Leaderboard
-
Seth Stohs
AdministratorPoints24,042Posts -
-
-
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 09/30/2022 in all areas
-
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Don't Feed the Greed Guy and 32 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic
33 pointsWhy the vitriol? He isn't doing or saying anything that wasn't expected. He was always going to opt-out. That was clear from Day 1. I thought he phrased it very well. It's actually a really good analogy, very true. Also, why would he get any less than Seager got? He's still young for a free agent, so he should get 10 years (like Seager), but certainly would get at least 8 years. And he'll get $30-35 million per year. At the lowest, he's looking at 8 years and $240 million, and at the highest, it could be 10 years and $325 million. All of that is more than 1 year, $35.1 million. Pretty sure none of us would do any different.33 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Don't Feed the Greed Guy and 16 others reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
17 pointsCorrea has been the best player in a Twins uniform since Mauer. There was never any question of how the decision would play unless there was a serious injury. The contract of three years was strictly insurance and the Twins had insurance if he was unable to play. It works both ways. The clip above just tells everyone what was already known. The Twins have an opportunity to sign Correa. They just have to decide what they want for their team. It's actually pretty straight forward. Correa is a classy player.17 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Brazilian Twins Fan and 13 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
14 pointsI expected him to be a little more tactful than that.14 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
kenbuddha and 11 others reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic
12 pointsWhen he signed the contract... his opting out was a foregone conclusion. Nothing surprising here. Yet... a reporter (who should have already known the answer to the question he was asking) stuck a microphone in his face and asked him what the Twins could do to keep him. Carlos answered the question honestly with a very apt analogy of how free agency works. The responses in this thread are once again another example of honesty being punished by us. If you ever find yourself wondering why you are being lied to, please understand that you are the reason. Please understand that if you keep punching the truth when it shows up... it will stop showing up for the beating and it has. Please understand that the manipulation of skilled public relations professionals, battle hardened political operatives and the researched marketing of Madison avenue is what we consistently ask for instead of the truth. If you can't handle the truth... you are just asking to be handled.12 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
Mortimerkenny21 and 10 others reacted to Karbo for a post in a topic
11 pointsJust sign him. Can't count on AK to ever be the player he was. Rotate Arraez, Miranda, and Urshela between 3B, 1B and DH.11 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
MauerGoat and 10 others reacted to Beast for a post in a topic
11 pointsPeople are really going to clutch their pearls over this? Unreal. It’s truly bizarro world around here. It was always delusional to think he was staying here. I basically got called a lunatic and idiot for saying that. If this is a surprise….it’s on you. Why should he be “tactful?” To lead a random group of fans to think their favorite organization isn’t a dumpster fire? To praise an organization that just did everything in their power to drain his value by surrounding him with hot garbage? He’s probably pretty pissed about how things went. Heck, I’d be more harsh and I’m just a fan. He was likely promised a number of things. Instead, he got caught up in one of the biggest displays of trade deadline and overall administrative failures ever seen (and for the 100th time, it’s not bad luck). Maybe if Twins media and fans also had a little belly fire instead of making excuses and lauding mediocrity, ownership would get the message. Its a hard pill to swallow for some. But, I think we’re entering some dark days here. Like late 90s level stuff. Where our All-Star rep and best player has a season line of .270, 16 HR, 54 RBI. Lifeless, soul-sucking baseball. Carlos isn’t an idiot. If he was in any way optimistic about what was going on here, he’d answer that question differently. He can’t get out of here fast enough. I’ve been saying that for months and have been repeatedly been told I don’t know what I’m talking about. Not much else to say to the “experts,” on that. Lastly, why the hell wouldn’t you want someone to be honest? What kind of world do we live in where people demand false tact and pomp over honesty and brass tacks. Good for you, Carlos. Go win, have fun AND get paid. Tell anyone outraged and offended where to go.11 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
D.C Twins and 9 others reacted to mnfireman for a post in a topic
10 pointsCan't have too much depth, as the injuries of the last few seasons have shown, so I say sign him. He is not a superstar, but seems fundamentally sound and comes up with the big hit or big defensive play often enough.10 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
tonderk and 9 others reacted to William K Johnson for a post in a topic
10 pointsSign him for whatever he wants. His defense is incredible, he appears to be a great clubhouse guy and hitting is acceptable. Miranda is not the answer at third.10 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
MauerGoat and 8 others reacted to dberthia for a post in a topic
9 pointsAbout as surprising as Buxton being injured. I just hope Lewis can eventually come back and stay healthy.9 points -
it's over. bye-bye carlos
it's over. bye-bye carlos
TwinsDr2021 and 7 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
8 pointsThe Twins won't pony up the money but given how loathe they are to spend on pitching, there's no good reason they shouldn't throw a monstrous pile of cash at Correa. But hey, signing six $8m or under guys has worked so well for them, it will be hard to convince them to stray from that path.8 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
Mortimerkenny21 and 7 others reacted to Whitey333 for a post in a topic
8 pointsYes by all means sign him. He's a good third baseman and hits decent. Why create a problem at 3 rd base that we already have solved? We have way too many other areas of real concern on the team.8 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
Mortimerkenny21 and 7 others reacted to Mark G for a post in a topic
8 pointsNo brainer. He is your starting 3rd baseman. His numbers match up with virtually anyone on the team all told, less power than Buck but hits for a much better average, has numbers overall that match pretty well with Correa and Miranda, and doesn't hit as much for average as Arraez, but has more power. Absolutely a better defensive 3rd baseman than Miranda, and I am SO sick and tired of saying 10M is too much to pay for a player with his overall performance. I would sign him to an extension, maybe 2 years with a team option for a 3rd, and if the team goes south you could trade him with his contract control being a good bargaining chip. He is a good all around player and not a problem child as far as I have ever read. Sign him!8 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
wabene and 7 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
8 pointsGood bye, thanks for coming to visit and bringing some quality to the table. I applaud the Twins for getting him, I wish him good luck, but I think there will be a lot of buyer remorse in the SS long term high dollar contracts. Remember how most felt about Donaldson and his contract after the first year? We were glad to dump it. SS do not age well at their positions. And neither do pitchers. I am sure that Dodgers are tired of paying David Price, the Red Sox have gotten nothing but injuries from Sales and below expectation production plus injuries from Story who played second - not SS. Look at the expectations and then production the Tigers got out of Javy Baez~! Marcus Semien moved to 2B - is his value as great there? Fernando Tatis looks like he is just as injured by the burden of so much money as he is physically. I just think BB has to adjust their thinking. I did like Correa's contract, but wish it could have been 2 years then opt out instead of one, but that might be the model the Twins have to follow. Meanwhile SS is waiting for Lewis and Lee, and our current fill ins are not good enough. But can we wait or do we make another move for someone to fill in and if so how does that work with the young guys are ready? Can we over pay a good SP like we did Correa? That might be our new strategy, lots of money, but not a long term commitment.8 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Don't Feed the Greed Guy and 7 others reacted to Mark G for a post in a topic
8 pointsI wonder about the context of that clip; what was said before and after would be helpful to know. It is in contrast to the article I read in Wednesday's paper about him wanting very much to stay long term. He used the analogy about being married vs. dating, saying he wanted to marry an organization and was waiting for the Twins to, in his words, "pop the question". It was a very positive article with more quotes suggesting he would like to stay here, but he did imply it would take a long term contract. The ball is in JP's court; he has to decide relatively soon. I have to believe the team wants him back, and Rocco would love to pencil his name in the lineup 140 times a year. But if it comes down to nothing but money, wish him well next week, because it will be the last we see of him.8 points -
Twins New Scoreboard to Only Show Night Court Reruns
Twins New Scoreboard to Only Show Night Court Reruns
nclahammer and 6 others reacted to RandBalls Stu for an article
7 pointsThe Minnesota Twins announced plans to revamp their uniforms and Target Field this offseason, including a massive upgrade to their outfield scoreboard. Just don’t expect it to be all about baseball. “Our marketing team, along with trusted advisers, says that our fans want to watch the antics and hijinks of NBC’s Night Court,” said Dave St. Peter, Minnesota’s President and CEO. “It’s the right call.” Night Court, a sitcom set in a New York City courtroom, ran from 1984-92 on NBC. No one over the age of 35 knows what it is, but the team is confident it will appeal to all ages more than batting averages or scoreboard updates. The new scoreboard will show a constant stream of reruns at the expense of highlights, statistics, and game updates. “The research is thorough and grounded in fact,” said St. Peter. “The zany antics of Judge Harry Stone, D.A. Dan Fielding, and Bull the loveable bailiff have cross-generational appeal. Millennials, Gen X, and Zoomers love Markie Post, and we intend to meet them where they’re at. If they want to know the score, the game is literally right in front of them. That’s not our problem.” One problem is the fact that the sitcom was filmed before the age of high definition, and the resolution of the images has been described as “a nightmare come to life, but covered in cataracts” by a source close to the situation. St. Peter brushes off these concerns. “The average age of our season ticket holders is 77,” said St. Peter. “They’ll just think they need to put their readers on. And you don’t need 20/20 vision to appreciate the gentle yet ribald humor of the wackiest municipal court in Manhattan!” Image license here.7 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
kenbuddha and 6 others reacted to PopRiveter for a post in a topic
7 pointsI was quoted as saying something similar. "When I go to Mills Fleet Farm and I go to the fishing lure clearance bin and I want something, I do some math to determine the price minus the color-coded percentage discount. But I usually decide it still costs more than I want to pay. So if you're a cheap enough guy, you can pass on just about anything. I'm the product here, and not especially good at baseball, so..."7 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
wabene and 6 others reacted to saviking for a post in a topic
7 pointsI've been contemplating this for over a month now. I love the heck out of the guy mainly because he's such a great teammate. But I see Miranda as our long term third baseman. Krilloff needs to man first and I don't know where else Miranda is capable of playing other than third base. His slow start kept his batting average down but Miranda has the ability to be an annual three hundred plus hitter with power. For that all he has to do is play an average third base. But I'm fine with resigning Ursela for one year, no extension. By 2024 Julian and Lee will be ready and Lewis will be back.7 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Heiny and 6 others reacted to RaoulDuke for a post in a topic
7 pointsHe was going to opt out unless he had a terrible year or a major injury, he is a Boras client that was basically typed in bold on the contract. I think I would be ok with him at 35-36 a year for 3 or 4 years (no opt outs), but anything past that years wise is paying for decline at a premium position. It's frustrating to watch the New York and California teams sign all the stars because they can eat the decline years, but it is what it is. This team is only signing big contracts that are short years or older/ riskier players with limited options, they will never buy a contending squad. Hindsight is 20/20 but I really wonder what they could have got for him at the deadline, incredibly hard move to make but that's how a team like the Rays competes consistently in that powerhouse division. /Deadhorsebeaten7 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
D.C Twins and 6 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
7 pointsTell us how you really feel, Carlos. Sheesh. I’m still unsure he’ll get the long term deal he’s looking for.7 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
wabene and 5 others reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic
6 pointsThis is why PR is necessary in the first place. In the age of social media. The expectation that anyone is able to parse their words perfectly (at a moments notice) to avoid pissing people off keeps public relations professionals necessary to provide the pre-packaged watered down statements that ultimately keep us in the dark and say absolutely nothing at best and lie to us at worst. Here is what he should have said out the PR Handbook to avoid the criticism. Q: What would it take for you to stay with the Minnesota Twins? A: I have really enjoyed my time in Minnesota, My Teammates, the coaching staff, the fans, everyone. My family and I have have felt welcome and comfortable here since the day I arrived. I will be having discussions with my agent about my future and God willing things will work out. And the cliche answers make us all feel better until he officially opts out and eventually signs with Philadelphia. We squeeze these people until the smart thing for them to do is to just shut up and then we hammer them for shutting up. The guy answered the question honestly. Do we really have to have a problem when he compares a potentially high dollar deal to a high dollar product? We deserve the darkness we live in. We act horribly whenever someone turns the light on. .6 points -
2022 Twins--What Went Wrong and How to Fix It
2022 Twins--What Went Wrong and How to Fix It
Kummel and 5 others reacted to jmlease1 for a comment on a blog entry
6 pointsI think this is a fair analysis. I will say the biggest organizational philosophy they need to examine in bullpen construction is identifying 2 pitchers that they intend to throw more than 1 inning per outing. The back end is looking a lot stronger going into next season than it was at the start of this one with Lopez, Duran, Thielbar, Jax, and (hopefully) Alcala. But I think with starters often being in the "5 and Fly" mode you need a couple of relievers that you expect to throw 2-3 innings when they come in to bridge the gap. Do they have that in Moran, Sands, winder, etc? Could Dobnak be that kind of guy? Don't know, but having TWO guys who can attack the game that way makes it viable to manage the innings load. Kepler is unlikely to ever have a 2019 season again; it's looking like a Brady Anderson-style fluke year. but Polanco was great in 2021 and has been injured in 2022, not bad. (and Kepler has actually produced enough to be a reasonable starter even with the injuries and sapped power...which almost certainly has a lot to do with the busted toe) Nick Gordon has improved as a hitter to the point where he's a quality player, especially as a super-utility guy; he's going to finish the year right around 2 bWAR. Larnach was having a fine season before injury, so saying that "he's not that good" is a snap judgment that's awfully hasty. We shouldn't assume he's going to be as great as he was in May, but we also should write him off already no better than he was in April. Buxton might never play a full season again, but even in 92 games he was worth 4 bWAR. That's a really good player. If they can get him to 120-130 games a season he's an all-star quality player every year. I mean, if you're determined to presume the worst case scenario for every Twins player, I don't know what to tell you. Find a new team if you think the twins are uniquely jinxed? While I don't think every fan has to look only on the positive side of things, casting everything in a negative light, even when the evidence suggests a different story isn't very helpful. Polanco isn't a bad player. Polanco doesn't need to go back to 2019; he was actually better in 2021. Nick Gordon is proof for why you shouldn't give up on Larnach too soon. Buxton, Kirilloff, and Lewis might never stay healthy enough to maximize their talent...but that's the great unknown.6 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
The Twins received fair value from the Mauer contract.6 points
-
it's over. bye-bye carlos
it's over. bye-bye carlos
jkcarew and 5 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
6 pointsCorrea is better than good. He's wrapping up his age 27 season and has over 30 career fWAR. The only real problem with Correa is his health issues, he's damned near a perfect player outside of being unable to stay on the field. He has played 120 or more games only three times in his career. But when he's on the field, he's spectacular. Extrapolate most of his seasons to 140-150 games and he's routinely around the 6 fWAR mark.6 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
6 pointsThe biggest issue with him is the 40 man crunch coming up. As it sits even after you remove the FA and assuming we opt out of Sano, we have 42 guys on our 40 man roster right now, plus the few guys that will need to be added to save from rule 5 draft. That will need to be a factor. He is an average player, maybe slightly above, but in a perfect line up is he in the top of it? I would say no. His defense is inflated by the eye test. He looks like he makes great plays, which at times he did, but he missed a lot of plays too that were not errors but others could have made. Not only do we have Miranda, but depending on what we decide to do with FA and SS we have possibly Lewis to slide over, Arraez, not sure Gordon has the arm to play third but sure he could fill in if needed. I am not saying dump him, but I am far from the bring him back for sure stance. It will be a hard decision. Depending on how team feels about Lee it is possible he could come up, they have been very aggressive with him so far.6 points
-
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
jorgenswest and 5 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
6 pointsI would give him what he wants. Someone will, why not us? Oh … wait … we won’t. I agree with Seth and RiverB … it was a really good analogy with a lot of honesty. And him opting out is no surprise. From the beginning it was always ever going to be a 1-year deal. Some of us, okay some of me, were hoping beyond hope there’d be a way he would stay, but reality was always there waiting. I’ll be sad when he goes.6 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
Swing Batter-Batter and 5 others reacted to Byrdman for a post in a topic
6 pointsSign and extend him. He is our starting 3B. There is virtually no one else. Miranda can play 3B when he Urshela needs a day off. Absolute no brainer here.6 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
I would give him 7-8 years at 33 mil per. He is worth every penny. This is a very young team that needs some veteran leadership, and he fits that bill. After all it has become clear that Rocco is not a good leader.6 points
-
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
5 pointsWhy should there be a crunch in the 40 man roster? Do you really want to keep Jake Cave on there? Sano? Thielbar? Archer, even Sanchez? C'mon. There has to be minor leaguers better than them. And cheaper too. And what does "ready" really mean? Prospect lists come and go and some of those on the team now doing ok were never top 10 prospects. If a player is that good, then play him. If not, then ????5 points
-
it's over. bye-bye carlos
5 pointsI said it at the beginning of the year and I will say it again, We are fortunate to have been able to watch such an amazing player on our team even if it is for just one season. True baseball fans I would think would appreciate the great plays he made all year while making them look easy and routine. I enjoy watching baseball. I enjoy watching greatness. I will enjoy every time I get to see Buxton or Correa make great defensive plays no matter how much or how little they are on the field. When they are out there, they are special to watch. I don't need titles to enjoy watching them and I will always hope to be blessed enough to be able to watch players like these for the time we have them. My favorite parts of 87 and 91 were not just winning the World Series both those years. When I think of those I think of Kirby's leaping grabs over the wall all year! I remember Jack Morris being a bulldog all year, not jsut in the 10th inning, I remember Gaetti's under appreciated glove work in BOTH series... I could go on and on. I don't just remember the titles, I remember the plays. Just like I remember great plays by Mauer, Hunter, Knoblauch, etc... in non winning seasons. I remember No Hitters and going to the Dome BECAUSE Radke was pitching (for a lousy team I might add) All this to say, I hope you all enjoyed watching Correa even while the season was VERY disappointing. He is special and I wouldn't mind watching him play for us some more...5 points
-
it's over. bye-bye carlos
it's over. bye-bye carlos
The Mad King and 4 others reacted to FlyingFinn for a post in a topic
5 pointsI'm not sure what you are talking about. Correa can opt to become a free agent or choose to take $35 million from the Twins next year. The Twins will pay $0 for him to play for another team.5 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
GopherJeff and 4 others reacted to TwinsDr2021 for a post in a topic
5 pointsThere are no free agent 3B IMO worth anything, MLB list Carpenter as DH FA. There are no minor league players ready to fill 3rd, so it comes down to three players, Gio, Miranda and Arraez. Gio seems the best option.5 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
dex8425 and 4 others reacted to Nashvilletwin for a post in a topic
5 pointsNo vitriol - just business. His signing with us was actually a shrewd roll of the dice by the FO - maybe we catch fire and wind up competing (which, btw, we did until the other not so shrewd FO’s pitching moves, Rocco’s management, bad fundamentals and injuries caught up with us). The FO deserves a lot of applause on the CC signing for sure. The question (certainly inevitable now given CC’s strong post contention performance) is what does the FO do? I see five possibilities: 1. Sign CC to a minimum 8 year deal @ at least $30MM per year. 2. Sign CC to a 5 year deal at closer to $40MM per year. 3. Sign a different SS to a more “reasonable” short-mid term deal. 4. Use the cash to sign FA pitching and try to compete next year with an in-house SS strategy while waiting for a home grown SS in 2024. 5. Save a lot of cash and basically “rebuild” in 2023 developing Lee or Lewis as your SS of the future. The first three choices are possible if the FO doesn’t see a long term SS in the organization who will be ready by 2024 and a one-year in-house stop gap solution isn’t viable. However, #1 isn’t likely - not the Twins way; #2 is what I’d hope for, but not sure CC goes for it with longer term deals on the table; and #3, to really move the dial, would take another unique situation, but we’ve now seen this film a couple of times and it’s not really worked. The last two make more sense if Lewis or Lee or someone else (Polacios or Miller perhaps) is viewed as the long-term SS. #4 is way more likely than #5 as this FO with the Pohlads support will never be in a publicly announced rebuilding mode (see our attendance numbers) and there will be a lot of cash available with CC and others moving on. And #4 could work with the right FA starter/relief pitching signings, a healthy Buxton, and another veteran FA signing like Cruz was. So we hope for #2, but in reality #3 or #4 are more likely and could be better options anyway. Please note, however, none of these work if the FO and Rocco don’t up their games in a big way, the new young core don’t develop, the team doesn’t somehow play better fundamental baseball, and we can’t significantly cut down on the injuries.5 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
LA VIkes Fan and 4 others reacted to Greglw3 for a post in a topic
5 pointsYou nailed it!5 points -
Reevaluating Minnesota’s 3 Young Outfielders
I see too many comments declaring the likelihood that AK may never play again. It is true that his surgery isn’t common for baseball players. But that doesn’t mean it can’t work. Don’t know how many doctors we have here today, but maybe one can offer some insight. The truth is WE don’t know anything about this surgery. But we aren’t the patient or the Twins. what is fact is that many people believed AK to be one of the best hitters in all of the minor leagues before his injury. Didn’t he have the second best stats to that superstar now playing for Toronto? So what we do know is this kid was a very special talent. I am willing to wait until spring training when we will know how he is doing before declaring his career is over.5 points
-
Reevaluating Minnesota’s 3 Young Outfielders
Reevaluating Minnesota’s 3 Young Outfielders
gman and 4 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
5 pointsI've spent a lot of time lately railing on the Twins for blaming their failures on factors out of their control. And I stand by that - a winning team should make its own luck. But, my goodness, the vengeful spirit of those Target Field displaced outfield evergreen trees is fierce. It took out Buxton's career, and then it came for Kirilloff and Larnach. Get a team of exorcists out there pronto. And somebody put some kind of protective amulet around Wallner's neck when he's playing. Sheesh.5 points -
Jordan Balazovic Ends Season on a High Note
Jordan Balazovic Ends Season on a High Note
MN_ExPat and 3 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
4 pointsI just really, really, really want a pitcher with the nickname "Jordy Blaze" to have a successful career here. It takes too much hope to be a Twins fan these days, but I've still got some left in the tank for both Martin and Balazovic.4 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
farmerguychris and 3 others reacted to GopherJeff for a post in a topic
4 pointsUrshela is a good deal for *at least* 2023. Offensively, he's not a star but he seems to be well-liked and is one of the team's better performers for '22 (which ain't saying much for this team). He's fine defensively - .985 fielding %, which is 2nd in MLB (behind only Matt Chapman). In short, he's definitely not a liability at 3rd base.. There are so many other needs for the Twins. Keeping Urshela around for another year (or more) is wise.4 points -
Jordan Balazovic Ends Season on a High Note
Jordan Balazovic Ends Season on a High Note
MN_ExPat and 3 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
4 pointsHe better start 2023 on a high note or he'll continue moving towards the top of the list for guys to be removed from the 40-man next year. He's got too much upside to take him off now, but if he starts next year the way he started this year he'll lose his 40-man spot pretty quick. Little glimmer of hope here in September, but he's got a long ways to go. Hopefully he's able to get his body, and mind, right during the offseason and hit the ground running come February in Fort Meyers. 2023 is a make or break year for him with the Twins. Hope he makes instead of breaks!4 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
kenbuddha and 3 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
4 pointsI don't get how anyone is surprised by this kind of comment or that he's going to go wherever he gets paid the most. This was literally always how things were going to play out unless he had a major injury. Corey Seager got 10/325 last year coming off a season with 3.7 bWAR and not having played more than 134 games in a season since 2017. Correa has 5.3 bWAR this year after having 7.2 last year and will be coming off 3 mostly healthy years. He was never going to opt in. He was never going to take any deal that was less than 10/325 before he hit the market again. So the only discussion that should be happening is whether or not the Twins should've just handed him 10/325 instead of this opt-out deal, or if they should've handed him 10/325 during the season, or if they should be offering it to him now. Any numbers below that weren't things that he would've signed. He didn't fire his old agent and hire Boras for any reason other than getting 10/325+.4 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
D.C Twins and 3 others reacted to Fire Dan Gladden for a post in a topic
4 points1/$10m is nothing in today's market for a (at worst) slightly less than average 3B. Especially when you do not have a clear backup. The Twins have bigger decisions to make than this. Sign him to a 1-2 year deal with an option and move on.4 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
wabene and 3 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
4 pointsActually, this site of late is worse than twitter. I go there now most of the time.4 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
wabene and 3 others reacted to whosafraidofluigirussolo for a post in a topic
4 pointsLee: ?? He was promoted through 3 levels of the minors and reached AA within 3 months of being drafted. He won't be ready for opening day 2023, but even in an organization that can be conservative about prospect promotions, he's going to be in the majors in much, much less time than 5 years. Basically agreed on Martin and Palacios. The Twins have been committed to playing Lewis at shortstop other than when he was in the AFL (with other SS on the roster to consider) and when they prematurely tried to shoehorn him in that super-sub role at the MLB level. They were willing to start him at SS every day when they first promoted him. I don't know that he'll stay there long term, and his knee is now a huge wild card, but if the latest surgery recovery goes anywhere near as well as the first one did, he'll get a chance to start at SS again. Certainly the timing of Correa opting out isn't good, with Lewis and Lee likely to be close but not ready at the beginning of 2023. IMO signing him could be a totally defensible decision and letting him walk could be too, depending on their evaluations of Lee and Lewis.4 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
4 pointsHonestly, I believe that we should keep him. He is exactly what a manager could have asked for. He has been durable as shown by him playing in 137 games, can play the hot corner at a very serviceable level, and he puts the ball in play. Honestly, you cannot ask for much more from a player of his caliber. Not that this is something, but that trade to MN might have taken less pressure off his shoulders to perform. We all know that as a NYY if you're on the starting roster, you're expected to perform at a superstar level all the time. Plus he was coming after of a very good 3B (A-Rod) the NY had for years. But now that he is in a smaller market team, he doesn't have that same expectations to live up to.4 points
-
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
tonderk and 3 others reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
4 pointsSign Gio and if one of the young players turns out to be the next Aaron Judge, we can deal with that "Problem" when it happens.4 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
SF Twins Fan and 3 others reacted to DJL44 for a post in a topic
4 pointsI agree with this sentiment. A 1 year $10M contract for Urshela is a no-brainer. Non-tender would be stupid. They won't find a better deal among free agents.4 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
Swing Batter-Batter and 3 others reacted to David Maro for a post in a topic
4 pointsHe is one of the few players on this team that has earned a place in 23. Just look what happened when the FO told good bye to Rosario. The team is still looking for a Left fielder. I have lost count after 10.4 points -
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
Carlos Correa Makes His Decision Clear
MauerGoat and 3 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
4 pointsThis needed to be said. And needs to keep being said, All of it, actually. Great post.4 points -
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
What To Do With Gio Urshela?
Strombomb and 2 others reacted to Cody Pirkl for an article
3 pointsThe Twins front office has some decisions to make for 2023 with time likely running out on their job security. With so many players set to return, there are some tough decisions to be made in order to shake this roster up and try to build a winner following two massively disappointing seasons. Gio Urshela is one of those many decisions. Having made $6.55 million in 2022 and being a decent supporting piece, Urshela has likely set himself up for something like a $10m payday for 2023 if they run through the arbitration process. He’s done his part in making the team want to bring him back with a bounce-back season of being over 15% above league average. His Wins Above Replacement of over 2.0 would make a $10m salary a worthwhile investment. That being said, there are several independent factors that will determine how the Twins proceed with their current starting third baseman. First Base Jose Miranda was a third baseman throughout most of his minor league career. It was only after losing Miguel Sano and Alex Kirilloff that he made the switch to playing first for most of the season. As someone who had rarely played the position in his career, he was a bit rough around the edges and established himself as a terrible fielder in the eyes of fans. That being said, his numbers at third base were predictably better. Miranda was a neutral 0 Defensive Runs Saved and Outs Above Average at the hot corner. It's possible the Twins don’t see him as a long-term third baseman, but if they have any hope at all of him holding down that position it’s easy to see them paying him the league minimum and spreading Urshela’s money around elsewhere. A lot has to do with health and other moves as well. Kirilloff in theory has the kind of bat you don’t platoon, and if he’s finally healthy in 2023, the goal is likely for him to play first every day. The Twins have also lacked some offensive thump against left-handed pitching for years. They could bring in several established options who play a legit first base such as Josh Bell or Trey Mancini to replace Urshela’s spot in the lineup while turning third base over to their star rookie. Their options are wide open. Free Agency In terms of sure-fire free agents, the best third baseman on the market this winter may be Matt Carpenter. It’s one of the worst free agent third base markets in recent history and could be an opportunity for Urshela to cash in if he’s cut loose. Instead, the Twins could play it smart and tender him a contract regardless of their plans. Teams are certain to be in need of third base help and the Twins could shop him around on the trade market to teams who are too competitive to pencil in Marwin Gonzalez as their everyday third baseman. Would Urshela bring some enormous haul back? Certainly not. Even something like a decent middle reliever or prospect facing a 40-man crunch would be a nice alternative to letting Urshela just walk away for free, however. They could still dump the $10ish million to spend elsewhere and get just a little something in return if that’s the route they choose to take. Gio Urshela is a likable player and has single-handedly made the Donaldson trade an inarguable win. That being said the Twins face a tricky offseason with the need to shake things up while having so many returning players in place. You don’t want him playing over Miranda, Polanco, or a healthy Kirilloff. It’ll be a difficult decision, but it’s just one of the many considerations this front office will have to take into account as they ponder how to restore the faith of the fanbase and ownership. How should the Twins handle Gio Urshela in 2023? Should he be the starting third baseman? Platoon/utility player? Should he perhaps be playing for another team entirely?3 points -
it's over. bye-bye carlos
it's over. bye-bye carlos
laloesch and 2 others reacted to ChineseGandalf for a post in a topic
3 pointsIt would be a terrible decision to pay Correa 30+ million per year on a 8-10 year contract. Looking around the league - how many of these long term deals for stars are actually worth it? There are so many albatrosses around the league on bloated deals. It seems like people are quickly forgetting Joe Mauer's deal (which was hardly insane by any metric). There was a great deal of moaning when Mauer got hurt and did not play up to the end of his deal, even though he certainly did earlier in his contract. How long will Correa play at a 30 mil value? He is likely playing there now, but he is in his prime. When you pay for a contract like that, the question is not really whether the player is worth it today, it is whether they are worth it halfway through the contract. He almost certainly will not be, and with Royce Lewis likely back at some point next year, I really do not see this making sense for the Twins.3 points -
it's over. bye-bye carlos
it's over. bye-bye carlos
Crackedfungo and 2 others reacted to Battle ur tail off for a post in a topic
3 pointsI have beaten on this drum for many years. Trust your minor leagues and play them instead of bringing in washups or guys that never really were that good and paying them. Sign and trade for only studs and use your minors leagues to fill out the rest of the team. Obviously there are times when you develop a stud and have to pay them too, but either way, you have high end talent surrounded by young hungry guys. I would much rather have seen some of our minor league arms this year than guys like Pagan, Archer, Joe Smith, etc. There has been a long line of this type of player on the Twins roster making that mid level salary that doesn't perform any better than what you could expect from someone within your system already.3 points