At this point the FA pitching market has shrunk to Michael Wacha and a bunch of former Twins so barring a trade I want to stick with our current rotation;
Here are their peak years:
Sonny Grey - 2015 (yes, that is 8 years ago) 14 - 7, 2.73 era, 1.082whip 3.5 WAR
Joe Ryan - 2022 13 - 8, 3.55, 1.102, 2.2 WAR
Kenta Maeda - 2016 16 - 11, 3.58 1.139, 2.8WAR (his whip was amazing in 2020 but that was a short year and things can change fast)
Tyler Mahle - 2021 13 - 6, 3.75 1.233 5.1 WAR
Bailey Ober - 2022 2 - 3, 3.21 1.054, 0.9 WAR
Chris Paddock 2019 9 - 7, 3.33, 0.981 2.9 WAR
Here are their worst years:
Sonny Grey - 2016 5 - 11 5.69 era, 1.496 Whip, WAR - 0.3
Joe Ryan (only 2 years) 2 - 1 4.05 (I looked at his minors and college stats and he really has not had a bad year).
Kenta Maeda - 2021 6 - 5, 4.66 1.298 0.3 WAR
Tyler Mahle - 2018 7 - 9. 4.98, 1.589 0.1 WAR
Bailey Ober - 2021 3 - 3 4.19, 1.202 1.9 WAR
Chris Paddock - 2021 7 - 7, 5.07, 1.209 -0.6 WAR
Where do you expect this rotation to be in 2023? High/low or in between?
Who rises? Who falls?
And who is next in line?