Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. ashbury

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    34,998
    Posts
  2. USAFChief

    Community Moderator
    Points
    24,700
    Posts
  3. Beast

    Verified Member
    Points
    202
    Posts
  4. tony&rodney

    Verified Member
    Points
    2,874
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 09/05/2022 in all areas

  1. First ever in person game, win Twins!
  2. 10 points
    Pagan reminds me of Homer Simpson working at the Springfield power plant. Doesn’t matter how many times he messes up, still can’t get canned
  3. Before this back and forth goes any further, I’m going to say you both have a point here. I agree that those in the FO do know more than most of us. They have more information than we do, for one, so their decisions are made from more than speculation, assumption and emotion like that of the average fans, or even above average fans, as is the case at TD. ? However, the proof is in the pudding. While I have no doubts they know more than most of us, they still haven’t shown us that in results. I didn’t think the Twins would be ‘in the hunt’ (which, technically, they still are) this season, that only shows the weakness of the division. At the start of the season, I had the team finishing in the 80-84 range. In May the team gave me reason to hope, but I’m at a ‘shrug, whatever’ point now. However, the FO, despite knowing more, has missed the mark in more than a few instances. And that, frankly, surprises and annoys me. They are paid not only to know more, but to do better. Somewhere in their realm, things are not right in their evaluation of players and their injuries and their risk. jjswol said above it’s too soon to judge the trade and I tend to agree. However, given the number of ‘mistakes’ made so far in this FO’s era, I will remain skeptical until I see results. I hope they know something and both Paddack and Mahle come back next season and prove it. But until then, they have earned my skepticism and annoyance.
  4. 7 points
    One loss down; three to go.
  5. Can't agree. The Yankees will win Cole's start.
  6. There were some who noted the injury risk at the time, much as when Paddack was acquired. No one has a crystal ball, and every athlete has the risk of injury at any time. But I think enough red flags were present for both Mahle and Paddack that it's not pure second-guessing now.
  7. Good comment about judging trades too early. I think the point many are making about Mahle is why trade for him when he had an injury issue earlier this season if one of the main reasons you acquired him is to help you make the playoffs. He might be great next year and the long term results of the trade may look better, but it does nothing for this year. And, all of this is the result of the FO's unwillingness to sign free agent pitchers of quality. They think that is too risky yet they happily trade for Paddack and Mahle, both of whom had some level of questions about their health. And, free agent pitchers don't cost prospects, only money. And that is the answer right there, money. Plus, who have they brought up through the system as successful starters--Ober, and we don't yet know how good he will be, but he has promise. Winder? Injured. Balazovic? Can't get people out at AAA. Canterino? Injured. Hajjar? Povich? Traded. Varland and SWR? Still in minors, but have promise. Ryan? Gray? Obtained in trades. Not a sparkling record methinks.
  8. I think the FO has messed up on a lot of things, but the deadline acquisitions this year are really questionable. Mahle is an example. He is a nice pitcher with good stuff, but the whole world knew he had some issues earlier this season. How many times have we seen it play out that a pitcher has a shoulder or arm issue that is reported to be minor, only to turn out a few months later to require surgery? If the main reason you acquire pitching at the deadline is to help the team make the playoffs, why risk trading for a player that has had an issue earlier in the season. Even if it does not end up requiring surgery, the chance that the injury reoccurs is pretty high. And, to give up what they did was unbelievable. But, how about Lopez. We gave up a lot for a reliever that has had a good partial season after years of failure. Doesn't it sound a little bit like a Pagan situation, one good brief run early in his career followed by 4 years of failure? What made them believe Lopez was a good long term bet? Why trade for a reliever with multi years of control, giving up excellent prospects, when he has no long term history of success? I could go on and on about Paddack, Dyson, Happ, Shoemaker, Colome, etc., but I fear this FO has a level of arrogance that makes them believe they are smarter than everyone else--smartest guys in the room syndrome. Throw in Cavaco and Sabato as number one picks and their record is pretty grim. When they do make good choices, they trade them away. God help us all.
  9. 6 points
    But think about it for a moment. Yesterday Duran entered a one run lead with the bases occupied and pitched 1.2 scoreless innings, during which the Twins scored multiple runs and put the game out of reach. Why would you ever use anyone but your best reliever to prevent a tie game or a loss during a critical late inning situation? Why risk having to mount a rally just to save your best relief option for a specific inning? Duran had a .385 WPA in that game. The next highest from a pitcher on either side was Dylan Bundy's .277 WPA. Duran was the most valuable pitcher in that game by a long shot. Isn't that where you want your best reliever when the dust settles?
  10. Well, at least he's not on the IL... yet. That's sort of a "win".
  11. I like the Mahle trade and still do because of the context of the situation. The Twins desperately needed a good starter who could go deep into games and take the pressure off the bullpen for the regular season, but also a starter they wouldn't fear putting on the mound if the team makes the playoffs. In addition, the Twins' farm system had taken a huge hit with their top prospects being traded off, performing poorly or injured. The prospects who have just recently graduated were also not setting the world on fire for various reasons. So, future value in the farm system was limited. Finally, the Twins were blessed with an unexpectedly weak division performance where the White Sox were not running away with the division as expected. There was blood in the water and the Twins were leading the division with a good opportunity to put some distance on before a tough September schedule. When a division looks tough with Cleveland's farm looking pretty outstanding and the White Sox have a payroll near $200MM so they're in it to win it, sometimes you have to take your shots. It may be worth noting that Mahle gave the Twins 2 - 6.0 six inning starts (162 pitches) where his fastball had normal velocities before the game where Mahle got pulled early so it's tough to blame the F.O. for Mahle's fatigue just based on that. Could there be an issue? Maybe. But, the fact Mahle made it to a 3rd start before the problem cropped up makes it tougher.
  12. Nice Job Bundy. Nice job Correa. Nice job Duran. And finally...I wonder if Falvine are feeling just a little snake bit. "OK. OK, Paddack ... Pagan ... Mahle ... Lopez ... Fullmer ... haven't exactly gone as envisioned. ... I know, let's add Billy Hamilton! His ONLY skill is speed! Speed can't possibly go into a slump! What could go wrong??!?"
  13. But he's able to eat up innings, and when he inevitably starts to put the game out of reach the decision not to use better arms becomes an easy one. #Value
  14. 5 points
    Someone tell me why Megill throws so many breaking balls. Somebody's computer is spitting out garbage.
  15. 5 points
    Slight title change: from "Judge Homer Beats Twins" to "Bringing in Megill to Face Judge Beats Twins." There, fixed.
  16. Benjamin Franklin said necessity never makes a good bargain. He was not talking about baseball trades but it applies. The Twins had a glaring need for a pitcher and they had to overpay. To avoid this situation don't get caught in a position where you are desperate. I know- easier said than done.
  17. Has Jorge Lopez Been a Disappointment?

    SanoMustGo and 4 others reacted to Beast for a post in a topic

    5 points
    He’s a really strange case. His numbers this year are very good, but it’s an extreme outlier from the rest of his career and he’s somehow still blown 20% of his save opportunities with a sub 2 ERA. I just don’t think he’s that good. I think he’s due to regress hard, and we’re seeing the beginning of that. Obviously the O’s felt the same. Savvy move on their part to dump him at that peak.
  18. You're whitewashing the varying levels of skepticism and annoyance with this "WS or bust," strawman...
  19. Mahle is indicative of the half-measures this FO take when the pitching staff clearly needs help to reach the next level. When The $#&! Yankees needed pitching, they went out and got Gerrit Cole. When Houston needed pitching, they pried Verlander away from Detroit. The Dodgers' arms stockpile drives me insane. So far the Twins have gone out and gotten the likes of Happ, Shoemaker, and the mending Archer. They signed Dobnak (career ERA in 125 IP, 4.94) to a long-term deal. I happen to like Bundy's bulldog approach, but he's long-in-the-tooth and not going to lead anyone deep in the playoffs. Looking at Mahle's stats with Cincy, it shouldn't be a shock that he's struggled here. This FO came in with it understood that the pitching staff needed help. Falvey came in billed as the guy who built Cleveland's pitching, which led them to the world series. I wouldn't ask that the media be too harsh in questioning them, but it's totally fair to ask what pitchers this FO sees at the front of a Twins rotation leading our excellent lineup deep into the playoffs.
  20. Sam Dyson should also be included on getting fleeced trading for an injured player. 1 time could be accidental, two is questionable, 3 times is indicative of a fundamental problem in evaluating pitchers for injuries/ injury risk.
  21. I'm convinced that advanced analytics has turned attention toward injury rates, and our Twins are somehow behind the curve relative to other teams. I can't see any other explanation for the front office's moves that rarely if ever move from a more-injured player to a less-injured alternative.
  22. It's a bad sign when the prospects you traded for a pitcher at the trade deadline are already outperforming that pitcher a month later. That being said, I'm more concerned about the Twins' medical staff than I am about "Falvine" per se. Point 1: Everyone is taking too much time to recover from injuries. That has been the case the entire year. Point 2: The whole Byron Buxton 2 games out of 3 ratio ended up with Buck hurt during the most crucial part of the schedule, leaving the team vulnerable to complete derailment, which is what we're seeing unfold in front of our eyes. It's unclear how to deploy Buxton properly, but I don't think this was the best strategy. If he's not injured, he's our best player and should be able to play more than 67% of the time. If he was dealing with nagging injuries, then he probably shouldn't have been playing 67% of the time. This solution was an overly simplistic approach to an absurdly complex puzzle. Point 3: If the Twins were in pursuit of Mahle for a long time, as has been reported, I suspect that there's a reason the Reds caved in now rather than, say, last offseason. We seem to have been fleeced by them; Mahle's arm is clearly not right, and it sure makes me wonder if this is something that could have been caught earlier. Thoughts?
  23. 4 points
    Is there anyone who can explain why pitchers are throwing the ball down the middle to Aaron Judge in that lineup? He only has about 80 walks. He had four at bats with 12 strikes thrown to him (using the MLB box), of which 4-5 were in the whooping zone with the HR exactly on a tee. Judge must be beloved across the game to see that many strikes in one game. If he is universally the guy who a team (the pitcher) cannot let beat you, this cannot happen. I'm willing to bet that Barry Bonds never saw that many strikes in a game the last 10 years of his career. I admire how disciplined Aaron Judge is with swinging through the location of pitches, but it is inexplicable to me why the Twins or any other team feels the need to assist Judge in his race towards the records that will easily fall if he continues to get so many batting practice opportunities in games. The only acceptable plate appearance (from my viewpoint) was in his first at bat. All three pitches were strikes (according to the box) with two on the edge and the one slammed for a double wholly within the box. At least each of these were down and away, which would be acceptable. The remainder of the at bats were lessons in how not to pitch, including the walk and the strikeout. On a different note, the Yankees look as weak as I can remember their teams. Of their positions players only Judge and the defensive replacement Florian looked good.
  24. The alternative was to add no starter.... they couldn't pay the price for Castillo. Montas had been hurt more recently. This site would have excoriated the FO for not adding a starter. But when they did, and the risk didn't work yet ... It was a good trade. You can make good decisions and still have bad outcomes. That's the reality of the universe.
  25. 4 points
    Tough to keep Bundy off of the list the way he’s been pitching lately. Not always pretty, but he’s been keeping some pretty good offenses in check down the stretch.
  26. 4 points
    Yesterday was a perfect example of why Duran isn't the closer. What he did in the seventh and eighth of a game that felt like it was slipping away is more valuable than coming into a clean ninth inning with a lead. I'm of the opinion that your "closer" should be your second or third best reliever and Lopez is the Twins' second best reliever. What the Twins are doing feels perfectly in line with what they should be doing in these situations.
  27. Has Jorge Lopez Been a Disappointment?

    SanoMustGo and 3 others reacted to bighat for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Here are Lopez's career stats before this year: In 2019 his ERA was 6.33 In 2020 his ERA was 6.34 In 2021 his ERA was 6.07 I guess I'm confused, did people think we traded for Peak 2002 Eric Gagne or something? Did fans think Lopez was going to be the slam-the-door-closer we've been searching for since Joe Nathan left? If so, then yeah he's a disappointment. But guys - we should have never expected him to be good in the first place. The Twins trade deadline moves weren't fixes, they were band aids. These were middle-of-the-road guys and the results are luke warm as expected.
  28. Week in Review: Crash and Burn

    D.C Twins and 3 others reacted to BH67 for a post in a topic

    4 points
    Crashing, burning, and yet back into a tie for first place. This is the most bizarre Twins season I can remember. No outcome in the stretch run will surprise me. Que sera, sera.
  29. Not everyone was a fan of the Mahle trade, more for the concern for his arm and skills than what was traded away. But, it is what it is and we hope the Twins play well in NYC.
  30. This is correct and there were also a number of suggestions of other options. While many were elated with the sequence of moves at the trade deadline as well as the offseason moves, others were not so enamored and voiced their feelings. However, it is only a visceral reaction at a moment in time and not a call for massive change. While not a fan, at all, of the crew in power I am just a fan and do not wish ill will towards our management ever. I just want to watch good baseball. Nevertheless, we trudge onwards with hope for the next series.
  31. Sad to read Minaya was released. He was pretty decent for the Twins but they did not trust him. There are so many variables to sticking in the major leagues. Pagan is assured of a job but Minaya is not worthy. This was a conversation with guys who were released and joined our mens' team in Florida about 20+ years ago. One minute a guy is pitching in AAA, getting a cup of coffee and sleeping in sweet sheets at the MLB level, and then a few weeks later they are playing with a crew of guys in Town Ball. Caleb Thielbar never needed to dip to pitching for the Dundas Dukes ( a fine tradition and squad) but he did find himself on the independent team roster for the St. Paul Saints and now he is among the top three guys in the Twins MLB bullpen. Baseball is a tough job.
  32. That’s such a huge win. How about the much maligned Dylan Bundy? The guy hasn’t allowed more than 2 earned runs in a start since the calendar turned to August. He hasn’t had a bunch of cupcakes, either. He’s faced Houston, Toronto, and Boston. Not to mention today’s goose egg in Chicago in the biggest road win of the year. He’s been a rock in this rotation lately when most everyone else is falling apart. Very impressed by his resilience this year. We were counting the days until was DFA’d a couple months ago. Jake Cave is doing more for this team in big spots than anyone (except maybe Gordon and Miranda). Another great play off the wall to turn a double into a single. Of course, the triple was huge. Good for those two guys. Good stories. You throw Gordon in there too. A rag tag group showing the stars how to grab a handful and get it done in clutch spots.
  33. Adley Rutschman (3.8 WAR) and Steven Kwan (4.0 WAR) are both having great rookie years. Miranda has been very good, but those two plus Rodriguez have been better and play much better defense.
  34. 4 points
    Dylan Bundy is now routinely providing five reliable innings per start and keeping the Twins in each game he pitches. Deserved congrats aplenty, Dylan.
  35. Just because someone gets paid for doing something doesn't mean they are good at it or know what they are doing.
  36. I love being surrounded by so many folks that know so much more than the folks getting paid to know stuff.
  37. They could have been in on the FA market. I’m actually okay with the trades they made for starters despite the results. But I am not as forgiving that attention was given to the BP. If they are going to rely on their BP as they have, then we need a BP filled with closer types
  38. 3 points
    Yeah I blame Megill. Freaking rolling hanger on a tee.
  39. 3 points
    Makes no sense to not intentionally walk Judge every time this series. Give him the Bonds treatment and let someone else beat them.
  40. You forget he would have been an All Star closer if not for all the bad outings he's had.
  41. How did the Twins blow this one so badly?? Have They? Was Steer or Encarnacion-Strand going to help us in the playoffs this year? Are Steer or Encarnacion-Strand guaranteed to be major league producers beyond this years? Is Mahle guaranteed to never pitch a decent major league inning forever more?
  42. 3 points
    I am not a fan of any of them but Celestino. Thielbar is average at best but can’t be trusted in high leverage situations. Urshela is also an easy out against the Verlanders of the world. I would not mind him as a utility guy, but not an every day starter. Nick Gordon deserves mention because he plays with fire. He hustles and has an igniter kind of quality to him. Too many hitters are trying to hit home runs at the expense of the little things needed to win. Gordon does the little things. I also think Bundy deserves to be mentioned. He is not an ace but he is solid enough to win some big games and gives us a chance to win each time he takes the mound.
  43. Has Jorge Lopez Been a Disappointment?

    Minny505 and 2 others reacted to raindog for a post in a topic

    3 points
    People talking about his career numbers prior to this year are ignoring the fact that this is his first year in the bullpen. He has the stuff to break dominant out of the pen and was for the majority of this year. Hopefully he can get back on track with us.
  44. Has Jorge Lopez Been a Disappointment?

    RJA and 2 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Yes I am disappointed and I questioned the trade at the time. His blown saves have been more than a bad outing. Like Pagan he has looked terrible in his meltdowns - like Chicago. I am disappointed because the FO sold him as a savior and Rocco has him penciled in as the closer, although the last game in the series the radio guys thought he was coming in and then were surprised when Rocco had second thoughts and brought in Thielbar.
  45. Okay, maybe there's fault to find here. The problem has been injuries for all of the guys named. Medical staff might be on the hook for okaying guys with arm issues and the brain trust could be catch flack for gambling on the health of guys with injuries. Beyond that guys like Fulmer and Lopez haven't been as effective after being acquired. Falvey and Levine could be faulted for acquiring these guys during breakthrough seasons and then have them regress to the mean. Lopez and Mahle will be back next year and could recoup the value received. I won't dispute that the trades haven't panned out as of yet, but I think the jury is still out.
  46. In spite of all the this team's shortcomings (some real, some perceived) today's win moves us into first place. Well, a tie for first place. Well, a tie for first place in the AL Central. In other words, we're no more mediocre than anyone else in our division.
  47. A few observations after a much needed W today: Correa: Nice to see our $35m player come through clutch today! Only his 4th 2-hit and 2RBI (should've been 3 RBI) game since July 1st. Hamilton: Yes, I realize his impersonation of Lonnie "skates" Smith proved to be a moot point after Miranda's double scored him, but how many Twins fans were thinking the following after that play: "Correa finally gets a KEY hit late in the game and Hamilton spins out rounding 3rd base---Now we're going to waste this scoring opportunity leaving runners stranded and out bullpen will find someway to blow this game?" Miranda: If not for Julio Rodriguez, is there a more deserving candidate (other than Duran) to win ROY? and finally... Dylan Bundy: Count me in the VERY SKEPTICAL department when Bundy was signed just before the lockout. He has exceeded my expecations not only by his OVERALL performance, but by staying healthy being a consistent member of the starting rotation. By no means do I think management should pick up his $11m option for 2023, but I would support a 2 yr/ 16m offer. Would be interested to hear others opinion on this. Looking forward to 2023 who are LOCKS for this rotation? I would venture 3 fall in that category: Ryan, Gray and Mahle (assuming his shoulder is healthy by ST). That leaves 2 open slots. I would argue that very few teams would be willing to offer Bundy a 2yr/$16m deal. I know there are more "sexy" candidates" for those 2 other rotation slots-----but all of them----Maeda, Paddack, Ober and Winder----come with serious health concerns. Wish I could say I was looking forward to the next 4 games before we face CLE next weekend. I'd be lying if I made that claim..
  48. I wasn't a big fan of the FO coming into the season so I'm ready to move on. I don't think they've done much to improve the Twins and, worse, have made baseball boring. Watching Gordon pitch tonight (to save the pitching staff?) was pathetic. I'll wait for the season to end but, right now, I don't see how we can keep supporting this crud.
  49. Yeah. This FO is just flat out bad. No way around it at this point. Enough excuses for these guys. Calling it hubris, etc. gives them too much credit. That insinuates some sort of competency. I’ve seen none. They won the lottery in 2019 with a bunch of prospects drafted and developed by someone else, and had Nelson Cruz fall in their lap because nobody wanted a 40 year old….in a year the ball happened to be superjuiced. They took that and ran it into the ground in the playoffs. Take that year off their record, and they’ve been absolutely abysmal at running the franchise. But, hey, at least they created a bunch of cool Excel spreadsheets.
  50. Ash, I'm wondering if their analytics reveal the same things in terms of injury rates, and what we're seeing is a strategy. Do you think it's possible that Falvey/Levine are also looking at some recovery rate data and making bets in an effort to gain advantage because of discount values associated with injured athletes? In any event, my concern has to do with whether or not we're witnessing a level of hubris related to a belief in their own capacity to rehab guys and capture that discount. Lots of examples we can ponder. And clearly, early as it is, the Mahle trade is at best worrisome.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.