Leaderboard
-
Brock Beauchamp
AdministratorPoints29,627Posts -
Mike Sixel
Old-Timey MemberPoints36,790Posts -
-
nicksaviking
Community ModeratorPoints18,707Posts
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/20/2021 in all areas
-
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Connor Gould and 8 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic
9 pointsTime will tell for sure, but I always get the impression that when it comes to the shortstop position, most pundits and fans only see the players' defense as a pass/fail proposition. But it isn't black or white, there's plenty of scenarios where a below average defender is acceptable. I mean statistically, half of the starting shortstops in the league are going to be below average. No one wants Jorge Polanco as a starting shortstop, but the team did win 100 freakin' games with him at the position. It's not ideal but it's not like it's going to destroy the season. Obviously, aim for higher quality defense than Polanco, but I don't want the team to get so caught up in the defensive side of things that they don't regularly put the optimal offense into the lineup.9 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Polonco at second, Lewis at short and Miranda at third. Keep Buxton and Kepler in center and right. Add Larnach and Martin in left field with Martin moving around to center and right as needed. Arraez gets a lot of at bats as DH, while also backing up Polo and Miranda at second and third. Kirilloff is the first baseman with Sano as DH and AK's backup. Would be heck of an every day lineup without the need to go out and sign any expensive free agents. But it all starts with Lewis being able to handle short. As for who plays short when Lewis needs a day off, could be Polo, Martin or another backup utility guy...maybe Gordon?9 points
-
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
wabene and 5 others reacted to stringer bell for a post in a topic
6 pointsArraez has quite a bit of value, I think. He does have elite contact skills and is an average defender. I remember listening to Joe Nathan say that if Arraez stayed healthy, he was a candidate for 3000 hits. I know he was speaking to a Twins audience, but that’s a pretty strong endorsement. There probably are 5-10 teams with better 2B, but many clubs would want an on-base machine with three years of team control, and he’s only 24.6 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
GopherJeff and 5 others reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic
6 pointsI found this a bit depressing. Rosario has, in one season in Atlanta, now played in more post-season games as a Brave than as a Twin.6 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Danchat and 5 others reacted to big dog for a post in a topic
6 pointsTo be accurate here, the Indians traded Eddie Rosario plus cash to Atlanta for Pablo Sandoval. The Indians released Sandoval the same day. So I don't think you can say it was an asset for an asset. They actually paid Atlanta to take Eddie's contract.6 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Unwinder and 4 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
5 pointsI'm at a loss to understand some people's belief that the Twins should basically never trust a rookie, and keep every veteran, even at a level of pay no other team was willing to come close to. I'm happy he is getting to have some success this year! I don't get why we can't be happy for that, and realize it was time to move on (even if it didn't work......not successful does not mean not correct, anymore than successful means correct).5 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Richie the Rally Goat and 4 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
5 pointsWhat's the point of keeping him if he has no value (which I disagree with, btw)?5 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
RpR and 4 others reacted to Aerodeliria for a post in a topic
5 pointsThe problem at SS does not magically disappear in any of these scenarios. The position requires range, speed, a good glove, a strong arm and mental toughness. I suppose the closest is Lewis, but his arm is being questioned in MiLB, so it seems unlikely that it will play well in MLB. As much as I disliked Simmons bat, I still liked his play at SS. He had the highest defensive WAR on the team outside of Buxton (I believe). My hope is to go get an all-star SS who can hit a bit better than Simmons, but if the plan is to stick a sub-par SS there who can hit, I think we're spinning our wheels. I'd rather sign Simmons to another one-year deal in that scenario.5 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
Free Agent starting pitchers
cHawk and 4 others reacted to Andrew Mahlke for a post in a topic
5 pointsI fail to see how trading Buxton and Arraez will get them ready for 2024-2025. Both of them will still be in their prime, with Buck at the tail end and Arraez entering it. If we want to compete 3 years down the line they are both definitely guys we want to hang on to.5 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
Free Agent starting pitchers
Twins33 and 4 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
5 pointsThere are 30 MLB teams and 15 players in those top four tiers. Expecting a single mid-market team to sign 20% of those those 15 players is a pretty unreasonable ask. But my expectation is for the Twins to sign one of those top guys (not top four tiers, maybe top three) and then one higher-upside reach on a shorter contract. Then they can go get a filler like Pineda. (not that it needs to happen in that particular order but come February, that's what I want to see)5 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Jerr and 3 others reacted to Hosken Bombo Disco for a post in a topic
4 pointsCame up in the 9th, with a chance to hit for the cycle, and, ... didn’t?4 points -
Eddie Rosario
4 pointsBoy I sure am glad the Twins don't have Eddie Rosario anymore. ?4 points
-
MLB teams to provide housing for minor leaguers in 2022
MLB teams to provide housing for minor leaguers in 2022
Brock Beauchamp and 3 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
4 pointsIt isn't out of the goodness of their heart to pay living wages to employees, but we'll just 100% disagree on that. The players have zero freedom to negotiate their pay (or even their employer).....all the power is on one side, granted by the government in opposition to freedom and capitalism. Ergo, the only way they can get paid fairly (that is, what they are worth).....MLB needs to impose things on them. If you think they are paid what they are worth, make them all FAs and see what they are paid.4 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Unwinder and 3 others reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
4 pointsQuick exercise. Name a player from the Washington/Minnesota baseball franchise that is regarded historically as among the top ten in baseball history at their primary position. Joe Mauer is among the top ten catchers in baseball history. I'll go first - Walter Johnson. Leave Joe Mauer out of any discussions about Eddie Rosario, contracts, etc., because it only makes you look foolish, jealous, or worse. Eddie Rosario is an absolute joy to watch right now and his bases loaded walk was precious. He looked almost sheepish taking ball four as if he knew what a free swinger he has always been but deferred to the situation. Fun.4 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
TopGunn#22 and 3 others reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
4 pointsProbably. However, I don't think this is the right question. Is trading him the best way to build a contender and how long will that take. That's the right question. Polanco is really important to this lineup. Yes, we could go with Arraez at 2B which is his best defensive position. One of them should be traded, IMO. If it's Polanco, it needs to be a big haul. Otherwise, trade Arraez a part of a trade to get a SS or pitching. Trading Polanco extends the time it takes us tom get back in contention. We have a very good chance of ending 2022 with a pitching staff that is homegrown. Extend Buxton and establish this homegrown staff and we have a great shot at contention for several years.4 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
flatlanddad and 3 others reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
4 pointsNo, We need his bat, he hits HRs, but he also gets other hits something that is lacking for many of our batters. As I watch the post season I have loved to see players get well placed hits against the shift. That is true baseball. Polanco has bat control and is a player I am happy to see come to bat.4 points -
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
What should the Twins offer Byron Buxton?
Minny505 and 2 others reacted to Andrew Mahlke for a blog entry
3 pointsBack in March, Matthew Trueblood wrote an excellent article on Twins Daily about what a potential Byron Buxton extension would look like. Now, obviously this was before Buxton’s phenomenal (injury plagued, but still phenomenal) 2021 campaign. After the season Buxton had, his value for a future extension skyrocketed. With Byron Buxton up until about 2019, the main question was always: “Will he be able to hit major league pitching?”. He always played phenomenal defense, ran the bases ridiculously well, and had an incredibly strong arm. He just had to put it together at the plate. Well, since the start of 2019, Buxton is 20th in the MLB in OPS and 4th in the MLB in slugging percentage. Buxton has really put it together at the plate in the last 3 seasons and it has been a joy to watch. Before we get into his contract specifics, let’s highlight how special Byron Buxton is. 5-Tool Player Byron Buxton helps the Twins win games, plain and simple. Since the beginning of 2019, the Twins are 104-68 when Buxton plays, and 106-106 when he does not. This means that they play at roughly a 98 win pace when he is on the field and an 81 win pace when he is not. This is the difference between not making the playoffs at all and getting home-field advantage in the playoffs. Let’s take a dive into what makes Buxton such a difference-maker for the Twins. Hitting I mentioned earlier how Buxton has really found his stride with his swing. Back in May of 2019, towards the beginning of Buxton’s outbreak, Parker Hageman wrote a phenomenal article about Byron Buxton’s swing. He took a deep dive into the swing adjustments Buxton had made that year that led to his success. Ever since then, his career has taken off. Buxton has been riddled with injuries his entire career, that is no secret. But since 2019, out of all players with a maximum of 700 plate appearances, Buxton leads with 102 extra base hits. The next closest player is Buxton’s teammate, Mitch Garver with 79 extra base hits. With limited appearances, Buxton is thriving. Using Baseball Savant’s handy Affinity feature, you can see which players have the most similar batted ball profiles to each other. In 2021, the most similar batters to Buxton were Yordan Alvarez, Fernando Tatis Jr., Rafael Devers, Salvador Perez, Josh Donaldson, and Aaron Judge. Buxton is up there with the cream of the crop. If you follow baseball at all, you know all of these guys are absolute stars and Buxton’s name belongs in that conversation as well. 2021 was his best year yet. He had a 169 wRC+, had 42 extra base hits (19 home runs), and a 1.005 OPS. Buxton proved in 2021 that he couldn’t just hit, but absolutely MASH major league pitching. Defense Buxton has always been elite defensively, winning a platinum glove as the AL’s best defensive player in 2017. Since 2016, Buxton has 58 outs above average (OAA), the 5th most among all center fielders. All of the players ahead of him (Lorenzo Cain, Kevin Kiermaier, Billy Hamilton, and Ender Inciarte) played at least 140 more games than Buxton in that span. If Buxton had played 140 more games, he would have the most OAA by 10 outs. It is safe to say that when Buxton is healthy he is the best defensive CF in baseball. He also has an absolute cannon in the outfield. His arm strength has been measured at 99 MPH before, so he definitely has an above average arm. Speed Buxton has always been one of the fastest players in the MLB. In 2021, Buxton was in the 99th percentile in sprint speed. His average sprint speed was 30 ft/sec and he had the fastest average home to first time at 4.00 sec. Buxton is a game-changer on the bases and has made a huge impact on many games on the basepaths, most notably walking off the Detroit Tigers on a seemingly routine ground ball to the shortstop. Overall Value Since 2019, Buxton has been worth 8.1 fWAR in 187 games, or a pace of 7 fWAR per 162 games. To put that number into perspective, there were zero position players with a WAR of 7 or over in 2021. In the last full season, 2019, the only players with a WAR 7 or above were Mike Trout, Alex Bregman, Christian Yelich, Cody Bellinger, Marcus Semien, and Anthony Rendon. Buxton’s WAR in 2021 was 4.2 over 61 games. Extrapolated to 162 games, that would be the equivalent of 11.2. That is absolutely ridiculous. That would be tied for the 17th best single season of all time in terms of WAR. Injuries Just looking at his raw per 162 numbers, you would think that the Twins should sign Buxton to a 10 year, $500 million extension. Unfortunately, Buxton has been injury prone throughout his career. As of July 2021, Buxton had only played 181 of 484 possible games since 2018. It is hard to justify giving him a big extension if he isn’t going to be healthy for a majority of it. Extension structure In short, I would offer Buxton an extension over seven years. It will start in 2023 and go through 2029, his age 29 through 35 season. As Buxton ages, his defense and speed will most likely deteriorate and he will not be as valuable. You also have to factor in his injury history so you won’t be paying full price. Consider the following: Since 2019, Buxton has played 187 of a possible 384 games, or 48% of possible games. Since 2019, Buxton has accumulated 8.1 WAR in 187 games, or 7 WAR/162 games According to Fangraphs, you should pay $8M/WAR. So, If Buxton were to play 162 games, he would be worth 7 WAR x $8M/WAR = $56M/year This is obviously egregious, especially considering the Twins usually have a payroll from 125-140M. According to spotrac, with the exception of the Dodgers, the top payrolls are right around $200M. We are going to assume those teams are able to use the $8M/WAR calculation Since the Twins will use maximum 140M of payroll, 70% of what the top payrolls use, we will also use 0.7 as our multiplier for the WAR value calculation. $8M/WAR x 0.7 = $5.6M/WAR Using our new 5.6M/WAR, he would be worth roughly $39M a year if he played 162. I think this is fair for a player of his caliber. He has been an MVP level player the last 3 seasons, and shows no signs of stopping. Besides injuries. Since Buxton has only played about 48% of possible games, I would pay him 48% of that $39M per year. 39M x 0.48 = about $19M a year. This is the base salary I would give Buxton. His base contract should be 7 years, $133 million However, we should account for the fact that there is a chance he remains healthy. This is where it gets tricky. This is where I bring in incentives to the contract. Buxton’s 7 WAR per 162 is worth 0.043 WAR per game. The current contract is assuming he plays 80 games If Buxton plays 120 games, he will get the original 19 million plus an additional amount of money We will determine this amount of money by multiplying his WAR per game by the additional 40 games he will be playing 40 games x 0.043 WAR per game = 1.7 WAR x $5.6M per WAR = $9.5M If Buxton plays 120 games, he should earn an additional 10 million. For 130 games, he will be worth an additional 2.4 million using that formula For 140 games, he will be worth another 2.4 million And for 150, he will be worth 2.4 million more. Contract Summary Base contract: 7 years, $133 million ($19M AAV) 120 games incentive: $9.5M/yr ($28.5M AAV) 130 games incentive: $2.4M/yr ($30.9M AAV) 140 games incentive: $2.4M/yr ($33.3M AAV) 150 games incentive: $2.4M/yr ($35.7M AAV) If Buxton plays 150 games, he could be making up to $35.7 million per year. This is the contract I would propose to Buxton because he would be getting a good amount of guaranteed money and it also helps him understand that playing a certain amount of games could get him an absurd amount of money. How does this contract compare? A salary of 19M per year (if he meets no incentives) would make him the 27th highest paid position player in baseball. Since 2019, he is 33rd in WAR among all position players, so this base contract would be just about right. If he meets all of the incentives, he would be the highest paid position player in baseball, which is fair considering the amount of talent he has and his production over a full healthy season would be at an MVP level. I think at his peak, he will play about 120-130 games, making his salary between 28 and 31 million. This would put him in the range of the 5th to 8th highest position player in the league. TL: DR version Pay Buxton a base salary of $19 million a year for 7 years, with games played incentives from 120 games to 150 games of various amounts that could net him up to $35.7 million per year. Conclusion Byron Buxton is a generational type of talent and I haven’t seen anyone like him in a Twins uniform my whole life. It would be a mistake to let him go just because of financial concerns. He is a player that you would rather overpay than not pay at all, so priority number ONE this offseason needs to be extending him. If there’s one player to offer this type of contract to, it’s Buck. Thank you for reading, and Go Twins.3 points -
Eddie Rosario
3 pointsHoly cow, a single, triple, and 2 HRs in one game for Eddie? Wowzers! What a series he's had... yup, I'm jealous of this playoff success Atlanta is having.3 points
-
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Rigby and 2 others reacted to annismark for a post in a topic
3 pointsthe anit-Rosario arguments seem to get weaker every inning.3 points -
The Twins Need Taylor Rogers
3 pointsWould a more accurate headline been: The Twins need a healthy Taylor Rogers?3 points
-
MLB teams to provide housing for minor leaguers in 2022
MLB teams to provide housing for minor leaguers in 2022
PseudoSABR and 2 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
3 pointsIf you go back to the link I posted of a thread that was started by a woman who organized housing for the team in Pensacola, she said this about housing in her market in summer: "In Pensacola...Summer is our high tourist season, so players are competing with condos on the beach which rent for crazy amounts, and every other guy and his dog putting their spare living spaces on Air BnB. That has made it a little harder than most areas to find player housing." Not all housing markets are created equal. What might seem 'easy' to you in Witchita is obviously not in other parts of the country, which might be why MLB has stated 'certain minor leaguers'. I'd like to hear the details of it before I start lumping everyone in the same boat, because they aren't. In some areas it just might be a Herculean task and it would be best not to judge it all the same. If there are many players complaining about this, then it isn't just a matter of budgeting and questioning if adult men are working hard enough to find an affordable place to live. There are a lot of variables that neither you nor I nor anyone else knows. But I'm glad that MLB will be working to provide some relief.3 points -
MLB teams to provide housing for minor leaguers in 2022
MLB teams to provide housing for minor leaguers in 2022
PseudoSABR and 2 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
3 pointsThis is a fallacy and don’t even think about going here again. Not solving a specific financial issue with one’s own money does not invalidate concern over that issue. It’s a deflection, not a legitimate point about a situation on this scale.3 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
Free Agent starting pitchers
RpR and 2 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
3 pointsI don’t consider that a defensive black hole until they fill the position. They’re absolutely going to acquire a shortstop, we just don’t know if that player will be any good.3 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
se7799 and 2 others reacted to MGM4706 for a post in a topic
3 pointsWhoever comes up there is one thing that was clear. Gardenhire in St Paul needs to do a better job of teaching the fundamentals of how to play a wall! Not one of the prospects including Kiroloff at first, Larnach, Rooker or Celestino in the OF had a clue on how to play a wall. They either run into it or shy away from it. That's on the organization.3 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
TopGunn#22 and 2 others reacted to Karbo for a post in a topic
3 pointsThis is why I can see Arraez as trade bait3 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
3 pointsAll I know is that whatever moves are suggested by the would be GMs on this board, the Twins group of researchers will study their spread sheets and do none of the above. Probably sign another "framing" catcher and say "Now the entire pitching staff will improve because the square root of pitches framed and called strikes x pie with a factor of 3x the left fielders ops = 20 more wins depending on which ball parks they occur in.3 points
-
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
TopGunn#22 and 2 others reacted to beckmt for a post in a topic
3 pointsA couple of issues here. I think you are correct on Miranda, assuming his bat will play here. As I hope the Twins sign buxton to an extension, you have more outfield prospects than positions. 1. Assumption Kirloff and Sano rotate between 1B and DH, with Kirloff in the outfield at times, this blocks up one position. And I would not give up on Sano this early, he could wind up being a game changer. Laurach is going to need a place to play unless he cannot cut it, too early to tell, but I doubt it. 2. By 2023 you are going to need a place for both Lewis and Martin. That to me would mean leaving Lewis at SS until other positions are sorted out. I like Martin (he like Arraez, can be a pest and put pressure on other teams, both by extending AB's, and running when be gets on). Will he hit enough, I am guessing yes. 3. That leaves you, with the Kepler issue. RIght now he does not have a lot of trade value, this all depends on buxton. If you extend Buxton, I would wait until late winter and see what he would bring. There is always going to be a cost controlled club (Miami, Tampa, Oakland, Cleveland), who would give you a pitcher if Kepler was packaged with another player. I can see this happening.3 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
Free Agent starting pitchers
roger and 2 others reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
3 pointsTrades could help on this front too since it is unlikely they corner the market.3 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
TopGunn#22 and 2 others reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic
3 pointsYou need offense and pitching. But how do you get better by trading one of your very best players? You don't unless you are rebuilding. And the Twins don't need to rebuild, they need to re-tool, and even management has been clear on this. The Twins can add pitching via FA. They can also trade from within their system, possibly with the addition of a different existing player not named Polanco, to acquire a pitcher. Maeda will be back in 2023. And there are a number of high potential arms a half to full season away from adding to the staff and the pen. Young, talented and controllable arms. You absolutely don't trade Polanco!3 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Scott51104 and 2 others reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
3 pointsNoooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo ! Just NO ! I do not want to build a team this way. As Cuba Goodin said : "Show me the money, Jerry !" Just spend the money and keep and reward the good players and sign some really good FA pitchers. Please. And start promoting players while they are younger. What more does Miranda need to do to get promoted? Get some more hitters, and jettison those hitters who are strikeout artists. Throw the ball hard and accurately, hit the ball where they ain't, catch the ball. It's not that complicated. Damn.3 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Twins33 and 2 others reacted to Unwinder for a post in a topic
3 pointsBoy, this is why I have no stomach for the offseason. Polo's an incredibly valuable trade chip who can get us what we need, but I love him too much. It'd be hard for me to pull the trigger.3 points -
The Twins Need Taylor Rogers
The Twins Need Taylor Rogers
mikelink45 and one other reacted to Ted Schwerzler for an article
2 pointsIt’s not just that the Twins pitching was in chaos for large portions of the 2021 season, that the starting rotation will need to be rebuilt from the ground up, or that the bullpen seemed to have a different trusted arm blow up every week. While all of those things are true, the more significant takeaway for Minnesota is that a guy like Taylor Rogers fits for this club, and his production is only heightened by the impact he has elsewhere. Although Alexander Colome was hardly the reliever expectations suggested when he signed with the Twins, that acquisition gave Rocco Baldelli more reason to utilize his best arm in non-save situations. Rogers had been the Twins closer for the past couple of seasons. Being removed from the rigid use solely in the 9th inning, Minnesota could deploy the talented lefty in critical spots as they presented themselves. He’ll be 31-years-old in 2022 and did see an ERA north of 4.00 for the first time in his career during the truncated 2020 season. However, his 13.2 K/9 in 2021 was a new career-high, and it came with a ridiculous 2.13 FIP. Although the 3.35 ERA was above the stellar marks from 2018 and 2019, it was clear Rogers was being done in by a combination of bad luck and bad fielding. Minnesota can’t afford the uncertainty of their pitcher having a finger injury that saps effectiveness as a whole. Still, the hope would be that an offseason of rest and recovery provides a runway for Taylor to be back on the bump as expected. Should that be the case, the only decision comes down to an arbitration valuation that currently projects just shy of $7 million. Entering the final year of team control, Rogers would be due for a payday that falls short of a $1 million raise over his 2021 season. Considering the injury and time missed, that would seem like a steal and no-brainer for the Twins. Unfortunately, paying relievers is a fickle beast, and you’re going to get burned more often than not. Minnesota handed the aforementioned Colome $6.25 million on a one-year pact this past season and was rewarded with the worst season of his career. Rogers being in that same boat is unlikely, and it’s hard to suggest that an arm with more upside is less deserving of the dollars. When the dust settles on this decision, it will largely represent the Twins plans for the offseason. Again, there has to be faith in Rogers being healthy and ready to contribute. Still, if that’s there, it’s hard to suggest that saving roughly $7 million would represent anything but cost-cutting for a team that has publicly indicated they intend to compete. Minnesota needs to add and supplement talent this offseason, and parting with their best reliever doesn’t seem like a good plan of attack. The opportunity to deal him passed them by when Rogers was put on the shelf, but giving him up for nothing would be a worst-case scenario to this saga. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email2 points -
My Ideal Twins Offseason
My Ideal Twins Offseason
PseudoSABR and one other reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
2 pointsI definitely like your thinking, but I think you range from 20-40% low on your price estimates. There are websites that could help you project those possible salaries as well.2 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Doctor Gast and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
2 pointsTo be clear, I think the team is better than its record if it gets a couple SPs.....and has better luck / outcomes from the RPs. But, this team wasn't good. Keeping it largely intact seems odd to me. I really want Martin in LF, and ASAP in the minors. He can hit and field. Other than that, I don't know what I'd do with the roster. Like, AK could be your LFer...as could Larnach. Maybe (I have my doubts) Rooker. Like, the construction seems redundant and off to me, which means they should make some trades.....2 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
wabene and one other reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
2 pointsI am with you, Mike. Time to shake it up. We have relatively poor roster construction. Reshape it. We also need to invest time in developing pitching and many here are unwilling to make that investment. Many ardent fans just can't accept investing in development. Their answer is to buy a team through free agency and trade away prospects for the here and now. This is simply not an effective approach for a below average revenue team and this has been proven around the league. I am (using your word) gobsmacked by how often the tactics of successful and unsuccessful teams are ignored. The Mets, Phillies, and Padres made all kinds of trades and invested in free agents. They all failed. In the case of the Mets and Phillies, repeatedly. Boston and San Francisco tweaked rosters. Tampa Bay traded Snell and let Morton go. They got lambasted by everyone. The national media proclaimed they were punting 2022. Some inferred they were incompetent. We should all pay a little more attention to how winners are built. Sure the big trades can be impactful but how many under the radar trades for A ballers turns out huge. Sure, trading for Tatis Jr. is a little lucky but there have been plenty of great players acquired for next to nothing. Those are the trades that really tilt the scales. Gil and Ynoa are not all that proven yet but how much better would we look if we had those two now. Fans are hyper focused on the right now and the block buster trades and that's not how a mid market team builds a contender. Tampa's trade for Snell was brilliant. Mejia is not as valuable as Snell but he is a good inexpensive role player will 4 years of control. They also got a SP that might be better than Snell with the exception of Snell's one exceptional year. He is already playing at the MLB level. Plus, they got a 50 FV catcher and a 21 yo A ball pitcher that had a .857 WHIP last year. This is how a team without limited financial resource builds a contender.2 points -
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
MLB working on in-market streaming service for 2023
Brock Beauchamp and one other reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
2 pointsFWIW, unlike air travel and hotels, consumers have never had the option to separate in-market Twins broadcasts from in-market Wolves or Wild in the way that you are describing. Also, you're making this way more complicated than it is. Sportsnet Now in Canada doesn't separate Blue Jays, Raptors, and Maple Leafs, but they offer a monthly plan for $15/month and an annual plan at $150/year. So if you just want the Blue Jays, subscribe to the monthly plan for 6 months and you'll pay $90 for the season. You can ignore the Raptors and Maple Leafs if the seasons overlap. Until I hear otherwise, I assume similar monthly/annual options would be part of in-market streaming in the USA too.2 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
se7799 and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
2 pointsI'm continually gobsmacked by people wanting to basically keep a horrible team together......if players don't have trade value, they don't belong on the MLB roster of a winning team (unless that lack of trade value is due to high, fair or not, pay). edit to add: to be clear, this is NOT aimed at one poster, but this site. Which seems to want to keep nearly every player on last year's 40 man ......that isn't a fungible RP.2 points -
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
Projecting the Defensive Future of Minnesota's Top Prospects
wabene and one other reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
2 pointsSS and CF are the most important and most demanding positions, almost all candidates don't make it let alone excel there. I don't know if Lewis or Martin will stick at their proposed positions, odds are they won't. We won 100+ games in '19 because we had an awesome line up that were all hitting on all 8cyl.s (with a juiced ball) and a top rate rotation ( where Pineda was the # 5 and he was raking) until the BP blew up. The rotation (especially a sick Gibson and a transformed BP Perez, they pitched much more innings than Odorizzi and Pineda) were overextended and limped across the finish line. We can't ever expect these conditions to exist and ignore our defense. Our goal isn't to be lucky & win a 100 games but to advance in the post season and even win the big one again.2 points -
2021 Postseason Discussion and Game Thread
2021 Postseason Discussion and Game Thread
Hosken Bombo Disco and one other reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
2 pointsDid anyone else think Roberts had a frantic depressed look on his face in the bottom of the 8th inning down 2-5? Managers face some serious stress seemingly. Meanwhile, Bellinger is swinging out of his shoes on a pitch low in the zone where he likes it and then again on a pitch right down the middle and then again at an unhittable high fastball and ..... bam, Roberts is healed. Baseball.2 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
GopherJeff and one other reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic
2 pointsAs a Twin? And at the position? Rod Carew at second base (1967-1975). 43 WAR, 130 OPS+ in those years. Kirby Puckett at center is still in some top 10 lists. He'll get pushed out in the next few years but right now, he's probably 8-10 all time. Here's a debateable one - Joe Nathan as a closer. Still top 10 in saves. His 2004 season was amazing. And he's 40th all-time among pitchers in WPA despite only 900 or so innings. Only closers ahead of him on that list are Gossage, Hoffman, and Rivera.2 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
We've got a great player on an incredible contract. That's pretty much what everyone wants - so yeah, his trade value is fantastic....but why would the Twins get rid of him? Are the Braves chomping at the bit to get rid of Ozzie Albies? No, because they have an incredible young player on a great contract. And they want to win. And to win you need incredible players. Polanco is the Twins most valuable asset. Period.2 points
-
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
nddan67 and one other reacted to Thebigalguy for a post in a topic
2 pointsWell played article. I agree with most above and say keep him unless a team makes an offer impossible to refuse. Extend Buxton. The offense is close. Minor moves there. Work on pitching.2 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
Free Agent starting pitchers
Andrew Mahlke and one other reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic
2 pointsThe Twins have the $ to make a serious 3-4yr deal for one of the better FA pitchers without breaking their payroll structure. Further, when said FA is entering his 3rd or 4th year, Donaldson's contract is off the books. They went after Darvish pretty aggressively and targeted Wheeler initially before the door was slammed in their face early, before they even got a chance to compete. (Not just them, other teams as well). So I think they are going to take a serious look see. Frankly, I don't know why a FA WOULDN'T look at the Twins. The FO has received high marks from the press and agents for their character and how they run things. Target Field is one of the best parks in all MLB. There is offense for support, and some more on the way. And let's not forget back to back winning/playoff teams in 2019-20. They lack pitching? Not so much if one or two of these guys signs on the dotted line.2 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
Free Agent starting pitchers
Karbo and one other reacted to lecroy24fan for a post in a topic
2 pointsI know you're thinking more recently but the only one I can think of is Jack Morris.2 points -
Free Agent starting pitchers
Free Agent starting pitchers
darwin22 and one other reacted to rv78 for a post in a topic
2 pointsI don't see any of the top tier Free Agent pitchers you mention coming to the Twins. They have other more appealing options, like organizations committed to winning and contending, not pretending. It'll be another off-season of "dumpster diving" and "hope and a prayer" signings of Free Agents. The only way they will acquire top tier pitching is thru trades and that is going to cost prospects. I'd rather see them punt 2022 and see what the top pitching prospects can do in 2022 that they have now.... Ryan, Ober, Duran, Balazovic, Canterino, Strotman, Winder, Sands, Woods-Richardson, etc, etc.... In the mean time they'll give Lewis another season to prove his worth, bring up Miranda, take a full-time look at Larnach, re-established Kirolloff's place on the team. Get rid of the dead weight in the lineup from Sano and Kepler. There are too many question marks going into 2022 to commit to it IMO.2 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
adorduan and one other reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
2 pointsWatch the fun and excitement of Rosario's walk off hit on ESPN - and you will see what some of us enjoyed about Eddie.2 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
Mike Sixel and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsExcept that Mauer had a .275 postseason batting average and that's not including Phil Cuzzi flat-out stealing a double from him. His postseason batting average jumps all the way up to .293 if you award him the double he obviously hit, which goes to show why we shouldn't put so much stock in such small sample sizes.2 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
TopGunn#22 and one other reacted to Doctor Gast for a post in a topic
2 pointsOf coarse he's our most valuable trading chip because he's our MVP, he did it all, was under paid and was durable. But should we? The answer is absolute NOT. 1st reason is he's still underrated because he's finally just recovering physically from his bout at SS and this was his 1st year return to 2B (Being 3rd defensively at 2B is amazing). As he continues at 2B and proceed to get completely well and find his groove, he'll regain his prowess (offensively and defensively), fulfilling his potential by becoming a MVP. Ever increasing his worth to us which is irreplaceable. 2nd reason is by trading Polanco we are stating we are rebuilding. Then we are committed to trade away all our underrated valuable core players (Polanco, Buxton, Kepler, Garver and Donaldson). And let's throw in Sano, we won't come close to get what they are worth. This will cause a large influx of prospects, flooding our roster. We have already a serious 40 man roster crunch, losing valuable undeveloped CF and pitching prospects via waivers. (I've stated this for a while now). Now multiply that by the wave of new prospects, this is irresponsible and impractical. Our problems this year weren't due to the players where we need to get rid of the core and rebuild. It was due to management. I give them credit for removing Polanco at SS and getting a real SS. But I do fault them for not going out and trading for very good starters and closer that were bargains, instead dumpster diving FAs. Also how they mismanaged LF and CF subbing, relying on a weak rotation and failing BP. To name a few. Many blame injuries, good management allows for this by providing quality depth. Chicago had more serious injury problems from the beginning of the season but still handily won the division. I could go on. Since our management is returning, our only hope is that they transform their mindsets. If not and they choose to rebuild. They would have appropriately selected the right uniform (to commemerate the '91 WS win) to usher in the new "Twinkie Era". UGH!2 points -
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
Is Jorge Polanco the Twins' Most Valuable Trade Asset?
TopGunn#22 and one other reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
2 pointsConsidering the contract and the way Polanco responded to better health with a fantastic 2021 season, the Twins would need to get back quite a haul. His at bats are generally tough for the pitcher and he could easily maintain his production throughout the length of his contract. My sheet always includes Jorge Polanco at 2B, but the Twins might find a trade possible if another team offers the right collection of talent. I have not thought about what a Polanco trade would generate because I'm keeping him.2 points -
Eddie Rosario
Eddie Rosario
adorduan and one other reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
2 pointsGood for Eddie. He was always entertaining, if not always fundamentally sound. His "ankles to forehead" strike zone led to some interesting ABs, both good and bad. As for the Twins not signing Rosario, I think it's fair to say Falvine were correct to move on. I think it also fair to say their plan to replace him was a pretty miserable failure.2 points