Leaderboard
-
TheLeviathan
Old-Timey MemberPoints18,575Posts -
Nine of twelve
Verified MemberPoints5,171Posts -
-
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/04/2021 in all areas
-
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
RonCoomersOPS and 6 others reacted to terrydactyls for a post in a topic
7 pointsAnd who were the three big spenders last off season - the darlings of the hot stove league? Philadelphia, Toronto, and San Diego. How many made the playoffs? None! Money apparently doesn't buy happiness or a division winning team. Make smart moves, not expensive moves.7 points -
Week in Review: Winning Out
Week in Review: Winning Out
wabene and 5 others reacted to Nick Nelson for an article
6 pointsWeekly Snapshot: Mon, 9/27 thru Sun, 10/3 *** Record Last Week: 4-2 (Overall: 73-89) Run Differential Last Week: +4 (Overall: -105) Standing: 5th Place in AL Central (20.0 GB) Last Week's Game Recaps: Game 157 | MIN 3, DET 2: Twins Edge Tigers in Pitchers' Duel Game 158 | MIN 5, DET 2: Polanco and Pineda Propel Twins Game 159 | DET 10, MIN 7: Buxton's 2 HR Not Enough as Ryan Struggles Game 160 | KC 11, MIN 6: Pitching Plastered as Royals Pound Twins Game 161 | MIN 4, KC 0: Arms Rebound, Blank Kansas City Game 162 | MIN 7, KC 3: Twins Close Losing Year with a Win NEWS & NOTES It turns out that Bailey Ober's start the previous week would be the last of his rookie season. He was shut down ahead of his scheduled final turn with a right hip strain, although the move surely had more to do with workload management than real injury concern. Ober completes his first MLB campaign with a 4.19 ERA, 1.20 WHIP, and 96-to-19 K/BB ratio in 92 ⅓ innings spread across 20 starts. A tremendously encouraging year from the big righty, who has vaulted directly into the club's rotation plans. HIGHLIGHTS With an offseason ahead that may prove decisive in shaping his big-league future, Byron Buxton ended his season on a high note. Generally speaking, he hasn't been quite the same offensively since returning from his broken hand, but Buxton's final week looked more like his first month. He went 11-for-25 with three home runs, five doubles, and 11 runs scored, mixing in a couple of stolen bases for good measure. We're seeing something special here, folks. The question now is whether we'll have the opportunity to keep watching Buxton's magic happen in a Twins uniform. He's got one year ahead until free agency and if Minnesota can't extend him, his trade market will be too hot to ignore. The decision with Buxton this offseason will primarily dictate whether the Twins actually aspire to contend in 2022, and will likely determine whether a lot of fans choose to stick with the team or tune out for the time being. I've written in the past where I stand: pay the man, or regret it forever. You cannot let a talent like this get away. Joining Buxton with strong finishes at the plate: Josh Donaldson went 6-for-21 with four walks, two homers, and five RBIs. He started all six games, which is pretty much par for the course by now. It was a huge proving year durability-wise for the 35-year-old, who returned from an immediate IL stint to play in 133 of the club's final 150 games, starting 125. The production was there too. While he still carries plenty of risk at this point, JD looks like a much more dependable building block than he did one year ago. The late drop-off of Luis Arraez was an under-discussed storyline in the second half for the Twins. From August 19th through September 19th, he batted just .176 in 99 plate appearances, sinking his average from .318 to .284. Given the lack of real defensive value, and the absence of power or patience in his game, Arraez's value plummets pretty quickly when he's not hitting for average, and we've never seen him slump in that department quite like he did during this late stretch. So it was nice to see him snap out of it with an excellent final week, in which Arraez notched 11 hits in 20 at-bats, lifting his final average to .294. It'll be very interesting to see what the team's plan is with him going forward. Miguel Sanó went 7-for-22 with a home run, a double, and four RBIs. He rebounded from a brutal April with production the rest of the way that was basically in line with his quality career norms. He also put up the lowest overall K-rate of his career (34.3%) after leading the league in strikeouts a year ago. It was ultimately a disappointing year for Sanó but offered some promising signs, and he's vowed to focus harder than ever on his body this winter, setting a goal of losing 20-30 pounds. With Alex Kirilloff looking more like a first baseman than outfielder, Sanó is another intriguing piece in the organization's future planning. He has one more guaranteed season under team control. On the pitching side, Michael Pineda wrapped his walk year with 5 ⅔ innings of one-run ball in a win over Detroit. He returned quickly from an August oblique injury to register a 5-0 record and 1.85 ERA in five outings. That'll give the pending free agency market a boost. Griffin Jax finished a rough rookie season in a positive way, delivering his best performance as a big-leaguer on Saturday with five innings of shutout ball against Kansas City. He was hardly dominant, striking out three and walking two, but he allowed only one hit. Jax showed some promise after the All-Star break, but in his final eight starts he went 1-4 with a 7.82 ERA, erasing any chance of factoring into the Twins' rotation plans next year. That said, with his effective fastball-slider combo, he's definitely earned a look in the bullpen. Speaking of which, the Twins received impressive final weeks from a trio of key relievers. Tyler Duffey, Caleb Thielbar, and Jorge Alcala combined to allow zero earned runs over 11 frames. Tough to overstate how impactful these three are for the Twins' bullpen outlook. At the All-Star break, it wasn't clear that any of them were going to be names to comfortably write into the 2022 plans. None pitched especially well in the first half. But since the break, they've collectively posted a 2.48 ERA and 85-to-24 K/BB ratio in 83 ⅓ innings. All three are expected to return in 2022, at a little over $5 million in total salary. It's not an amazing bullpen foundation to build around, but if Taylor Rogers can return to form following his finger injury, it's certainly a viable starting point for a contending relief corps. LOWLIGHTS He's been a beaming beacon in the Highlights section nearly every week since arriving in the majors, but in his final turn as a rookie, Joe Ryan finally hit a road bump for the first time. Facing the Tigers at Target Field on Thursday, Ryan was knocked around for six earned runs in 4 ⅔ innings, with a pair of homers by Niko Goodrum accounting for much of the damage. The poor finale may diminish a bit of Ryan's shine, but hardly removes the luster from a tremendous showing in September for the rookie. He finishes with a 4.05 ERA, 3.43 FIP, 0.79 WHIP, and 30-to-5 K/BB ratio in 26 ⅔ innings. Small sample and lack of experience aside, it's tough to imagine he won't be at least tentatively penciled into a rotation spot come next spring. Will Max Kepler still be the man in right field at that time? He closed out one of the worst offensive seasons of his career with a 3-for-19 week, leaving him with a pedestrian final slash line of .211/.306/.413. Just flat-out sub-mediocre production from a right fielder. It does bear noting that Kepler supplements his value in other ways, like on the bases (10-for-10 on steals this year) and in the outfield, but with emerging corner outfield depth in the Twins system, Kepler and his favorable contract will likely be shopped on the trade market. Andrelton Simmons put the finishing touches on an all-time dud of an offensive season, going 2-for-11 with a couple of singles. He posted a .480 OPS in the second half, managing three total extra-base hits (all doubles) in 189 plate appearances. Most Twins fans will be more than happy to be rid of the pending free agent, and while his defense was customarily good this year (albeit unspectacular), I do wonder if any team will view him as a starting-caliber player on the offseason market. In an interesting trend, Simmons finally started losing some his playing time at shortstop to Nick Gordon toward the end of the year, much to the pleasure of fans who'd been clamoring for such a shift. Gordon first start at short didn't come until September 11th, by which time he'd been in the majors for three months and appeared in 55 games. From that point forward, however, he started eight of the team's final 21 games, including three times in the final week. Gordon's bat went cold during this final stretch, producing just one hit in 13 at-bats, and his overall production for the season was underwhelming (.647 OPS, 0.2 fWAR), but if he's viewed as a credible option at short, that cements his value as a utility guy. The team's usage late in the season inspires optimism on that front. TRENDING STORYLINE There are plenty of trending storylines ahead as we turn our attention to the offseason. Once a World Series champion is crowned in about one month's time, the page will turn and Hot Stove season will officially get underway. (Theoretically, anyway ... a looming CBA expiration could throw a wrench in things.) As they seek to rebound from a terrible season, the Twins face a number of key decisions this winter. Will Buxton be traded? What about dealing a semi-redundant yet valuable fixture such as Kepler, Arraez, or Sanó? Who will survive the 40-man roster crunch? How hard will Minnesota attack the free agent markets at pitcher and shortstop? There's plenty to explore as we size up a critical offseason. I'm pleased to say we'll have an exciting announcement on that topic dropping on Monday morning. Make sure you tune in for it. On a final note: a heartfelt THANK YOU to everyone who has consumed, commented on, or complimented these Week in Review columns over the course of the year. It's been fun, and for me, a good way to stay plugged into a season that was often difficult to find motivation to care about. Hopefully these weekly recaps served a similar purpose for many of you. We'll be back next year. Here's to much happier weeks to break down in 2022. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Latest Twins coverage from our writers — Recent Twins discussion in our forums — Follow Twins Daily via Twitter, Facebook or email6 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
Linus and 5 others reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic
6 pointsI'm quite worried that the idea that "we weren't that bad after mid-May" wins out and we deceive ourselves on how bad this team was. 8th worst record in all baseball, 3rd worse in AL. They need to somehow figure out how to get a pitching staff that can cover 1500 or so innings and they have basically nothing to rely on right now. Essentially, ownership has to step up and pay big in free agency. If not, the Twins should just blow it all up, trade everyone with any value, and look forward to 2024.6 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
LastOnePicked and 4 others reacted to wsnydes for a post in a topic
5 pointsOn a more serious note, thanks to @Matthew Lenz and all of the game recappers. I'm sure that they're not always an enjoyable assignment, but I look to them every day!5 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
Linus and 4 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
5 pointsThis is what we needed in the 2020-21 offseason, and this FO couldn't deliver. Now the SS need is even greater and 3-4 starters are needed. I appreciate positivity, but the hole we're in is a lot deeper than folks think.5 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
milkytoast and 4 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
5 pointsA top contender in the 2021 preposterous statement tournament. Not even the most disappointing season this year. The Nationals lost 97 games in a year they had Max Scherzer, Juan Soto, Trea Turner, Kyle Schwarber, and Josh Bell on roster. The Cubs lost 91 games with an even more talented lineup on roster during the season.5 points -
One Season-Defining Moment from Each Month of 2021
One Season-Defining Moment from Each Month of 2021
glunn and 3 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
4 pointsOctober: in a rather weird twist, Twins and Vikings seasons end on the same day.4 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
Danchat and 3 others reacted to KirbyDome89 for a post in a topic
4 pointsThey still finished 7 games below .500 from June 1st through yesterday. I don't see moving from a 100+ loss pace to one in the high 80s as a silver lining. They were just as bad in June, and worse in July. They sunk themselves in April & May, but the poor play didn't stop there.4 points -
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Basking in Buxton’s Season
DocBauer and 3 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
4 pointsHas anyone’s mind changed due to Buxton’s last month of play? From what I can gather, everyone commenting here has been entrenched in their opinion for a long time. I’m glad my employment is not on the line making this call. There isn’t a previous example of negotiating long term with a player who’s played over 100 games once in a 6 year career. The terms that were discussed before (7/$70) terrify me, frankly. The contract length could torpedo this organization if he can’t stay healthy. It might be worth the risk, but it could just as easily blow up in their face as he loses speed and defensive chops into his 30s.4 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
wsnydes and 3 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
4 pointsPre-season, 90 wins was a common win total not just for fans, but publications around the league. It’s amazing that the Twins only provided one week of hope for making the playoffs. They started 5-2, overcoming some shaky play, then the wheels flew off. This game against the A’s sticks out as the most frustrating game in the season: Twins @ A’s April 21, 2021 You knew things weren’t going to go our way after blowing 5 leads in that game. Whether we want to admit it or not, they were out of it by May 1, which made this an extremely long season.4 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
DocBauer and 3 others reacted to stringer bell for a post in a topic
4 pointsLooking at run differential and where they ended in most team stats, I think the Twins pretty much got the record they deserved. I'll repeat my observation that just about anything that could have gone wrong did and at the worst possible moment early in the season. But over the course of the year, it seemed that things evened out. There is a lot of work to be done. The club needs to rebuild their starting rotation, fill about half of the bullpen and find a shortstop who can make the plays in the field and isn't at the bottom of hitting statistics. Moreover, I think the club has way to many guys whose calling card is hitting homers and too few that are good at making contact and being as asset in the field and on the bases. With a little tweaking, I think the Twins can be at or above .500, but in order to challenge for post season play, they need to augment their pitching staff and add quality at shortstop.4 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
HerbieFan and 3 others reacted to LastOnePicked for a post in a topic
4 pointsPart of me agrees, and part of me thinks that's a clear sign we're sliding back into an era of diminished expectations. They were the third-worst team in the AL in 2021. That's beyond terrible for a team expected by most to win the division. Some big changes better be coming, and we fans better demand that the FO follows through on all their big talk about "retooling not rebuilding."4 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Mike Sixel and 3 others reacted to Nine of twelve for a post in a topic
4 pointsI've said a million times not to exaggerate.4 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
nicksaviking and 3 others reacted to Nine of twelve for a post in a topic
4 pointsThey played competitively for most of the season. There was the season-killing stretch in April and May when they went 9-26. They were 64-63 otherwise. Had they not gone through that horrid time the front office would have done things much differently and that 64-63 might have been even better.4 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
mikelink45 and 3 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
4 points"One of the most disappointing seasons in MLB history"??4 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
RpR and 2 others reacted to Nine of twelve for a post in a topic
3 pointsEach year has two seasons: baseball season and waiting for baseball season.3 points -
The fallacy of Free Agency AAV @ 8M per WAR
What is a free agent worth? $8M AAV per WAR. That's what they all tell me. It never felt right because it never seems to work out that way, ESPECIALLY for the top end of the FA market. It is based on this article ( https://blogs.fangraphs.com/the-cost-of-a-win-in-free-agency-in-2020/ ) as well as an older article that he reference a couple times There are two problems here. 1) He is relying on future WAR projections, attempting to quantify the Qualifying Offer silliness (not his silliness... the system's silliness), as well as some other assumptions. All of these things might seem logical on their own but once you roll them all together things get messy and lack real world context. 2) That's not how people are using his work. They are looking at past WAR and saying "based on his 2.3 WAR average the last two seasons he's worth 20M in free agency." -- Spolier Alert: 2.3 WAR players are lucky to get half of that in free agency --. Even for the people that might claim that they are actually saying that player provided 20M in VALUE .... That's not true either. In 2021 MLB payrolls were about $4 Billion and Players provided about 650 positive WAR. So really in that context a "WAR" is worth $6M. ($4B/650), but that's not really what I'm after here. I'm after what is actually happening in free agency and how it correlates to past performance. Here it is. I looked at the top 20 free agents (according to MLB Trade Rumors) from two recent offseasons, looked at their free agent contract AAV, then looked up their WAR from the previous three seasons (fWAR in this case). I looked at it two similar ways. First was just their WAR from the season before free agency, and second I looked at it based on the average of their previous two seasons. Key points: The average is right around $6.0M/WAR (There's that number again) Almost nobody gets 8.0/WAR. If they do it's usually one of two special circumstances. a) They're a RP, or b) they missed a bunch of time which suppressed their WAR in a given season The top end free agents definitely don't get $8/WAR. They are more around $5/WAR Conclusion: We can project future value, make assumptions, and try to account for market factors all we want, but at the end of the day, the numbers are the numbers. We have baseball-wide economics telling us that the value of 1.0WAR is about $6M ($4B/650WAR) and we have front offices signing free agents at about $6M per WAR from previous seasons. Maybe the number we should start using for projecting free agent AAV is $6M, not $8M3 points
-
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
wabene and 2 others reacted to KirbyDome89 for a post in a topic
3 pointsYou extrapolated a single instance of an individual blowing through a 100K signing bonus to "The thing that struck me was that it seems like a lot of these MiLB players make pretty poor decisions on their finances," and then made the claim that financial illiteracy was a societal issue, i.e. not baseball's problem. Your argument is that because young adults might not have their finances completely dialed in, it's therefore justifiable for MLB to underpay them by a ridiculous amount. I mean..... When you're forced to bunk 2+ to a room or keep the cost of every meal you consume to $5, just so you can put a couple hundred into savings each month, you're living the definition of check to check.3 points -
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Basking in Buxton’s Season
DocBauer and 2 others reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
3 pointsWalk away for now and explore the market. I won't guarantee him 200M because I am bidding against myself. He won't get that much in guarantees unless he plays 150 games at an MVP level. I would play those odds. The fact it was reported 7/105 was a real negotiation point tells me that counter would be silly.3 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
Major League Ready and 2 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
3 pointsSo, the years before this one just didn't happen? I just don't get this thought at all. They have a great minor league system. Much, much better than when they came. They have Ober and Ryan, neither of whom is Berrios, but the two of them are better than anyone not named Berrios from the years before they came. My thought is they thought Shoemaker was a placeholder for a AA/AAA arm. That arm turned out to be Ober, but they didn't want to start with a rookie in April.3 points -
40 Man Roster Management October Update
Rooker had a ball hit off the wall over his head yesterday for a "double". Dan Gladden and Corey Provus both said that was a ball that should have been easily caught and pointed out how Rooker's footwork was exactly the wrong way to do that. He has a lot of work to do to be adequate, I think.3 points
-
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Basking in Buxton’s Season
DocBauer and 2 others reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
3 pointsLol. Of course I can't prove that. Man, rather than accept the scientifically verified data that there are reasons some people get injured more than others you went straight off the rails. Your contention that injuries are purely luck based has been debunked. I won't argue with strawmen, sorry.3 points -
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
Mike Sixel and 2 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
3 pointsI find it interesting that so many people want to rid ourselves of players that are actually producing. And, how great the exceptions are for prospects to immediately field openings and produce at MLB levels because they had a great year in the minors. The players to move are Astudillo and Arraez. Arraez through trade and Astudillo by removing him from the 40-man. If he doesn't get picked up, then we can assign him to AAA. Miranda comes up to spell Donaldson at third, maybe play some outfield. It's a huuuuge assumption that Miranda will just instantly become this MLB fixture. All prospects need some time. If he looks like he can take over, then you move Donaldson (or try to) mid season or next off season, but now is not the time. I mean ... we actually want to improve the team, and getting rid of Donaldson to replace him with Miranda does not do that3 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
wabene and 2 others reacted to Dantes929 for a post in a topic
3 pointsI believe they have now missed the playoffs 8 times. To put into perspective though, in that time period, the Indians have missed the playoffs 7 times. the White Sox 10 times, the Tigers 8 times and the Royals 10 times. Making the playoffs a third of the time when there are 5 teams trying for it every year isn't really so bad. The last place finishes are more remarkable.3 points -
Week in Review: Winning Out
Week in Review: Winning Out
tarheeltwinsfan and 2 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
3 pointsThese weekly recaps are a strong addition to TD. Well done Nick.3 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
DocBauer and 2 others reacted to Brandon for a post in a topic
3 pointsI guess I see that the fall happened in April and May. There were adjustments made and yes we need more help, but at this point its just a few players. We need a good SS and 2 starters and a reliever. Beyond that we should be set.3 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
wabene and 2 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
3 pointsYeah. Pointless understatement. How about, THE most disappointing result in the history of human endeavor.3 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
DocBauer and 2 others reacted to Nine of twelve for a post in a topic
3 pointsThis, and getting a pitcher or two.3 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
DocBauer and 2 others reacted to Brandon for a post in a topic
3 pointsI will also add they didn't quit like past teams. and that is something I appreciate. while I am not happy with their record I am happy they went 6-4 their last 10 games to avoid 90 losses. This gave us something to root for the last week. Also I think with better health on offense and continued development and no more covid shut downs in the minors we should be back to winning around 90 games next year.3 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
milkytoast and 2 others reacted to BH67 for a post in a topic
3 pointsBuxton finishes 2021 with a 1.005 OPS.3 points -
Minor League Report (10/3): Closing Time
Minor League Report (10/3): Closing Time
Devilsadvocate and 2 others reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
3 pointsThank you for the milb game summaries. This is a big reason I come to Twins Daily.3 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
3 pointsTwins go from first to last. Didn’t they once go from last to World Series champs? Can they do it again?3 points
-
Maggi returned to minors without getting into a game
Maggi returned to minors without getting into a game
ashbury and 2 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
3 pointsMaybe this means they’ve already seen enough of Maggi to make him the opening day shortstop next year.3 points -
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Mike Frasier Law and 2 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
3 pointsThere is nothing the front office can do this offseason more important than getting Buxton under contract. Whatever it takes. Pay the man. It's criminal it has gone this long.3 points -
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
Mike Sixel and 2 others reacted to joefish for a post in a topic
3 pointsI don't want to see Jorge starting at SS. No. Gotta get better defender. Make ss a priority.3 points -
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
Squirrel and 2 others reacted to tony&rodney for a post in a topic
3 pointsI'm also confused why anyone sees Donaldson as anything other than a positive for the Twins. I guess it continues to beg the question - what are the Twins plans going forward? Jose Miranda has had a terrific season and if he is ready to contribute at the major league level there will be a spot for him. He can be a piece next year or perhaps included in a trade for pitching. If the Twins are planning to be competitive next season (.500 or better), they will need to explore every decent free agent and trade possible. Every single player can be traded from the current roster if the trade makes the team better. Obviously, there are players we want to hold (Polanco, Buxton, Donaldson) or develop further (Ryan, etc.), but the goal needs to focus on a better team in 2022. Miranda needs to play where he is a better defender. If he can play an average LF and hit, fine. The Twins do not need any more weak defenders. I'm hoping he gets 500-600 at bats next year for the Twins and hits .280 with production as well as playing sound defense, likely between 3B, 1B, and 2B.3 points -
Is Brent Rooker Better Than His Stats?
Among Twins fans, few players have been given a shorter leash despite showing flashes of solid play than Brent Rooker. While Rooker’s results in 2021 have hardly been inspiring, the underlying data says Rooker may be much better than his weak triple slash has shown so far. So what are his “results” so far? Regardless of the metrics you want to use, be it the traditional triple slash or others: .201/.294/.397, OPS .691, wRC+ 91, wOBA .302 or OPS+ 90, Rooker’s offensive production has been below par. In fact, for somebody who is touted as a glorified DH, way below par. Rooker would really be expected to produce an OPS above .750 to remain viable and over .800 to produce good value. Of the 15 players who qualify as “DH” with more than 300 plate appearances in MLB this year on Fangraphs, the median OPS is Josh Donaldson’s .816. On his way to the triple slash he’s produced, Rooker has struck out 32.5% of the time while walking in just 7.6% of his plate appearances. That’s not a great ratio, but for a power hitter, 32.5% K rate isn’t unusual and it’s also in only 197 plate appearances so far this year. This is, for all intents and purposes, Rooker’s rookie season and his first taste of MLB action after showing far above average production in the high minors for years now. The question at this point is not whether Brent Rooker is too good for AAA, it’s whether or not he’s destined to be labeled a AAAA player. I’ve seen some other posts suggesting Brent Rooker may be cooked already, but a dive into some of the advanced metrics show a very different set of numbers. AVG OBP SLG OPS wOBA Actual .201 .294 .397 .691 .312 Expected* .236 .325 .448 .773 .345 *BaseballSavant has xBA at .237 and xSLG at .449 which result in 41.24 hits and 78.13 total bases. Those aren’t real numbers so I rounded them down to 41 hits and 78 total bases. I used Rookers actual walks and hit by pitch numbers to calculate his new xOBP so I could calculate his xOPS. So Rooker’s expected batting line numbers are far better than his actual results, but that can be true for a lot of hitters who don’t use the whole field because of the shift; however, Rooker is not the typical dead pull hitter who is helpless against the shift. Of course, Rooker does pull the ball a lot, 44% of the time in fact, but he also goes to the opposite field 26% of the time. Among qualified hitters, Rooker is actually in the top half of hitters going to the opposite field and he’s not in the top 25% in pull hitting. Fangraphs has limited data on Rooker’s plate appearances, but he gets shifted against about 59% of the time vs. say Max Kepler who gets shifted against 97% of the time (yes, 97% is the real number). Another consideration is whether or not the shift should even actually hurt a hitter. Ground ball hitters are hurt the most, then fly ball hitters, then line drive hitters. The shift is less effective against line drive hitters because the balls generally have high exit velocities and hit the ground quickly so even if defenders are “shifted,” the ball really has to be hit directly at the defender in order to have a play. Despite his excellent power, Rooker is more a line drive hitter than a pure fly ball hitter. He very rarely pops the ball up, and Fangraphs has him at 26% line drive and 38% fly ball with Baseball Savant having him at 31% line drive and 31% fly ball. With Rooker’s batted ball profile, the shift should not be highly effective against him. Beyond Rooker being somewhat shielded from the shift, there are other things to consider when it comes to hitting. Exit velocity, launch angle, hard hit and barrel rates are extremely important when trying to figure out whether or not a hitters bad luck is actually bad luck and not a function of just a lot of weak contact. Rooker’s average exit velocity is very good at 90.9mph (top 82% in baseball). His launch angle is 12.8% this year which reflects the high line drive rate, but it’s not quite high enough to be “optimal” for a hitter with Rooker’s power. There’s a hard core, in depth article on Fangraphs if you’re interested in getting into the deep end of the pool (I’m not, haha). https://fantasy.fangraphs.com/lets-talk-about-launch-angle-generally/ Rooker would probably experience better slash lines and an increase in home runs with a launch angle closer to 20* because of his power, but he should be very close to having his optimal batting average where he is. What about hard hit rate? Fangraphs says Rooker is 35.5% hard hit rate based on Baseball Info Solutions algorithms, which is good for the top 37% of hitters with 300 plate appearances, but BaseballSavant has Rooker with a higher 47.6% hard hit rate (different definition at 95mph+) and puts him in the top 15% of hitters with 100+ batted ball events. When it comes to barrel rate, Rooker is showing up as 11.8% putting him in the top 16% of hitters for Fangraphs and BaseballSavant. Btw, think of barrel rate as absolutely crushing a ball. The baseline is a launch angle of 25-31* and an exit velocity of at least 98mph. For every 1mph of exit velocity you add, you get about 2 degrees more leniency in the launch angle. Like 100mph gets you to 24-33*. It’s that no doubter home run or absolute rocket off the bat where no amount of shift makes any difference because the ball is in the outfield before the infielders even know what happened. Some charts to help folks who don’t follow metrics closely. This data was pulled from Fangraphs using Statcast numbers for the 252 players with at least 300 plate appearances this year prior to today. Rooker himself was not included as he only has 197. Now we can discuss his plate discipline. Does Rooker have the hit tool to play at the MLB level? How do opposing pitchers view him? BaseballSavant shows pitchers have become wary of testing Rooker, throwing him fewer fastballs and more breaking balls while avoiding the strike zone as much as possible. Interestingly enough, Rooker has better results against the breaking balls than fastballs, but according to the expected data, it should be the exact opposite. Rooker against the fastball is batting just .177 with a SLG of .375, but his xBA is 80 points higher at .256 and his xSLG is .487. Rooker’s performance against breaking balls is closer to where it should be with a .245 AVG vs. xBA of .225 and a SLG of .434 vs. an xSLG of .418. His bat is not a black hole against breaking pitches in practice or theory and his bat looks like it should be downright dangerous against fastballs and changeups. In regard to plate discipline, Fangraphs shows his O-swing% (swing percentage of pitches outside the zone) at 30.6-32.3% depending on the source, but that’s not bad at all. His PitchFX data shows Rooker swinging outside the zone at 32.3%, which would rank as better than 43.5% of MLB hitters with more than 300 plate appearances so far this year. A tick below average. His contact rate on balls outside the zone does need some work suggesting he can be completely fooled a bit too easily. His Z-swing% (swing percentage of pitches inside the zone) rates are a little lower than they should be and Rooker takes too many called strikes because he’s not aggressive enough when he gets a pitch in the zone. Again, based on players with 300+ plate appearances from PitchFX data on Fangraphs. Lastly, something pretty interesting to me. Defense. While Rooker carries with him the expectation he’s a lost cause at the corners, BaseballSavant hints at Rooker not being a guaranteed waste in the outfield. Rooker’s sprint speed is above average. Yes. You read that right. His sprint speed on BaseballSavant shows 27.3 ft/sec, above average for an MLB player or left fielder for that matter. His defensive metrics show Rooker is above average when it comes to route running, but his reaction is terrible (feet in 0 to 1.5 seconds) with Rooker’s acceleration in sprint speed being iffy. The combination of Rooker not recognizing the ball off the bat quickly enough and his mediocre acceleration is what is hurting Rooker defensively. Some of that can be improved with work and experience, though it’s a little bit late for Rooker to take an active role in becoming a better fielder. In summary, What does all of this mean? Well, for starters, we don’t have a ton of data on Brent Rooker. He’s only at 197 plate appearances this season and a paltry 21 from 2020. At about 200 plate appearances in a season is where the first set of luck metrics just start stabilizing and they move quite a bit to 300 plate appearances where things start to get pretty stable. Rooker shows adequate plate discipline, his batted ball profile suggests he’s having terrible luck, but he’s frequently shown off his power. Opposing pitchers have formed enough respect for Rooker that they’ve made the adjustment to try to avoid throwing him anything decent to hit and Rooker hasn’t turned into a strikeout machine in the process. Rooker is primarily a pull hitter, but he’s gone to the opposite field enough to keep defenses semi-honest on the shift. Rooker also hits the ball much harder than the average major leaguer, he barrels up the ball well enough and doesn’t make a lot of weak contact. It seems like Rooker needs to be more aggressive when he gets a strike rather than waiting for a meatball because MLB pitchers are definitely being extra careful not to give him something easy to hit and MLB pitchers do not make mistakes like MiLB pitchers do. An MLB hitter might see 1 mistake pitch per game vs seeing several in the minors. Defensively, he waits a little too long to make a jump on the ball and he could work on improving his running technique to get better off the line acceleration, but he has the speed to cover a corner outfield position. With a little opportunity for his luck to even out and some minor adjustments, Rooker may turn into a real force at the plate with adequate corner outfield defense. Despite his limitations, it’s too soon to pull the plug on Rooker as he’s definitely got the potential to be a legitimate every day starting MLB player.2 points
-
The Bradbury Award.
The Bradbury Award.
wabene and one other reacted to the_neds for a post in a topic
2 pointsLet me preface this with a disclaimer: I'm Australian. I tell you this because - firstly, that means there might be some colloquialisms in here that you scratch your head about. Secondly, it explains why the man I have named this award after is considered such a folk hero. In 2002, Australian speed skater Steven Bradbury competed at the Winter Olympics. He won his heat of the 1000m short track event, scraped through the quarter finals after someone else was disqualified, won his semi final after trailing all the other competitors and watching them crash out and advanced to the final. In the final, he was well off the pace by a good 15 metres. The four medal contenders - all far ahead of him - were jostling as they raced to edge each other out for gold and avoid missing the podium. All four of them crashed, leaving Bradbury unimpeded, and he skated past them all to win gold. Thus, a legend was born. Immediately thrust into the vernacular, in Australia to 'chuck a Bradbury' means to succeed unexpectedly against all odds. The man was featured on a postage stamp. Truly, an icon. Dude has probably never paid for a beer at the local in the last 19 years. And that brings me to an award with absolutely no merit other than it tickling me, The Bradbury. The Bradbury is going to be awarded to Minnesota Twins players who have succeeded unexpectedly, maybe even after the successive failures of those who should have succeeded ahead of them. Honestly, the 2021 season was pretty heartbreaking from start to finish, but it has had some exceedingly bright and entertaining moments. I've selected two recipients for this, the inaugural Bradbury Award, as there seemed to be a distinct tale of two players who could have fit the bill - one for a short stretch, one for a longer stretch. Bradbury Award: Season 2021 Runner Up - Rob Refsnyder. This award almost got named The Ref. Let's be real, this guy had no business being as awesome he was through the start of the year. Nobody saw it coming. Refsnyder has played for about seven thousand different teams now, mostly being held to the Minors with his brief appearances for the Major League clubs proving underwhelming. He signed a minors deal with the Twins after the 2020 season and started the 2021 year in St Paul, until the Center Field Curse hit and both Byron Buxton and Max Kepler hit the injured list. Despite never playing in the position before, The Ref gof the call-up out of sheer desperation, and proceeded to go on a tear, cracking .320 over 16 games and committing just a single fielding error before he came off second best in a fight against the wall at Camden Yards and hit the injured list with concussion. I wish I could say that he performed as well after he returned but that concussion seemed to sap all of his magic powers and he basically finished the year without batting over .200 again, flipping back and forth off the injured list and spending a chunk of time in the Minors. Bradbury Award: Season 2021 Winner - Bailey Ober Bailey Freakin' Ober, man. The only tale of woe that comes close to the Center Field Curse (how far down did we go, exactly? Five? Six?) this year was the dramatic implosion of the Minnesota Twins rotation. On paper, they should have been ready to contend. Kenta Maeda was Cy Young runner up in 2020 so we had no worries about him. Berrìos was coming off another solidly impressive year. JA Happ and Matt Shoemaker were touted to be great value for money additions to the rotation. Dobnak's offseason extension was talked about as putting stability in the rotation long term. Pineda was a workhorse who could guarantee you innings with minimal damage. And it couldn't have gone any worse. Maeda was shaky, showing flashes of the ace we'd seen in the 2020 season mixed with an unprecedented lack of command. Eventually he hit the injured list and it was the worst news possible - Tommy John surgery, or a new hybrid version of it, was performed and we now won't see Maeda until the latter half of 2022 in a best case scenario. Pineda went back and forth on the injured list three times even though he did post good innings when he was around. Dobnak looked nothing like the moustachioed folk hero who'd pitched his way from part-time Uber driving into the post-season, and has battled a right finger strain since June. JA Happ was traded away at the deadline after posting a 6.77 ERA in the first half of the year. And Shoemaker was designated for assignment before being sent to St Paul and eventually being released, slinging some interesting accusations about the pitching staff on the way out. He's now causing woe in someone else's minor league system. Pineda was proving consistent despite the minor injuries but he and Berrìos alone could not carry an entire rotation. Especially after we traded Berrìos to the Blue Jays for a haul of prospects, essentially saying goodbye to our best and most consistent starter. So, what to do? Enter Bailey Ober. Ober was a surprising addition to the 40-man roster, in a move to protect him from the Rule 5 Draft. He was called up mid-May, and since that date has performed like he's always been here. He's been a steady, quiet performer, starting 20 games and posting a 4.19 over the season. His stuff is - in my personal opinion - a lot better than the 4.19 suggests, and that's backed up by the 9.36 K/9 he posted. He was very carefully managed in pitch count by Baldelli this season - sometimes frustratingly so, but the management paid off. He pitched 92 innings for the year - his highest number ever, Ober finished the year almost entirely avoiding the injured list, only succumbing to a hip strain last week that meant he would miss his final start for the season. It surely seems like - in a year where every possible thing that could deplete a starting rotation happened, Ober became a reliable mainstay through the season. Would we have seen Ober this year had the rotation not completely fallen apart? Maybe in September callups. But honestly, probably not. He wasn't talked about as a high ranking prospect. However you look at next year's rotation and Ober seems like he's a lock to start - Pineda is a free agent (hello baseball gods, please re-sign Big Mike), Maeda is off long term, mid season fill-ins Gant and Jax don't quite seem up to the task. The only certainties seem to be Ober and new addition Joe Ryan in a rotation that is very much in flux for a Twins team that wants to contend in 2022. So Bailey Ober, you win the 2021 Bradbury Award. Congratulations. It was an absolute melding of catastrophe that brought you into the team, but I am ever so glad you're here.2 points -
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
Does MLB need to change way minor league players live?
PseudoSABR and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
2 pointsNo one can live on the current minimum wage. Are you arguing that minor leaguers are paid a living wage, or that they should not be paid a living wage? https://www.foxsports.com/stories/mlb/ben-verlander-minor-league-baseball-player-not-so-glamorous-life-behind-the-scenes https://bleacherreport.com/articles/2062307-an-inside-look-into-the-harsh-conditions-of-minor-league-baseball https://www.sportingnews.com/us/mlb/news/even-after-overdue-salary-bump-baseballs-minor-leaguers-still-paid-far-below-nba-nhl-counterparts/1gpql94asy7a10uo5nvc3yp4k https://www.espn.com/mlb/story/_/id/32172108/can-union-fix-minor-leaguers-say-poverty-level-pay-poor-housing-driving-mental-health-crisis that took me all of 3 minutes.2 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
wsnydes and one other reacted to KirbyDome89 for a post in a topic
2 pointsThe two aren't mutually exclusive. Who is arguing that they shouldn't make smart moves?2 points -
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Basking in Buxton’s Season
DocBauer and one other reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
2 pointsAnytime Buck can play baseball for a long stretch and not get hurt is a win. 7/125 with incentives is still where I am.2 points -
And the season comes to an end.
And the season comes to an end.
Danchat and one other reacted to cHawk for a post in a topic
2 pointsThis. Exactly this. There’s a reason the Rays are in the playoffs and the Mets and Padres are not.2 points -
And the season comes to an end.
2 pointsI don't think that just because one acknowledges that they weren't that bad after mid-May, that it means that that line of logic carries into next season. They played one game below .500 since their low point mid-May, IIRC. That's not great, I don't think anyone is suggesting otherwise. Considering everything that happened to this team, there is some positivity related to that. However, that obviously doesn't give them a pass going into next season. Clearly they have work to do heading into next season.2 points
-
Basking in Buxton’s Season
Basking in Buxton’s Season
KGB and one other reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic
2 pointshttps://www.theatlantic.com/health/archive/2015/02/the-genetics-of-being-injury-prone/385257/ This is but one study of many that debunks this whole "Injuries are a matter of luck" argument. Muscle flexibility, technique, genetics, injury history, etc. If the Twins gamble on him, and I hope they do, it IS a gamble. He needs to start playing 100+ games a season. Not 55.2 points -
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
Game Score: Twins 7, Royals 3
milkytoast and one other reacted to Old Twins Cap for a post in a topic
2 pointsYeah, me too. Buxton could be Willy Mays over the next five years. I will never get over watching him win the World Series for the Yanks or Dodgers. DO SOMETHING Falvine!2 points -
Minor League Report (10/3): Closing Time
Minor League Report (10/3): Closing Time
Danchat and one other reacted to roger for a post in a topic
2 pointsWasn’t it fantastic having their AAA club in St. Paul? Hopefully several guys like Maggi, Kerrigan, Telis and a few more will be back so the fans can connect with a good part of the team.2 points -
Ticking Time on The Doof
Ticking Time on The Doof
DocBauer and one other reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
2 pointsSign the Duff. Sign Buck. Sign Buck. Sign Buck. Sign Buck.2 points -
Simmons Wants to Know the Real Story Behind Reliever’s Broken Hand
Simmons Wants to Know the Real Story Behind Reliever’s Broken Hand
woolywoolhouse and one other reacted to a-wan for a post in a topic
2 pointsThat is discernibly false, yes, with the variants the vaccines especially the mRNA vaccines are not as great at preventing spread as they were initially but they still do prevent spread in those are fully vaccinated. It isn’t 100%, but the mRNA vaccines do slow the spread. Whether due to lower viral load in the fully vaccinated person, they would be less likely to spread to others.2 points -
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
chpettit19 and one other reacted to chopper0080 for a post in a topic
2 pointsIf there is a serious desire to get Miranda regular reps in the majors, the move is to move Sano. Donaldson is a fairly consistent player that young players can depend on, he can play a couple different spots as needed, and will take pressure of young players to produce. He is the type of guy you keep with a young roster. Sano is just too inconsistent to have hang around because his strikeouts are a lot for a roster to deal with that is trying to build confidence and grow, Also, his lack of versatility hinders the managers ability to shift players around to give young players and vets the rest they need. I like Sano, but he is a player best suited for an established roster. Keeping Polanco at 2B should be priority 1 and should not be shifted to give unproven MLB players reps. Putting consistency around Larnach, Miranda, Kiriloff and the other young players on the verge should be priority 2. I feel like Donaldson does that more than Sano.2 points -
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
What Happens to the Twins Emerging Star?
Twins33 and one other reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
2 pointsI do not have the solution, but would have loved to see Miranda get some MLB exposure. However, moving Donaldson to DH does not work for me, I watched him run out to LF and catch a fly that I don't believe more than 2 or 3 players would have gotten to. His bat is valuable, but so is his glove. I want Miranda up, but I do not know where.2 points