Leaderboard
-
chpettit19
Community LeaderPoints3,028Posts -
-
Mike Sixel
Old-Timey MemberPoints36,790Posts -
nicksaviking
Community ModeratorPoints18,707Posts
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/21/2021 in all areas
-
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
RonCoomersOPS and 13 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
14 pointsOber didn't pitch last year and never topped 78.2 innings in his professional career because of injuries. His max was 106 back in 2014 when he was a freshman in college. He's a terrible example for your point. Jose Berrios was second in the AL in innings pitched this year. He didn't get there by pitching 14 innings a game for the Jays. When pitchers are throwing well Rocco lets them go.14 points -
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
Mike Sixel and 6 others reacted to adorduan for a post in a topic
7 pointsoff topic, but the sooner Sinclair dies, the better.7 points -
Twins Fans Living Vicariously Through Rosario
Twins Fans Living Vicariously Through Rosario
tarheeltwinsfan and 5 others reacted to Ted Schwerzler for an article
6 pointsAt the end of the 2020 season, Rosario posted just a 1.0 fWAR which was worth $7.7 million. He was projected to land somewhere in the $10 million range through arbitration and fell short of that number again in 2021, putting up a 0.9 fWAR and $7.3 million valuation. The Twins saw that Rosario hadn’t been worth $10 million over a single season since 2018, and it was more than evident the type of player he was. No team disagreed with Minnesota’s assessment as the talented Puerto Rican went unclaimed on waivers. He ended up in Cleveland and bottomed out. The .685 OPS across 78 games was a career-low, and despite being at peak age, Rosario was finding new ways to fall short. He was sent to Atlanta for peanuts, or better yet a Panda, and somehow came alive. He attributes the resurgence to the warming temperature, and maybe he’s right. It’s certainly easier to perform outside of the frigid north, and Rosario’s .903 OPS in his final 33 games was the performance at its best. Now he’s on center stage and has given braves fans the full experience. In Game 3 of the National League Division Series, the Braves leadoff man found himself doubled off second base on a gaffe Minnesota fans had become too acquainted with. That came after the outfielder misplay against the Milwaukee Brewers on a ball hit by former Twins teammate Eduardo Escobar. That’s just half of the Eddie Rosario experience, though. The flip side of this coin is that Atlanta is using the former Twins lefty as a leadoff man and anchor in the middle of their lineup. He’s responded with a 1.690 OPS in the NLCS, complete with two homers, a triple, and coming up just shy of a postseason cycle. Across both rounds of the Postseason this year, Rosario is batting .467 (14-30). In six previous postseason games for the Twins, Rosario had just five hits and a .217 average (5-23). There are two different stories at play here, and they’re both fascinating to watch. The first is that the highs and lows of The Eddie Rosario Experience are a complete thrill ride. The man is on his way to winning the NLCS MVP, and something like that only highlights the latter point. Winning in the postseason is about getting hot at the right time. That can be a team thing or an individual completely carrying the load. It’s hard to spend and guarantee success (just ask the Dodgers in this series or the Yankees over the last decade). Money stacks the deck in your favor, but when you deal a Panda for an Eddie, and everything breaks right, you sit back and crack some peanuts while enjoying the show. Minnesota may be riding an 0-18 streak, but this is a thrill ride all of Twins Territory can enjoy. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook, or email6 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
TopGunn#22 and 5 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
6 pointsLast night (Wednesday) Framber Valdez went 8 innings in a playoff game. 8!!!! Why? Ask Dusty Baker, "If a guys dealing you let him keep dealing. Today it was in the hands of Framber Valdez." We have seen that Dusty can win and use bullpen games and pitchers, but he also knows the value of letting a pitcher pitch. Please put this statement on you office wall - starters are supposed to go more than 4 innings.6 points -
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
Richie the Rally Goat and 5 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
6 pointsAnother Rosario thread?6 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
6 pointsYou watched Ober wanting to go longer? Based on what? Ober's situation was explained over and over and over again on this site, and Ober himself said he was fine with how he was handled this past season. This isn't a Rocco decision alone, this is an organizational philosophy, and it is not unique to the Twins.6 points
-
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
DocBauer and 5 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
6 pointsFeels like the definition of small sample size here. Innings by Astros starter during playoff games 2021: 6.2, 4.1 (Valdez himself!), 2.2 (not a bullpen game, Luis Garcia was the starter and had made 28 starts this year), 4, 2.2 (Valdez again!), 1 (again, not a bullpen game, Luis Garcia was just really bad again they then turned to Odo who only got them through the 5th), 1.2 (not a bullpen game, Urquidy just sucked), 1.1 (still not a bullpen game, Grienke just walked everyone), finally we get to Valdez going 8. That's an average of 3.1 innings per start. All of which were started by legit starters. Without that 8 inning start they've averaged less than 3 innings a start from their starters this postseason.6 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Major League Ready and 5 others reacted to cHawk for a post in a topic
6 pointsThe Twins haven’t had SP Performances where they can really go more than 4-5 innings this year6 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Unwinder and 5 others reacted to chinmusic for a post in a topic
6 pointsMr Rosario has always had a flair for the dramatic. Remember, homering on FIRST PITCH of 1st AB, back in 2015? He's entertaining, fun to watch, and seems like a good guy. I choose to enjoy him.6 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
big dog and 4 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
5 pointsAs a baseball fan and a guy who appreciates the history of the game, Dusty Baker is pretty much the ONLY thing I like about this post season. But he's the kind of guy I like from a distance and on somebody else's favorite team. I absolutely do not want the Twins to go back to the old school type of manager. Rocco might not be the right guy, but I don't want a throwback.5 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
DocBauer and 4 others reacted to Andrew Mahlke for a post in a topic
5 pointsTo be able to have guys go 7-8 innings, you first need pitchers who are able to go this long and still be effective. To solve the problem of Rocco pulling guys soon we need to get arms who are able to go 3 times through the order while still being effective5 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Jerr and 4 others reacted to Hosken Bombo Disco for a post in a topic
5 pointsCame up in the 9th, with a chance to hit for the cycle, and, ... didn’t?5 points -
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
Minny505 and 3 others reacted to Andrew Mahlke for a blog entry
4 pointsBack in March, Matthew Trueblood wrote an excellent article on Twins Daily about what a potential Byron Buxton extension would look like. Now, obviously this was before Buxton’s phenomenal (injury plagued, but still phenomenal) 2021 campaign. After the season Buxton had, his value for a future extension skyrocketed. With Byron Buxton up until about 2019, the main question was always: “Will he be able to hit major league pitching?”. He always played phenomenal defense, ran the bases ridiculously well, and had an incredibly strong arm. He just had to put it together at the plate. Well, since the start of 2019, Buxton is 20th in the MLB in OPS and 4th in the MLB in slugging percentage. Buxton has really put it together at the plate in the last 3 seasons and it has been a joy to watch. Before we get into his contract specifics, let’s highlight how special Byron Buxton is. 5-Tool Player Byron Buxton helps the Twins win games, plain and simple. Since the beginning of 2019, the Twins are 104-68 when Buxton plays, and 106-106 when he does not. This means that they play at roughly a 98 win pace when he is on the field and an 81 win pace when he is not. This is the difference between not making the playoffs at all and getting home-field advantage in the playoffs. Let’s take a dive into what makes Buxton such a difference-maker for the Twins. Hitting I mentioned earlier how Buxton has really found his stride with his swing. Back in May of 2019, towards the beginning of Buxton’s outbreak, Parker Hageman wrote a phenomenal article about Byron Buxton’s swing. He took a deep dive into the swing adjustments Buxton had made that year that led to his success. Ever since then, his career has taken off. Buxton has been riddled with injuries his entire career, that is no secret. But since 2019, out of all players with a maximum of 700 plate appearances, Buxton leads with 102 extra base hits. The next closest player is Buxton’s teammate, Mitch Garver with 79 extra base hits. With limited appearances, Buxton is thriving. Using Baseball Savant’s handy Affinity feature, you can see which players have the most similar batted ball profiles to each other. In 2021, the most similar batters to Buxton were Yordan Alvarez, Fernando Tatis Jr., Rafael Devers, Salvador Perez, Josh Donaldson, and Aaron Judge. Buxton is up there with the cream of the crop. If you follow baseball at all, you know all of these guys are absolute stars and Buxton’s name belongs in that conversation as well. 2021 was his best year yet. He had a 169 wRC+, had 42 extra base hits (19 home runs), and a 1.005 OPS. Buxton proved in 2021 that he couldn’t just hit, but absolutely MASH major league pitching. Defense Buxton has always been elite defensively, winning a platinum glove as the AL’s best defensive player in 2017. Since 2016, Buxton has 58 outs above average (OAA), the 5th most among all center fielders. All of the players ahead of him (Lorenzo Cain, Kevin Kiermaier, Billy Hamilton, and Ender Inciarte) played at least 140 more games than Buxton in that span. If Buxton had played 140 more games, he would have the most OAA by 10 outs. It is safe to say that when Buxton is healthy he is the best defensive CF in baseball. He also has an absolute cannon in the outfield. His arm strength has been measured at 99 MPH before, so he definitely has an above average arm. Speed Buxton has always been one of the fastest players in the MLB. In 2021, Buxton was in the 99th percentile in sprint speed. His average sprint speed was 30 ft/sec and he had the fastest average home to first time at 4.00 sec. Buxton is a game-changer on the bases and has made a huge impact on many games on the basepaths, most notably walking off the Detroit Tigers on a seemingly routine ground ball to the shortstop. Overall Value Since 2019, Buxton has been worth 8.1 fWAR in 187 games, or a pace of 7 fWAR per 162 games. To put that number into perspective, there were zero position players with a WAR of 7 or over in 2021. In the last full season, 2019, the only players with a WAR 7 or above were Mike Trout, Alex Bregman, Christian Yelich, Cody Bellinger, Marcus Semien, and Anthony Rendon. Buxton’s WAR in 2021 was 4.2 over 61 games. Extrapolated to 162 games, that would be the equivalent of 11.2. That is absolutely ridiculous. That would be tied for the 17th best single season of all time in terms of WAR. Injuries Just looking at his raw per 162 numbers, you would think that the Twins should sign Buxton to a 10 year, $500 million extension. Unfortunately, Buxton has been injury prone throughout his career. As of July 2021, Buxton had only played 181 of 484 possible games since 2018. It is hard to justify giving him a big extension if he isn’t going to be healthy for a majority of it. Extension structure In short, I would offer Buxton an extension over seven years. It will start in 2023 and go through 2029, his age 29 through 35 season. As Buxton ages, his defense and speed will most likely deteriorate and he will not be as valuable. You also have to factor in his injury history so you won’t be paying full price. Consider the following: Since 2019, Buxton has played 187 of a possible 384 games, or 48% of possible games. Since 2019, Buxton has accumulated 8.1 WAR in 187 games, or 7 WAR/162 games According to Fangraphs, you should pay $8M/WAR. So, If Buxton were to play 162 games, he would be worth 7 WAR x $8M/WAR = $56M/year This is obviously egregious, especially considering the Twins usually have a payroll from 125-140M. According to spotrac, with the exception of the Dodgers, the top payrolls are right around $200M. We are going to assume those teams are able to use the $8M/WAR calculation Since the Twins will use maximum 140M of payroll, 70% of what the top payrolls use, we will also use 0.7 as our multiplier for the WAR value calculation. $8M/WAR x 0.7 = $5.6M/WAR Using our new 5.6M/WAR, he would be worth roughly $39M a year if he played 162. I think this is fair for a player of his caliber. He has been an MVP level player the last 3 seasons, and shows no signs of stopping. Besides injuries. Since Buxton has only played about 48% of possible games, I would pay him 48% of that $39M per year. 39M x 0.48 = about $19M a year. This is the base salary I would give Buxton. His base contract should be 7 years, $133 million However, we should account for the fact that there is a chance he remains healthy. This is where it gets tricky. This is where I bring in incentives to the contract. Buxton’s 7 WAR per 162 is worth 0.043 WAR per game. The current contract is assuming he plays 80 games If Buxton plays 120 games, he will get the original 19 million plus an additional amount of money We will determine this amount of money by multiplying his WAR per game by the additional 40 games he will be playing 40 games x 0.043 WAR per game = 1.7 WAR x $5.6M per WAR = $9.5M If Buxton plays 120 games, he should earn an additional 10 million. For 130 games, he will be worth an additional 2.4 million using that formula For 140 games, he will be worth another 2.4 million And for 150, he will be worth 2.4 million more. Contract Summary Base contract: 7 years, $133 million ($19M AAV) 120 games incentive: $9.5M/yr ($28.5M AAV) 130 games incentive: $2.4M/yr ($30.9M AAV) 140 games incentive: $2.4M/yr ($33.3M AAV) 150 games incentive: $2.4M/yr ($35.7M AAV) If Buxton plays 150 games, he could be making up to $35.7 million per year. This is the contract I would propose to Buxton because he would be getting a good amount of guaranteed money and it also helps him understand that playing a certain amount of games could get him an absurd amount of money. How does this contract compare? A salary of 19M per year (if he meets no incentives) would make him the 27th highest paid position player in baseball. Since 2019, he is 33rd in WAR among all position players, so this base contract would be just about right. If he meets all of the incentives, he would be the highest paid position player in baseball, which is fair considering the amount of talent he has and his production over a full healthy season would be at an MVP level. I think at his peak, he will play about 120-130 games, making his salary between 28 and 31 million. This would put him in the range of the 5th to 8th highest position player in the league. TL: DR version Pay Buxton a base salary of $19 million a year for 7 years, with games played incentives from 120 games to 150 games of various amounts that could net him up to $35.7 million per year. Conclusion Byron Buxton is a generational type of talent and I haven’t seen anyone like him in a Twins uniform my whole life. It would be a mistake to let him go just because of financial concerns. He is a player that you would rather overpay than not pay at all, so priority number ONE this offseason needs to be extending him. If there’s one player to offer this type of contract to, it’s Buck. Thank you for reading, and Go Twins.4 points -
The Twins Would Be Wise to Avoid Signing Zack Greinke
The Twins Would Be Wise to Avoid Signing Zack Greinke
DocBauer and 3 others reacted to Lucas Seehafer PT for an article
4 pointsZack Greinke — a six-time All-Star and the 2009 AL Cy Young recipient — will be among the marquee names in free agency following the conclusion of the World Series, along with the likes of Justin Verlander, Clayton Kershaw, and Max Scherzer. However, there’s a catch: the soon-to-be 38-year-old is coming off arguably the worst season of his illustrious 18-year career. Greinke has a deep repertoire of pitches, though he primarily relies on a four-pitch mix consisting of a four-seam fastball, curveball, slider, and changeup. Statistically speaking, the changeup — his second-most utilized in each of the past four seasons — is his best offering as opposing hitters have mustered a batting average above .200 against it only once since 2018 (.205 this past summer). His changeup sits in the mid-80s and features devastating tailing action against left-handed batters with an average spin rate of 1,594 RPM. Opponents have consistently whiffed at approximately 30% of Greinke’s changeups over the years. On the opposite end of the spectrum sits his four-seam fastball. Over the past two seasons — in which he has struck out 187 batters in 238 innings to go along with an ERA over 4.00 — Greinke’s fastball has been lit up by opposing batters to the tune of a .280 batting average, a slugging percentage north of .500, and 17 home runs. This past season, Greinke’s “fast” ball sat 89 mph with an average location of middle-middle. Additionally, the effectiveness of his curveball and slider has dropped off significantly over the past two seasons, which, when combined with his lackluster fastball, ultimately led Greinke to post a scanty 17.2% strikeout rate in 2021, his worst since 2005 (13.8%). Greinke’s strikeout rate was only one of the lackluster stats the former ace put up this past summer: a 98 ERA- (worst since 2016); 3.33 K%-BB% (worst since 2016); 4.16 ERA (worst since (2016); 171 innings pitched (worst since 2016); 4.71 FIP (worst since 2006); 17.4% home run per fly ball ratio (worst of his career). In short, Greinke’s performance over the last two seasons reinforces the notion that he is no longer ZACK GREINKE and is now more akin to a third or even fourth starter. (His numbers aren’t all that dissimilar to that of Michael Pineda.) The Minnesota Twins have only two starting rotation spots — Bailey Ober and Joe Ryan — locked in for the 2022 season and will undoubtedly be active in the starting pitcher market, both in free agency and via trades. However, signing Greinke, even on a one-year deal, makes little sense. His age and recent performance suggest that a continued downward trend should be expected next summer, and he’ll likely command more money than a pitcher of equal or greater talent, such as Pineda. The Twins would be wise to look elsewhere in search of a top of the rotation starter. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook, or email — Read more from Lucas here4 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
cHawk and 3 others reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
4 pointsRocco Baldelli's pitcher usage is absolutely in line with the rest of baseball.4 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
TopGunn#22 and 3 others reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
4 pointsJust out of curiosity...why is it Rocco that "needs to hear this", anyway? If you really think twins pitchers need to be left out longer, then you better direct this critique at Wes Johnson, Derek Falvey, and Thad Levine too. pretty sure they're all on the same page right now in terms of pitcher usage. (and they're hardly Captain Hook on starters in comparison to the rest of MLB) Also, I never want Dusty Baker near my pitchers. Cubs fans would agree (old school Dusty let Kerry Wood chuck 120+ pitches 12 times in 2003. Mark Prior threw over 120 pitches in 5 out of 6 starts in Sept that year. neither pitcher was ever the same after 2003, Prior was out of the league in 2007 and after 3 injury filled seasons, Wood had to move to the bullpen to keep his arm from falling off).4 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
PatG and 3 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
4 pointsWho should he have replaced in the last three years? Not Donaldson. Not Polanco. Not C or 1B or CF or probably any OF position. Certainly not SS. Not Cruz at DH. That said, on another team w/o those players (or the guys coming up) he likely has a defensive position. He's not nearly so bad defensively as some think. But he didn't hit as well this year as the previous two....so some think he's a better hitter than he is. Like I said upthread....he's a 2-2.5 WAR player, which is a good player.4 points -
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
darwin22 and 3 others reacted to Sousy for a post in a topic
4 pointsIt seems that signing a full-time DH is (and should be) on the bottom of the priority list. Next year they'll be in a position (assuming no trades / moves) there are several players that could rotate in and out of the DH slot; and having that spot for players to rotate in and out of in order to allow for a bit of rest without being out of the line up was a pretty good feature in the last half of the year. * Donaldson struggled with being an 'everyday in the field' guy with leg issues; being able to rotate to DH was huge. Being able to rotate Miranda into 3B would be helpful. * Sano is a guy that has struggled with particular scenarios, and it seems that Kirilloff is waiting in the wings to take up some time at 1B, if not become a full time 1B / OF player. * Arraez was in a few spots where having his bat was great, but having his knees in the field full time wasn't. Short story: I like Cruz, would love to see him come back in some role if the desire is there, but it's certainly not something the front office should (or would) put a lot of time / money / priority into.4 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
cHawk and 3 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
4 points1000x this4 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Nine of twelve and 3 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
4 pointsYeah, if only everyone was more like Dusty Baker with his immaculate postseason record. Step aside Cora, Hinch, and Roberts, Dusty Baker's on the job.4 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
USAFChief and 3 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
4 pointsWill be interesting to see what kind of contract Eddie Rosario gets this winter. Could it be reminiscent of Daniel Murphy circa 2015? In terms of overall production by OPS+ and bWAR (plus left-handedness), Rosario today is a pretty close comp to Murphy through the 2015 season. Then Murphy had a great NLDS, an even better NLCS (was MVP), before coming back to earth in the WS. Murphy went from getting $8 mil in his final arb season before that postseason, to getting a 3/37.5 mil FA deal immediately after it.4 points -
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
bighat and 3 others reacted to Harrison Greeley III for a post in a topic
4 pointsCruz needs to do the right thing. He needs to sign with the White Sox and be a shadow of himself like a good Twins hall of famer.4 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
h2oface and 3 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
4 pointsI think Rosario could have walked to the dugout after touching 2nd on his home run trot — he’d be called out at that point, but credited with a double.4 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
wabene and 3 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
4 pointsI don't think the Twins have anyone in the minors who projects to be an asset at SS. In addition to the questions about Lewis' defense, he's shown no ability to hit at a level that should get anyone excited. And there's no reason to think he'll be ready in 2022. They need to go outside the organization to fill this position.4 points -
Deja Vu - Buxton Extension and Mauer Extension
Deja Vu - Buxton Extension and Mauer Extension
tarheeltwinsfan and 3 others reacted to raindog for a post in a topic
4 pointsWell the Mauer extension was a net positive, so yes, I feel fine about extending Buxton too.4 points -
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
wavedog and 2 others reacted to Cody Christie for an article
3 pointsLast December, the Twins had a tough decision to make about offering a contract to Eddie Rosario. He was heading to his final year of arbitration eligibility, and he was expected to cost around $12 million in arbitration. To put that in perspective, Rosario was coming off a season where FanGraphs had him pegged at providing $7.7 million worth of value to the Twins. The front office used the money not spent on Rosario to sign 40% of the team's starting rotation. Minnesota also had other options for filling corner outfield spots. Alex Kirilloff and Trevor Larnach were both expected to make their regular season debuts in 2021, and they were scheduled to cost significantly less than Rosario. Each had the potential to provide equal or more value than Rosario during the 2021 season, so this made it easier to make their Rosario decision. He was designated for assignment and no other teams put a claim on him. Rosario eventually signed with Cleveland at the end of January for $8 million. He played in 78 games and hit .254/.296/.389 (.686) with 23 extra-base hits. Among AL outfielders with 300 plate appearances, he ranked in the bottom eight in wRC and wOBA. His 86 OPS+ was five points fewer than his previous career low. At the trade deadline, Rosario was traded to Atlanta for Pablo Sandoval, who Cleveland immediately cut. The Braves added multiple outfielders at the deadline to try and make up for the loss of Ronald Acuna Jr. Rosario found his swing again with the Braves as the club was fighting for a playoff spot. In 33 games, he hit .271/.330/.573 (.903), which raised his OPS+ by 45 points compared to his time in Cleveland. He hit seven home runs in fewer than 100 at-bats which were as many home runs as he had in over 280 at-bats before the trade. During the NLDS, Rosario went 4-for-13 with two RBI and a walk as the Braves surprised the Brewers. In the NLCS, his bat has continued to stay hot. Through the first four games of the series, he went 10-for-12 with two home runs, one triple, and six RBI. Rosario has clearly impacted Atlanta’s success so far this October. Fans may be excited by Rosario contributing to a team having postseason success, but the front office still made the right decision when it came to tendering him a contract. He was still a well below-average player for a majority of the season in Cleveland. As Twins fans recall, Rosario is a very streaky hitter, and he happens to be in the midst of one of his hot streaks at the season’s most impactful time of the year. Rosario will hit the free-agent market again this winter, and his market will largely remain unchanged. He makes poor baserunning mistakes and plays below-average defense. His offense also doesn’t make up for his other deficiencies. Rosario can undoubtedly be exciting, but Minnesota made the right decision in the short and long term. What are your thoughts on Rosario’s playoff performance so far? Leave a COMMENT and start the discussion. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email3 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
chpettit19 and 2 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
3 pointsPeople here complain about the Twins all the time....without looking at what EVERYONE ELSE in MLB is doing....players, managers, et. al. Over and over.3 points -
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
TwinsDr2021 and 2 others reacted to prouster for a post in a topic
3 pointsMan, I'd hate to be in a relationship with some folks here, given how frequently the past gets brought up.3 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
TheLeviathan and 2 others reacted to stringer bell for a post in a topic
3 pointsAccording to BBRef, Arraez profiles pretty close to average as a defender. He has positive numbers in both Total Zone Fielding Runs Above Average and BIS Total Runs Saved Above Average at second base in both 2020 and 2021. He was one run below average in Total Zone Fielding at third in 2021 and zero runs in left field. The BIS numbers are better--three runs saved in left and five at third. Overall Arraez' defensive numbers look decent except for his rookie year. I'll edit to add that Arraez is far from a complete player. He lacks power and speed and has been injured a fair amount, but in the batter's box, he sees a lot of pitches, makes contact at a high rate and gets on base more than any other Twin.3 points -
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
Revisiting the Eddie Rosario Decision
Major League Ready and 2 others reacted to jmlease1 for a post in a topic
3 pointsWell, obviously the Twins were also hoping for a bounceback from Jake Cave to fill in some of those LH ABs in the OF to prevent Kirilloff or Larnach from having to carry the burden before they were ready. Unfortunately, Cave struggled, got seriously injured, and never bounced back. Considering how effective he'd been pre-pandemic, it wasn't a crazy bet, but it was one that didn't work out. I think the Twins would have been happy to keep Eddie Rosario from another season, just not for $9M+, and once that decision happened Eddie was gone because pride gets in the way. He'd take less money (he had no choice) but wasn't going to take less from the Twins. Kirilloff was more effective in fewer games even with the injury and cost the league minimum, so it's hard to say the twins made a mistake: they didn't, no matter how fun Eddie Rosario is. He's having one of his patented hot streaks with Atlanta right now, which is great for them, but no team is going to bet on eddie staying hot like that for a full season. He's a good player and a useful one. but he's not a guy to commit to for 3+ years and for significant money. he's had two seasons with a bWAR over 2, and one was his rookie season. (to be fair he probably would have met that in 2020 if there had been enough games). He's likely to be worth 1-2 bWAR next year, containing a fantastic hot stretch and a couple of brutal cold ones at the plate, while adding very little else on the field (the baserunning is poor, the fielding is poor, and that stuff matters). He's unlikely to get a multi-year contract. he is who he is. He's made over $20M in MLB and been a starter for basically 6 seasons. Good for him. But it's a poor financial and baseball decision to pay him more than $5-6M at this point and he was never going to agree to stay with the twins at that number.3 points -
Twins Fans Living Vicariously Through Rosario
Twins Fans Living Vicariously Through Rosario
cHawk and 2 others reacted to chpettit19 for a post in a topic
3 pointsTwins season was doomed in the first half, can't argue that. So your argument would have to be that Rosario's bat would've helped right the ship early in the season in order to suggest it was an error not bringing him back. In the first half when Eddie was with Cleveland he had an 86 wRC+. The Indians paid to get rid of him. They traded him and cash to Atlanta for Sandoval who they cut immediately. He was so bad they literally paid money to get rid of him. But you think he was the guy that was going to save the season? For reference Larnach had an 89 wRC+ on the season. Refsnyder was 86. Kirilloff was 93, Kepler 95, Garlick 99. Eddie catching fire to end the season and during this series is the definition of small sample size. Rosario wouldn't have made any difference to the results of the Twins season.3 points -
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
adorduan and 2 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
3 pointsI hope not. Sano. Rooker. Donaldson. Arraez. Larnach. Garver. They have enough guys that can DH (and play other spots). A DH only type is worth it for a team that is on the cusp of being great....maybe. But not on this roster. No way.3 points -
Twins Fans Living Vicariously Through Rosario
Twins Fans Living Vicariously Through Rosario
PopRiveter and 2 others reacted to RpR for a post in a topic
3 pointsAt this point we have no outfielder that has an arm like him or a bat like his; unless .200 hitters whose fielding skills are lessor than Rosario's are the new norm for the Twins, we made an error not bringing him back.3 points -
Hey Rocco - did you hear this?
3 pointsIt’s the pitchers. Most of them simply weren’t good pitchers (for the Twins).3 points
-
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Crackedfungo and 2 others reacted to dxpavelka for a post in a topic
3 pointsSo Eddie's WAR 1.1 Now look at Kirillog, Larnach, Garlick, Refsnyder, Celestino & Cave. Could very easily have kept their leading run producer from each of the three prior seasons. I even remember a time when management would have been ridiculed for allowing that kind of production to leave rather than pony up for $8-$10 million. Could have kept Eddie. Brought up Kiriloff whenever they thought was best to game the system and divided OF starts between, Eddie, Buck, Kep and Kiriloff with someone getting a start at DH every week to 10 days. Second most plate appearances by an OF in 2021 was Larnach at 301. Would have been plenty of ABs to go around. When those injuries come you throw Larnach into the mix and never have to lay eyes on a guy like Cave again. You don't get better when your good players are playing for other teams. And I haven't even mentioned the one thing Eddie has always brought to the party that can't be measured -- HEART. Which, let's be honest, outside of half a season from Polanco, NOBODY on this team had this year.3 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Mike Vendsel and 2 others reacted to roger for a post in a topic
3 pointsWhat we are seeing in Atlanta, or Los Angeles, is what Eddie has always been able to bring to the game. That was several streaks a year when he was on fire, could lift the entire team and carry it for X games. Was common to happen several times a year and something sorely missed by the Twins in 2021. We are now seeing one of those streaks....Eddie, Eddie, Eddie!3 points -
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
Will the Twins Consider a Nelson Cruz Reunion?
darwin22 and 2 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
3 pointsJust like Greinke - time to move on. Age is not negotiable and we have enough bats to fill the DH/1B/corner OF slots. He was great to have on our team, but like Thome he has only so much gas left in the tank at this stage and if you remember he left us mid season for a contender just like Cruz and then the next year he was on three different teams and called it quits. Time for the old song - Thanks for the memories -3 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Danchat and 2 others reacted to mickeymental for a post in a topic
3 pointsgood thing danny santana isn’t still with the braves or it’d be 20-2.3 points -
Eddie Rosario
3 pointsBoy I sure am glad the Twins don't have Eddie Rosario anymore. ?3 points
-
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
dex8425 and 2 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
3 pointsStill developing, maybe--although he's gotten worse each of the past two years since 2019--but a .777 OPS is not a "really damn good MLB hitter."3 points -
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
Minny505 and 2 others reacted to Doctor Gast for a comment on a blog entry
3 pointsAndrew, love your article! Love your common sense backed up with unbias data. I encourage you to write as often as you can because you're a pleasure to read and to disarm any false ideas out there. This is a fair contract (the # of years could be tricky), no more fooling around. Get it done!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! BTW, what has been offered?3 points -
Deja Vu - Buxton Extension and Mauer Extension
Deja Vu - Buxton Extension and Mauer Extension
beckmt and 2 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
3 pointsI'll accept the very real possibility that Buxton could flame out; but I'd still extend him. This team really has no other internal players who are even close to ready for a long-term big money extension, even if Buxton busts, it just seems there is so little risk to the actual long-term team building.3 points -
Why isn't Johan Santana in the Hall of Fame?
Why isn't Johan Santana in the Hall of Fame?
Jerr and one other reacted to Zach Hartford for a post in a topic
2 pointsBefore I begin this discussion, I might be slightly biased because Johan Santana is my favorite player of all time. He's who I wanted to be growing up and I never missed one of his starts. I will always remember where I was during his 17 strikeout game against the Rangers. I'll never forget how sad 8 year old me was when he was traded in the 2008 offseason. He was a huge part of my childhood and one of the best pitchers in Twins history. Now, why was Johan not inducted into Cooperstown? Starting with his accolades, he was a 2x Cy Young winner (we'll talk about 2005 later in this post), the triple crown winner in 2006, 4x All-Star, 3x ERA title winner, and won a Gold Glove. He accumulated 51.7 WAR according to Baseball Reference, had a career 3.20 ERA over 2025.2 innings, with 1988 strikeouts, and a 1.132 WHIP. Obviously, a crazy good prime and list of accolades. His career was cut short due to injury which is the biggest argument as to why he doesn't have a plaque in New York. Now, let's talk about the reason why he isn't in Cooperstown, the 2005 season. Most people are aware of what happened in the 2005 Cy Young race, but let's vent about it some more. Bartolo Colon won the 2005 AL Cy Young over Johan Santana, who finished third with Mariano Rivera coming in second. Bartolo Colon led the league in one category: pitcher wins. Johan led the league in strikeouts, ERA+, FIP, and WHIP. Let's compare the two's statistics from that season: Colon ERA: 3.48, Santana ERA: 2.87 Colon IP: 222.2, Santana IP: 231.2 Colon SO: 157, Santana SO: 238 Colon ERA+: 122, Santana ERA+: 155 Colon FIP: 3.55, Santana FIP: 2.80 Colon WHIP: 1.159, Santana WHIP: 0.971 As we can see, the 2005 Cy Young clearly should've belonged to Johan Santana. This means that he should've been a 3 time Cy Young winner, with those being 3 straight from 2004-06. This is very important because every 3 time Cy Young Award winner is either in the Hall of Fame now, or will be in the Hall of Fame once they are retired. So, although Johan's career was a little shorter than other Hall of Famers, it's impossible to argue with the 3 should've been Cy Young Awards. Johan Santana should be in the National Baseball Hall of Fame. Thank you for reading! Follow me on twitter @zach_hartford for more Twins discussion.2 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
USAFChief and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
2 points"Home run hitters drive Cadillacs, singles hitters drive Fords." -- Fritz Ostermueller (regarding Ralph Kiner)2 points -
Things Twins Players Did This Week
Things Twins Players Did This Week
chinmusic and one other reacted to Joey P for a post in a topic
2 pointsI am happy for him. He is the kind of player who lives for the clutch.2 points -
Things Twins Players Did This Week
Things Twins Players Did This Week
chinmusic and one other reacted to adorduan for a post in a topic
2 pointsEddie is on fire! Good for him.2 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Jerr and one other reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
2 pointsYes, Holy Cow - that was fun. Eddie! Eddie!2 points -
Things Twins Players Did This Week
Things Twins Players Did This Week
mikelink45 and one other reacted to Lucas Seehafer PT for a post in a topic
2 pointsGlad to see that Max is having the best Fall.2 points -
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
Linus and one other reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
2 pointsFootball built their empire by putting aside their regional selfishness to build a game with parity and national appeal. Baseball had national appeal and slowly allowed it's worst element (fervent regionalism) take over via cable contracts and fan bases. It has killed parity, left small markets with literal decades of non-competitive play, and destabilized the ability for the league to story-tell about the game. Making a streaming service that is still rooted in regionalism will only perpetuate the same problems. Baseball needs to sacrifice some profits for the sake of exposure and goodwill to sports fans or they'll continue to die. This idea and price point will be argued by the league, and has here, to be perfectly fine and reasonable because they are focused on a very narrow range of fans they listen to. Like people in a baseball forum conducted by baseball fans significantly more passionate than the average viewer. As has been the case for about two decades....baseball makes all their decisions based on the feelings of diehards and never recognizes the value in casual fandom. And because of that....they kill the casual fans. Nobody who says "I like to have a baseball game on sometimes" is going to pay $20 for a streaming service for 4 hour slog-a-thons. A streaming service could be the savior of baseball. But that price point needs to be at a spot a casual fan would jump at.2 points -
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
chaderic20 and one other reacted to Cap'n Piranha for a post in a topic
2 pointsI perhaps have been unclear--I think there should be one package that every fan buys, and it gives them access to every team in the league(s) they include. Football has managed to be a sport where market, while still important, is not critical to viewership. As such, it doesn't matter that both NY teams are terrible, and have been for years--the league thrives even though it's best teams are in Baltimore and Green Bay (among other places). MLB/NBA/NHL should be trying to get to that place, where they are creating not Twins or Mariners or Rangers fans, but baseball fans (who still have a favorite team, but will watch a Braves/Padres game while living in St Louis, for no other reason than that they like baseball). MLB is declining in popularity, and needs a refresh now. Embracing the times, and eliminating as many barriers to viewership as possible is the path forward.2 points