Before this back and forth goes any further, I’m going to say you both have a point here. I agree that those in the FO do know more than most of us. They have more information than we do, for one, so their decisions are made from more than speculation, assumption and emotion like that of the average fans, or even above average fans, as is the case at TD. ? However, the proof is in the pudding. While I have no doubts they know more than most of us, they still haven’t shown us that in results. I didn’t think the Twins would be ‘in the hunt’ (which, technically, they still are) this season, that only shows the weakness of the division. At the start of the season, I had the team finishing in the 80-84 range. In May the team gave me reason to hope, but I’m at a ‘shrug, whatever’ point now. However, the FO, despite knowing more, has missed the mark in more than a few instances. And that, frankly, surprises and annoys me. They are paid not only to know more, but to do better. Somewhere in their realm, things are not right in their evaluation of players and their injuries and their risk. jjswol said above it’s too soon to judge the trade and I tend to agree. However, given the number of ‘mistakes’ made so far in this FO’s era, I will remain skeptical until I see results. I hope they know something and both Paddack and Mahle come back next season and prove it. But until then, they have earned my skepticism and annoyance.