Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Leaderboard

  1. Brock Beauchamp

    Administrator
    Points
    29,622
    Posts
  2. Seth Stohs

    Administrator
    Points
    24,042
    Posts
  3. ashbury

    Old-Timey Member
    Points
    34,998
    Posts
  4. nicksaviking

    Community Moderator
    Points
    18,707
    Posts

Popular Content

Showing content with the highest reputation on 10/23/2015 in Posts

  1. 7 points
    To be fair I imagine most TD posters are fine tuned athletes and would be kick-ass base runners. As durable as AJ is, he has got be be pretty close to falling off the cliff - is the catcher market that low? Would he take over the smoke machine if Torii does not return? I might change my mind if he can lead the dance party -- because when you think of AJ - you think of dance moves. [Not sure this is how I wanted to use my 1000th post. I was hoping to save that for when we won the World Series.]
  2. 6 points
    I think it's really wrong-headed to look for a catcher to complement Suzuki. The Twins should be looking for a catcher who Suzuki can complement, not the other way around.
  3. Just to look at my 2015 Twins Prospects, #s 16-20. #16 - Tyler Duffey - knowing what we know now, and if he had only pitched 49 innings with the Twins, where would he rank now? #17 - Chih-Wei Hu - he took another step forward in 2015 and was traded for a solid late-innings reliever. #18 - Jake Reed - he took a step back, but he still is top 25 for me and is a good candidate to be successful in the Twins bullpen at some point in the next couple of years. #19 - Stuart Turner - Defense matters... I still think there's some offensive potential in there. He had a solid second half... with graduations and such, he stayed the same for me. 2016 will be a big season for him to determine whether he goes up the list, or drops a bit. #20 - JR Graham - he was a Rule 5 guy who was clocked at 95+ despite it being in his return from injury with the Braves. Obviously he's not a 'prospect' anymore, but given a little time, he can be a solid 6th/7th inning type of guy. 2014 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Amaurys Minier, 17.) Kennys Vargas, 18.) Ryan Eades, 19.) Felix Jorge, 20.) Niko Goodrum. 2013 #s 16-20 --> 16.) AB Walker, 17.) Chris Herrmann, 18.) BJ Hermsen, 19.) Jorge Polanco, 20.) Luke Bard 2012 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Manuel Soliman, 17.) Levi Michael, 18.) Max Kepler, 19.) Niko Goodrum, 20.) Hudson Boyd 2011 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Max Kepler, 17.) Eddie Rosario, 18.) BJ Hermsen, 19.) Danny Ortiz, 20.) Bobby Lanigan 2010 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Jeff Manship, 17.) Tyler Robertson, 18.) Alex Burnett, 19.) Blayne Weller, 20.) Billy Bullock 2009 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Shooter Hunt, 17.) Joe Benson, 18.) Mike McCardell, 19.) Steve Tolleson, 20.) Brian Duensing 2008 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Jason Pridie, 17.) Erik Lis, 18.) Deibinson Romero, 19.) Nick Blackburn, 20.) Jay Rainville. 2007 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Kyle Waldrop, 17.) Brock Peterson, 18.) Jay Rainville, 19.) Trevor Plouffe, 20.) Joe Benson 2006 #s 16-20 --> 16.) Kyle Waldrop, 17.) Boof Bonser, 18.) Matt Garza, 19.) Juan Portes, 20.) David Winfree There are some really good players... Duensing, Plouffe, Garza, There are some guys who got a cup of coffee. There are some guys who "Roger" might be the only one who remembers. That's the nature of these lists... It's what makes them fun.
  4. Everyone has their personal rankings and has guys they are likely higher on then most... or lower. I guess I don't look at other rankings when I come up with mine. As noted, these are all subject to change when I come up with my final rankings in the Prospect Handbook. I haven't really talked to anyone associated with the Twins about these rankings. I've talked to some about some of the players, but not about how to rank them. What am I looking for in a catcher? #1 - Defense. I think that's the most important thing a catcher can do for his team. Both Turner and Navarreto are terrific. Tools-wise, Navarreto has good size, strength and a powerful arm. He's working on calling games, and he'll get better at blocking, but those are the tools I look for defensively. Yes, I would like to see more offense, but again, he's got the size. He's got decent speed, especially for a catcher. He hasn't shown it yet, but he has tremendous power potential. Maybe I'm biased some by the monstrous home run I saw him hit off of JO Berrios in spring training. Obviously a pretty small sample size (1 AB), but it does speak to his potential. The Salvador Perez comp is based on size and defense, and offensive potential. It doesn't mean he will get there, and it certainly doesn't mean he'll be an All Star by 23. I frankly don't care if it takes him til 25-26 to get to the big leagues. For me, comps are about potential, not about age-to-level and stuff like that. What 'could' he become... Navarreto may never get to AA. No way to know. But with his defense, I think he's got a good chance to get to the big leagues. But mainly, just my personal opinion.
  5. 3 points
    Can't we all just get back to bashing AJ?
  6. Questions For Terry Ryan?

    glunn and 2 others reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    3 points
    By the way, thanks for all the questions, everyone. Parker held the interview this morning and we're in the process of transcribing the audio now.
  7. 3 points
    It's a pretty direct implication that you don't want to move Plouffe because it creates "uncertainty". Any plan this team choose to upgrade the team will create uncertainty, it's simply an impossible thing to protect from. Trading Plouffe this offseason is the very essence of prudent management of resources and selling high. The problem around here is that people say "you should've sold high!" after the guy drops and whines that "you can't deal him, he's good!" when he's at his high point. You can't have it both ways. The Plouffe circumstances, because of his age, team control, and available alternatives on the roster, make for an ideal "sell now" time. If you wait, chances are pretty decent you'll regret it.
  8. 3 points
    First off, I'd like to thank DRizzo for creating such a great thread, one that certainly caught my own interest as I read through the discussion. Unfortunately, the Twins politely asked to remove the thread so we, as a group, decided to hide the thread from public viewing. This is the first time we have done such a thing on Twins Daily or any MinnCentric site and we did not take the decision lightly. Initially, we asked the Twins "Why should it be removed? Isn't this public knowledge on a public conference call?" but once we learned the specifics of the call and its intentions, we agreed to the front office's request. While we respect original content and information - which is why we did not remove the thread after the initial request - this conversation could adversely affect the Twins' internal operations and their public planning for the upcoming season. The details of the conversation were not intended to be public knowledge and were said to an advisory board. The Twins were gracious in the request, gracious after our initial hesitation, and have been nothing but understanding through this process. Again, I stress this decision was not made lightly. And double again, we'd like to thank DRizzo for the great thread and all the conversation it spurred on the site.
  9. About the St. Peter thread

    Brock Beauchamp and 2 others reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I endorse the decision made, if the information was not public, frankly. These aren't state secrets we should all know....
  10. Assembling the New York Mets

    Mike Sixel and 2 others reacted to nicksaviking for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I am so jealous of the DeGrom, Harvey, Syndergaard, Matz and Wheeler rotation. To have just one young power arm is so rare in Minnesota. I don't know what the Mets did to evaluate these guys in trades and drafts, and I don't know what they did to make sure they all developed properly, but I'd sure be open to hiring someone from their front office or scouting department if only to get any inside information.
  11. I would say that the top 2-3 prospects are what makes a prospect ranking for an organization. The Twins have 6-7 guys that will have them ranked pretty high even with the 'graduations' of Rosario, May, Duffey and Sano. How I look at rankings... You look for one of the top 2 to become an All-Star caliber player. You hope that guys in that 3-7 range can become regular starters in the lineup or 3-5 starters. You hope that guys in that 8-15 range can become quality role players, maybe bullpen arms, etc. You hope that guys in the 16+ range can get to the big leaguers and help in any way. Of course, there's so much wiggle room in all of that. I mean, guys like Blankenhorn, Diaz, Cabbage simply don't have enough track record and not quite enough prospect hype to be Top 10-12 guys right now but clearly do have the potential to someday breakout and become a Top 10 guy. I just need something more. Consider Jorge Polanco signed out of the DR as a mid-sized signing bonus, good defense, questionable bat prospect. Sano was my #3 Twins prospect right away after the Twins signed him. Polanco wasn't in the top 30. Polanco took two seasons in the GCL and didn't hit until he moved to Elizabethton, and then proved that was real in Cedar Rapids. Now he's easily a top 10 guy and someone who, in the right situation, can be a big league regular. Prospect rankings are for fun discussion and learning about players and recognizing them. But they're subject to change year over year as players develop. That's the beauty of it!
  12. Fair point, but what if he does take the step in 2016 and people think that he can be more than a backup catcher. Also, what's wrong with being a backup catcher. If the Twins would have moved Butera to the bullpen, it's pretty likely he never makes the big leagues. As a backup catcher, and one of the smartest baseball players around, he's now over 5 years of MLB service time. He's considered valuable by MLB Insiders, front offices, players, coaches, etc. That's nothing to scoff at, even though many chose to do so.
  13. Probably. Guys who look like eventual utility infielders or fourth outfielders, or starting pitchers who will likely have to accept bullpen duty if they want to be in the majors, litter top-20s, even strong lists. Think of it this way. How immensely strong would a farm system be, if the entire top 20 was entirely made up of "this guy projects as a starting first baseman, this guy projects as a starting second baseman, this guy projects as a front line starting pitcher, this guy..."? Practically a whole new competitive 25-man roster, including a few apparently qualified players riding the pine, if you'll just wait a few years. Top 10, I'm probably with you, regarding backup catchers.
  14. I would agree with that, but I'm always a proponent of that. Others asked why I have Navarreto and Turner as high as I do. Part of it is their size. Part of it is seeing some offensive potential. And, my personal opinion is that to see that potential, they need to get an extra half-season at a level. I've written on a few occasions that I'd like to see Turner get another half-season in Chattanooga in 2016. Same thing with Navarreto. I'd like to see him get another half season in Cedar Rapids. Both hit better in the 2nd half than they did early in the season. Neither will be a great hitter, most likely, but if they can be near-.700 OPS guys and play the kind of defense they can play, that's pretty valuable. Will that happen? No way to know, but I love both upsides. And, I guess if I were to make one other statement, or acknowledge one mistake, it's probably that there is so much separation in ranking between these two and Garver. When I come up with my final rankings, I would guess these two will stay pretty close to where they are, but Garver will move up a little bit.
  15. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    Drew and 2 others reacted to TheLeviathan for a post in a topic

    3 points
    I don't see any reason to keep Plouffe as fielding insurance. If this team doesn't think Sano can field they should know that already from their minor league field staff. Molitor wants to play him there, as far as I'm concerned that's an endorsement of ability. We don't need spring training to decide it. So shop Plouffe and see if you can land something spicy.
  16. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    Loosey and 2 others reacted to Physics Guy for a post in a topic

    3 points
    Wouldn't it make more sense to keep the good 3B at 3B and move the guy who probably ends up at 1B anyways?
  17. Al playoffs

    USAFChief and one other reacted to Squirrel for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I'll be in KC on Tuesday and Wednesday for work. Gonna be interesting!
  18. 2 points
    Probably not quite the same as the airspeed velocity of an unladen swallow.
  19. All fair rebuttal points, and definitely good food for thought. Five questions for your consideration to counter: 1) You mention some "people think" with regards to Navarretto, I'm assuming they helped in convincing you that there's more than currently meets the eye with him? Are these people inside the organization, or outside? 2) Drew Butera has accumulated all of -1.7 of bWAR in parts of 6 seasons- shouldn't we question, at least a little bit, all of these people who consider him having any more value than as a BP catcher? 3) Do you have any idea what Butera's highest Twins prospect ranking was? 4) If Butera was touching 94 in his Twins outing as a pitcher- and he has a 10.13 K/9 in his limited pitching duties- without ever taking the pitching thing seriously- who's to automatically dismiss what his chances were at becoming a MLB RP? 5) Doesn't every organization have at least a half dozen Eric Fryer's up and down their organizational chart who can get plugged in as the MLB back-up catcher at a moment's notice? I'm still unconvinced that a guy with a back-up catcher ceiling should merit much fan excitement about that organization's great/deep farm system. Based on your rankings here, the Twins may very well have 2 back-up catchers in their Top 20. Hopefully, Turner builds on his second half and changes the ceiling projection for good. I still say your team's system isn't all that deep with back-up ceiling catchers in the Top 20 and RP-ceiling pitchers in the Top 10.
  20. Questions For Terry Ryan?

    glunn and one other reacted to Brock Beauchamp for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Mad? Heh, no. Tired? Hell yes. Criticism is fine. It's welcomed, actually. But I have little patience for passive aggressive juvenile bull****. I'm worn down by its ever persistent aspect of the internet culture. It shouldn't be too much to ask adults to act like adults after we tried to be as transparent as possible about this difficult situation, one we talked about at length before making the decision.
  21. 2 points
    We would finally get a throw out % in the 30's! 15 for Kurt, and 16 for AJ.
  22. 2 points
    The time of that comment is so appropriate for its content There are better choices that Pierzynski for a LHB C, as cheap free agents, including this guy and this guy and this guy.
  23. Questions For Terry Ryan?

    Mike Sixel and one other reacted to Vanimal46 for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Last year we saw Lester Oliveros transition to a starter during the season, and flounder. Meanwhile we saw Trevor May transition to the bullpen and succeed. What goes into determining who can make that switch from the bullpen to a starter and vice versa?
  24. 2 points
    Aside from injuries to the veterans, is there a scenario where Duffey, May and Berrios are all in the rotation by May?
  25. This is where I expected to see Palacios and he's definitely ahead of Navaretto. I never expected to see Navaretto this high and just assumed he was out of your top 50. >50 makes more sense than 20th.
  26. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    DocBauer and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    2 points
    First, it's a strawman that if Sano isn't playing 3B every day then Plouffe must be playing 3B every day. Playing time can be shared, and the ratio need not be static. Second, you are right that Sano's missed time due to injury was costly to the process. Third, what "they don't know" isn't some static thing - what they want to see is whether he is making progress, because what we saw on the field from him was sometimes intriguing (stellar looking plays coming in on slow rollers and throwing off-balance) but too often inadequate (matador moves on hot smashes, poor tracking of popups). They know he's young and progress is expected, but adequacy must be demonstrated. Fourth, infield drills and spring games will go a long way toward determining the amount of his playing time once the games count (and of course the drills continue). If he looks reliable in the games he plays in-season, Plouffe will soon be riding the pine (or DHing/1Bing) full time. And then it's time for a trade. Profit!
  27. 2015-16 Wolves thread

    TheLeviathan and one other reacted to FattCrapps for a post in a topic

    2 points
    "In this world nothing can be said to be certain; except death, taxes, and betting the under on the Timberwolves."
  28. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    TheLeviathan and one other reacted to bluechipper for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I totally agree. I also don't really see how just giving Sano occasional starts at third will help him improve his fielding in the long run. I think he needs to be penciled in as the everyday third basemen, and I'm sure he will settle in and be fine there.
  29. Cubs-Mets

    spinowner and one other reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    2 points
    The fork has now been officially stuck. Book it!
  30. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    jimbo92107 and one other reacted to jokin for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Unfortunately, Turner hasn't shown to this point that he can even hit half a lick. Fortunately, a glimpse of hope did spring up over the last 50 games this year- (including the playoff games)- Turner slashed .269/.384/.340/(.724), with a 114 wRC+... plus a really stellar 14.7% BB/16.2% K ratio. I suspect the Twins will push hardest for acquiring a veteran catcher via FA or trade, giving Turner a chance to perform well enough in Rochester, and very importantly, get regular everday reps both at, and behind, the plate while getting to know all of his pitchers in game situations. And then, if all goes according to the best-case scenario- look to claim a spot from one of the veterans in July.
  31. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    mnfanforlife and one other reacted to Trov for a post in a topic

    2 points
    For the right deal I would be okay with trading both. Dozier needs to learn how to hit a ball to the opposite field. My problem with him is he does not hit well with runners on base, but he hits HR like he should hit lower in the lineup to drive in runs, but he does not hit when runners on. The book is out on him, and he only hits mistake fastballs up and in. Once he shows he will drive the fastballs away to right field for hits he will get more inside pitches that are not just mistakes.
  32. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    Hosken Bombo Disco and one other reacted to Danchat for a post in a topic

    2 points
    I don't get why Dozier is in the trade talk. He's going to be in the 2nd year of a 4 year deal - I know TR doesn't deal players when they're still early in their contracts. I also know that there's no way this team trusts Polanco to take over at 2B. They'd find a bottom-rung veteran 2B to play there for who knows how long until Polanco can shred AAA, and not to mention learn how to play 2B. Also, I recently got a Dozier jersey for my birthday, so they better not trade him.
  33. Questions For Terry Ryan?

    SwainZag and one other reacted to dougkoebernick for a post in a topic

    2 points
    Do you read TwinsDaily daily or twice a day?
  34. It's really easy to sit back and criticize people who have to make tough decisions every day to keep a community on track and balanced. The real bias is in this post, not the moderator action that led to it. You see what you want to see and disregard all the action taken against the "other side" on a regular basis. The moderators here do a hell of a lot of work and we're able to give them very little in return. I have little patience for those who undermine all the work they put into this site to keep it operational.
  35. I expect you, "D. Hocking", may suffer a broken hand during the World Series winning celebration and may be unable to post at that time anyway.
  36. Al playoffs

    Willihammer reacted to Monkeypaws for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Watching the rain delay in game 6 - FS1 has assembled a team of A-Rod, Pete Rose, Frank Thomas, CJ Nitkowski, and a sports guy. Well, damn, they are great! Pete Rose is funny, old-school, A-Rod is intelligent, deferring to the players in the game, Big Hurt is very keen in the analysis. Surprising. I like A-Rod in the booth: there, I said it.
  37. Given all the pros who value Butera as much much more than a BP catcher, shouldn't we question, just a little bit, the use of bWAR as the be-all and end-all when discussing a player's value?
  38. Twins interested in AJ Pierzynski reunion

    Platoon reacted to jimmer for a post in a topic

    1 point
    I guess I have a few questions on this: 1. If the Twins and St. Peter didn't want the info out there, why did St Peter say it in the first place? 2. Was this told to a bunch of employees only and it got leaked or was the info told to some fans too? 3. If told to fans, why is it okay for those fans in attendance to know this and not anyone else? 4. Was there an understanding agreed upon between St Peter and the people listening to him that everything said was said in confidence (non-disclosure agreement or something)? I ask because someone actually suggested that by deleting the thread, it saved the originator of the thread from getting in trouble. Not sure how he would get in trouble because someone blabbed something he shouldn't have. 5. See question #1 again.
  39. Hurricane Patricia

    Squirrel reacted to Craig Arko for a post in a topic

    1 point
    From Scott Kelly, on the ISS.
  40. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    Thrylos reacted to jokin for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Bold statement, hard to state that with the "certainty" you're utilizing. (I do go along wit h the part about next year, though).
  41. 1 point
    I was trying to be clever with the timing of this thread.
  42. About the St. Peter thread

    nicksaviking reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    1 point
    One should not go out of one's way to be an irritant, no. Oh, and welcome to the site. http://twinsdaily.com/topic/8228-twins-daily-comment-policy-latest-revision-september-2013/
  43. Questions For Terry Ryan?

    glunn reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Moderator's note: folks, this is one of those threads where we'd like to keep to the topic. I've removed a few posts that weren't. Thanks.
  44. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    ashbury reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    1 point
    that's a fair belief, I just don't think they grow much at 3B in game, but I could be 100% wrong on that.
  45. Assembling the New York Mets

    dbminn reacted to gunnarthor for a post in a topic

    1 point
    I think it would be tough for the Twins to pass on 2016 by trading those three, unless the return was amazing. Dozier, I think, can be replaced by Polanco but I don't know if Sano can handle third and, if he can't, then we have someone like Nunez there. The AL central next year should be open for us. Detroit and Chicago suck and, while Cleveland has some supporters, they always seem to underachieve. The Royals are losing a lot of important parts (Cueto, Gordon, Zobrist, Morales, Madson, Young) and have options on a few more that might not be picked up. The Twins can reasonably expect better years from a lot of their players and still have some good minor league depth behind them. I wouldn't trade Dozier for someone who isn't going to immediately help (unless the Nats wanted to give us Gioltio or something crazy like that).
  46. But what if that's all there is? In terms of prospects. I'm kind-of with mikelink45 to this point in the rankings. Not too much to get excited about here, even most of the lotto tickets, between 16-50 on this list. Lots of guys moving backwards, most only projecting as bench/back-up/utility MLB players or low-leverage RPs- but as mikelin45 also hinted at- How much should we expect from this group, anyway?, and, How good really is the Twins farm system in terms of prospect depth beyond the 6 or 7 Top 100 types?
  47. Yep. I'd like to hear more of Seth's rationale for this placement of Navaretto in the top 20. MLB.com doesn't even have him in their Twins Top 30. Are there MiLB coaches or Twins management sources pushing this idea? What stood out in what Navarretto accomplishments in 2015 that Jonathan Mayo, et al, missed? And mentioning a Perez comp in way of support of Navarretto's anointment to the top 20 is a little dangerous, even if it's only iterated in relating their catching abilities. Salvi was OPSing at .732, in High A at age 20 (nearly 3 years younger than league average), vs. Navaretto's .537 OPS at A level (1.4 years younger than league average). Seems more like the ceiling of a future defensively good-to-strong back-up catcher, not the floor. Hope to be proven wrong on this.
  48. Trade Dozier, Plouffe, now

    mnfanforlife reacted to ashbury for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Through lots of drills, and Grapefruit League game time, during spring. Then at the start of regular season, if the results are promising, aim for about half his games at 3B and half at DH. Shuffle Plouffe and Mauer among 1B/DH to allow for this. At whatever point the on-field staff feels he's become solid enough (and the bar doesn't have to be super high, maybe it will be during spring training), you can pursue trading Plouffe. While, if Sano's looking shaky at 3B, either coming out of spring training or sometime early into the season, then you've still got Plouffe to man the position while you decide what Plan B with Sano needs to be. If Sano hadn't suffered the injuries that limited him to batting-only during the last weeks of the season, maybe there would be better progress in his fielding, and thereby confidence, to allow for trading Plouffe during this off-season. But it is what it is; he looked raw in the field and then didn't get the chance to adjust to the major league level with his glove. I don't think what I'm proposing is super-cautious. The injuries to our best prospects have thrown a monkey wrench into the team's plans.
  49. Questions For Terry Ryan?

    jokin reacted to Mike Sixel for a post in a topic

    1 point
    Why did Berrios not come up for the May spot start? Or, at al this year? Did you feel you did enough at the break to get the team into the post season, or was this a matter of waiting for next year?
  50. 1 point
    Yeah, and I'll collect on those 3 drinks one day, too.
This leaderboard is set to Chicago/GMT-06:00

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.