Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Nick Nelson

    Administrator
    Points
    7,006
    Posts
  2. jorgenswest

    Verified Member
    Points
    5,937
    Posts
  3. Squirrel

    Community Leader
    Points
    31,121
    Posts
  4. ashbury

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    34,998
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 12/31/2018 in all areas

  1. Haha, whew. A couple nuggets of food for thought before I go to bed and wake up to a hell storm. Since appearing in the 2017 All Star Game, Miguel Sano has: * Hit .210/.291/.370 in 437 plate appearances * Played in 103 of a possible 236 games for the Twins * Struck out at a 38% rate, with only 9% walks * Suffered two serious injuries to the same leg, each lingering into the offseason * Been optioned straight to Single-A Because these are annually updated rankings, I'm attempting to heavily factor recent track record into the equation. You can argue I'm going too far with that here, and you might be right. But in the last 17 months Sano's stock has been on a steady downward plane.
  2. Actually a big Garver fan....and beyond frustrated with Sano....but alas... Sano is clearly still a MUCH more significant asset based on his "value to the franchise's current path and vision" Unless the "fanchise's current path and vision" does not include trying to win the WS. Come on man?!
  3. 4 points
    As we all look forward to celebrating the transition from 2018 to 2019 today, it’s fun to look back at the Twins 2018 season and think about all of the rookies that came up. There were 15 rookies who played for the Twins in 2018. Today we are going to focus on the eight players who made their Major League debuts.14 players made their major league debut for the Twins in 2017. So it shouldn’t be so bad to just write about eight of them this year. Some made strong first impressions. Some struggled. Most are somewhere in the middle. Tyler Kinley - April 7, 2018 The Twins selected right-handed relief pitcher Tyler Kinley in the December 2017 Rule 5 draft from the Miami Marlins organization. The right-hander reached into the upper-90s, and he had a sharp slider. Rarely did he have control. Hence, he was left unprotected. He made the Twins Opening Day roster. It took a while, but in the Twins seventh game, they found themselves down big, so Kinley got the ball for the ninth inning. He came in and did as reported. He threw hard. He gave up one run on one hit. He walked one and struck out two batters. But he pitched just once in the Twins first 11 games. He pitched three times over the Twins next six games. He had one good outing, but over his final two outings, he gave up eight runs on seven hits and three walks in just 1 1/3 innings. The Twins designated him for assignment, and after clearing waivers, he was returned to the Marlins. He was called up to the Marlins in September. He pitched in nine games. He gave up five runs in one of those outings. In the other eight games (10.1 innings), he gave up just one run. Fernando Romero - May 2, 2018 Romero has long been a Twins prospect, but after missing two seasons with Tommy John surgery, the Twins have kept an eye on his innings. But, he has moved quickly up the system. He had impressed in his spring training outings the past two seasons, and fans got very excited when they learned that he was coming up to start for the Twins. On a sunny day in early May, Romero got Twins fans even more excited. Not only was he throwing hard, but he showed a good changeup and a good slider. Against the Blue Jays, Romero threw 5 2/3 innings and did not allow a run. He gave up four hits, walked three and struck out five. His second start was in St. Louis and he was even better. He threw six shutout innings and gave up just three hits and three walks. He struck out nine batters. In his third start, he went head-to-head with Angels star rookie Shohei Ohtani. He gave up a run, but just one hit, over five innings. In his first five starts, Romero went 2-1 with a 1.88 ERA. His sixth start did not go well. He gave up eight earned runs in just 1 2/3 innings. Then over his next five starts, he went 1-1 with a 5.33 ERA. He was sent to Rochester and continued to make starts. He was not called up in September due to an innings limit. 2019 will be Romero’s final option season. Will he get another opportunity to start? Could he be moved in to late-inning relief duties? Jake Cave - May 19, 2018 The Twins acquired outfielder Jake Cave in a mid-March trade with the Yankees in exchange for hard-throwing prospect Luis Gil. He got a few games in big league spring training before heading to minor league camp. With Zack Granite out most of the year with a shoulder injury, Cave got an opportunity and really stepped up. His big league debut came at Target Field against the Brewers. He batted seventh and played center field. He went 1-for-3 with two runs and two RBI. The one hit? A two-run homer. He played in three games before heading back to the Red Wings. He was called up again in early June, and then called up for good late in June. With the Byron Buxton injury, Cave was able to play most every day. He responded by hitting .265/.313/.473 (.786) with 16 doubles and 13 home runs in 91 games. Some of those homers went a long way! The Twins named him the Bill Boni Award recipient as Twins Outstanding Rookie. In addition, the Twins had five episodes of The Man Cave Show. He was named the Twins Daily Minor League Relief Pitcher of the Year. For much more on Andrew Vasquez, there is a feature story in the 2019 Minnesota Twins Prospect Handbook. The other rookies to play for the Minnesota Twins in 2018 were Matt Magill, Gabriel Moya, Chase De Jong, Aaron Slegers, John Curtiss, Mitch Garver and Ryan LaMarre. They had all made their MLB debuts in previous seasons. Discuss the Twins 2018 rookies, their debuts, and which will take a step forward in 2019 and beyond. Secondly, which rookies do you think will debut for the Twins in 2019? Click here to view the article
  4. Opinion, I guess, based on the fact that Cruz has averaged 40+ HR and been extremely durable the last 5 years while Sano has never hit more than 28 and never played 120 games in an MLB season. Fwiw, FanGraphs projects Cruz to hit 37 next year and Sano to hit 29 (which seems generous to me based on his broken plate approach and injury history). Are you aware of how good he was this year upon returning? His numbers across the board were on par with the game's best relievers. In what way is he overrated?
  5. 3 points
    Exploring typical a little further and using last 5 years data so that the data has stabilized. Odorizzi’s numbers in 2018 were consistent with his career. First inning ERA: Odorizzi ranks 5th of 77 behind Scherzer and Arrieta and ahead of Kluber and Sale Inning 2: 39th Inning 3: 26th Inning 4: 71st Innings 1-3: 18th (3.25) Innings 4-6: 66th (4.72) I don’t think that is typical of a 3-4 starter. Those are clear number 1s in the first group.
  6. Um, Cruz is a MUCH better bet to reach 20 or 40 home runs in either of the next two years than Sano at this point. That's not even debatable. And then Sano has one year of control remaining after that. Sano's age obviously does work in his favor but his trend line has been moving consistently downward for some time and he has established a new floor.
  7. I'd switch Gordon and Gonsalves. I'd also switch Sano and Garver. Nice list so far. As for Sano, I'm done waiting. If he ready next year bat him 8th or trade him for a solid starting pitcher. Power hitters (Sano is) are fickle. We need a bat we can count on everyday in the Middle of the order. We have one now in Cruz.
  8. Nick, I love this series and I love the discussionit has created. Thanks for putting the time and effort into it. All that said, I can’t fathom how any of Gibson, May or Garver, by any measure, can be placed ahead of Sano on this list. I don’t care if we are talking trade value, WAR, or traditional stats. Sano (and his three years of team control) is a significantly more valuable asset for the team than Gibson (one year), May (two years) or even Garver (five years).
  9. Angels DFA Alex Meyer

    howieramone2 and 2 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic

    3 points
    The same Kyle Gibson that made it to AAA in his first year of pro-ball, had TJ surgery and got called up to the majors less than a year after he recovered from it? He was awful in 2011, likely due to the arm injury which would later result in surgery. I really liked Meyer and desperately wanted him to be the ace the Twins always needed, but there are no caveats with a 5.6 BB/9 nor should there be with 4.4 or 4.7 BB/9 which is what he did his last two full seasons in Rochester. No team needs to be chastised for not giving a guy who can't find the strikezone unconditional looks.
  10. Vikings Off-Season Thread

    gil4 and one other reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I think he was suggesting you could replace Richardson in the second or third round and reallocate that money. Maybe to the offensive line.
  11. Odorizzi - 75 pitches and done.

    Riverbrian and one other reacted to Jim Hahn for a post in a topic

    2 points
    This thread has been a very interesting and civil discussion. I thank all of you who participated in it. I nothing have more to add to it, except a likely off topic observation. Baseball, not just major league baseball, but all levels of baseball, has not done a very good job of protecting pitchers arms. This has been true for years, but it is especially true today, even with modern medicine and greater understanding of various stresses placed on arms. Weight training and other trainings have increased velocity and spin, but they have also increased stress on the arm. Too many promising and a great many successful pitchers get washed out of baseball far too early. I really don't have a lot of ideas about how to improve this aspect of baseball, and I realize many major league organizations are working on this, at least to a degree. I just want to point out that as teams go about changing how pitchers go about pitching, protecting pitchers arms needs to be a part of this. I am somewhat concerned that these new pitching models could, however inadvertently, actually cause more arm injuries.
  12. 100 MPH, maybe? My impression was that jsteve96 was referring to the relatively recent evolution of pitching toward harder throwers, along with the resulting shift in innings from starters to relievers. My guess is that the shift means it takes starters longer to reach a given number of innings for them to be 'ready' for the majors. Relievers should then develop faster, but it probably doesn't matter as much because they tend to be sheltered from high-leverage use at the back end of a 7 or 8 man bullpen anyway
  13. It's a combination of all those things, weighted in my own (admittedly vague and subjective) manner. When you come to terms with the fact that these rankings are heavily influenced by recent trends and established performance (the idea for me is akin to stocks going up and down) the methodology should become easier to understand. Maybe not. Also, I did these same rankings last year so I dunno why people keep acting like it's a random idea that materialized solely due to the circumstances of this offseason. The objective is taking stock of what's currently on hand and how it figures into the plan going forward. And to try and chart the movement that takes place from year-to-year. People want him to be a starter because he's never really gotten a full shot and has four quality pitches. He came back from TJ surgery throwing 94 MPH with his fastball and inducing a 15% swinging strike rate, which would rank top-15 among qualified MLB relievers. When used as an actual reliever (so, subtracting the one outing as "opener") he had a 1.85 ERA and 2.23 xFIP When you say, "If numbers make him seem good then look at other numbers," then cite a relatively arbitrary one like IR%, it makes it sound like you're the one with the agenda, not everyone else.
  14. Vikings Off-Season Thread

    diehardtwinsfan and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Two new starting OL. Even competent play would be a huge upgrade. Spielman should be fired for the fact his OL has been awful every year since the good players left. He's drafted poorly, and been bad at signing free agents on the OL. And it was totally predictable. Hire an OC that can stand up to Zimmer, and runs a modern offense. I'd prefer to trade or fire Zimmer, but that's not happening. Cut Remmers. Cut sendejo. Either everson and Rudolph take pay cuts, or they are gone. Same with linval. I'd keep Richardson over him. Fire the special teams coach, as he's been wrong on every kicker and punter.
  15. I tried to understand the idea behind this list, but failed. It's not current value, future value, trade value, 2019 projection . . . seems more like a symptom of a slow-to-date off-season.
  16. Angels DFA Alex Meyer

    howieramone2 and one other reacted to jorgenswest for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Trades of an established position player for a top prospect pitcher in A-Ball are going to be own most often by the team acquiring the established player. When the team acquiring the prospect wins, they can win really big.
  17. Trevor May continues to be the most overrated player in the history of TD. Austin is starting to give him a run though.
  18. If Hrbek played today, he’d be a borderline HoF case (though he didn’t play long enough to make it). He was criminally underrated during his career because the game didn’t properly appreciate his skill set.
  19. Odorizzi - 75 pitches and done.

    Riverbrian and one other reacted to jorgenswest for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I think you need a pretty deep bullpen for the opener strategy to work. That opener is going to see the opponents best hitters in the first inning. It can’t be a guy from the back of the bullpen. Last year AL pitchers had a 4.71 ERA in the first inning vs an ERA of 4.05 and 4.02 in the second or third inning, Odorizzi doesn’t fit that pattern. He pitched well in the first inning last year with an ERA of 3.09. That is only meaningful because over the sample of his career he has performed well in the first inning. I don’t think the Twins can pull a reliever for the back of the bullpen and match that 3.09 ERA in the first inning. Do the Twins try to change Odorizzi so he goes against his career tendencies of dropping off around the 4th or 5th inning? Do the Twins try to utilize the talents he has established? He might be best utilized opening and going three innings. Last year’s line innings 1-3: 94.2 IP, 3.14 ERA, 100 K, 36 BB, .628 OPS against The sample is relatively small but consistent with his career. He wouldn’t get any wins being pulled after 3 innings but those numbers would certainly help a team win. Those are tough innings. You probably are seeing the top of the lineup a second time. I don’t know how you configure a staff to utilize that talent. I don’t know if he can go out and pitch 3 innings more often than every 5th day. I do think there is an underutilized role of a pitcher who can be effective for 3-4 innings.
  20. 2 points
    Interesting study from SABR and the origins of the pitching rotation. https://sabr.org/research/origins-pitching-rotation I don’t have any definitive takeaways but it did cause a few thoughts. - I wonder about the typical size of a pitching staff over time. I know it has increased to the point where platooning isn’t very viable. - I wonder if today’s rotation 5 man model is too rigid and whether pitching roles themselves have become too rigid. - I wonder about the history of pitcher health. This is difficult to track as I suspect pitchers were injured but kept pitching many years ago. I do think the construction of the pitching staff will evolve again. I think the Twins are trying to be in the front side of that curve.
  21. Odorizzi - 75 pitches and done.

    Riverbrian and one other reacted to Jim Hahn for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I get what you are saying here and elsewhere , Brian. I could even construct models that perfectly fit together 2 inning pitchers, 3 inning pitchers, 5 inninng pitchers, 1 inning pitchers and the increasingly rare 7 inning pitchers. It would look wonderful on a chart, and would get everyone their proper rest and you could fit around scheduled days off and everything. But baseball doesn't really work like that. There are rainouts and rain delays. One inning pitchers don't always complete 1 inning. Your workhorse starter sometimes doesn't get through 1 inning, which would mess up my model for at least a week. The reason baseball has used a 5 man rotation since the 70's is that largely, it works. It has some built flexibility, you can skip a starter after a rainouts or not. You can usually compensate for 1 poor start with a long men, etc. Now, right now it seems to be increasingly hard to find enough durable, effective starters to fill out a traditional 5 man rotation model. There are at least two ways to fix this problem. Work harder at making starters last longer and be more effective, or throw away the old model and try to create something new and theoretically more effective, as you suggest. I personally am leaning to the first solution for a lot of reasons. First, with a 25 man roster most of these new solutions are pretty hard to implement. You really can't contract the position player bench anymore than it is and shuttling pitchers has certain limitations that can inhibit its effectiveness. That tends to mean that at certain times during the season you will find yourself using the 14th and 15th best pitchers on your 40 man roster or dropping players off your 40 man roster and adding new ones merely to keep from overusing players. Another issue with these ideas is that relief pitchers are getting overused in any number of ways. Too many times pitchers are asked to warmup multiple times befor getting in games. Max delivery relievers asked to pitch multiple innings too often. Short relievers pitching too many games in a row. I am having a hard time seeing how new use models will help that, and it likely it could make this kind of abuse even worse. Finally, even if you change roster rules to make these ideas easier to implement, you are still using more pitchers. Since part of the real problem here is that there are not enough good pitchers, using more pitchers is a counter intuitive solution to the problem. Again, I would like to see baseball working harder to get more innings out of your pretty good starters rather than using more less good pitchers.
  22. 2 points
    Why are we bringing up the Cy Young Award in a thread about Jake Odorizzi?
  23. Regardless of where each of us might rank Sano on such a list today, how depressing it is to think back to 2012 and imagine someone from the future coming back to tell us then that we'd even have a discussion someday about Sano being somewhere in the second-ten in a team asset ranking.
  24. Article: 2018 Twins: The Year in Debut

    Doomtints and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    2 points
    This kind of recap is really cool. We had a clunker or two for rookies, but also some contributors and rays of hope.
  25. We had 3 big cornerstones we all waited for a few seasons ago- Sano, Bux, and Berrios. So far, only 1 has been a consistent major league asset, and no world beater. I'm sad. Still somewhat hopeful, but about to cut bait and begin the wait for the Lewis - Kiriloff axis to 'arrive.'
  26. 2 points
    Yes it's hard to understate the importance of this. Cousins is getting a lot of flack for this but it's not like he had much of a chance to do anything. No QB looks good when they are under siege all night because the OL is getting worked over. Look at Super Bowl 42.
  27. In Part one we covered to injuries that had a massive affect on this era of Twins teams. I didn't even get into the concussions that derailed both Morneau's and Mauers careers. In Part 2 we will cover what I consider personnel decisions that range from bad to ridiculous to borderline criminal. The first one I want to cover is the one I alluded to when discussing Jason Kubel's injury. Kubel was a very solid outfielder before the injury, even playing some centerfield. His range after the injury was greatly reduced. In looking for better production in LF the Twins made a bad trade after the 2007 season. The Twins sent Matt Garza and Jason Bartlett to Tampa Bay for Delmon Young and Brendon Harris. Delmon was famously the number 1 overall pick in 2003 and was considered the top prospect in baseball for several seasons. In his first full season he had slashed .290/.336/.405 with 21 doubles and 12 homers in roughly 3 quarters of a season. He finished 2nd in the ROY voting. Delmon would go on to have 1 really good and 2 below average season for the Twins while playing horrendous defense in LF. He would be traded during the 2011 season. Harris would have 2 nondescript seasons for the Twins. Garza and Bartlet would go to Tampa Bay and were huge reasons why the Rays went to the World Series in 2008. Before being traded Bartlet had hit .309/.367/.393 and .265/.339/.361 in his previous 2 seasons for the Twins. He had 3 seasons of team control left and was only 27 at the time the trade. Bartlet would hit .286/.329/.361 and .320/.389/.490 for the Rays in the next 2 seasons while garnering MVP votes in 2008 and making the All Star team in 2009. Garza was 24 at the time of the trade and entering his 1st full season 5 seasons of team control remaining. Garza had been solid for the Twins when called up during 2008 season with an ERA+ of 117 and an FIP of 4.17. He definitely showed promise. Over the next 4 season from 2008 to 2011 for the Rays and then the Cubs after being traded he would average 200 innings per year and had ERA+ of 119, 110, 100 and 118. He was absolutely the type of above average innings eater that the Twins craved during these years. To add a little salt to the wound Garza was traded for Chris Archer among others when he was sent to the Cubs after the 2010 season. The next decision is still hard for me to think about. David Ortiz was non tendered after the 2002 season. We all know what Big Papa went on to a HOF career for the Red Sox leading them to 3 World Series titles. This is not a case of 20/20 rear view vision. The release of Ortiz made no sense at the time. He had struggled to stay healthy at times, wasn't in the greatest shape and clashed with TK. But there was no reason to non tender him. In his final year for the Twins Ortiz had hit .272/.339/.500 with 32 doubles and 20 homers. His OPS was .839 and OPS+ was 120. He was just 26 years old. He was one of the few Twins that showed plus power. It isn't like the Twins had some huge prospect they needed to make room for. Mathew LeCroy received most of the DH at bats in 2003. He had a respectable .832 OPS. But it doesn't mean there wasn't at least room for a platoon with Ortiz batting against righties and LeCroy vs lefties. The Twins would struggle to get production from the DH position for the next decade while Ortiz was crushing for the Red Sox. The Twins trotted out luminaries as Jose Offerman, Rondell White and Jason Tyner as designate hitters during this time. In 2006 while White was putting up a .641 OPS, Ortiz was hitting 54 homers and knocking in 137 RBI. Instead of non tendering Ortiz you should have been signing him to an extension. The 2006 batting order could have been Luis Castillo 2B, .358 OBP. Jason Bartlett SS .367 OBP, Joe Mauer C .936 OPS .429 OBP, David Ortiz 1.049 OPS 54 HR, Justin Morneau 1B .936 OPS 34 HR, Torii Hunter .826 OPS 31 HR, Jason Kubel LF .800 OPS 25 HR (Projected) Michael Cuddyer .867 OPS 24 HR, Nick Punto 3B .352 OBP Lack of reasonable extensions and filling the bottom parts of the roster. Terry Ryan hated spending the Pohlads money. I truly believe he did this because he looked it as badge of honor that the Twins could compete with a budget that often times was less than half of the big boys. I liked this fact too. I'm not advocating doubling the payroll during this period, But a well placed additional 10 to 15 million dollars per season could have done wonders. Ryan was very leery to go past 4 years for contacts even for his best players. Santana, Hunter, Mauer and Morneau all signed similar 4 year deals that contained no options. Meanwhile the rest of the industry was signing guys to 6 and sometimes even longer deals. If Santana had been offered a 6 year deal at market value there is a strong chance he would have taken it. This would have you allowed to have him for 2 to 3 more years of his prime. Same for Torii Hunter. You would have had Mauer signed thru 2012 originally and not been forced to sign him to a monster extension after his incredible 2009 season. I know small market teams cannot afford to get stuck in long expensive contracts but all 4 of these guys were young when they signed there 1st big contracts but already had proven track records of excellent production. They were all worth the risk of longer extensions. A longer contract can have good and bad risks. Sometimes the market grows so quickly that a contract is outdated by the time it is up. Sometimes it turns out like Mike Hampton. In the case of Mauer, the Twins could actually have saved millions of dollars by signing him to a longer more expensive extension the 1st time. By the time Mauer would have been a free agent after say a 6 year contract he would have already moved to first base. His next contract would have paled in comparison to the 8 year deal he signed in 2009. Longer contracts would have allowed the Twins to keep Santana's and Hunter's services farther into their primes. It was always frustrating to see the Twins fill out the rosters with the fillers all making near the league minimum or signing hope and a prayer types. Too many rejects like the cast covered earlier that played DH, plus all the middle infielders, relief pitchers and 5th starters that they brought in. If they would have sent just a little money on a few free agents they could have extended the quality of their lineup, bullpen and/or rotation. With better decision making and injury luck I really believe this era of Twins could have been a dynasty that won multiple championships. The top end talent was just so good. In Santana, Nathan, Mauer, Morneau and Hunter they had 5 of the best 20 players in baseball all in their prime at the same time. With better decisions and luck you could have added Kubel, Liriano and Ortiz to that list. No team in baseball could have matched a group of high end talent like that. A lineup that boasts Mauer, Morneau, Hunter, Ortiz, Cuddyer and Kubel reads like an all star game. This would have been the best lineup in the majors even if you had Seth playing SS, Arron at 3B and Nick at 2nd. A rotation led by Santana and Liriano would have been favored in any series against any opponent during the playoffs in this time. The rest of the rotation spots would have been filled by pitchers such as Brad Radke, Matt Garza, Scott Baker, Kevin Slowey, Carlos Silva and Nick Blackburn during different years. Just imagine all the 10 year, 20 year and 25 year anniversaries we could celebrate for championships in 2004, 2006, 2007 and 2010. Oh what could have been.
  28. This is the second in a four-part series ranking the top 20 player assets in the Minnesota Twins organization. The idea is to think solely in terms of commodity valuation, factoring in things like age, cost, control, and risk management in answering the question: which players are most essential to this team's vision? Last week we looked at Nos. 20 through 16. Today we continue the countdown with Nos. 15 through 11.15. Stephen Gonsalves, LHP (24) 2018 Ranking: 10 In some ways, Gonsalves took a big step forward in 2018. He pitched brilliantly over 100 innings at Triple-A, solidifying his supremacy over minor-league hitters. He then received his first promotion to the big leagues, making seven appearances for the Twins in August and September. Gonsalves' MLB debut was a mixed bag. He was brutal in his first four starts (11.68 ERA and 3.00 WHIP in 12 1/3 innings) then excelled in three appearances as a "primary" (1.46 ERA and 1.05 WHIP). The true pitcher lies somewhere in between these two extremes, but there were enough troubling signs during his time with the Twins (shoddy control, untenably low 6% swinging strike rate) to cast serious doubt on his viability as anything more than a back-of-rotation starter. Not that this is without value – especially at a low cost. 14. Miguel Sano, 3B (25) 2018 Ranking: 4 It was a rough, rough year for the third baseman, who saw his stock plummet like a mile-high fly ball hurtling down to Earth. Seemingly never quite right after undergoing major surgery on his leg during the previous offseason, Sano played poorly enough to merit a demotion all the way to Single-A in June. He made his way back six weeks later but didn't look much better, and played only four games in September due to another leg injury. The innate talent that resides within Sano is plainly obvious, but so too is the reality at hand: if he doesn't reverse course, he's on his way to going from promising young slugger to marginal asset – chronically dinged up, obscenely strikeout-prone, defensively inflexible, and generally unproductive. (This is also known as the Oswaldo Arcia Path.) He's got much to prove, and it starts with completing his ambitious offseason conditioning program, which the Twins are monitoring closely. If he comes back in improved shape, with his left leg issues finally behind him, maybe that talent starts to reemerge. Few players can hit or throw the ball as hard. Sano is eligible for arbitration this offseason for the first time, meaning free agency is only three years away. The clock ticks on his turnaround. 13. Kyle Gibson, RHP (31) 2018 Ranking: N/A At long last, things came together for Gibson. For many years, his arsenal showed the potential to overpower big-league hitters, but that didn't really come to fruition. In the latter half of 2017 he seemingly turned a corner, and then he backed it up big-time in 2018. His 11.5% swinging strike rate was easily a career high, edging Jose Berrios (11.3%) to lead the rotation. Gibson's performance wasn't flawless by any means, but he was steady and effective, bringing length to a starting corps that needed it. As long as he stays healthy in 2019 there's little reason to expect a step back. The factors suppressing his ranking on this list are age (turned 31 in October), cost (likely to make around $9 million in 2019), and control (free agent after next season). 12. Trevor May, RHP (29) 2018 Ranking: 19 It's not clear yet how the Twins plan to deploy May going forward. He might be a closer, after looking awfully good in the role down the stretch. He might be a bullpen fireman, called upon in tight spots to unleash his elite swing-and-miss stuff. He might be a multi-inning long reliever, given his historically strong and durable arm. And I still happen to think he could be a pretty good starter. This much is clear: May is an awfully nice piece for the Twins to have around, and a real game-changer for their pitching staff. He is under control for two more years and will remain inexpensive in 2019, since he's spent most of the past two seasons rehabbing. 11. Mitch Garver, C (28) 2018 Ranking: N/A A few weeks ago, I posed an open question: Is Mitch Garver still a catcher? I'm not sure we definitively know the answer, but the general assumption right now seems to be "yes." And if so, he's a borderline Top 10 asset to the organization. This is true because of the scarcity he addresses – Jason Castro is one year away from free agency and the system lacks any high-level catching depth – but also because he's just shown to be a solid player at the position. Garver's rookie production, which progressively improved over the summer, was above-average for a catcher. Reviews on his defense varied but he did show some positive signs of improvement and making adjustments. Turning 28 in a couple weeks, he's not young relative to others in this emerging core, but he's inexpensively controllable for years to come. With that said, concussion concerns will hang over him until he goes a prolonged period without incidents or setbacks. RECAPPING THE RANKINGS: 20. Nick Gordon, SS 19. C.J. Cron, 1B 18. Adalberto Mejia, LHP 17. Jake Cave, OF 16. Wander Javier, SS 15. Stephen Gonsalves, LHP 14. Miguel Sano, 3B 13. Kyle Gibson, RHP 12. Trevor May, RHP 11. Mitch Garver, C Click here to view the article
  29. Dogs

    PseudoSABR reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Well worth the 6 minutes. I'm not crying, you're crying.
  30. Article: 2018 Twins: The Year in Debut

    wabene reacted to nater79a for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Good overview, Seth! Here are my 2019 call up categories: First, from the "Yeah, kind of expected it at some point" list: Lamonte Wade - a DL stint from one of our outfielders will necessitate a call for Wade. Lewis Thorpe- Twins seem to always need a dozen or more starters each season. Thorpe will be one of them. From the "Obligatory September Call Up" list" Nick Gordon - Might struggle some again at Rochester preventing an earlier MLB debut. But I think he gets a call up this time for the season's final month. Brent Rooker - Will get a look after once again showing a lot of power at AAA Rochester. From the "We need an 'opener' or 26th man, pronto!" list: Ryan Eades - Forgot about him? Yeah, I almost did too. From the "Whoa! Did not see that coming at all" list: Cody Stashak - May well start out with the Blue Wahoos but quickly move up to the Wings. Will pitch well enough for the Twins to grab him mid-season and install him in a middle relief role on the big club. Luke Raley - Corner infielder. Corner outfielder. Yeah, I think he's versatile enough that the Twins just might provide him with his MLB debut sometime in 2019. Ohh, and poor Jake Reed. Will not see his MLB debut with the Twins in 2019. Again.
  31. Yeah, local teams are allowed to value players differently than sportswriters in Vermont do. I'd prefer the retired numbers don't get watered down, but I don't think they are at this point. The Twins Hall of Fame has made some selections that make me slightly hesitate.
  32. Mike Zimmer

    gunnarthor reacted to Badsmerf for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Zimmer has almost a.600 win percentage as a head coach. This was with Bridgewater, Bradford, and Keenum as qb for 3 seasons. I'd be surprised if any are ever named a starter going into another season. Zimmer has faults, most glaringly his record in prime time games is unacceptable. There have been clear preparation let downs. The Bills game is a good example. These are exceptions and not the rule though. Even Bill Belichick has games like that, and he has had an all time great qb for almost his entire time at New England. I don't think the talent is consistent on this roster. That is why I put more blame on Spielman than Zimmer.
  33. I understand the collective frustration with Miguel Sano. Still this ranking is ridiculously low. He remains as one of the few potential superstars in theTwins system. This is a guy in a Home Run era of baseball, who could hit over 40 dingers on a yearly basis for 3 straight years or more. Granted, he could be confirmed disaster and done in two years as well. He clearly is a more valuable asset than Gibson., May and Garver - and several of the players yet to be higher on your list. Craaaaazy!
  34. Man, I really hope concussions don't force Garver away from the plate. He's a terrific asset there and his bat plays so nicely. he's showing a nice combination of patience with a decent amount of pop. His positional flexibility is helpful to any roster, but if he can't catch any longer, it's a real loss. i can't blame Nick for dropping Sano down to this level. It's fair to think that his upside should still rank him higher (he is only a year away from smacking 28 hrs in 114 games), but in 4 seasons he's never played 120 games in any of them. He's had 2 that were...not good. Last season was a disaster. At the same time...he's only 25 and it wouldn't take a whole lot for him to step back up as a premiere slugging 3B. he's an asset, but his value definitely has dropped pretty far and pretty fast. I like May a lot, probably more that is warranted. He was terrific this season, but is it the dreaded SSS or a combo of him finally being healthy and figuring it out? I suppose this season is a prove it one, but I'm glad to have him in mix.
  35. Week 17: Vikings vs Bears

    nicksaviking reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Both Spielman and Zimmer have one year left, so you are probably right. Cutting Sendejo, Rudolph, and Remmers will give this team 30M in cap space. Griffin could also be cut for another 10M. But the team will need TE, DT, LB, OG, and maybe WR on their shopping list. O'Neill looks to have been a good pick, so that helps. Richardson may be willing to return too. I hope we're done with Rudolph though.
  36. Very interesting, Nick. But the biggest disagreement I would have of your first 10 is Gonsalves. I don't see him as ever being more than a AAAA pitcher for the Twins. One of those great minor league guys that can't get it done on the big stage. Not only wouldn't I have him in the Top 20 most valuable, I wouldn't have him on the list if you did a Top 30. Hopefully he will prove me wrong, but I expect he will be out of the organization within two years.
  37. 1 point
    You're not confused Jim. The whole purpose of the changes is to increase the chances of winning. Otherwise you don't consider it and you know that. Trying to run traditionally is lowering the chances of winning. Compensation is an issue... It's a big issue. The 5 man rotation is baked into the system, there is going to be resistance and money is going to be a big part of that resistance. However... Mr. Brooks is right. The goal is to win games. The current system is going to have to adjust.
  38. The problem is it just isn't that easy to know what players to keep or discard. Are most first graders ready for third or fourth grade?. No. They need to build skill sets to be ready for the next level. Sure every now and then you get genius but it is rare. Look at Gordon as an example he had a 900 OPS in AAA. In your scenario he starts is ready for MLB but we know that he can't even handle AAA. Also you completely ignore service time issues. If it takes two to three years for them to figure out MLB than you wasted valuable service time. If you give up too soon then you run the possibility of an Aaron Hicks scenario. There is more to these decisions than you are allowing for.
  39. Check that....after watching it a couple more minutes its up to the funniest this month and climbing.....just soooo many nuances to appreciate
  40. Meh, I'd probably have Sano in this 11-15 block, though probably closer to 11. He is what he is, which is ok, could be great, but probably not. I think most the other starters with team control plus some pitchers are just as valuable at this point.
  41. If 29 other teams didn't want Nelson Cruz, we'd have gotten him for the league minimum. 29 other teams didn't want him for the same price we did. But, that's true of any negotiable item. By your logic, 29 teams won't want Harper, 29 teams won't want Machado, and nobody on the planet wanted any of our currently owned homes.
  42. 1 point
    I think the talent is there and underperforming. Which puts the onus on the coach. I've been in his corner since day 1, but I think firing Zimmer is justified. I'd keep Spielman.
  43. 1 point
    I think Romero will be in the pen to start 2019, and I think that is a great plan.
  44. 1 point
    I suspect these players would net...Brian Duensing.
  45. Odorizzi - 75 pitches and done.

    Dantes929 reacted to Riverbrian for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Great Topic. This is what I’ve been talking about. For decades... Everyone has to fit in a box. Starters throw 100 pitches... relievers throw 25. Smash that box. Relievers can throw more than 1 inning and starters can throw less than 5. There is no reason to force something that isn’t working just to remain in an old box. And we don’t have to create a new box to lock pitchers into either. Such as stacking Odorizzi and Mejia together. Get 13 pitchers and give the ball to your best performers more often. If Odorizzi has a 75 pitch shelf life and it’s been consistent. Why would you keep trying to get 25 more pitches out of him. The only reason you would do that is because of the decades old box that requires a starter to go 100 and relievers go 25. You want a new plan to incorporate what Jorganswest is smartly suggesting. You can start by removing the Starter and reliever labels. Just call them pitchers and simply smash the box. A 5 man starting rotation. That’s for teams who have 5 guys to rotate and that’s like a 3 teams.
  46. Let's think big and try to win the division! 1. Sign David Robertson to a 2 yr/$22M deal with a $11M vesting option for year 3. Robertson would solidify the back end of the bullpen and if the third year is a vesting option, the Twins would reduce their risk. 2. Trade Nick Gordon, Blayne Enlow, Lamonte Wade and Tyler Austin to the Diamondbacks for Zach Grienke, Eduardo Escobar (and $44.5M to help cover Grienke's salary). I have no idea what the Diamondbacks think they'll get for Grienke or how much money they're willing to eat, but adding Grienke to the top of the rotation with Berrios would solidify the starters and replacing Austin on the roster with Escobar would provide a ton of flexibility that the Twins currently don't have with the Cruz signing. Line-up 1. Eduardo Escobar 3B/SS/2B 2. Jorge Polanco SS 3. Nelson Cruz DH 4. Eddie Rosario LF 5. Miguel Sano 1B/3B 6. Max Kepler RF 7. Jonathan Schoop 2B 8. Byron Buxton CF 9. Jason Castro C Bench Mitch Garver C C.J. Cron 1B Ehire Adrianza IF Jake Cave OF Starting Pitchers 1. Zach Grienke 2. Jose Berrios 3. Kyle Gibson 4. Jake Odorizzi 5. Michael Pineda Bullpen David Robertson Trevor Hildenberger Addison Reed Taylor Rodgers Trevor May Fernando Romero Aldeberto Mejia
  47. Angels DFA Alex Meyer

    howieramone2 reacted to Shaitan for a post in a topic

    1 point
    So because Meyer "wasn't terrible" some 5 years after the trade, no player should ever sign with the Twins? Meyer was terrible with the Twins MLB team during his cup of coffee, he wasn't good in Anaheim either, and he's had repeated health concerns dating back to before his time in the Twins organization.
  48. Pineda 2019 season

    DocBauer reacted to bird for a post in a topic

    1 point
    By all accounts, Pineda had recovered nicely following his TJ surgery. He had surgery to repair a meniscus in September and not an arm issue. Surely he's fully recovered from that by now. I guess I'm encouraged that they're penciling him in as a good bet for back end production. I also wonder, with Pineda, Mejia, Gonsalves, (Romero as a high-leverage bullpen guy), Stewart, and maybe even Thorpe, if they can even set the rotation for the better part of the year and avoid a rotating door due to performance problems. Injuries are another matter. Even if they have a string of injuries and failure in some combination, guys like De Jong, Littell, and even Slegers are better back-ups than what we had to put up with for #6-8 options in the past few seasons than those guys at #9-11 on the depth chart.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.