, and he may spend significant time there. His unrefined plate approach became too obvious in 2022, and his plan of what to work on is pretty straightforward. He hit the ball to the opposite field more often than any other direction, and as the season went on, he was successfully challenged by pitches inside. He rarely made loud contact, as he appeared to just be trying to hang in there at the plate against MLB pitching. In Triple-A the Twins can work on him pulling the pitches he should be. Even developing some gap power would make him a much more serviceable fill-in. He has one minor league option remaining and won’t even be arbitration eligible until 2025, meaning the Twins have a solid timeline to develop Celestino just a bit more offensively. There is likely still a slight chance that the Twins could trade Celestino if a team calls them up and sees him as a legitimate piece in a trade for an impact player. The Twins would likely prefer however to turn the keys over to Celestino next season after Michael A Taylor departs in free agency. Even if Celestino doesn’t show the offensive upside he flashed in his brief AAA stint, he can play a valuable part in the Twins outfield mix the next few years. It’s obvious that Gilberto Celestino is the big loser in the Michael A Taylor trade, but the Twins have to ensure they don’t find themselves in the same spot as last year. Celestino was dealt a tough hand the day he was promoted directly from AA, and it likely set him back a bit. With Taylor, the Twins bought time for Celestino to develop into the player he’s capable of however, and now it’s up to him to make use of the development time he missed out on in AAA. View full article2 points -
2023 Vikings Off Season Thread
2023 Vikings Off Season Thread
Aggies7 and one other reacted to Parfigliano for a post in a topic
2 pointsHarken back to my comment about how people inside football say...fixed. I dont think its fixed like wrestling where obviosly scripted. But god damn some calls.2 points -
2023 Vikings Off Season Thread
2023 Vikings Off Season Thread
Mike Sixel and one other reacted to Aggies7 for a post in a topic
2 pointsThe officiating today is abominable for championship games2 points -
Twins Daily Winter Meltdown Returns with a Bang: Event Recap
Twins Daily Winter Meltdown Returns with a Bang: Event Recap
wsnydes and one other reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
2 pointsConcur!2 points -
Area Cranks on High Alert with Mauer Hall of Fame Candidacy
Area Cranks on High Alert with Mauer Hall of Fame Candidacy
Nine of twelve and one other reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
2 pointsFTFY2 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Nine of twelve and one other reacted to jorgenswest for a post in a topic
2 pointsHe missed 2020 to the pandemic. Prior that he was in A ball mostly as a teenager. The last two years instead of learning and adjusting to the speed of the game in AA and AAA he was on the major league roster spending a lot of time on the bench. A big part of fundamentals is the speed of the game and how much faster the game is at the major league level compared even to AAA. He mostly jumped from A with a year off. That is a huge speed of game jump. Mental mistakes should not be a surprise.2 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Lasorda_This_Out and one other reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
2 pointsThe Taylor trade was 4 years too late. It’d have been better for Celestino not have been rushed it hás been too much too soon for him. Some player would not recover but Celestino will continue to mature & develop at AAA. A little patience will go a long way with Celestino2 points -
Center field ?
Center field ?
USAFChief and one other reacted to Reptevia for a post in a topic
2 pointsBuxton will play CF when Taylor isn’t available or the matchup dictates. I don’t think Gallo will see any time in CF. Kepler only played 9 innings in CF last year. The depth chart is Taylor/Buxton/Gordon.2 points -
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Nine of twelve and one other reacted to Blyleven2011 for a post in a topic
2 pointsNot a forgotten player , just a player that needs to go get regular playing time and focus on his offensive , Hitting and base running and some throwing to tge right bases ... He should be back up playing mlb baseball with the twins or another team , he should not be forgotten ...2 points -
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
wabene and one other reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
2 pointsVarland and SWR in particular need to get a look given Gray / Mahle and Maeda are free agents. The dream is one or both of them are pitching so great that they force their way onto the team even if it means one of the pending free agents gets moved at the deadline. There is room for Lewis / Wallner and Larnach. Let's hope for a similar situation with them. Let's hope Larnach and Wallner are good enough that they obvious play becomes trading Gallo at the deadline. Dare to dream, right. The IF spot opened via the Arraez departure leaves room for one of Julien / Martin or Lewis. It will be interesting to see how that plays out. They can always trade Farmer if they are so fortunate as to have guys beating down the door. I would be really happy if our problem was too many prospects making a great case to be at the ML level.2 points -
Bally Sports Networks Preparing for bankruptcy
Bally Sports Networks Preparing for bankruptcy
glunn and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
2 pointsGlad to know my dad is hip, now, with it and wow as a 62 year old and cut the cord on cable. He is not a drooling old fool and perfectly capable of using more than 1 remote and 1 app on a TV.2 points -
Bally Sports Networks Preparing for bankruptcy
Bally Sports Networks Preparing for bankruptcy
glunn and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
2 pointsSure. Giving customers more for less always works for the consumer. You were proposing a 43% off solution from MLB.tv’s current price point. How is that going to make up St Louis’ $100 million TV contract that will be lost when the bankruptcy becomes reality? I see MLB.tv offering several payment terms if they purchase all of the RSN TV broadcasts. You want all MLB games and MiLB games with no restrictions? $250-300 annually. One team and their MiLB? $200 annually. One MLB team? $140. They could also offer monthly payment options for fans of teams that may not be competitive by July 31.2 points -
Twins Will Win the Division (An Overly Optimistic Post)
Twins Will Win the Division (An Overly Optimistic Post)
Mike Sixel and one other reacted to Matthew Lenz for a post in a topic
2 pointsI don’t think you need to be an optimist to think the Twins could win the division in 2023. A LOT went wrong in 2022.2 points -
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
wabene and one other reacted to Fatbat for a post in a topic
2 pointsThey should be fully motivated to play great in St. Paul and basically force the team to bring them across the river. Its just a matter of time when someone is tearing up AAA.2 points -
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
One could reasonably state that I'm very pro-analytics. However, there comes a point where analytics are not to be trusted. Analytics suggesting Joey Gallo should bat leadoff are a prime example of that point. Correa or Polanco should bat leadoff.2 points
-
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Julien and Lewis look like they both could do it if they perform well enough when they reach the majors. I’d be fine with Gallo if he’s more of the 2019/early 2021 Gallo, if not then put him at the lower end of the lineup. Polanco and Buxton both could get some reps in and see if they stick. Correa is a big no. I do like one external option that still fits perfectly into this lineup: Mark Canha. The Twins should swap good defense for a high-OBP Righty bat, who could easily be the leadoff hitter of 2023.2 points
-
Bally Sports Networks Preparing for bankruptcy
Bally Sports Networks Preparing for bankruptcy
glunn and one other reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic
2 pointsMusk will probably buy the whole shebang and we can watch games live streamed from Mars, subject to the 5-20 minute communications delay, of course.2 points -
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Melissa and one other reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
2 pointsAt least if Gallo batted lead-off, he would not kill a first inning rally with a strike out.2 points -
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
2 pointsMy bet is on Ronny Henriquez, early, as a bullpen piece who establishes himself immediately as integral. My hope is that his role is as a 6th inning type, preceding a group of effective rp's that include Pagan (yeah yeah, I know), Moran, Jax, Alcala, Thielbar, Lopez, and Duran. Wishful thinking, I know.2 points
-
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
roger and one other reacted to TopGunn#22 for a post in a topic
2 pointsI'm totally in the Julien camp. If he hits and gets on base in St. Paul at the level he has previously, he will be up whether it's to play 2B or 1B. He would also be a perfect leadoff guy. Would love to see Balazovic at some point. That would indicate that he's made a significant turnaround. But the Twins have a LOT more pitching depth than before and Winder, SWR and Varland would certainly be up before him. And if each of THOSE guys are up we've probably suffered another round of pitching injuries. Brooks Lee is a guy I could certainly see up at some point. The kid can hit and is a switch hitter to boot. Lewis will need about 3-4 weeks in St. Paul once he's cleared to play to knock off the rust, but he's a lock to be called up. Finally, my great white whale of a prospect, Matt Canterino!! If this guy can EVER stay healthy he could become the lock down closer that allows Duran to start. OR, the two of them flat out dominate the 8th and 9th innings and they headline one of baseballs BEST bullpen for several years.2 points -
An Ace From Within; Dreams of Duran
An Ace From Within; Dreams of Duran
wabene and one other reacted to twins_89 for a comment on a blog entry
2 pointsThe reason Duran is in the bullpen to begin with is because he couldn't stay healthy as a starter. I have no doubt that if the Twins believed that Duran could pitch 150+ innings a year he would be in the rotation, unfortunately that just isn't the case.2 points -
An Ace From Within; Dreams of Duran
An Ace From Within; Dreams of Duran
Nick Hanzlik reacted to TopGunn#22 for a comment on a blog entry
1 pointThis is a good topic Nick. We already have a lights out closer and that's fine with me. But the prevailing wisdom is that a dominant SP is always worth more than a dominant closer due to the higher number of quality innings delivered. I don't think the Twins should completely settle on Duran as a closer but it depends what happens with other guys on the team and in the system. Alcala is pretty much a bullpen guy now. What if he explodes this year? Jorge Lopez has shown he can be a quality closer. And what about Matt Canterino? He's also got lights out stuff and due to HIS durability concerns will probably be a bullpen guy going forward and who could also be a lights out closer. I would probably leave Duran where he is for 2023, but if Lopez returns to form and Alcala impresses the calculation may change on Duran. By 2024 we should have a good idea about Canterino's health and the quality of his stuff. Heck, I'm happy to leave Duran as our closer. But going into 2024 we could be looking at different scenarios depending on which starters were effective in 2023 and determining who is going and who is staying. Duran's role could stay the same, but it could change as well.1 point -
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
I believe that Prielipp will be the next Chris Sale. He didn't play at all in his draft year, thus, it is less likely that he debuts for the Twins this year as Sale did for the Sox in his first full year. Thus, I see him breaking in early in 2024. But there is a chance, albeit small, that Connor Prielipp will step onto the Target Field mound late in 2023.1 point
-
VIDEO: How worried should we be about Pablo Lopez’s Shoulder?
Sure - am concerned about every player’s health that has been on IL previously with more than a minor ailment. Your examples of other guys shoulder problems & recovery rates were informative but nothing gives the FO nor the fans a warm feeling. Lopez’ 2022 is encouraging but not any kind of guarantee. P. López - yes Maeda - fixed? T. Mahle - yes Gray - routinely tender Ober - yes Larnach - routinely out Polanco - yes Winder - in & out Buxton - YES Kirilof - YES Am probably missing an obvious one or two guys? These guys are key pieces to our success, so, fingers crossed. Health killed us last year & there’s 38% of our roster listed here that we should have legitimate questions about……..how many of these 10 start the season healthy?….,,how many get through June unscathed??1 point
-
The Twins Forgotten Center Fielder
Guys have been making errors with the mental game aspects of baseball forever………the problem with Celestino comes in when most fans realize after 1 season that he has an issue with base running & outfield play judgement. I get he’s 22-23 years old and theoretically has time to learn. As a guy who played baseball from age 8 - 14 & watched from 6 to 60, Gilberto has had plenty of field time & coaching & practice to be aware of “baseball situations” and know, out of wrote, what play to make. Awareness & smarts in sports are difficult to teach……you coach and then at some point the player absorbs and routinely does the right thing. Or not! Not trying to just be a negative take, but his lack of ability to hit the ball to the left of the 2nd baseman, coupled with the issues with making the right play in clutch or simple situations tells me he may never develop into a guy we want playing outfield in the Show in Minneapolis.1 point
-
Twins Timeline for Prospects in 2023
Ted's OP is prospects to DEBUT for the first time. And that's the key. Even in very SSS we've seen a bunch of the current 40 man do so. And I think Elliot is correct when he states you can pretty much forget anyone not currently on the 40 man roster, barring trades. And even without that rather obvious criteria...and the 40 man is pretty well stacked to be honest...the choice is CLEARLY Julien. Signed too late in 2019 to play, and no 2020, college draftee or not, his development and production has skyrocketed him through the system in TWO YEARS. He was great in 2021, dominate in 2022, and was "cheated" out of MVP in the recent AFL season, still earning the nice "breakout player" award. Still looking for a defensive "home", you find room for a hitter with all of his potential and ability. Very good chance he, more or less, swaps places with Arraez as an OK defensive player at a few spots, and sess time at DH, so he can be in the lineup most days. He won't hit like Arraez, or have the same uncanny ability to avoid K's like him, but will walk more, and have more power and speed. (Better knees, one would think). I wouldn't be shocked if he broke camp, but I don't see the room for him, as the roster stands today. And I don't think the Twins will want to push him that fast, wanting him to get some AAA time before promotion. But he's just got to be #1 on the list. The remaining options, as listed, I don't have a problem with, in general. It all seems to make sense. The exception might be Balazovic. I still have a lot of faith in him after a single nightmare season. The talent is still there, the potential is still there, and sometimes s**t happens and just goes wrong. I wouldn't be surprised if they guarded him a bit and let Winder/SWR/Varland get time before him to just give him all the time he needs to get right. DARKHORSE CANDIDATE: Don't sleep on the older Helman to get a shot at some time as a super utility RH bat with pop and speed and some bat ability to be a fill in player at some point in 2023.1 point
-
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
tarheeltwinsfan reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
1 pointCan Spring Training be useful in answering this question? I want Gordon to start in LF, but the Twins may go with Gallo and Kepler unless Kirilloff is not ready. If Kirilloff is not ready, there is an opportunity for a player to make a big impression before the season starts. If Julien can be that player, and he is somewhat of a long shot because the Twins seem to look towards their veterans, then a line drive machine with power who draws walks and can run could look mighty fine in the leadoff spot. Make someone earn a spot.1 point -
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
Who do the Numbers Endorse as Twins' New Leadoff Hitter?
LA VIkes Fan reacted to CRF for a post in a topic
1 pointPolanco. Buck isn't a lead off hitter, and never was. If they put Gallo at the 1 spot, I'll rip up my tickets.1 point -
Does Alex Reyes Make Sense for the Twins?
Does Alex Reyes Make Sense for the Twins?
darwin22 reacted to TopGunn#22 for a comment on a blog entry
1 pointI've been wanting this for a LONG time. He's affordable and the stuff is electric. It's worth a gamble to start him in low leverage situations and see how things play out. Who would you rather the Twins spend money on, Pagan or Reyes? To me, it's 100% Reyes.1 point -
The Twins Need to be Realistic With Max Kepler
He played nearly every day in Sep/Oct and slashed .252/.298/.396 (.694 OPS) compared to .279/.323/.439 (.762 OPS) through August 31 as a part time/utility player. He also slashed .200/.298/.275 (.542 OPS) vs LHP compared to .289/.329/.465 (.793 OPS) vs RHP. He is best suited to a utility/platoon role.1 point
-
2023 Twins Top 10 Prospect Rankings: Where Does Jose Salas Fit?
2023 Twins Top 10 Prospect Rankings: Where Does Jose Salas Fit?
Oldgoat_MN reacted to Heistyman for a post in a topic
1 pointI received my Twins Prospect rankings from Prospects Live yesterday and this is how they ranked him. They are not kind to Wallner and Balazovic. 1. Brooks Lee, SS - 55 OFP 2. Royce Lewis, SS - 50 OFP 3. Emmanuel Rodriguez, OF - 50 OFP 4. Edouard Julien, 2B - 50 OFP 5. Connor Prielipp, LHP - 50 OFP 6. Louie Varland, RHP - 50 OFP 7. Simeon Woods Richardson, RHP - 50 OFP 8. Marco Raya, RHP - 50 OFP 9. Jose Salas, SS - 50 OFP 10. Austin Martin, SS - 45 OFP 11. David Festa, RHP - 45 OFP 12. Matt Canterino, RHP - 45 OFP 13. Tanner Schobel, SS - 45 OFP 14. Yasser Mercedes, OF - 45 OFP 15. Misael Urbina, OF - 45 OFP 16. Jose Rodriguez, OF - 45 OFP 17. Noah Miller, SS - 45 OFP 18. Jordan Balazovic, RHP - 45 OFP 19. Alejandro Hidalgo, RHP - 45 OFP 20. Matt Wallner, OF - 40 OFP 21. Ronny Henriquez, RHP - 40 OFP 22. Cole Sands, RHP - 40 OFP 23. Danny De Andrade, SS/3B - 40 OFP 24. Aaron Sabato, 1B - 40 OFP 25. Michael Helman, UTIL - 40 OFP 26. Blayne Enlow, RHP - 40 OFP 27. Cory Lewis, RHP - 40 OFP 28. Sean Mooney, RHP - 40 OFP 29. Bryan Acuna, SS - 40 OFP 30. Ben Ross, UTIL - 40 OFP1 point