Leaderboard
-
Seth Stohs
AdministratorPoints24,042Posts -
-
-
Brock Beauchamp
AdministratorPoints29,627Posts
Popular Content
Showing content with the highest reputation on 08/24/2016 in all areas
-
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
PseudoSABR and 12 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic
13 pointsI can't help but wonder how things for the Twins and Mauer's career perception would be different if his RBI double in the playoffs had been accurately called fair.13 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
gagu and 10 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic
11 pointsThis is where I'll disagree a little. Just because we never see his emotions does not mean he doesn't have tremendous drive and passion. It doesn't mean he doesn't care. For some, being able to control one's emotions helps make them great. I'd have to think that's part of why his career numbers in "clutch" situations, late in close games, runners in scoring position, are better than his overall numbers. Because he can stay calm when others might try to do too much. I just don't think the fact that he doesn't outwardly show fire means that he doesn't have tremendous passion for the game.11 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Dozier's Glorious Hair and 9 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic
10 pointsThere is no doubt in any Twins fan’s mind that Rod Carew is one of, if not the greatest players in team history. He is beloved by Twins fans who may or may not even remember his playing career which ended (and not prettyily) with the Twins after the 1978 season, nearly 40 years ago. Now consider this. In his 12 seasons in a Twins uniform, his on-base percentage was .393. His slugging percentage was .448. His OPS was .841. Now consider, Joe Mauer career numbers in a Twins uniform include a .393 on-base percentage, a .447 slugging percentage and an OPS of .840. Now, not even I will tell you that Joe Mauer’s Twins career has been as great as Carew’s. Carew was an All-Star all 12 of those seasons. Mauer has participated in six. Mauer has won three batting titles. No catcher had a batting championship in about 55 years when Mauer did it the first time, and no American League catcher had ever done it. Carew won so many American League batting titles that Major League Baseball announced at this year’s All-Star Game that all AL batting champions going forward will win the Rod Carew Award. No, I won’t tell you that Joe Mauer is the greatest player in Twins history. There’s no reason to make such claims. What I think the numbers below will illustrate for you is that he is, without a doubt, one of the top five hitters in Minnesota Twins history. (In fact, I wouldn’t rank him lower than fourth if I were asked to.)Below is where Joe Mauer ranks in most offensive statistics in his career with the Twins. Obviously there have been a lot of really good players, and there have been Hall of Fame caliber players. To be an all-time great for a team, obviously longevity plays a huge role. There aren’t a lot of players who have played 12 years in the big leagues with the same organization anymore. It seems that with greatness these days, players are expected to be more. Mauer is expected to keep hitting .330 every season despite the fact that he is now 33-years-old and caught for the first 14 seasons of his professional career (not to mention the years of amateur ball). People seem to forget the fact that when he suffered his season-ending concussion late in the 2013 season, he was hitting .324/.404/.476 (.880) which as 42% better than the average player by OPS+. BC (Before Concussion): .323/.405/.468 (.873) - 135 OPS+ AC (After Concussion): .272/.356/.385 (.741) - 105 OPS+ WHERE JOE MAUER RANKS IN MINNESOTA TWINS HISTORY? Games Played: 1,573 - #6 in Twins history As you would expect, Harmon Killebrew (1,939) leads the way with Kirby Puckett (1,783) about a season behind. Next up for Mauer is Rob Carew (1,635). By the end of his current contract, Mauer should have played around 1,900 games and in clear sight of Killebrew’s top spot. WAR (Wins Above Replacement): #4 in Twins history Rod Carew has a big advantage in this one, sitting at 63.7 for his Twins career. Harmon Killebrew was at 53.7, and Kirby Puckett was at 50.9. By Baseball-Reference, Mauer has been worth about 2.4 WAR in 2016. He’s not going to catch Carew, but with two more seasons like 2016, he’ll easily pass Puckett and Killebrew in the Twins rankings. Runs Scored: 879 - #5 in Twins history Kirby Puckett tops the list at 1,071. Harmon Killebrew is #2 at 1047. Next up for Mauer on this list is Kent Hrbek and 903. By the end of the two years left on his current contract, he should have passed a thousand runs scored and be right on the tail of Killebrew. Hits: 1,814 - #4 in Twins history Kirby Puckett leads the way with 2,304 hits. Second is Rod Carew at 2,085. Next on the list for Mauer is Tony Oliva, whom he should pass around the All-Star break next year. He will likely pass Carew by the end of the 2018 season as well. Doubles: 360 - #2 in Twins history Only Kirby Puckett has more doubles in Twins history. He hit 414 doubles in his career. Though inexplicably he has hit fewer doubles this season, Mauer is typically good for 30+ doubles a year. If he can reach that number the next two seasons, he’ll likely be atop this category by the end of 2018 too. Triples: 28 - #13 in Twins history Rod Carew tops this list by a bunch with 90. Next up for Mauer will be John Castino at 34. Unlikely he’ll do that, though triples are a bit random. Home Runs: 129 - #12 in Twins history Obviously Harmon Killebrew tops this category with 475 homers. Kent Hrbek is well behind at 293. Eight players in Twins history have hit over 200 homers in a Twins uniform. Mauer isn’t going to get there, but it’s possible he jumps into ninth place. With 34 homers, he can pass his current hitting coach, Tom Brunansky, who hit 163 homers in his six seasons with the Twins. Next for Mauer are Jacque Jones (132) and Michael Cuddyer (141). RBI: 800 - #6 in Twins history On Tuesday night, Mauer knocked in the 800th run of his career. He is the sixth player in Twins history to reach that number. Again, Killebrew leads the way with 1,325 RBI. Mauer should surpass Justin Morneau’s 860 next season. Walks: 811 - #3 in Twins history Surprise! It’s Harmon Killebrew leading the way in this category as well with 1,321 punch outs. Early next season, he will pass Kent Hrbek who walked 838 times in his Twins career. Intentional Walks: 137 - #2 in Twins history Mauer is just 15 intentional walks behind Killebrew’s 152. This statistic speaks to the respect that Mauer has around the league and with opposing managers. Even this year, there have been several times that Mauer has been walked to get to Miguel Sano. Strikeouts: 852 - #5 in Twins history You’ve got it! Killebrew leads this one by a wide margin too, with 1,314. Torii Hunter is #2 on the list with 975. Mauer will pass Gary Gaetti late this season or early next year, and he’s almost certain to pass both Puckett and Hunter before the end of his contract is up. Batting Average: .310 - #3 in Twins history (2,000+ PAs), #5 in Twins history (1,500 PAs) Carew leads this one by a healthy margin with a .334 career average. Next up is Kirby Puckett at .318. That is the same average as Lyman Bostock who didn’t reach 2,000 plate appearances with the Twins. Paul Molitor also didn’t reach 2,000 plate appearances, but he hit .312 over his three seasons with the Twins. Let’s hope that Mauer is able to keep his career average over .300. On-Base Percentage: .393 - #1 in Twins history (2,000+ PAs) Mauer is currently tied with Carew at .393. They are just ahead of Chuck Knoblauch’s .391 on-base percentage during his six seasons with the Twins. OPS: .840 - #5 in Twins history Killebrew tops the list at .901. Shane Mack’s underrated time with the Twins ranks second on the list at .854. Kent Hrbek ranks third at .848, and Rod Carew is at .841. So there you have it… a look at the raw numbers of Joe Mauer, with how they rank among Twins all-time leaders. In his 13 years in the big leagues, Mauer has some terrific overall numbers. His rate numbers have certainly taken a tumble the last few years, again, since the concussion. 2014 and 2015 were difficult, but 2016 has been a nice season for Mauer. No, not a .330 season, but a very solid season. Mauer is hitting .276/.376/.406 (.781) which equates to 13% above average (113 OPS+). HALL OF FAME? Yes, Joe Mauer will be inducted into the Twins Hall of Fame. He will also be the last player in Twins history to wear the #7. But is the Hall of Fame in Cooperstown still a possibility for Mauer. It’s never a real good reason to simply compare the numbers of any player against current Hall of Famers because there are certainly several Hall of Famers who, under today’s scrutiny,would likely not be inducted. But, just so you have it at your fingertips, here is a complete list of the 17 players in the Hall of Fame who played primarily at catcher: Johnny Bench. Yogi Berra. Roger Bresnahan. Roy Campanella. Gary Carter. Mickey Cochrane. Bill Dickey. Buck Ewing. Rick Ferrell. Carlton Fisk. Josh Gibson. Gabby Hartnett. Ernie Lombardi. Biz Mackey. Mike Piazza. Ray Schalk. Deacon White. Add Ivan “Pudge” Rodriguez who should go into the Hall of Fame on the first ballot, though likely not for a couple of years. I feel like Mauer will likely be one of those guys who is on the ballot all ten years and then doesn’t get it. But I would be pleasantly surprised if he does. Like I said earlier. I get it. Mauer set the bar high when he came to the big leagues as a 20 year old in 2004. He set it high when he became the first American League catcher to win a batting title. And then he did it two more times. He set the bar high when he led the league in batting average, on-base percentage, slugging percentage and OPS in 2009 when he won the AL MVP. People want to complain about the contract. He earned the contract. Get over it. People want to complain about him not catching. There isn’t a doctor who would support that idea. It won’t happen. Get over it. The doctors won’t support it because he had a brain injury. Its effects lasted a few years. He’s been durable the last few years, and he’s become a pretty good defensive first baseman through hard work. He’s been in the lineup most days. He doesn’t say the exciting things to the media. Oh well. He doesn’t pull the ball often enough. He doesn’t expand the strike zone. He takes too many first-pitch strikes. He doesn’t show enough fire. He should get thrown out of games more often. He may not be the perfect baseball player. He may not be what you picture for a great major league player. But, if you consider his position, his rankings in the organization’s history, and the respect that he has earned in the game of baseball, he’s had a pretty good career (note - ‘pretty good’ is low-balling it significantly). I get that the Twins haven’t been great the last several years. I get that Mauer’s career trajectory took a huge fall the day that that foul tip jarred his face mask. But of all of the things to complain about in 2016 for Twins fans, Joe Mauer (anything about Joe Mauer) should not be in the top 15-20 things. Maybe it's time for Twins fans to realize the greatness that we have had the opportunity to see the last 13 seasons so that kids wh will be our age in 40 years don't think more highly of Mauer than we do today. Click here to view the article10 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
gagu and 9 others reacted to KirbyDome89 for a post in a topic
10 pointsI've never been a fan of using postseason play as an indicator of HOF worthiness in any sport, especially not baseball. Mauer could only bat once every nine chances, and he certainly wasn't pitching during the playoff series. In a sport where the regular season is 162 games I can't understand how 9 career playoff games (good or bad) are somehow indicative of whether or not he is a HOF player. I also have to disagree with the notion that he didn't "carry the team," and therefore isn't worthy. Baseball isn't like the NBA where a star player can lead a mediocre team to low seeded playoff spot. You need good players at every positions in baseball to even have a chance at the playoffs. Mike Trout with the angels is a prime example. I'm not sure whether Mauer is a HOF player, but I am sure little stock should be put into the 2 criteria above.10 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
kellyvance and 9 others reacted to dbminn for a post in a topic
10 pointsOne method used to determine if a player is HOF-worthy is the "JAWS" system created by Jay Jaffe. It looks at both career WAR and 7-Year Peak WAR. There are 14 catchers in the HOF. Mauer is ranked 11th all-time in career bWAR and 5th all-time in 7-year peak bWAR. (JAWS uses Baseball Reference, not Fangraphs) By these numbers, Mauer should get into the Hall. Arguments against him include lack of championships, down years late in the career, and not playing in New York, LA or Boston. I'd vote for him.10 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
gagu and 8 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic
9 pointsTo be fair... the compensation in the game of baseball is more than a bit different in the last 15 years than it was when Killebrew and Carew played for Calvin Griffith. And it's much different now than when Puckett and Hrbek played. In fact, at one time, Kirby Puckett was the highest paid player in baseball (for a few days, I believe). Mauer wasn't. So, the compensation is what it is, and dependent upon era.9 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
PseudoSABR and 8 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
9 pointsHe accumulated 79 of those IBBs from 2004-2010. The hitter slotted behind Joe in most of those games? Justin Morneau. So... no.9 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
8 pointsI see zero situations around the league where Joe would be one of the most hated players in baseball.8 points
-
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
gagu and 7 others reacted to TheBoofIsLoose for a post in a topic
8 pointsShould they retroactively award contracts to those more deserving players? Mauer was on an absolute tear the years before his contract extension and in all honesty the Twins got the hometown discount to keep him. The Twins had to shell out to keep an MVP level, beloved player. It hasn't worked out perfectly, but we still have a first baseman playing excellent defense, with a high OBP and a solid batting average.8 points -
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Deduno Abides and 6 others reacted to Otto von Ballpark for a post in a topic
7 pointsAccording to B-Ref, Willie Wilson had 46 career WAR -- 31 of it during his six likely team control seasons (ages 23-28, ignoring his age 22 season spent as a pinch runner) : http://www.baseball-reference.com/players/w/wilsowi02.shtml That career WAR would be 4th best ever among 2nd overall picks: http://www.baseball-reference.com/draft/?overall_pick=2&draft_type=junreg&7 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
7 pointsFirst of all if Carew or Killebrew played in this era they would have been compensated equally or greater than Joe. Second, piggy backing off of the first part of my post, the game has changed drastically from an economic point of view. Yes, Joe makes a lot of money, and it would have been nice if he played like 2009 for every year since, but he didn't. If Twins front office decided to let Mauer walk in 2010 because his asking price was too high in the same year as they were moving into Target Field you would have been the loudest one on these message boards and on your blog calling for every member of the management to be fired and complaining about how cheap the Twins are.7 points
-
Article: Byungho Park To Have Season-Ending Wrist Surgery
Well, I hope his recovery is short. I want to see what he can do when fully healthy.6 points
-
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Tom Froemming and 5 others reacted to Loosey for a post in a topic
6 pointsIt is strange to me that so many people dislike Mauer to the degree they do. If someone put Mauer points down on paper without his name and said a large portion of fans dislike this player it would be confusing as to why: 1) #1 Overall Draft Pick 2) Grew up in city he plays in 3) Multiple Batting Titles 4) Multiple Batting All Star Games 5) 1 MVP award 6) Chose to stay "home" after going into Free Agency 7) Struggled through brain injuries forcing him to change positions 8) Has never been in trouble with the law or said/done anything offensive Yet a large majority of people dislike him.6 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
6 pointsIf Mauer is disliked by fans for batting 3rd, then their dislike is misplaced.6 points
-
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
gagu and 5 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
6 pointsIf Joe's OPS continues to drift upward for a year or two and flirts with .800 for awhile, I think that helps his cause. At that point, it's painfully clear the concussion is what derailed his career (despite what many have argued over the past few years). Just look at that OPS by year: .939 (SSS) .783 .936 .808 .864 1.031 .871 .729 (bizarre injury year) .861 .880 concussion .732 .718 .779 If Joe posts another .780-ish season, I don't see how anyone can argue the concussion is what did him in. It wasn't the shifts, it wasn't aging, it was the knock to his face. Sure, maybe those other things contributed a bit but shifts and aging don't account for 150 OPS points overnight. Hell, look at the Cubs, the most advanced team in the league. They (mostly) stopped shifting, which puts into doubt its overall efficacy.6 points -
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
dbminn and 5 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
6 pointsI shake my head at any notion of a "ruined" player who is 22 years old. This isn't a dish towel. It's a human being who plays baseball and has barely entered adulthood. We're not talking about child abuse here or something that emotionally scars a human for life. Anyway, not really arguing with the idea the Twins (or other teams) haven't helped their prospects in any way, I simply don't care for that word in reference to a human being.6 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
notoriousgod71 and 5 others reacted to TwinsWonWithHunter for a post in a topic
6 pointsI know that Joe Mauer is a fan-favorite of many, and that his 9-season run from 2005-2013 easily qualifies him as the best catcher in team history. At one point in his career, he seemed destined for Cooperstown. The fact is, however, that careers are a total body of work. At age 31, his decline was steep. From one season to the next, he morphed from a .320 hitter to .270. And the .270-range is where he has resided since 2014, at first base no less, with an average of about 12 home runs and 65 RBI per season. That type of production (such as it is) is what we can expect during his two remaining seasons in a Twins uniform. Or when his contract mercifully expires at the conclusion of 2018. The best comparison I can come up with is Don Mattingly. His first 7 or 8 seasons, he absolutely raked. But injuries took their toll, and from ages 30-34 his drop anticipated that of Mauer’s. And by age 35 or so, he was out of baseball. Don Mattingly and Joe Mauer are not going to the Hall-of-Fame because A - their run of greatness just was not long enough B - the mediocre era of their careers started too early and lasted too long C - They had no defining October moments. It is what it is.6 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Dantes929 and 4 others reacted to SwainZag for a post in a topic
5 pointsI still see nothing wrong with Joe taking 1st pitch strikes.5 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
gagu and 4 others reacted to Seth Stohs for a post in a topic
5 pointsThat's probably something that is true as well. I think Kevin Garnett went through some of that with the Wolves. Garnett was often unselfish to a perceived fault. Garnett chose to trust his teammates to take and make a better shot than he was going to get. It wasn't until he was part of a championship and more competitive teams that people better understood how great he really was, not only himself for his teammates. Different game, of course, but I think it's the same with Mauer. Could he have expanded his strike zone and swung at more balls in RBI situations? Sure, and maybe a few times it would have resulted in runs. More often, it would have resulted in a bad at bat. Instead, he looked in the on-deck circle and noticed Morneau or Cuddyer or Sano and said, but if I get on base, then that guy can knock in the run and me too and at the end of the day, we have even more runs.5 points -
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
PseudoSABR and 4 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
5 pointsPerhaps he has tried, but that is just not the type of hitter he is or can be. Perception is one thing, actuality is another. Sometimes they are the same, but unless you know for sure, and I suspect you don't, then I think your dislike is misplaced. If your perception is true, then it's still up to the manager to bat him in the appropriate place, and that's not what happens. If he won't or can't adjust, then the manager is wrong to continue batting him there. Period. And I think your dislike of Joe for that is still misplaced, with all due respect.5 points -
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
glunn and 3 others reacted to Willihammer for a post in a topic
4 pointsTonight's game features a matchup between 25 year old LHP Matt Boyd and 25 year old RHP Tyler Duffey. Here are lineups: Tigers Matt Boyd (L) 1. Cameron Maybin ® CF 2. Erick Aybar (S) SS 3. Miguel Cabrera ® 1B 4. Victor Martinez (S) DH 5. J.D. Martinez ® RF 6. Justin Upton ® LF 7. Casey McGehee ® 3B 8. Jarrod Saltalamacchia (S) C 9. Andrew Romine (S) 2B Twins Tyler Duffey ® 1. Brian Dozier ® 2B 2. Robbie Grossman (S) LF 3. Miguel Sano ® DH 4. Trevor Plouffe ® 1B 5. Jorge Polanco (S) SS 6. Eduardo Escobar (S) 3B 7. Max Kepler (L) RF 8. Kurt Suzuki ® C 9. Eddie Rosario (L) CF Have a great game thread everyone. http://static2.businessinsider.com/image/4d5d2a9649e2ae8f20010000-506-253/miguel-cabreras-dui-incident-is-much-worse-than-previously-thought.jpg4 points -
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Danchat and 3 others reacted to Aggies7 for a post in a topic
4 points4 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Platoon and 3 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
4 pointsI respect that you're a business owner. But what does your size have to do with anything?4 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Pardon My Dinger and 3 others reacted to S. for a post in a topic
4 pointsPaul Molitor's Patented Lineup Generator ©4 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Platoon and 3 others reacted to twinssporto for a post in a topic
4 pointsThe lineup order looks a little crazy to me. I don't like Plouffe in the 4 hole either...Oh well. Too bad Vargas isn't around. I would like to see him at 1st base versus Plouffe. I'm sorry. Maybe I should start a Plouffe Forum Thread. My apologies again.4 points- Article: Byungho Park To Have Season-Ending Wrist Surgery
Article: Byungho Park To Have Season-Ending Wrist Surgery
Tom Froemming and 3 others reacted to bluechipper for a post in a topic
4 pointsHopefully the wrist problems were a big factor in his struggles this year. And hopefully he has a successful recovery too.4 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Tom Froemming and 3 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic
4 pointsMauer is one of the best hitters ever, in terms of BA and walks. The criticism reads a lot like the Votto criticism. To the person who talked about war and ops.....ops is not an advanced stat at all. It is not in war. Has anyone looked at the stats in context of era, other than war? He did pay in an offensive time, mostly. My issue with Joe isn't really with Joe, but those on both sides of the love hate gap that have no nuance in their emotion. He isn't some awesome god, nor is he a devil.4 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
gagu and 3 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
4 pointsI understand your point about hits v. walks - and to an extent, I agree - but you lost me when you transitioned to seasonal comparisons of counting stats. Puckett was an everyday centerfielder who had 600+ PAs most seasons and a few 700+ seasons. By comparison, Mauer was a catcher who crossed 600 PAs only four times and never approached 700. Some of that was due to injury - Puckett was mostly healthy while Joe had issues - but a large portion of it is due to the demands of catching. Seasonal comparisons of counting stats will always skew in favor of the non-catcher.4 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
USAFChief and 3 others reacted to Steve Lein for a post in a topic
4 pointsI am not at all saying Joe Mauer is not one of the Twins all time best with the following comments (he is), but I see him in a much different context than most. There is a large obsession with on-base percentage around the world of Major League Baseball these days, thanks to sabermetrics and WAR and everything else. What I dislike about this, is how batting average (and in turn, hits) has somehow become less valued when comparing players in this age. The fact is, HITS are worth a hell of a lot more than walks. Give me a .300/.350 hitter any day of the week over a .280/.370 hitter. Yet what you will find, is the .280 player (all other things being equal) is valued more by things like WAR. Since this is a Twins list, here is the comparison I always use for Mauer, when discussing the best Twins of all time (I think there is a clear #1): Player X: 1783 games, 2304 hits, 1071 runs, 414 doubles, 57 triples, 207 home runs, 1085 RBI, and a triple slash for his career of .318/.360/.477. Mauer: 1573 games, 1815 hits, 879 runs, 360 doubles, 28 triples, 129 home runs, 800 RBI, and a triple slash for his career of .310/.393/.447. Mauer's pace numbers compared to Player X's career come out to: 2057 hits, 996 runs, 408 doubles, 32 triples, 146 home runs, and 906 RBI. If you hadn't figured it out yet, Player X is Kirby Puckett. For all the things Mauer is lauded for doing now, Kirby is often times looked back upon in retrospect as flawed, despite the facts (to me) that Puckett was far more productive than Mauer due to the volume of HITS he collected. He had over 200 hits in 5 different seasons, leading the AL in that category 4 times (and had 190+ in 2 other seasons). Mauer has eclipsed 190 hits once in his career. Puckett scored 100+ runs in four seasons, 80+ in nine. Mauer has eclipsed 80+ runs five times. Puckett drove in 100+ runs in three seasons, and 80+ in ten. Mauer has eclipsed 80+ RBI four times, with a peak of 98 in his MVP season. Just another interesting note, for all the people who say Puckett swung at everything and struck out too much as a result: Mauer is on an exact pace to match Kirby's 965 career K's in the same amount of games played at this point. Walks are definitely a good thing, but to me, there comes a point, or is a certain type of player, where the curve starts to be a detriment if too many walks are taken. Mauer is what he is (and has been great), but I have to believe with his hitting ability and youthful skills he hurt his overall production by being that type of player. I'd sacrifice the same amount of on-base percentage points for slugging any day of the week, and with his skill as a hitter, Mauer could have done much more in the HITS category to drive something like this. Again, with these nitpicks, he still is undoubtedly one of the best Twins ever. I just think he is credited for some things that others get bashed for, when it should be the opposite. I would love to see what Mauer's WAR totals would be in comparison to these others if he was not ever a catcher. Say a CF who played defense just as good as Puckett did.4 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
USAFChief and 3 others reacted to bird for a post in a topic
4 pointsMy "dislike" of Joey is misplaced, irrational, and based on misperceptions. But it just won't go away. I keep seeing pitchers pour hittable first pitches down the heart of the plate while Joey's bat stays superglued to his shoulder as if he'd face a firing squad if he dared swing. I see a big, strong, remarkable athlete that apparently lacks the athletiism to adjust his swing and pull hittable pitches over the right field fence a dozen times a year. Or maybe he's stubborn. I see a player who is selfish and unimaginative, and one of the confirmations of this particular misperception is that he appears to be unwilling to expand the zone by just a fraction with men on base and seems happy to coax a walk in situations where the team needs its stud player to carry them on his back with a big knock. I see a player vulnerable to injury, and unlucky for sure, but also perhaps somewhat deserving of the nickname of General Soreness. I see a player who lacks the "it" factor. I see a player who demonstrates almost no visible leadership dimension. He's uninspiring to watch on the baseball diamond much of the time, and he's boring in the interview room. I can't recall the last time a teammate sung his praises to the media, especially regarding something he did to help them personally. I see a remarkable athlete, taken 1/1 in the draft for a reason, who has under-shot the mark in his career, and, as misguided and irrational as it is, I tend to think injuries played a smaller role in this than his own human flaws did. So, as great as his career has been, in my mind it should have been better. The arithmetic doesn't tell the full story of the performance I've witnessed over the years.4 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Tom Froemming and 3 others reacted to wsnydes for a post in a topic
4 pointsLet's not also forget that Mauer's new deal was negotiated around the time that the team was having a funding bill being signed for a shiny new ballpark. This team would have been crucified if they let the hometown boy walk when they were using the "we need the ballpark to keep players like Joe" excuse and he was coming off of an MVP season. Edit: my timeline is off...The deal was negotiated as Target Field was set to open, which would make him walking look even worse in my view.4 points- Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/23): Wheeler Dominates, Kennys Hits Ball Far
Article: Twins Minor League Report (8/23): Wheeler Dominates, Kennys Hits Ball Far
Bill Tanner and 3 others reacted to nytwinsfan for a post in a topic
4 pointsGotta showcase Plouffe so we can get at least a bag of balls for him. I really hope they were very clear with Vargas that it had nothing to do with his performance, and that it was all about the short-term roster and building value for trades.4 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Jham and 3 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
4 pointsOr, perhaps some of that dislike stems from a perception that he refuses to modify plate appearances to fit the role, or fit specific situations, as some of us believe is required to maximize the team's chances of winning.4 points- Article: Dozier's Not Jerking Around
Article: Dozier's Not Jerking Around
smackle and 3 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic
4 pointsThe Minnesota Twins in August: .798 OPS, 2nd in the AL. 5.69 ERA, 14th in the AL (props to the Angels for somehow being worse than this team). 9-12 record. So, yeah, you kinda have to trade Dozier for pitching. Not catching, not another positional player... Pitching. It's risky but when your rotation has this little upside, it's a move you need to consider. This trend isn't going to reverse by itself. Yeah, maybe Berrios gets better. Maybe you put May in the rotation. Maybe Santana holds steady. If everything goes right, this rotation is league average. One needs to aim a little higher than that.4 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
Dman and 3 others reacted to diehardtwinsfan for a post in a topic
4 pointsIf his career ended a couple years ago, I think he'd have been a lock like Puckett. Not quite sure now to be honest, though I'm not sure how a couple of bad seasons post concussion suddenly makes him not an HOF. I think if he can rebound a bit in his 30s and post a few .800ish OPS type seasons, that might change some perception as his counting stats will clear that 2000 hit mark. If he could make another run at a batting title into his 30s, that would probably help as well. That said, Mauer would be served making an HOF case if he could switch to a defense first position, play said defense well, while continuing to hit they way he has hit this year... I'm guessing that won't happen for a number of reasons, most of which I'd add are quite valid (note I'm not saying he should become a SS). That said, if I had a card, I'd vote him in based on his run as a catcher.4 points- Article: Game Thread: Twins v Tigers, 8/23 @ 7:10pm CT
Article: Game Thread: Twins v Tigers, 8/23 @ 7:10pm CT
twinsnorth49 and 3 others reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic
4 pointsWere they wearing hats that looked like big wedges of cheese?4 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
twinssporto and 2 others reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic
3 pointsGlad I had a flight to catch tonight.3 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Squirrel and 2 others reacted to Platoon for a post in a topic
3 pointsWell it's unlikely Van was wearing his high heels. Last time he wore them for golf, the greens keeper was very upset!3 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
twinssporto and 2 others reacted to Platoon for a post in a topic
3 pointsWell I about 5-6 years we can find out. . Sarcasm aside, the most entertaining threads seem to be in the worst games. It seems to bring out the snarky, yet overall harmless side of the bunch.3 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Platoon and 2 others reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic
3 pointsSample World Series Game Thread. ****.......****......Holy ****....wtf was that?.......****......Oh ****......c'mon ffs!......please.....please......****!!!!!!!3 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Vanimal46 and 2 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
3 pointsSome jokes just write themselves.3 points- Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10
ScrapTheNickname and 2 others reacted to twinssporto for a post in a topic
3 pointsCan you imagine what these Game Threads would be like for a World Series run? Brings me goose bumps!3 points- Wolves Site
Wolves Site
twinsnorth49 and 2 others reacted to Pardon My Dinger for a post in a topic
3 pointsYou just made "the List."3 points- Pitching In 2017? Twins Don't Need Any
Pitching In 2017? Twins Don't Need Any
Danchat and 2 others reacted to Ted Schwerzler for a comment on a blog entry
3 pointsLike Ryan before him, Molitor shouldn't be given that opportunity. He's been awful this season more often than not, and should be shown the door as soon as the new GM steps in the building.3 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
3 pointsI guess it depends on what you see is more valuable. Joe is a career .408 hitter on the 1st pitch in the at bat. Does that mean he should swing at more or is him being extremely selective pushing up his numbers? There are only 7 players in baseball this season who see more pitches per plate appearance than Joe, who is currently averaging 4.27 pitcher per PA. I find that extremely valuable as starters generally throw 100 pitches max these days. If Joe was striking out more and/or walking less maybe I would let it bother me. Working a count and waiting for your pitch seems to be a diminishing art anymore with the generation of free swingers.3 points- Food and other such holidays
Food and other such holidays
formerly33 and 2 others reacted to twinsnorth49 for a post in a topic
3 pointsSome things just don't need to be explained.3 points- Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Fangraphs (and other national publications) on the Twins
Mike Frasier Law and 2 others reacted to jimmer for a post in a topic
3 pointsBeing disappointed if Buxton turns out like Willie Wilson or Coco Crisp is nowhere near calling him a bust.3 points- Food and other such holidays
Food and other such holidays
Vanimal46 and 2 others reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic
3 pointsQuite possibly. You're pretty slow if you have just now come to that realization.3 points- Article: For The Love Of Joe
Article: For The Love Of Joe
SF Twins Fan and 2 others reacted to wsnydes for a post in a topic
3 pointsWere you calling for a pay increase when he was putting up MVP numbers making $10.5M a year? This notion is laughable. Salary means nothing on the field.3 points- Article: Dozier's Not Jerking Around
Article: Dozier's Not Jerking Around
wsnydes and 2 others reacted to USAFChief for a post in a topic
3 pointsI think it's tough to trade Dozier, but I'd do it if the return was a starter very likely to be the Twins best starter as soon as 2017, 2018 at the latest. In general, I am very leery of trading established position players for potential pitching. It's just very difficult to know what you're getting with young pitchers. Very difficult. But in this case, as others have pointed out, I don't know where else needed pitching comes fom, Dozier has a lot of trade value, and Polanco makes trading a Dozier less risky.3 pointsThis leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00 - Game Thread: Tigers vs Twins 7:10