I guess it depends on your definition of "solid and reliable". As far as solid goes, Mauer hit .277 last year, is hitting .274 this year with OPS of .732 and .699 respectively, and with 4 and 0 HR, respectively. These numbers are about on par with Nick Punto's best seasons with the Twins. Punto provided great defense, position flexibility and speed on the bases. Mauer is generously, average at first base and no threat to steal a base. We also batted Punto 8th or 9th, and not 3rd. Mauer needs to get on one of his patented 2 month terrors where he hits everything on a line, if he has that left in him. If he's a mid .270's type hitter with no power at a corner position, he's a liability, and that's without factoring in his contract (which means we will have to stay with Joe no matter the production while someone like Sano, Vargas, Pinto, or Plouffe will get traded).