Leaderboard
-
Mike Sixel
Old-Timey MemberPoints36,790Posts -
-
-
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 11/24/2019 in all areas
-
Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
For all who asked for it here's a link to calculate the State Tax Affect Not interested in the Spreadsheet here's what $10M looks like for each team in the 2020 Season (Yes it calculates based on the Home Team State for every game*) For those who believe that it costs more to live in some states here's one that is Dollar Value Adjusted based on the home state * - I thought about adjusting for the Field of Dreams Game in Iowa (Yankees @ White Sox) or Puerto Rico Series (Mets @ Marlins 3 games) but had spent enough time with this so sue me for not including those adjustments Here's links for where I came up with the rates: Value of a Dollar by State Value of a Canadian Dollar Schedule info Income Tax Rates Pro Players Tax in Canada8 points
-
Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
Melissa and 6 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
7 pointsIsn't Kendrick a plus defender at first, who could play third occasionally? Who hit better, him or Cron? Which will cost more? Depending on how you answer those questions, I'd consider changing your answer...7 points -
The Value of Prospects
The Value of Prospects
Hosken Bombo Disco and 4 others reacted to biggentleben for a post in a topic
5 pointsOr both have been in roles that required that mindset. With Friedman, he's been with a team that had minimal money to spend overall and then a team with significant long-term money spent that needed to maximize on the edges to stay under luxury tax, so prospects would always have high value. Dombrowski has, in fact, built a winner from within. He cleared off an older roster in the early 1990s in Montreal to give playing time to guys like DeShields, Walker, and Grissom while drafting guys like Cliff Floyd, Mark Grudzielanek, and Rondell White before heading to take over the Marlins in 1992. There, he made Charles Johnson his first draft pick and in the organization's first season traded for 24 y/o Gary Sheffield. He plugged in Robb Nen and acquired guys like Quilvio Veras for the lineup. Heck, a look at the expansion draft for the Marlins, orchestrated by Dombrowski is a sign of just how in tune he is to roster construction via young players - Bret Barberie, Trevor Hoffman, Chuck Carr, Bryan Harvey, Jeff Conine, Carl Everett, David Weathers, and Robert Person, along with another 3-4 guys who were decent middle relievers were all in that expansion draft. The 1997 team is infamous for having a ton of big-time players, but Kevin Brown, Al Leiter, Alex Fernandez, Devon White, Moises Alou, and Bobby Bonilla were all free agent signings, none of them costing prospects, and that '97 team famously played rookies Luis Castillo and Edgar Renteria up the middle and even with three FA starters, rookie Livan Hernandez was their playoff hero on the mound (along with Eric Gregg). Ownership forced the tear-down after the 1997 season, but the team that won in 2003 was built largely on the back of Dombrowski as well, with guys like Beckett, Adrian Gonzalez, and Josh Willingham coming from his drafts between 1998-2001, and 2003 cornerstones like Derrek Lee, A.J. Burnett, Juan Pierre (via Preston Wilson), Braden Looper, Mike Lowell, Brad Penny, and Dontrelle Willis (via Matt Clement) were all part of trades between the end of that World Series and his departure after the 2001 season. Add in that he signed Miguel Cabrera in that time, and he built a pretty incredible team that eventually won in 2003 again.5 points -
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
It's November, not March, my friend, so let's give them some time here. You're being a bit uncharitable. While most of us agree that the Pressly trade created a glaring hole and therefore was ill-advised, even THAT trade may eventually turn out okay for the Twins. Escobar may very well have been dismayed, like Dozier seemed to be, by what he perceived (rightly in HIS case) to be an unenthusiastic attempt to re-sign him. In Dozier's case, I'm sorry, but that was a fabulous decision to pass on him. We spent less to get MUCH more in the way of production AND we got Raley and Smeltzer, whose 0.7 WAR was the equal of what bench player Dozier generated for WSN. I personally LOVED the Dozier trade. Many of us didn't really like the Escobar trade, although the final hour acquisition of Marwin softened the blow, and now Alcala and Celestino are at least valuable enough to warrant 40-man spots. The jury is still out, too early to call that one a fleecing. The off-season isn't over, and I recall a few rants like yours a year ago too, before we had any inkling that they'd assemble a staff and a roster that would bring us 101 wins and a division title.5 points
-
Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
tvagle and 3 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
4 points4 points- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
I think that this is a factor for players who have smart advisers, but would note: 1. TX, FL and WA have zero income taxes. Does this help the Rangers, Astros, Marlins, Rays and Mariners score top free agents? 2. My understanding is that states that have income taxes pro-rate income based on time spent in the state. So even a player whose team is in a no tax state will pay taxes in every state where he plays. For this reason, a careful adviser would make a spreadsheet that takes this into account. For example a player in the AL West will play a lot of games in California (the highest tax state) and Texas and Washington (which have no state income taxes). 3. The rest of the AL Central includes states with moderate top rates -- Ohio (5%), Michigan (4.25%), Kansas (5.7%) and Illinois (4.95%). 4. Assuming that spring training counts, it's better to play for a team that has spring training in Florida (0%) versus Arizona (4.54%). The Twins train in Florida. 5. If the Twins wanted to pay me for 5 hours or so of number crunching, I think that I could prepare a spreadsheet that rebuts the article.4 points- Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
Vanimal46 and 2 others reacted to darin617 for a post in a topic
3 pointsI will probably get savaged for this. With nothing happening now we could use something to distract ourselves for a moment. .3 points- Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
Melissa and 2 others reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
3 pointsAvila would be a nice back-up to Garver and add a veteran presence with young pitching. I had not thought about Kendrick but he would be a good bridge if we could get him on a 1 year deal. Would prefer to see the rumor of Josh Donaldson come to fruition and move Sano over. Wow... that would be a scary offense. Add Wheeler and Pineada and you have a 105 win team, right!3 points- Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
Tom Froemming and 2 others reacted to tarheeltwinsfan for a post in a topic
3 pointsTimely and important article Tom. Thank you.3 points- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
Monkeypaws and 2 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
3 pointsSo the Angels have no chance to sign Cole then,I guess. And no free agent will ever go to California, like, I don't know, the most expensive one last year..... Just another excuse. If they want a guy, offer him a little more.... If that's really a sticking point3 points- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
Cost of living on the east coast would more than offset the tax variance. I can't believe this is a huge determinant.3 points- Music
Music
Craig Arko and one other reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
2 pointsI don't know what it is, but I never tire of hearing/listening to 'The Planets' by Gustav Holst; especially by a really great orchestra, live.2 points- Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
brvama and one other reacted to Tom Froemming for a post in a topic
2 pointsThe law has had to prevent Major League Baseball from destroying itself to some degree on multiple occasions over the past 25 years. Fans of minor league teams under threat of elimination in Rob Manfred’s new proposal, such as the Elizabethton Twins, might have to hope justice prevails once again.If the MLB and the team owners get what they want, the landscape of minor league baseball is about to change dramatically. Commissioner Manfred, apparently backed by unanimous support from the owners, is actively working to eliminate 42 affiliated minor league teams. John Sickels of The Athletic recently wrote a great piece titled “On MLB’s plan for minor league contraction: You gotta be crazy.” Sickels evoked memories from a time when it appeared the Minnesota Twins would be contracted. It’s easy to forget that appeared to be a foregone conclusion at one point. In November of 2001, the MLB owners voted 28-2 in support of contracting two teams, widely assumed to be the Twins and Montreal Expos. Luckily, the Twins lease agreement on the Metrodome was in effect through the ‘02 season. A Minnesota judge granted an injunction to force the Twins to play their home schedule in the Metrodome that season. Not only did the MLB appeal that decision, but so did the Twins. In January ‘01, the Minnesota Court of Appeals upheld the injunction. Once again, the MLB and the Twins appealed to the state’s Supreme Court. On Feb. 4, the Minnesota Supreme Court announced they were refusing to consider the appeal, essentially forcing the Twins to play the 2002 season in the Metrodome. But how did the downturn in fan interest that led to the threat of contraction come about in the first place? While the 1994 strike hurt every team, it was particularly devastating for the Twins. Backlash to the ’94 stoppage was compounded by the fact the Twins had the worst record in baseball in ‘95. Then Kirby Puckett lost vision in his right eye during spring training in ‘96. It was as if the Baseball Gods were doing everything in their power to send Minnesotans to the St. Paul Saints (who had both Jack Morris and Darryl Strawberry that season), their local town ball team or simply to pick up a new summer hobby. The ‘94 strike lasted 232 days, but it only ended because the U.S. Court system issued an injunction that reinstated the previous collective bargaining agreement until a new one could be agreed upon. The owners’ only option at that point was to impose a lockout. If that lockout would have been ruled illegal, however, it would have resulted in owners paying huge amounts in damages and back pay to players. So the show went on. Could there be hope the courts could protect minor league teams against this proposal? The New York Daily News quoted an anonymous “major league official” who expected there to be plenty of legal action. “I don’t see any way we can do something like this. My God, we’ll be sued all over the place from these cities that have built or refurbished ballparks with taxpayer money, and this will really put our anti-trust exemption in jeopardy. It’s crazy.” More than 100 members of Congress have expressed opposition to the proposal, but MLB already responded with what The Boston Globe depicted as a “feisty” letter. How do we keep finding professional baseball in the position in which it needs to be saved from the individuals running Major League Baseball? Hopefully Elizabethton, a Twins affiliate since 1974, manages to survive this threat of contraction. Afterall, the city recently dedicated funding to renovate the ballpark’s facilities in an effort to appease the Twins and keep minor league baseball in Elizabethton. Here’s hoping the law will be on Elizabethton’s side. We know Major League Baseball isn’t going to be. Please share your thoughts in the comments below. Not registered? Click here to create an account. To stay up to date, follow Twins Daily on Twitter and Facebook. MORE FROM TWINS DAILY — Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First? — Jhoan Duran Headlines Twins Roster Additions — Episode 8: Get to Know RHP Austin Schulfer, C Caleb Hamilton, RHP Nick Anderson Click here to view the article2 points- Front Page: The C.J. Cron Conundrum
Front Page: The C.J. Cron Conundrum
Melissa and one other reacted to RochesterDave for a post in a topic
2 pointsI sincerely hope that a healthy CJ Cron returns, perhaps with a base salary of $5-6 mil with bonuses based on games played, performance etc. to get him up to the. $ 7.5-8 mil figure. In his absence no one compared to his defensive work when healthy. The Twins rotated Sano, Marwin and Adrianza at 1st in his absence and they were all mediocre to say the least, bringing about a sharp decline in fielding prowess , especially on stretches and scooping short throws. In the old days, 1B was for an inferior fielder, but no more. I think that was what was missed most about Mauer in 2019 - his glove at first.2 points- Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
Vanimal46 and one other reacted to MN_ExPat for a post in a topic
2 pointsI bet he could “Force” his way onto the roster pretty easily .2 points- Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
MMMordabito and one other reacted to mikelink45 for a post in a topic
2 pointsI see this as stupidity. We want baseball to be more popular, but we are going to eliminate the arm of baseball that reaches out into the communities and states where MLB cannot exist. Is this considered smart? Lets just juice the ball some more and watch Home Run Derby, lets forget about developing dreams of reaching the majors, lets eliminate how many players???? Yes this is eliminating players and fans. How many rounds are there in MLB draft? With this reduced number of leagues we can go to the NBA two rounds. So MLB wants more independent leagues. Do enough and we can get a Major Independent League and forget the millionaires league (sorry - billionaires). This is another really frustrating development. If they had eliminated one league or even a dozen teams it would have slid by, but baseball likes to be stupid in a way that everyone can see.2 points- Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
Melissa and one other reacted to sweetmusicviola16 for a post in a topic
2 pointsRich Hill, sure. If we've already signed both Wheeler and Ryu. Otherwise we shouldn't even be discussing him. We need a backup C. Best ones would appear to be Avilla and Maldonando. Either way more time should be given to Garver. I don't expect Castro back since the role is backup and I suspect he may have higher aspirations than that. Clippard could be a solid uninspiring addition. If Cron is let go Kendrick would be very useful to add too.2 points- Front Page: Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First?
Front Page: Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First?
puckstopper1 and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
2 pointsOf course not. First base, and first base only.2 points- Cubs Hire Female Coach for Minor Leagues
Cubs Hire Female Coach for Minor Leagues
Shaitan and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
2 pointsI got a reply back from the chair of the SABR Women In Baseball committee. She mentioned the Yankees just hired Rachel Balkovec as minor league hitting coach, and that "there have been a few with different roles", but said she's not aware of such an article giving an overview, and thinks it's a good idea for one. Great, now another thing on my plate.2 points- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
SwainZag and one other reacted to Dman for a post in a topic
2 pointsI was totally onboard with the Twins making trades in 2018. It wasn’t going to make sense to extend Dozier after the season he had and getting two decent players in Smeltzer and Raley seemed about as good as you could do given his production that year. Lance Lynn wasn’t going to help us and again wasn’t having a great statistical year so getting a look at Tyler Austin and getting Luis Rijo seemed like a better deal than getting nothing. The Zach Duke trade ended up netting us Chase De Jong and Ryan Costello and neither player worked out but Duke was gone at the end of end of the season anyway. Duke was having an OK year and I thought we might be able to do a bit better than what we got but in the end that trade did not move the needle. Getting anything for Rodney especially a high K relief pitcher seemed like a steal IMO. Chalmers still has control problems but the potential is there. I couldn’t take Rodney and all his walks any more. I really liked Escobar but was afraid we might not get him to sign at the end of the year and if he did really want to play for the Twins then I felt we could try and sign him in the offseason anyway. That didn’t work out but we did get a possible mid rotation starter and a potential 4th outfielder for giving up the last few months of his production in a year we were going nowhere anyway and since he didn’t sign with us in the end at least we got something instead of nothing. The Pressly trade was always controversial but I still felt like it was on OK deal. Looking back they really should have pressed for a top 100 prospect in that deal but I think Alcala can still be a middle reliever and Celestino’s floor is a 4th outfielder with great defense. He did manage to hit 10 home runs this year so he might grow into some more power which would give him starter potential. Not a bad haul but given what Houston got it should have been better IMO. While Pressly was controlled for another year he couldn’t help the Twins in 2018 and even though he could have helped us in 2019 we still won the division without him and he wasn’t going to single handedly help us win playoff games. He also was injured so wasn’t available all of 2019 either. The question for me is if the Twins had kept him could they have extended him or would he still have wanted to play closer to his family in Houston? If he was gone anyway I prefer having the prospects if he would have signed I would rather still have him. Do these trades mean this FO is savvy or good at trading? I don’t think we can determine that at least not yet. As others have said they haven’t netted any top 100 prospects in any trades and have given up some prospects with little to show for it at the MLB level. I am happy they made the trades in 2018 as they might have gotten nothing and I am glad many of those players appear worthy of being on the 40 man but until they pan out it is hard to say they moved the needle for the MLB club.2 points- The Value of Prospects
The Value of Prospects
Dantes929 and one other reacted to bird for a post in a topic
2 pointsI think these spit balls all hit the blackboard, RB. I can think of some other plausible theories, but what I guess I'd like to see is a narrowing of the divergence of opinion about how likely a top prospect is to become successful as a pro, based on current, more credible support. The facts one gets from a look at the 2013 and 2014 MLB Top 100 lists doesn't just call into question a statement that 80% of the pitchers on a Top 100 list fail and 65% of position players do too. It blows that notion totally out of the water! Remember, 43 out of 46 pitchers on the 2014 list have thrown pitches in major league baseball, the exceptions being the deceased Yordani Ventura, Mark Appel, and Trey Ball, the #97 guy on the list who was known to be a high risk two-way athlete. I want to see a study from 2001-2014, not one that's analyzing stuff from 1990-2003.2 points- Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
Front Page: Do Any of These Underrated Free Agents Fit in Minnesota?
SomeGuy reacted to alphanumeric for a post in a topic
1 pointNo mention of Alex Wood? I'd really like to see the twins try and get him, i think he could still be a very good #4. He's only 28 and his price tag might be down significantly (so we can throw it all at Wheeler).1 point- Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
Front Page: Minor League Contraction Plan Conjures Painful Memories
brvama reacted to Hosken Bombo Disco for a post in a topic
1 pointIf it’s just the Eastern short-season teams that are eliminated, maybe that’s not so bad. I don’t know. Don’t know if the fans of those teams are just tourists or summer vacationers, or if they have true fan bases. Like I said, I don’t know. Another article stated how MLB wants to trim the draft to 20 rounds and send those late round kids to classrooms and training facilities instead of the short season leagues. I wouldn’t be outraged by that. However, it would be nice to hear more or get some more reporting. I do think it would be rotten to eliminate any Iowa teams or other teams with established fan bases.1 point- Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
No character issues with that guy1 point- Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
Sign this lefty now! I don't care that he's 50 years old.
MN_ExPat reacted to Richie the Rally Goat for a post in a topic
1 pointI bet he throws a wicked knuckleball1 point- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
I *think* it is time of residence that matters, and where the income is earned. All players (Twins and visitors) pay Minnesota income tax on the salary they earn when playing in Minnesota. If they are Minnesota residents for a certain percentage of the year, they are also subject to Minnesota income tax, but the rules are complicated for income earned elsewhere. I'm not a tax attorney or accountant, so I don't know the details. A local example, though: Portland (~9% income tax) is located just across the river from Vancouver, Wash., (no income tax), but if I lived in Vancouver and worked in Portland, I'd still have to pay Oregon tax on my earnings because they were earned in Oregon. But in retirement, I'd get a 9% raise by moving to Washington, as long as I could still buy all my stuff in Oregon where there is no sales tax.1 point- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
Trust me, your Wife's free agency will cost more than any state taxes.1 point- Front Page: Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First?
Front Page: Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First?
Doctor Wu reacted to yeahyabetcha for a post in a topic
1 pointCorner outfielders don’t seem to have much trade value, unless they are elite. So don’t expect a trade of any of them, including Rosario. So the order of the backup outfielders is likely Cave-Wade-Raley. I would be surprised if any of the other three see the bigs this year. Barring injuries1 point- Front Page: Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First?
Front Page: Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First?
Danchat reacted to Mr. Brooks for a post in a topic
1 pointRooker has way too much swing and miss in his game, IMO. I don't even think he's close to the same class of prospect as Larnach.1 point- The Value of Prospects
The Value of Prospects
bird reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic
1 pointI totally understand the complexity of your quest. It should make you tear your hair out if you are doing it right. My tendency is to believe that there isn't a simple right answer that will remove the complexity of the question. Let me put this way... If you took Andrew Friedman and Dave Dombrowski, locked them in a room and then forced them to honestly (without decorum) debate roster construction, the value of prospects, overall operational style, long term planning, things like that. Let's say that you tied them to chairs and only the winner of the debate would be untied at the end of the debate to make sure they won't mince words with freedom on the line. It is my opinion, that Andrew and Dave will argue, shout and roll their eyes at each other. The difference between them would be extreme, it probably wouldn't be pretty and the value of prospects would be at the heart of the debate. Andrew Friedman isn't going to drain the farm to acquire talent, he won't do it. He values prospects higher. Dombrowski will drain the farm, he has done it, he values veteran talent higher. Neither camp is wrong... The Red Sox have won a recent world series so the drain the farm strategy is legit and can't be dismissed. Personally, I'm in the Friedman camp. You have to keep the farm productive at all times. However, we have some posters on Twinsdaily who think that prospects typically don't pan out so we might as well cash them in... and those posters are in the Dombrowski camp. When they believe that 80% of prospects don't pan out. This is Dombrowski speak. But, here's the deal... The Dombrowski's are disappearing fast. New hires are almost exclusively coming from the Friedman style camp now. And as the Friedman's take over... the value of prospects goes up accordingly. From 1990 to 2003... they were all Dombrowski's. This renders research from 1990 to 2003 concerning prospects panning out... basically not relevant to today's discussion.1 point- Front Page: Pending Prospects: Which Outfielder Will Be Called up First?
Might be a little high on Raley's HR potential. And I believe he can also play 1B.1 point- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
If any reporters who attend team press conferences are reading, maybe you could just ask? I don't see a reason why the team would be evasive in answering a general question like that, something that all player agents are well aware of. ''Does the state income tax rate come up in contract discussions much?"1 point- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
If I am being paid 18M a year by the Twins, then I will have to recognize 9M of Minnesota income for tax purposes. That amounts to a lot of state income tax. Hopefully I can keep my wife's spending habits under control so that the "cost of living" in Minnesota being lower than New York is not a major factor. If it is a major factor it will be time to non-tender her and make her a free agent!1 point- Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball
The taxes are ridiculous and there's no media market to speak of? Well hey, at least the weather sucks.1 point- Tesla CyberTruck
Tesla CyberTruck
PseudoSABR reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic
1 point1 point- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
wabene reacted to In My La Z boy for a post in a topic
1 pointThat's not what I want to hear today1 point- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Dave Overlund reacted to Darius for a post in a topic
1 pointGive me back Escobar and Presley and you can keep all of those prospects. Eduardo Escobar posted a 4.2 WAR in 2019. For reference, that tied Tatis Jr (who was phenomenal in him games played). Juan Soto posted a 4.7. Freddie Freeman and JT Realmuto 4.4s. Nelson Cruz a 4.3. He posted a higher WAR than Max Kepler and Mitch Garver. Higher than Jose Altuve, Austin Meadows, and JD Martinez. Crude measurement, I know, but that’s what I’m using for the sake of time. We all know about Pressley. He’s been, arguably, the best reliever in the MLB since he arrived in Houston until his injury issues late in the season. These guys are among the best in Major League Baseball at their positions (both positions we need). I don’t know how, with a straight face, you can list the likes of Devon Smeltzer, Luke Raley, a couple of hard throwers who will be a fraction of Presley if we’re lucky, and Celestino, who was awful save for a few months and is years away from the majors on a team with a loaded outfield, and say “See, these guys are killing it.” There are some things people seem to forget. This front office had a pretty good offseason last year....the year before that was an epic disaster. Also, many of the significant contributors on the team were holdovers from the previous regime. They brought in Cruz who was a resounding success....but he fell into their lap (nobody really wanted him that badly due to his age). Aside from that they’ve brought in guys like Morrison, Lynn, Zach Duke, CJ Cron, Jonathan Schoop, etc. Hardly a murderer’s row. Don’t get me wrong, I have faith in them. But way too many people in the media and fandom are anointing Falvine the Kings of Baseball. In reality l, that isn’t really based on a whole lot. They won the worst division in baseball and got utterly dismantled by the team that lost to the team that lost to the Nationals in the World Series. I still need to see some things play out. I don’t think they’ll be giving a long runway in terms of spending (not as much as people think), and a lot of players are due for regression. There is a good chance everyone will be writing articles expressing the opposite sentiment this time next year.1 point- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Battle ur tail off reacted to Dave Overlund for a post in a topic
1 pointI'm glad that Falvine got good minor leaguers in their trades in 2018, but I can't help but think that Escobar and Pressley would have looked real good on last year's team.1 point- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Battle ur tail off reacted to darin617 for a post in a topic
1 pointTwins traded Luis Gil to the Yankees for Jake Cave. Luis Gil is now the Yankees #4 prospect.1 point- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Battle ur tail off reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic
1 pointThis seems like another pro-FO piece without a lot to back it up. The FO didn't trade Dozier when his value was at it's peak and threw in the towel at the trade deadline that year as well. Smeltzer is a bullpen and Raley might be a 4th OFer. Escobar is probably the best trade here in that Duran has some real potential as a #3 type (which is a good thing). I don't know how anyone can say the Pressly trade was good. Alaca is 25 years old now and put up nearly a 6.00 era in AA. Pressly is one of the best relievers in the game. Chalmers isn't anything to get excited about. He's 23 and thrown 20 innings above low A ball and has serious control problems. Not a lot of upside there. Last year the Twins had 10 players amass at least 2 WAR. This FO acquired only 3 of them (Cruz, Odorizzi and Pineda). I liked the Schoop and Gonzalez signings last year, Cron was a good pickup and I like that the FO hired Rocco and decided to go with Garver instead of signing someone else to play with Castro. Those were all good moves. But this FO also traded away Huascar Ynoa (who made the majors at 21 for Atlanta) and while they've made a number of trades, they have yet to trade for a top 100 prospect and Jake Cave is the only guy that's managed more than even a 1 WAR season in the majors. I'm not saying our FO is a failure but so far most of their moves haven't done much, although they've made a lot more moves than normal. They didn't understand when they had an opportunity in 2017, didn't do anything to reinforce this team at the deadline this year. There is value in letting guys like Polanco and Kepler play instead of replacing them and those moves look great now. But most of the success is because of the players, not the FO or ownership.1 point- Front Page: Miguel Sanó Was Everything We Were Promised in 2019
I'll just say this. Watching Sano home run highlights is a delight.1 point- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
wabene reacted to Cory Engelhardt for a post in a topic
1 point1) The Dyson trade didn't work out. That said, in scouting, can you "see" that a player is injured? Is that possible without X-ray vision? I'm not being snarky, I really don't know. 2) Odorizzi was a really good trade. Will the player they gave up ever make it to AA? 3) You didn't mention that they turned Garcia into Zack Littell. That turned out well, no?1 point- Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Front Page: Twins Trades Show They've Got This Down
Battle ur tail off reacted to KGB for a post in a topic
1 pointJust adding plays to the 40 man roster and claiming a trade a win, seems to be a pretty low bar we've set for this front office. Maybe we should wait to see if they actually contribute anything at the major league before we call this a huge haul.1 point- Front Page: Offseason Blueprint: Riding the Rochester Shuttle, Improving the Rotation, and Going Big on Catcher
Front Page: Offseason Blueprint: Riding the Rochester Shuttle, Improving the Rotation, and Going Big on Catcher
Richie the Rally Goat reacted to Patrick Wozniak for a post in a topic
1 pointProbably Dobnak but Smeltzer or moving either Thorpe or Graterol out of the pen would be fine as well.1 point- Front Page: Was Luis Arraez for Real in 2019?
Front Page: Was Luis Arraez for Real in 2019?
adorduan reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
1 pointVery few people hit .300 anymore. Imo, he'll have to develop some power as the average drops. Also, that defense....1 point- Front Page: Was Luis Arraez for Real in 2019?
Front Page: Was Luis Arraez for Real in 2019?
adorduan reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic
1 pointI'm rooting for him but I think in the end he's a solid bench player. My guess is that Nick Gordon plays most games at second base for the Twins after July next year.1 point- The Value of Prospects
The Value of Prospects
Dman reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
1 pointYet, among playoff teams, there were twice as many high performing players that were acquired as prospects as compared to those acquired as proven MLB players. While this leaves some room for interpretation, established players are generally traded for prospects. The fact that there were so many more players acquired as prospects does suggest that trading for prospects is more productive than trading away prospects. It would be interesting to put together the data for the last 10 years. Not so interesting that I would take on that task but interesting none the less.1 point- The Value of Prospects
The Value of Prospects
Dman reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
1 pointIt also ignores that higher ranked prospects actually succeed at a pretty good rate (according to the study), and that the kinds of players the Twins trade for are more likely to be successful than the entire population is.1 point- The Value of Prospects
The Value of Prospects
Dman reacted to Major League Ready for a post in a topic
1 pointThe problem with this type of study is that the majority of people glean from it whatever supports their predisposed position. The tendency is to focus on whatever subset of the data supports a given position. In this case, 80% of prospects fail. One of the first steps in any data analysis is to assess the correlation with whatever it is you are trying to conclude. I will come back to that point. First, let’s take an objective view of this data. Perhaps this high failure rate defines the key to success in a different way. Perhaps the difference between success and failure is relative success in converting (developing) prospects to MLB players. Maybe the key is producing MLB contributors from players outside the top 100 or a combination of these two factors. The data clearly shows there is a wide difference in success rates between MLB teams. What are we trying to conclude here? Is it what percentage of prospects fail? I don’t think that is the end game. IMO, the question is actually what is the most effective way to construct a playoff team. The most effective way to do that is to actually look at how each form of player acquisition contributes to the construction of playoff rosters? It’s much more conclusive to look at the actual results as opposed to drawing a conclusion as to how important prospects are to building a playoff roster based on failure rate of top 100 prospects. Last year, the 7 teams (not counting the Twins) who made the playoffs had a total of 88 players that contributed 1.5+ fWAR. 28 (32%) were drafted. 21 (24%) were traded for as prospects. 8 (9%) were Intl signings. 10 (11%) were trade for after becoming established. 21 (24%) were signed as free agents. Drafted players combined with players traded for as prospects represent 56% of the highest contributing players. Established players acquired in trade represent only 11% of the players that contributed the most to playoff teams. Free agents had a much higher contribution. However, many of them were the type of players / contracts frowned upon here. Of the 21 free agents, only 4 had 5+ year deals. 6 were two-year deals and 11 were 1 year contracts. The two lowest budget teams are very interesting in terms of the value of trading for established players vs the value of trading for prospects. Between Oakland and Tampa, they only 23 players with a WAR of 1.5 or higher. They only drafted 5 of those players. However, they traded for 12 of their 23 highest performing players as prospects. They had 6 free agents. Four of them were 1-year deals and two were 2-year deals. The total for all six contracts was $55M, $30M to Charlie Morton. 2 players (Tommy Pham / Homer Bailey) were acquired in trade. What do the actual results of these practices tell us?1 point- What do we think Twins payroll REALLY will be?
$136,292,374.05 Approximately.1 pointThis leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00 - Rosenthal: Minnesota Tax Rate 2nd Highest in Baseball