Leaderboard
-
bluechipper
Provisional MemberPoints2,268Posts -
nicksaviking
Community ModeratorPoints18,707Posts -
-
Mike Sixel
Old-Timey MemberPoints36,790Posts
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/13/2016 in all areas
-
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
SF Twins Fan and 9 others reacted to diehardtwinsfan for a post in a topic
10 pointsI think the TD consensus is to trade BD and install Polanco there. That's where I am. That said, Polanco does have value. He's young, has 5 or 6 seasons remaining under control, has had stellar minor league numbers, and pretty decent major league ones. Is there risk there? Sure, but it's low. The question is what the reward would look like. That said, I think it would be downright foolish for the Twins to trade him. I really hope option 5 is not on the table here. I've got to think it's option 2. I'd rather him not be the SS, for no other reason than I think it would be odd to rely on BD knowing he is either gone after 2018 or very expensive during what would be his decline phase (which to be fair could start as soon as this season, asking him to hit another 40 HR is asking a lot). I've got to think the smart move is trading BD. Polanco won't likely upgrade Dozier. He may never upgrade Dozier, but what he can be is above average with the bat and glove at an up the middle position. A high OBP and a low 800s OPS with above average defense is still a fine player, and if trading the 900s OPS guy with sub par defense nets a top shelf pitcher, the team is better off in both the short term and long term.10 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
SF Twins Fan and 9 others reacted to bluechipper for a post in a topic
10 pointsReally? He's made several top 100 lists the last couple of years. It'll be years before the Twins, or any team, considers waiving Polanco.10 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Danchat and 6 others reacted to SydneyTwinsFan for a post in a topic
7 pointsHe just turned 23 and has been remarkably consistent through all levels - .280/.340/.410 ish throughout his minor league career with a 109 OPS+ in his limited time with the big club. He certainly has trade value; the question is whether he has more value as a young player on a rebuilding team than he would return in a trade. I suppose the supplementary to that question is whether Polanco + the return from a Dozier trade > Dozier + the return from a Polanco trade. It all depends on the trade market, but I would plan to roll with him as the starting SS in 2017 unless the Twins are blown away in the offseason in a trade for Dozier, in which case I'd happily slide him across to 2B. There's a reasonable prospect Dozier gets traded in the next 18 months anyway, if not this offseason, at which point you put Polanco at 2B and hope Gordon is ready at SS.7 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
SF Twins Fan and 5 others reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic
6 pointsI will continue to bear the drum of trading Dozier and letting Polanco take over 2B full-time.6 points -
Article: Give Them A Chance
Article: Give Them A Chance
USAFChief and 4 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic
5 pointsIn February of 2012, we merged four prominent Twins blogs into one. It was the start of Twins Daily. We are quite proud of the community of Twins fans that we have established here at Twins Daily. Our forums are busy, filled with generally intelligent, civilized discussion on Twins topics, positive, negative or informative. We encourage you to create your own blog on our site for more discussion. If you’re like us, you’re not just a Minnesota Twins fan. Many of you, presumably, are Minnesota sports fans. We have Monday morning quarterback tendencies and have all had our moments of Vikings disappointment. That’s true even if we were born since the last time the team lost a Super Bowl. Names like Herschel Walker, Mike Lynn, and Gary Anderson cause a reaction inside us. It is the same reaction many Minnesotans still get when they hear the names of Norm Green or Nick Leddy. Minnesota fans love Minnesota sports, at least a couple of them.Tonight, the Minnesota Wild will take the ice in St. Louis for their first game of the 2016-17 season. This should be an exciting season for the Wild. Last spring they fired Mike Yeo. He was replaced by Bruce Boudreau. The 2016-17 roster is a nice combination of veterans like Zach Parise, Ryan Suter and newcomer Eric Staal. They also have a group of 25-and-unders that remain exciting. Names like Mikael Granlund, Jason Zucker, Charlie Coyle, Erik Haula and Nino Neiderreiter need to take a step forward. Two years ago, we launched Wild Xtra with the same goals and the same mission as we have here at Twins Daily. We look to provide quality articles that provoke thought and discussion. We would love to have a intelligent, civil discussion. We want to encourage independent writers to create their own blogs on the site to share their thoughts on the club. The Minnesota Vikings are the NFL’s lone undefeated team as they enter their bye weekend. Even with injuries to their quarterback, future Hall of Fame running back, several offensive linemen and others, the team has played very well. The offense has been all right. The Vikings defense is elite, one of the best in the game. Vikings fans have had reason for optimism in various years over the last decade or so. This year is something different. There is a feeling that this defense can carry the team to the Super Bowl. There is a lot of season remaining for that to be the case, but the team and its players are certainly deserving of its accolades to this point. We launched Vikings Journal a little over two years ago. It has undergone several changes but there is a core of writers each week that provide content. As important, there is a community in the forums that civilly discuss the goings-on with the Vikings and the NFL. Twins Daily, Vikings Journal and Wild Xtra are tied together under the MinnCentric family. If you are registered at Twins Daily, you can use the same Username and Password on the Wild Xtra and Vikings Journal sites. That makes it easy to go from site to site and comment or blog. We would really like to help build those communities. Obviously we appreciate you spending some of your time each day reading and commenting at Twins Daily. But today we want to encourage you to take a couple of minutes of your time to visit Wild Xtra and Vikings Journal. Register your username and spend a few minutes reading the content, and commenting in the forums. Also, if you would like to express your thoughts on the Wild or the purple, start your own blogs. You can follow the MinnCentric sites on social media: Follow Twins Daily, Wild Xtra and Vikings Journalon Twitter. Like Twins Daily, Wild Xtra and Vikings Journal on Facebook. Give these sites a chance. We really appreciate all of your support despite the losing we have seen from the Twins over the last half-dozen seasons. The Minnesota Wild and Minnesota Vikings both have a good chance to make the playoffs and an opportunity to do some special things this season. Hop on the bandwagons and help us grow. Click here to view the article5 points -
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
big dog and 4 others reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic
5 pointsHe'll be very rusty. Not a risk I'm willing to take, in the 7th game of the World Series.5 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
cjj td and 4 others reacted to bluechipper for a post in a topic
5 pointsHave you seen Brian throw? I think he would be pretty bad defensively at 3B.5 points -
Twins 40-man Report Cards
Twins 40-man Report Cards
DJSim22 and 4 others reacted to Brandon Warne for a post in a topic
5 pointsNone of those guys are making the team out of Fort Myers. So you keep Boshers until they're ready. And frankly, if Boshers pitches like he did last year again next year, he has trade value. Maybe more than Abad, due to years of control. As I noted, Boshers outpitched guys who got multi-year deals for lots of cash -- relative to value -- so there's a reason to keep him, even if it's just to flip him.5 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
EddieMatthews and 4 others reacted to NE Gopher for a post in a topic
5 pointsWhy isn't there more interest in moving Dozier to third?5 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Taildragger8791 and 4 others reacted to bluechipper for a post in a topic
5 pointsMy plan would be for Polanco to open the season at SS. No, his defense is not at the level that you'd want, but his offensive upside makes up for a lot of that. Plus, if he's not the starting SS, I don't think Eduardo Escobar is enough of a defensive upgrade to justify putting Polanco in a utility role.5 points -
Article: Give Them A Chance
Article: Give Them A Chance
twinsnorth49 and 3 others reacted to Doomtints for a post in a topic
4 pointsThis is hands down the best community-driven Twins site on the web. The Vikings side could use more activity and it will grow with time. The Wild and Wolves are a bit past my days in Minnesota so I don't follow them, but there is no reason this can't be the place for fans of both. One question. Though users can use their Twins Daily accounts on the other sites, there is still a bit of a registration hoopla one has to do in order to post on sites you didn't initially sign up on. Why not make this completely seamless? You register for one, you can post anywhere. One registration and you are automatically a member of everything on the site. I will certainly be blogging for the Twins and possibly the Vikings in the future. Great thanks to Seth and all the others who made this place an open community where everyone can contribute and express their opinions. I was once a regular on 'another' Twins forum where the comments can get a bit disrespectful. I assumed this was because the site was lightly moderated and simply accepted it as a place where people could freely express themselves. After some time I learned that the people who were disrespectful were all of the moderators. At that point I realized it wasn't a place where people can express themselves at all, but it was a place where the moderators were bullying people. Once I figured that out I left and never came back. Twins Daily is a site where I know this would never happen.4 points -
Article: Give Them A Chance
Article: Give Them A Chance
twinsnorth49 and 3 others reacted to PDX Twin for a post in a topic
4 pointsThanks for all the great work you do on this site. It's my first click in the morning and has brought me much closer to the Twins in the last few years.4 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
Hosken Bombo Disco and 2 others reacted to biggentleben for a post in a topic
3 pointsMichelle Obama making a speech today that was tremendous. That is all I'll say on that. Trump's line today about the women coming forward: "Just look at them, c'mon..." Wow.3 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
HitInAPinch and 2 others reacted to Mr. Brooks for a post in a topic
3 pointsDozier barely has the arm strength to make the throws from 2B. The left side is not an option for him.3 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
SF Twins Fan and 2 others reacted to wsnydes for a post in a topic
3 pointsI see it as a matter of time before Polanco gets shifted to 2B with Gordon coming down the pipe. Why not capitalize on Dozier's season and trade him now? Move Polanco to 2B and use Escobar at SS until Gordon is ready to come up. A utility role for Polanco would be a complete waste. Polanco seems destined to be a 2B regardless of his defensive abilities at SS. With that considered, Dozier wouldn't seem to be in the long term plans for this team and frankly shouldn't be. They've got to let this core group of youngsters grow as a team together. Keeping Dozier, in my view, is a wasted opportunity to improve the club and free up space for younger players that figure to be a part of the resurgence of this club.3 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
Bark's Lounge and 2 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
3 pointsYa, I doubt any real number of people want to make it so women can't vote.....3 points -
Article: Give Them A Chance
Article: Give Them A Chance
Jerr and 2 others reacted to theBOMisthebomb for a post in a topic
3 pointsWhy no love for the Wolves?3 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Broker and 2 others reacted to Thrylos for a post in a topic
3 pointsHard to criticize the guys defense at SS when the Twins have moved him all over the place the season after Baseball America rated him the best defensive SS in the FSL (scroll down.) One has to realize that Polanco, outside of the Twins farm brass that for some reason do not like his play at SS, has been seen as a better than average defender. In addition to the above, BA rated him the Twins best defensive infielder in 2009 and 2010 (same link.) The Twins' talent "evaluators" and "developers" messed with him by not letting him develop in the position. It is hard to play SS well right away, after you play 2B only for 2 seasons. Let the kid play a full season or two at SS and then we can talk about his defense.3 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
TheLeviathan and 2 others reacted to Badsmerf for a post in a topic
3 pointsI've been to a lot of desperate, no future small towns in the year in eastern Colorado, western Oklahoma, western Texas ect. It's sad really. Those people have nothing to look forward to. They have no agriculture to inject money into the local economy like Minnesota and Iowa do. I live in small town Iowa but it's different. Farmers here (well I'm in Prague right now but you get) get 200 bushels an acre from corn and 80 from beans. They kill it. With that much money coming in, combined with a bunch of manufacturing all over the state, Iowa is very well off. The same explanations can't be used here as a general rule, however, at a smaller level the sentiment is the same. The problem is, the Democrat party has failed to appeal to them. Many small town people don't like change. I'm generalizing, but they like the good old days and the nostalgia that comes with it. It's hard to accept that everything is changing and adapting. That is where the gop capitalized and took control is the message. A lot of them are religious too and always leaned Republican. Trump just spoke to them and ignited the darkside (anger, fear, hate). Side note. I use Yoda quotes about the dark side with my religious wife all the time. If you follow Yoda, it very closely resembles Christian ideals. I tell her to use the force all the time, which of course she translates as God. It works for us.3 points -
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 8 (1-5)
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 8 (1-5)
howieramone2 and 2 others reacted to bird for a post in a topic
3 pointsTake heart, h2oface. Over the years, there have been a lot of fans who have needed glasses when it comes to the early stages of a player's big league career. We don't know which of these guys will end up more like Torii Hunter versus Marty Cordova, but it's not drinking koolaid to be optimistic, for example that Berrios will get it figured out any more than it might have been to excuse Frank Viola or Brad Radke for a shaky start. Or Brian Dozier. Or Gary Gaetti, especially defensively. Or Byron Buxton. Kepler. Sano. There's been plenty of evidence beyond the raw numbers that are telling discerning baseball people that Buxton and Sano still have the makings of future stardom. That's reality. In short, I think it's reaonable to be optimistic that most of the players you mentioned with fulfill expectations eventually, and I think it's reasonable to be optimistic about this next wave too, as long as we remember they don't quite have the elite pedigree of Buxton or Sano.3 points -
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
No. I like his glove and obp, especially if he sits against lefties. Plus I want to see you tortured for the next two years.☺3 points
-
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
glunn and one other reacted to Nick Nelson for a post in a topic
2 pointsAs we gear up for a crucial Minnesota Twins offseason, we have talked – and will continue to talk – about pitching a great deal. But on the other side, Jorge Polanco stands out as one of the most pivotal figures in the organization's planning. Today, we'll take a look at five options for handling the talented young infielder heading into 2017.Polanco has been a longtime star in Minnesota's system. He has been among the Top 10 on Twins Daily's top prospect list each of the past three years, performing well at each level of the minors. In 2014 he became the youngest Twin to debut in the majors since Joe Mauer a decade before. And this year, in his first prolonged taste of the big leagues, he put up very strong numbers and looked every bit the part of an everyday MLB player. But the problem now, as it has been for the past few seasons, is that there's no obvious full-time opening for the 23-year-old switch-hitter. And while patience has been an affordable luxury in the past, that is no longer the case. Polanco will be out of options in 2017, meaning that the Twins will need to keep him on the roster out of spring training or lose him. That reality will weigh heavily as they lay things out for next season. As I see it, the Twins have five different routes they can take with Polanco. Let's run through the merits of each: 1. Starting Shortstop For a few reasons, this would appear to be the most likely outcome. First, because the Twins don't really have another strong candidate for the position. Eduardo Escobar is the only alternative and he had a tough year that ended on an extremely sour note (.384 OPS in September). Second, because Polanco was Paul Molitor's exclusive starter at shortstop in the final six weeks of the season. That would seem to set the stage for a full-time assignment going forward. However, there's a problem here, and it's a big one. Polanco is not a good defender at shortstop. The organization had essentially given up on playing him there in the minors before he was called up. Defensive metrics rate him very poorly at the position. Even Molitor, the manager who wrote his name in at shortstop daily in the final stretch of the campaign, would only say that Polanco "handled it fairly well" and was "not going to get an 'A' grade." The Twins need to vastly improve in terms of run prevention, and defense is a big part of that. Outside of catcher, shortstop is arguably the most important position on the field. In my opinion, rolling with a subpar glove like Polanco is simply not an option. 2. Starting Second Baseman I think everyone can agree that this is Polanco's best position. It minimizes his primary weakness (his arm) and allows his strengths to shine. It's where he spent all of his time in the Dominican Winter League last year and in Rochester this year before joining the Twins for good. Of course, he happens to be blocked at this position by Minnesota's best player. As long as Brian Dozier is on the roster, second base is off limits. I do think the possibility of a Dozier trade is reasonably strong, so Polanco could still end up here. But as things stand, it's not an option. 3. Starting Third Baseman Sort of an intriguing possibility. If the Twins want to move on from Trevor Plouffe and his expensive 2017 commitment but aren't ready to entrust Miguel Sano with the position following a very shaky defensive showing this year, Polanco could be a solution. He didn't look especially good in his nine starts at the hot corner this year, but could improve if it is his focus heading into the offseason and spring training. However, the downsides here are clear. His arm might play a little better at third than short, but still would hardly be an asset. And while his bat stands out at a middle infield spot, that's less true at an offense-driven corner position. This year, American League third basemen posted the highest OPS of any position other than DH. 4. Backup or Utility Man This idea has its appeal. In a utility role, Polanco would be able to fill in a few times per week around the diamond, and would be an excellent fallback if (when?) one of the starters fizzled or got hurt. With his ability to swing from both sides and his solid speed, he would be a handy piece of have on the bench. Yet, it feels like a bit of a waste. It's also not especially fair to the player. Polanco has shown enough during his time in the majors to justify an everyday role. He's still in a developmental stage and that could be hindered by a lack of regular playing time. 5. Trade Him I really wonder if this is what they are leaning toward. In the latter part of the season, Polanco was constantly playing shortstop and frequently batting third in the order. Does the team really view him as that caliber of player, or were they simply showcasing him for the rest of the league? Everyone knows Polanco would be fine at second, but now teams have plenty of film to evaluate and make their own judgments about his proclivity at short. The Twins know that if they want to acquire impact talent via trade, it might mean giving up some of their own coveted young players. Polanco is among the only ones among that group that could really be viewed as expendable. What it comes down to is how much the rest of the execs around the league value Polanco. It doesn't make sense to give up a young, controllable middle infielder who has proven his capabilities at the major-league level unless you're getting a significant haul in return. Given that Polanco has a well-rounded yet unspectacular skill set, I do wonder if a sufficient offer is going to come. What would be your plan for Polanco this offseason? Click here to view the article2 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
USAFChief and one other reacted to notoriousgod71 for a post in a topic
2 pointsKevin Haessig reincarnated as Kenneth Bone.2 points -
Article: Give Them A Chance
Article: Give Them A Chance
glunn and one other reacted to John Bonnes for a post in a topic
2 pointsThanks for all the kind words in the post (that I erased in the quote out of modesty). The registration isn't as seamless as we would like it to be between the sites, but it's the best we can do for now. It's just technically very tricky to make two separate site use the same security IDs and such and keep them in sync. In fact, if you remember, the original Twins Daily platform that we had until two years ago, the whole reason we switched was because there was just no way to do it with that platform. We had to build this one from the ground up just to have the IDs be able to be used across the platforms. So I appreciate your patience. We will work on that along with some other changes when we have a little more bandwidth.2 points -
Article: Early 2017 Draft Prospects
Article: Early 2017 Draft Prospects
Cory Engelhardt and one other reacted to Bob Sacamento for a post in a topic
2 pointsStarting next week I will be in Jupiter for the Perfect Game WWBA World Championship. Last year saw the likes of first rounders: Matt Manning, Ben Rortvedt, Alex Kirilloff, Jason Groome, Josh Lowe, Delvin Perez, Carter Kieboom, Cole Ragans. Of the Top 50 HS players (rated by PG), the majority will be playing in the tourney: 2 Jordon "Jo" Adell OF 4 DL Hall LHP 6 Hans Crouse RHP 7 Alejandro Toral 1B 10 Conner Uselton OF 14 Calvin Mitchell OF 16 Tanner Burns RHP 17 Nick Allen SS 18 Brady McConnell SS 21 Cole Brannen OF 22 Adam Hall SS 23 Jeremiah Estrada RHP 25 Mitchell Stone LHP 26 Garrett "Hunter" Ruth RHP 27 Kyle Jacobsen OF 28 Mervyl "MJ" Melendez C 30 Mark Vientos SS 31 Drew Waters OF 32 Jayson Gonzalez MIF 34 Caleb Sloan RHP 36 Oraj Anu OF 37 Jordan Anderson OF 38 Jacob Pearson OF 40 Terriez Fuller OF 42 Ricardo De La Torre SS 43 Luis Campusano C 45 Jacob Gonzalez 3B 46 Logan Allen LHP 47 Tim Elko 3B 48 Philip Clarke C 49 Johnathan Rodriguez OF 50 Heliot Ramos OF2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
SF Twins Fan and one other reacted to Linus for a post in a topic
2 pointsAgreed. At this point they will really win fans over by winning.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
brvama and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
2 pointsIndividual players don't sell tickets, not Brian Dozier. How many less people buy tickets if they trade him? 50? 100? 1000 (no way)?2 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
TheLeviathan and one other reacted to biggentleben for a post in a topic
2 pointsFunny thing is that I'd hit any one of those three towns depending on the route I chose to take from home to the Twin Cities.2 points -
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
wsnydes and one other reacted to Doomtints for a post in a topic
2 pointsMy theory is that if he is given days off every week throughout the season -- 30-40 days off -- he'll be fine. So I think he can do 120-130 games without injury as long as he gets the days off. Play him more than that, and he'll get injured and give you the same amount of games.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Cory Engelhardt and one other reacted to Platoon for a post in a topic
2 pointsI would trade BD. I think the defense is close to a wash, with Polanco eventually being better than Dozier. And while Dozier had a four month stretch like few before him, I think Polanco is easily a much better pure hitter, and will continue to be so. Will he hit 40 HR's? Nope, and I really don't think Dozier will ever do that again. Or for that matter 30. They have added done and in to off the plate in how he is being pitched, and it's been very effective. He will still hit his 20 HR's, which is nothing to sneeze at. But I would sell as high as I can on him, while I can.2 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
Vanimal46 and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsA self-flagellation retreat, I heard.2 points -
Front Page: 1987 Revisited: Twins Upset Tigers
Front Page: 1987 Revisited: Twins Upset Tigers
Parker Hageman and one other reacted to Blake for a post in a topic
2 pointsMy then wife and I went to the Metrodome for the welcome home party. The people at the Metrodome later told me (I did some contract work at the Metrodome for a while and got to know a few of the people who worked there) they were stunned at the crowd that showed up to welcome the Twins back from Detroit.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Cory Engelhardt and one other reacted to Nick Nelson for a post in a topic
2 pointsIsn't this the kind of thinking that helped lead them to their run prevention mess this year? I've seen enough, honestly. He doesn't have the arm to be an asset at the position. He can play it serviceably, but they need more than that. Pointing to Baseball America's accolades from 2 or 5-6 years ago doesn't really support a strong case. Instead of pointing to those maybe you could look at what BA said about him in their most recent profile, from last year: "He has averaged 34 errors the past two seasons since moving to shortstop, showing fairly soft hands but an average arm that strains at times to match the added burden of the position. His range is only average and his play clock gets sped up, leading to unforced errors. Quiet and intelligent with a grinder's mentality, his makeup is strong. With all-star second baseman Brian Dozier locked up through 2018, Polanco is blocked at his best projected position"2 points -
Article: Give Them A Chance
Article: Give Them A Chance
Riverbrian and one other reacted to ThejacKmp for a post in a topic
2 pointsLove Twins Daily. My view of Vikings Journal has been that it lacks good content and rarely has enough of it. That isn't helped that the comments sections are rarely entertaining to read - no one making an argument or starting a discussion. Maybe it's due to the basic difference between baseball and football? Baseball's stats make it easier for an everyday fan to make an argument and playing everyday keeps stories going. Football is significantly harder to understand and there's only 16-20 games a year.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Having both Dozier and Polanco on the same team is a sub-optimal use of their talents, as they belong both at 2B and putting one at SS or 3B diminishes his contribution. The question for me is whether trading either one brings back enough to exceed the suboptimal combination. (SydneyTwinsFan among others also expressed this point of view.) Therefore, before making any other decisions, I would shop both Dozier and Polanco hard. I want to know concretely the return either player would bring. Tactically, I think letting it be known both are being shopped will slightly increase the offers for the one who other GMs want more, probably Dozier - "I don't especially want Polanco, but if I lowball on Dozier, the Twins might accept an offer on Polanco from someone else, and then Dozier won't be traded". Dozier is at an age that he'd be the natural one to trade, if your business model is to exploit your minor league talent pipeline. We may look back and realize 2016 was his career year. On the other hand, if he's achieved a new level of performance, it's enough above average that he's the kind of player you want to retain. There is also the public relations problem with trading your best player, something that can not be ignored. So I want a lot in return for him, if I trade him - high upside starting pitching, to start with. The point of putting together a contending team is to fill all your positions with above MLB-average players. Those don't grow on trees. We finally have one. Polanco, as has been stated by others already, is less likely to bring back much in trade right now. If that assumption proves wrong, he's the one I probably deal. He projects as an above average 2B eventually, so I don't let him go for scraps in return. If neither trade option works out, I would roll with Polanco at SS for 2017.* I have been a harsh critic of Polanco's arm for a couple of years now, and I remain very skeptical he can ever become even an average shortstop overall. But his bat looks like it's good enough to make up for it, during a transition season; and unlike some players, being in over his head on defense didn't seem to harm his offensive production. Keep the channels open for a trade during 2017, and re-evaluate a year from now if I still have both players. * An option I haven't seen discussed: move Dozier to SS instead of Polanco. Both players are about average at 2B; if Dozier might provide marginally better defense at SS then that change has to be considered. The old regime seemed to give undue preference to veterans in their choice of positions; maybe under Falvey that changes. I think Dozier sees himself as enough of a team player to accept the challenge of being a mediocre SS for the good of the team. It's something Molitor wouldn't have asked of Dozier mid-season, but perhaps now he would.2 points
-
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 8 (1-5)
Article: Seth's Preliminary Top 50 Twins Prospects: Part 8 (1-5)
howieramone2 and one other reacted to bird for a post in a topic
2 pointsEvery single one of the scouts assigned to the international draft had more influence about both who should be signed and for how much than Billy Smith. And anyone who thinks they should all be fired is frightfully ignorant about the Twin's comparative success in the international arena. Smith's influence on the international effort, in truth, began much earlier than his short and disastrous tenure as GM. He, along with Andy MacPhail and Jim Pohlad, waged a long battle with Carl Pohlad before Carl finally capitulated and approved a massive budget increase that allowed the organization to finally build the necessary infrastructure of facilities and staff to build relationships and compete for talent in the D.R. This initiative took years, but they now have a beachhead there. Smith was a huge part of building this, and is still leaving his prints in this effort in very positive ways. The most striking recent evidence is the new joint facilities there, and anyone familiar with how the organization works will tell you that Billy Smith has been one of the people at the center of this undertaking.2 points -
Twins 40-man Report Cards
Twins 40-man Report Cards
HitInAPinch and one other reacted to Thrylos for a post in a topic
2 pointsI suspect that some (O'Rourke, Schafer, Wimmers) might not be on that roster when it is time for their name to be called2 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
Vanimal46 and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsIt's best if we all just learn to ignore Twitter and the fringe lunatics that reside on that platform. The site is full of people who your racist uncle believe are too far gone to reclaim. All it does it conveniently reinforce the worst stereotypes of both sides and allow us to brush aside legitimate concerns voiced by not-crazy people.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
SF Twins Fan and one other reacted to mazeville for a post in a topic
2 pointsYeah, the problem with this is that the regime at Target Field is changing. So any alleged showcase could be dismissed with the presence of Derek Falvey. Personally, I think the trade Brian Dozier scenario is the most likely given where the Twins are at and what they need. You trade Jorge Polanco when you need to trade for a veteran because you're close to contention. You trade Brian Dozier when you need prospects to help your team improve. This team is definitely in the latter category.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
leopoty and one other reacted to mickeymental for a post in a topic
2 pointsstick him at short with sano at third. let them take their lumps.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
bluechipper and one other reacted to curt1965 for a post in a topic
2 pointsI agree with Shane- starting SS. He actually is NOT horrible, and would be a great bridge to 2018. His bat will make up for a lot of defensive questions.2 points -
Front Page: 1987 Revisited: Twins Upset Tigers
Front Page: 1987 Revisited: Twins Upset Tigers
Parker Hageman and one other reacted to Tibs for a post in a topic
2 pointsParker, I love your writing. If you wrote a book I'd buy it in a second.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
bluechipper and one other reacted to Shane Wahl for a post in a topic
2 pointsStarting SS.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
TheBoofIsLoose and one other reacted to KirbyDome89 for a post in a topic
2 pointsPolanco as SS could be dicey if Sano is playing 3B. I think some of the offensive that Polanco may lack at 3B can be found at 2B by Dozier, 1B if Vargas platoons, and an improving OF of Rosario, Buxton, and Kepler. It isn't an ideal fit but giving up a little offense at 3B won't devastate this team. I agree, a utility role isn't appealing, but if Molitor uses Polanco like Dantana (i.e. playing him nearly every day) then I can stomach the utility role. Obviously 2B is the preferred spot for Polanco. I can see scenarios where options 1-4 work out. If somebody is traded, I hope its Dozier. He'll absolutely return more than Polanco, and he has only 2 years left on a good contract before free agency. Given the outlook for 2017 I think it makes much more sense to trade Dozier.2 points -
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
PDX Twin and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsAre there 25 people better than Mauer in the organization right now? No. Joe still has a specific skillset that's useful. And if there aren't 25 people better than Joe, you don't cut him. Bench him, maybe. Platoon him, sure. But I don't see the point in cutting him.2 points -
2016 Election Thread
2016 Election Thread
nicksaviking and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
2 pointsMust-read article about rural America from Cracked. That's not something I expected to say today. http://www.cracked.com/blog/6-reasons-trumps-rise-that-no-one-talks-about_p2/2 points -
To Tender or Not To Tender
To Tender or Not To Tender
Dman and one other reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
2 pointsTwins (7) Trevor Plouffe (5.162) – trade, or no tender Hector Santiago (5.016) – $8.6MM---tender Brandon Kintzler (5.003) – $2.2MM--meh, I don't care Eduardo Escobar (4.128) – $2.9MM--tender Tommy Milone (4.113) – $4.9MM--non-tender Kyle Gibson (3.056) – $3.5MM--tender Ryan Pressly (3.053) – $1.1MM---meh, i don't care2 points -
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
Can the Twins Afford to Release Mauer?
Oldgoat_MN and one other reacted to DuluthFan for a post in a topic
2 pointsWhile Mauer's skills may have diminished, he still leads the team in OBP, OBP w/ runners in scoring position, tied for 2nd BA w/ runners in scoring position, 3rd OPS w/ runners in scoring position,most walks on team, highest BA, triples and stolen bases among 1st base candidates (Sano, Plouffe, Vargas, Park) on team, and plays defense well. You're premise that Mauer is hurting the team is false. He performs better than the alternatives. Your only argument is with the amount he is being paid in comparison to others. Yes, he is getting paid a lot. He has earned it with his past performances. He is still earning it by outperforming the alternative options on the roster. Cutting him will not relieve the team of the salary, and it will surely not make the team better as seen by the stats. Mauer may not be leading the team in power numbers, but he is still among the best performing players on the team. He has two seasons left on his contract. He has earned his spot on this team.2 points -
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Article: Pondering A Plan For Jorge Polanco
Richie the Rally Goat reacted to Cory Engelhardt for a post in a topic
1 pointThat said, whatever the offers are this year (and you could argue at least 2-3 teams would see Dozier as a HUGE upgrade over what their currently have at 2nd base) that whatever those offers are, they are not going to be higher a year from now, or even at the deadline. Maybe I'm wrong, but Dozier having a career year this year certainly made it so the offers will never be higher. If the new GM and Falvey don't think they are getting requisite value now for Dozier, they will like the offers that come in a year even less.1 point -
Luke Cage (no spoilers!)
Luke Cage (no spoilers!)
TheLeviathan reacted to ericchri for a post in a topic
1 pointAt one point Mariah literally tossed out options like, "Does he breathe? Drown him." And Cottonmouth responds to that by basically going, "Nah, I've got it covered" cause he wants to spend a gajillion dollars on the super-bullet thing to take out Cage. Worst moment in the show for me. And then he doesn't even get the chance and Diamondback is the one using the bullets. I liked the feel of the show, the actors were almost all really good (except as previously noted Diamondback), and it was still a relatively interesting story, but they just dropped the ball hard in working up a way to deal with the whole invulnerability thing.1 point