One last thing and then I'll hang up and listen This is more about outs than anything. They're precious. The only way a baseball game advances is by making outs. I really hate the idea of willfully giving them away, especially the first one. OK, on the bunting decision. If you want to get into the math on the specific scenarios, you can review Tom Tango's Run Expectancy Matrix, which is based on real-life data pulled from Retrosheet. From the 2010-15 tables: Chance a run will score at some point First and second, no outs: 61% Second and third, one out: 67.6% Average number of total runs scored First and second, no outs: 1.437 Second and third, one out: 1.367 So while you have slightly increased your odds of scoring a run, you've also hurt your odds of scoring multiple runs. But we're also taking a very broad look at this. For me, the range of things that can potentially go wrong is not worth the increase of 6.6% that you'll score a run (also, that increase was only 5.4% from 1993-2009, 4.6% from 1969-92 and 4.1% from 1950-68). We're assuming the bunt gets executed properly, which you obviously cannot do. There's also the potential that Schoop could have gotten a hit or drew a walk. Heck, the opposing team could have committed an error (like the play prior to the bunt attempt) or the pitcher could uncork a wild pitch, who knows? So accepting all the things that could go wrong and ignoring all the things that could go right just for a 6.6% better chance of scoring a run seems like a poor choice to me. Now specifically in terms of the 2019 Twins, I think when you have a lineup with this kind of firepower and a bullpen with as many questions this one has, playing to tie the game in the seventh inning seems like a fool's errand. Obviously the pen took care of business in the final two innings last night, but that's not really something I'd like to bank on.