Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Brock Beauchamp

    Administrator
    Points
    29,624
    Posts
  2. ashbury

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    34,998
    Posts
  3. Mike Sixel

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    36,790
    Posts
  4. Hosken Bombo Disco

    Community Leader
    Points
    14,795
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/09/2021 in all areas

  1. It's odd that we are just now hearing this. And we have no details as to what the Yankees supposedly offered.
  2. Oh FFS. Come on, they had a chance to move that guy and didn't leap at the opportunity? Yuck. Just yuck.
  3. We don't actually know what transaction was discussed. Maybe the Twins would have had to eat half of the remaining salary just to be rid of him, with Ryan LaMarre coming back as a fig leaf for dignity's sake, and the discussion never progressed from that kind of insult. I don't believe the Yankees actually acquired any middle infielders at the deadline, so whatever discussion there was was likely brief and not terribly motivated.
  4. It’s not hard to imagine that the Yankees called the Twins inquiring about Simmons, and that would be enough to call it “interest.” Still, the response from the Twins should have been: DoneDeal!He’syoursNoBacksies TooBadSoSad *click*
  5. Totally classless and clueless decision by Baldelli and Falvey. Still leaves a very sour taste with me. Maggi was EVERYTHING you'd want as a professional with over 4000 milb ABs. F- grade on failing to get Maggi into a game.
  6. Who Can the Twins Deal?

    Heiny and 4 others reacted to Sielk for a post in a topic

    5 points
    I don't want to trade Garver. Catcher is a position of strength right now. But would it remain one if your catchers are Jeffers/Rortvedt/new acquisition? I'm not convinced that Jeffers could just replace Garver right now. I hate to say this, because Luis Arraez has been my favorite player these last three years, but it might make sense to trade him. 2B/3B is really a strength of this team. Between Polanco, Donaldson (who you probably can't trade), Miranda and Arraez you already have four players for two spots. And while there are always some injuries, we already saw that little logjam this season when the lack of regular playing time was probably one of the reasons why Miranda wasn't called up. Speaking of injuries, let's talk about Arráez'. He has already missed a lot of time because of his knees. Even when he has been on the field, the injuries have caused some extended slumps we haven't seen from him before. A Luis Arraez who hits .330 is a special hitter. If he hits only .280 with no power and bad defense? Not so much. That doesn't mean the Twins should just dump him. But right now he is still only one season removed from hitting .320. If another team is willing to bet on his health and offers them a good return, they should maybe pull the trigger instead of banking on better health in the future. If you wait longer and it goes poorly, his value might plummet rather quickly. Ugh, I really hated writing this...
  7. After reading the article, I’m more skeptical of the report. Why was it never reported before? Why is the first mention of it a small handful of throwaway words in an article about this off-season? I’m going to need someone to show their work on this one. Maybe it’s true. In that case I vehemently disagree with the decision. But I need to see the work.
  8. Tell me this wasn't another "he's a leader/vet and we need to maintain respectability," decision, a la Pineda.
  9. Leaving my error uncorrected because trying to cover it up now would be all the more shameful.
  10. Sigh

    LastOnePicked and 3 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    4 points
    I'm closer to his age than yours, so I can relate a little bit to a slip of the tongue that harkens back to older usages. (I still trip up and say "stewardess" when "flight attendant" has been the preferred term for decades now.) But honestly I have no idea where in his memory banks he pulled that phrase - I chalk it up to a casual racism in his youth that would have been a bit shocking to encounter even by the time I arrived on the scene 15 years later. Because I feel like Kaat's basically a good human being, I'll be an optimist and say that maybe it shows we have made some progress as a society in his lifespan. But that doesn't excuse the words he used, and his apology seems to reflect that he understands how ugly they were.
  11. 4 points
    Celestine is probably a better value based on what he did in AAA vs Larnach Ober at an ERA a little over 4 is better than a back end starter. The state of pitching is that bad. If he can pitch every 5th time through the rotation for a full season at that ERA or slightly better that is a very high value
  12. Stop being reasonable. This is the internet!
  13. It also doesn't typically have 9 guys on the 60-Day IL. These were definitely the easy decisions. There are the free agents who will come off after the World Series. Then there are several tough decisions.
  14. Dropping Maggi after not giving him an at-bat is just a kick in the teeth. Though I believe in the kid and think he will have a place on a roster somewhere next year, would have been right for the Twins to reward the kid a little for the years and time he has given this organization, especially in a lost year like 2021. Best of luck to him.
  15. Better Late Than Never

    RpR and 2 others reacted to Cody Pirkl for an article

    3 points
    Corey Kluber Kluber was heavily linked to the Twins last winter before the Yankees threw $11m at the right hander. Kluber pitched quite well in his first year in the Bronx with a sub 4.00 ERA. Unfortunately after throwing just one inning in 2020, Kluber missed significant time and only reached 80 frames. Kluber is likely a candidate for another one year deal at age 36. He still looked like a valuable pitcher in a tough stadium and division, and a move back to the soft AL Central would do him wonders. He may not be counted on for a significant amount of innings, but pairing him with a pitcher like Michael Pineda would be valuable. There’s upside to be had similar to the Twins 2020 Rich Hill signing, upside the Twins will surely be looking for in order for a bounce back in their pitching staff. Marcus Stroman The Twins were bullish on Stroman in 2019 when the Blue Jays eventually shipped him to the Mets. The Twins claimed Toronto never returned their call for a counter offer. Stroman wasn’t much help in 2020 but performed exceptionally well in 2021 with a 3.02 ERA in almost 180 innings. Stroman would definitely require a long term deal with some good money attached. He may not be a flat out ace, but he’s a durable, experienced arm. His reliance on movement, location, and weak contact should make him a valuable pitcher for the foreseeable future now that he’s surpassed 30 years of age. He’d also immediately slot in as an Opening Day starter and top of the rotation anchor. Noah Syndergaard Digging way into the well here, remember when the Twins were in on Noah Syndergaard in 2019 and the Mets wanted Byron Buxton in exchange? I’m sure no fans were angry at the Twins for not pulling the trigger, right? Syndergaard has a storied past when it comes to injury, most recently returning from Tommy John just this year. The result of this being there isn’t much of a body of work to see since 2019. It’s hard to forget the arm they call “Thor” throwing one 100 mph fastball after another. While never quite an ace, it’s hard to deny that the upside is there. With Syndergaard's recent history, he’s another candidate for a one year “show me” deal. It may be high risk, but there may not be a pitcher on the market with a higher potential payoff. The Twins will be looking high and low on both the free agent and trade market this winter to try to fix a pitching staff that straight up cost them any shot at contending in 2021. It wouldn’t be the most surprising development to go back to the well and revisit some arms they were previously interested in. Is there any one of this trio that stands above the rest? Should these three be avoided altogether? Let us know below! — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email — Follow Cody Pirkl on Twitter here
  16. 3 points
    It seems as if every playoff team has an opponent or two they dominate. For example, Tampa Bay went 18-1 vs Baltimore Milwaukee went 15-4 vs the Cubs and 14-5 vs Pittsburgh Houston went 14-5 vs Texas The Dodgers went 16-3 vs Arizona and the Giants went 17-2 vs the Diamondbacks.
  17. 3 points
    I guess the Yankees didn't have a bucket of baseballs handy to complete the trade.
  18. I agree in that I would have given him for nothing. My problem comes with the report itself, which is beyond sketchy. It’s a throwaway line in an article about a different subject, two months after the deadline during which we heard zero reports about Simmons and the Yankees.
  19. 3 points
    Right. There’s a difference between serious discussion and “just asking”.
  20. If they plan to retain Pineda and didn’t receive any decent offers, I can understand keeping him. I literally would have given Simmons away to anyone who would take him.
  21. 3 points
    I don’t think it’s an AL Central problem. If the Twins has pulled their weight and won 90+ games, the Central would have looked like several other divisions this season. So that’s why I say it’s a Twins problem, not a Central problem. As far as the possibility of the White Sox being swept and having this be the fourth consecutive season where the AL Central winner has been swept out of the first round? First, other teams are allowed to be good. But secondly, yeah, that’s a bad look. The Twins have played a big part in that streak. Three different AL Central teams represented the American League in the World Series for 4 out of 5 years recently, from 2012 to 2016. So that tells me that a good team or mid-market team from the Central division can compete just fine.
  22. Sigh

    Nine of twelve and 2 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Same. I also ran that phrase through various scenarios and came up with no even remotely justified usages of it. It's probably a holdover because let's face it, Kaat was well into elementary school by the time Jackie donned a Dodgers uniform. He surely has a head full of truly unfortunate phrases and thinking. But he apologized and it seemed real. Hopefully he's a touch more careful from now on and we can all move on instead of trying to crucify an 82 year old man who grew up in a wildly different era. He seems like a genuinely decent guy so I hope this doesn't spiral out of control.
  23. Sigh

    Linus and 2 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I like Kaat but he's an old man. I appreciate he didn't go with "I'm sorry if I offended anyone" and stuck to "I used hurtful language and I'm sorry".
  24. Better Late Than Never

    Melissa and 2 others reacted to IndianaTwin for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Please not Stroman. I'm not sure I can handle several years of TwinsDaily articles arguing whether or not Stroman is an "ace." ?
  25. I think Refsnyder is a harder decision than Astudillo at this point. La Tortuga may be a fun player and fan-favorite, but he's also not all that good. If the Twins think Refsnyder figured something out that unlocked him for the first half and the poor performance in the second half was all injury-related...he's got more value than Astudillo. (That said, I think he's still a cut with the option to sign a minor league deal as depth)
  26. The Cusp Guys

    glunn and 2 others reacted to whosafraidofluigirussolo for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I thought i remembered something about Rooker's stolen-base numbers in college, so I looked them up. It looks like he only ran during his final college season, but that season he stole 18 bases at a 78% success rate. With the caveat that stolen bases aren't equivalent to raw speed, it seems like his issue in the outfield may be reads and routes more than speed? I recall some discussion of one of Rooker's "highlight" catches late in the season, and this seems to track - he may have taken a worse route to that ball than another defender would, but he also had the closing speed to get to it.
  27. Better Late Than Never

    TwinsDr2021 and 2 others reacted to mike8791 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    ://Kluber/Thor, Ryan, Pineda, Ober and Dobnak work for me as their opening day 5. That rotation would lead to another 90 loss season. I can see Ryan and Ober as maybe being a decent back end of the rotation, though more likely only one will be successful. Pineda would be a decent middle rotation guy. Can't rely on Dobnak for anything. The league seems to have figured him out and to count on him in the rotation on a contender takes a big leap of faith at this stage. With all that said, its the top two arms that will make or break the FO's designs on contending next season. Kluber is simply too high a risk to be counted on; he fits more in the Happ/Shoe category of a Hail Mary at this point in his career. The twins need to shoot for an ace-type, either Rodon or Ray head the list, with Stroman, then Thor being good alternatives. As many others have mentioned a trade of some surplus players(Arraez, Garver/Jeffers?) should bring back a young, controlled major league pitcher. FO must utilize a two - pronged approach - sign one of top FA pitchers and add a #2 via trade route. This should allow enough money to also add a much-needed closer, as well as a FA SS. This is a team full of holes; half way measures will never work.
  28. Who Can the Twins Deal?

    TwinsDr2021 and 2 others reacted to old nurse for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Other than the there are less home runs, how is Polamco’s 2019 season any less than 2021? There are no reasons to think his 2021 season is a fluke other than inmate pessimism
  29. Who Can the Twins Deal?

    glunn and 2 others reacted to Nashvilletwin for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Ted, good list but you left off Josh. He’s the number #1 person I’d move. I get that he actually had a pretty good year - particularly in the late 2nd half when the season was already lost. He’s a good, actually very good, baseball player both at the plate and in the field if healthy (which has been fairly unreliable). He’s a veteran presence as well (but has that really translated in the dugout and the clubhouse though?). He very well may be worth his $20+MM. But not to us - not at this time. Josh is a declining asset taking up valuable cash and real estate on a mid market team that has lost lots of money over the past couple of years and has a strong emerging player ready to take his spot. Signing him was a great bet at the time. It made tremendous sense for a team willing to go all in. But that window has passed. Let me repeat that for all of us fans who think 2021 was just some sort of an aberration. That window has passed. The Twins exiting 2021 are not in the same position as the Twins heading into 2019. Josh’s late season play will contribute to getting a better deal for him from a team looking for that key piece. Even more likely if the NL adopts the DH. If all the analytics guys on this site are correct, then there should be takers at full value for Josh’s WAR. Resigning Buxton, signing a SS, and adding pitching (targeting the BP and maybe Big Mike) are simply better uses of that cash at this point in time for the Twins. Give Miranda and Luis the 3B innings and turn over the veteran leadership to Buxton. BTW, I’d move Kepler as well……
  30. There is still 42 players on the 40 man roster including the 60 day DL. Simmons will be a FA. There are still several easy decisions. Garlick Cave Refsnyder Thorpe Maybe Astudillo And then it gets more difficult but there are a few players we can cut.
  31. Who Can the Twins Deal?

    SF Twins Fan and 2 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I don't trade Garver unless I'm punting next year, of someone gives me an insane deal. You win by having players be A LOT better than other team's players (position by position)....and Garver is one of the best hitting catchers/1B/DHs in the game. I'm ok with dealing any of the others you mention, because I believe in the next wave of corner fielders. (not counting Buxton, who you didn't really mention).
  32. The Cusp Guys

    TopGunn#22 and 2 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Rooker - Depth and potential DH if Cruz isn’t replaced Larnach - Wouldn’t mind him starting at LF/RF for the Twins opening day. Potential trade bait as well. Kirilloff - Dude is a stud. He was hitting the cover off the ball before he tore ligaments in his wrist and tried playing through it for 1-2 months. It’s a shame he couldn’t show off his skillset for most of 2021. Lewis - Don’t think he’s a realistic option in 2022. I’m the low guy on him and would trade him if he’s still a top 100 ranked prospect. Celestino - Competing with Larnach for a starting spot in RF/LF for the Twins. More than likely starting in St Paul opening day 2022. Gordon - probable utility guy for the Twins. Rortvedt - AAAA filler. Ideal 3rd catcher Smeltzer and Thorpe - I’d hate to give up on left handed, breathing pitchers. Their best bet is in the bullpen. Hopefully both gain a tick or 3 on their fastball in the pen.
  33. The Minnesota Vikings. They looked incredible in one game and lost the other three games in unique and frustrating ways. It’s the platonic ideal of four Vikings games and there’s no reason to think it won’t continue. The Minnesota Timberwolves. They have a talented young core and are surrounded by front office chaos. They’ve been around for 30 years and been good for about two of them. A safer bet is hard to find. The Minnesota Wild. The most playoff-ready team in town. In March, that title was held by the Minnesota Twins. It’s not a crown you want to wear. The MLB Postseason. So many enemies of the common good, so few teams to pull for. If you have any friends rooting for the White Sox because they’re from the AL Central, you know they’ve never really been your friend and will try to get you to invest in their MLM someday soon. And yet, you can’t root for the vile, cheating Astros either. No thanks to Atlanta or Boston or LA. The best-case World Series scenario is probably Rays/Giants? Grim. Maybe you can talk yourself into the Brewers, just for having a Wisconsin fan base less insufferable than Green Bay’s? That’s between you and your God. The weather. It’s either going to be too warm to snow and everything is grey and brown, or too cold to enjoy. The worst storm of the season will be on the day you have to drive or fly somewhere. Thankfully, this will only last for 5-7 months. Also the sun is already setting as you read this. University of Minnesota athletics. Football team lost to Bowling Green. Men’s basketball team is picked to finish 14th out of 14 teams. They killed the track program. Lindsay Whalen can only do so much. New music from your favorite band or singer. It’ll probably be super slow, overly experimental, or have too many horns. This always happens and we don’t talk about it enough. The global supply chain. If you’re reading this and haven’t ordered your holiday gifts yet, it’s too late. If you’re reading this and have ordered your holiday gifts, it’s still too late. Cutting the cord. Add up the cost of your streaming services. Compare it to your old cable/satellite bill. Remember that none of them carry the Twins or NewsRadio seasons 1-4. Scream into a pillow. Minnesota United. They’re fighting for a playoff spot. The supporter groups want to fire the coach. They’ll probably get eliminated on an own goal or forfeit because they’re too injured to field an entire team. Free Agency. Remember how hopeful you were when the Twins made those veteran signings last year? Remember how sad you were all summer? Yeah. Uncle Gene. Dammit, Gene.
  34. Better Late Than Never

    Heiny and one other reacted to terrydactyls for a post in a topic

    2 points
    You certainly pulled that response out of thin air. The commenter never said he was satisfied about any win total. All he mentioned was that the Twins won more games than any other last place team. Dispute what he said, not your opinion of something you think he might be vaguely implying. Or try something completely different for you - say something positive about the Twins.
  35. Better Late Than Never

    Heiny and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    2 points
    You know for a fact he didn't say he wanted to test free agency, or even leave? Or, maybe they decided multiple years of what they got was more valuable? That's fairly likely why they did it. This year was lost. So, what is worth more, one year of Berrios next year, or six of the guys they got? As for spending, these last two years they've spent the most they ever have. They signed Donaldson to a huge deal. I'm just not sure we agree on your facts being facts and not opinions.
  36. “Look - legally you have to give up something in a trade. Don’t you have a dollar in your pocket or something?”
  37. Ok....now I'm on board for firing them.
  38. You got a point... Yes. (2 birds, 1 post!)
  39. Any relation to Drew DiMaggio?
  40. Sigh

    nicksaviking and one other reacted to shortround81 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Is what he said s*****? Yes. Am I also used to "old" people calling me "Oriental" instead of "Asian"? Also yes
  41. The Cusp Guys

    TopGunn#22 and one other reacted to the_neds for a post in a topic

    2 points
    What are everyone's feelings going into the offseason about our position guys who are middling between St Paul and Minnesota? In this category I'd put Rooker, Larnach, Kirilloff, Lewis, Celestino, Gordon, Rortvedt? How is Royce Lewis going to look after essentially not having seen a game for two straight years? Are Rooker and Larnach going to be guys who show a lot of promise but in the end get leapfrogged by guys like Martin, Miranda etc? How's Kirilloff going to adjust post-surgery? Has Gordon possibly played himself into contention for a utility spot if he has a good Spring in 22? On another note - what's the plan for pitchers like Smeltzer & Thorpe? DFA? Is there a point to keeping Astudillo on the roster at this point? If we had Gordon and Arraez in utility spots, his only limited upside would be a barely passable catching option. We've got Rortvedt who has a framing/arm upside above Astudillo in the wings. To me it seems like we have an abundance of potentially good but unproven depth and it could still go either way.
  42. Who Can the Twins Deal?

    glunn and one other reacted to RonCoomersOPS for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I'm not outwardly excited about trading anybody if I'm Falvine. The cost associated with everyone is very, very high, and my price tag for Buxton is just this side of certifiably crazy. But I'm definitely listening intently on just about everyone. It's not overly likely that Polanco has another season like this last one, and I don't want to have to pay for past performance if I'm negotiating his next deal. But, at the same time, a guy who plays solid 2B and swats 25 homers while batting in the .280-.300 range is still awfully nice to have next year. If someone blows me away, I'm going to think really hard about it. I'm not quite sure about Arraez after this past season. He could be that guy who comes into Spring Training healthy and serves as a .330+ hitting leadoff guy next year, but he could also be a good hitter with mediocre defense everywhere. I want to believe, so my price tag for him is higher than that of Polanco. I like the swagger that Donaldson brings to the team, and I want my young guys to cut their teeth in the majors around a guy like him. I'm paying a lot for his services, but on the other hand he showed unexpectedly good durability and was a big part of the offense this year. I'd especially love for Jose Miranda and Royce Lewis to get plenty of exposure to him, but how do I manage that while still getting the kids into the lineup on a regular basis? In the end, I'm probably most likely to trade him this winter but not without several gut checks first. Buxton is going to have to personally insult my mother to her face for me to even think about backing away from contract negotiations. Yeah he's hurt a lot, but on the other hand when he's healthy he's arguably the best player in the league. My asking price gets my rival GMs to hang up on me several times this winter. I really don't want to move on from Kepler either, especially since his defense gives me a lot of roster flexibility for those times when Buxton is hurt. He's a guy that, if he begins sitting back on pitches more often, he might start beating the shift and put up video game numbers for a good long time. I don't want to be the FO that traded him away right before he does that. On the other hand, I think Trevor Larnach is an all-star right fielder before his contract is up, and I want to show ownership that I was right to pick him. My price for Kepler is almost as high as it is for Buxton. I like Garver. He's among the better hitting players in the league when healthy, and he's elite at the plate compared to the rest of the league's catchers. But, on the other hand, he's also on the wrong side of thirty and his situational hitting was pretty poor last year. And while I really like Jeffers, too, I'm not sure I want to risk the offensive drop-off that will happen when he eventually takes over for Garver just yet. I know that I'm likely to get a ridiculous haul for Garver if I were to move him this winter, so I probably do mention his name more often than the rest but also set his price tag just this side of what I'm asking for Buxton and Kepler.
  43. Who Can the Twins Deal?

    Otwins and one other reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic

    2 points
    One of Sano/Kepler has to go. Opens a spot for Kirilloff. I'd also deal Arraez if there is a market. Not sure he's worth as much as people think.
  44. Who Can the Twins Deal?

    Heiny and one other reacted to DocBauer for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Huge ^5 to the posts above I liked! Very good takes, even if I don't agree 100%. I agree Donaldson should have been included in the OP. He can't be ignored as a trade piece due to depth and replacement options. His biggest problems as a trade option are obvious and we all know them; age, injury and salary. I am and have always been OK with moving him if the right deal, presents itself. But there is also the idea of how little he may bring back prospect wise and salary relief wise vs being a good ballplayer and veteran presence and "red ass" who could bring a little fire to the team. It's not just about finding room for Miranda and others to play. A lot of times these things just work out over a full season. We've seen this over and again. But having too much talent is NOT a bad thing! That's when your manager FINDS ways to get guys in the lineup. Which is easier without a fixture at DH, which I believe will be the case in 2022. Please trade Donaldson IF IT MAKES SENSE for what you gain vs what you lose. So why do I start with Donaldson? Because keeping him or moving him affects the rest of the roster and the others proposed here in the OP. A healthy Kepler is way better than what we saw in 2021. Unless someone blows us away, you are selling low. He is a premium RF defensively and a solid CF with power who just needs to sit more against LH pitching. Despite my belief in Kirilloff, Larnach and Celestino, all other OF options are solid journeyman or prospects a year away. Garver is a good, not great, solid catcher who is one of the best offensive catchers in the game. He needs to catch 50-60% of the games and spend time at DH and maybe even a little 1B to keep his bat in the lineup. I think Jeffers has a bright future, but I'm not ready to give him the #1 spot right now and move Garver. As has been pointed out by others in various threads, you don't necessarily get better by trading someone who is amongst the best at his position. Arraez may be the best pure hitter and clutch hitter and OB hitter on the team. And with a team of talented producers with BIG TIME power you'd want to trade the BEST pure hitter, contact hitter, and OB guy? He's only 24yo and has basically 2yrs at MLB. He's OK defensively at 3 positions and can also DH. Again, why does a DH have to be ONE GUY? He will only get better, I propose, defensively with experience. He fills a needed spot in the lineup as something different than a 3 outcome player. The Sano debate has been ongoing for a few years now. You're either done with him, or, you recognize his career OPS and how dangerous he is as a streaky producer but would just love to see him as a lower fixture in the lineup as a 1B/DH and "emergency" 3B and want to hold on to him for at least one more year because he can carry a team at times. Look, I am NOT opposed to making trades to re-tool the roster. Not at all! I just don't feel moving Kepler or Garver or Arraez at this time makes roster and production sense. I think those moves potential hurt as much as they help. I'm OK with moving Donaldson and Sano if it makes sense. I think the FO WILL make some FA moves. I think they WILL make some trades. But when you make trades, you have to give up something to get something! But I'm tired of the Twins traded Gil, or Yanoa, both low A prospects to get something they thought could help the team. Doesn't every team, even the best and smartest teams, still make deals of prospects in hope of augmenting their roster? I just keep reflecting on the Odorizzi and Maeda trades. Can this FO do it a 3rd time? They need to find a quality veteran and spend the $ to lead this team and Stoman is the obvious choice. But isn't there enough milb depth to make a similar move without depleting the ML roster?
  45. When I read your comment about “roster scraps,” it pained my heart. These are all fantastic baseball players, just not among the best 780 in the world.
  46. I could be wrong too, but probably Colina WAS included with the other six. Waivers take three days and generally are unannounced during the process, so the team didn't know until now that the other six had cleared and they could be outrighted?
  47. The Cusp Guys

    TopGunn#22 and one other reacted to DJL44 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Kirilloff will be fine and I still think Larnach can turn into Geoff Jenkins. I expect both of them to start next season in AAA to get an extra year of club control and to make them earn a roster spot. I see Austin Martin claiming LF eventually because he's the better defender and he gets on base. That leaves RF for Larnach but that will mean trading Kepler to open up the spot. Is Celestino just a good 4th outfielder or can he be a starting CF? I'm not sure but he's a definite MLB talent. Can Royce Lewis play SS? They need to find that out with him in AAA to start next season. Nick Gordon can be the futility infielder until someone else beats him out. I doubt he's ever more than a bench player in the big leagues. He doesn't field well enough for SS and doesn't hit well enough to play anywhere else. Rooker is a tweener - not enough bat for DH, not enough glove to play the field. He's the kind of player who ends up playing in Japan. Remember Michael Restovich? Astudillo is just blocking Miranda. Sign him as a minor league free agent and send him to St. Paul. The Saints fans will love him. Smeltzer and Thorpe are both likely DFA. They're lefthanded so they will both get a few more chances but they'll both have to settle for minor league free agent contracts.
  48. I agree on Celestino. Assuming no trades of outfielders, I think Celestino profiles nicely as the 4th OF in 2022 playing in a platoon in RF with Kepler and being Buxton's primary backup. Let's get him 250-300 plus ABs next year and I think he could be starter material by 2023.
  49. The 40 man doesn't usually have this many easy decision. Clearly the roster depth isn't what it used to be.
  50. The Cusp Guys

    TopGunn#22 and one other reacted to 4twinsJA for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Time to move on to next group of pitchers, Winder, Duran, Balazovic, Sands, etc. Not high on potential for Smeltzer, Thorpe, Stashek. I think Jax may have a chance to contribute, Barnes-see him as #8 starter type at AAA. I haven't given up on Dobnak, possible #5 starter to open season. Need to move on from pitchers whose ceiling is borderline MLB pitcher.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.