Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

Twins Daily

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Article: Kurt Suzuki Signs Extension With Twins

Featured Replies

What other impact catchers are available?

  • Replies 106
  • Views 9.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • nicksaviking
    nicksaviking

    Consciously, I never liked extending him because it's not a smart move to sign guys at their peak, especially when they seem to have value to other teams that could be exploited.  However $6 mil per i

  • I'm not sure what there isn't to like about this. Sure, he isn't an All-Star catcher.... wait.... So he is having a career year in his mid 30's... wait... he is only 30. Pinto is an alright prospect,

  • $6M a year is fair. I love the part about the 2017 option only being based on PAs.   However, something inside me tells me this move is not OK. We should be rebuilding, but we're not. We're continuing

Suzuki's contract is reasonable. He has been a major league average catcher this year ranking 16th in WAR.

 

The reasoning that he should or shouldn't be signed because no one else is available should never be used. Catchers are always available through trade.

 

There will be organizations that need a catcher his winter. They will find one. Catchers better than Suzuki will be moved this winter. Martin will sign with someone. Trades are allowed in the winter. The Twins haven't solved the catcher problem if Pinto is not a catcher. They should seek a prospect for prospect trade. The Padres, Red Sox and Mets have multiple young catchers. Meanwhile Suzuki is an adequate holder at the cost of a 5th starter.

 

Suzuki's signing is only a problem if it closes the door for the Twins on trying to find a longer term solution to this position.

What other impact catchers are available?

None, really.  That's why I am fine with extending Suzuki, in a vacuum.

 

But this is a team that has neglected to even patch, much less adequately address, a variety of positions the past few years, not to mention ignoring potential impact players available outside the draft.  So I wonder, what's the point of patching this one spot now?  Especially with a semi-viable option sitting at AAA?  It feels like we're still just hoping for prospect luck and a 2017 target contending date anyway, with or without Suzuki, I think.

None, really.  That's why I am fine with extending Suzuki, in a vacuum.

 

But this is a team that has neglected to even patch, much less adequately address, a variety of positions the past few years, not to mention ignoring potential impact players available outside the draft.  So I wonder, what's the point of patching this one spot now?  Especially with a semi-viable option sitting at AAA?  It feels like we're still just hoping for prospect luck and a 2017 target contending date anyway, with or without Suzuki, I think.

 

We have young pitchers that are going to be filtering in a the next couple years. A guy like Suzuki who is very smart and has very good game plans on how to get batters out is a huge benefit. It helps teach the pitchers on how to get batters out.

Except, there is no evidence that Suzuki does that. Not in MN, not in he previous jobs (where you can better compare pitcher outcomes with different catchers). There just is zero actual evidence in outcomes produced he does that well. And, there is evidence he doesn't do it well (see other teams' results with and without him). All the positives are anecdotes, right?

I don't see how a Ryan could have managed this better.

 

He waited as long as possible to get a return in trade. Absent a reasonable return, he signed Suzuki to a deal that slots between their 2014 commitments to Correia and Willingham.

People who are against the signing would probably point out that we have no clue if there was a reasonable return offered.  For all we know Ryan was offered Dylan Bundy but still said no and opted for an extension.

 

Or he may have been offered a box of gas station doughnuts.  We will never know if this was a good move barring full disclosure from the front office, and we know that will not happen.

Edited by nicksaviking

People who are against the signing would probably point out that we have no clue if there was a reasonable return offered.  For all we know Ryan was offered Dylan Bundy but still said no and opted for an extension.

 

Or he may have been offered a box of gas station doughnuts.  We will never know if this was a good move barring full disclosure from the front office, and we know that will not happen.

 

 

We'll never know what they might have gotten because the TWINS will never know what they might have gotten if they had been serious about moving him.

 

It's pretty clear from this Rob Antony quote that they weren't trying very hard to trade him:

 

"We had some calls about him. There was some interest,” Antony said. “We were telling people we might get something done. We were trying to get something done. That was the No. 1 priority when it came to Suzuki was we wanted to keep him rather than trade him."

 

http://blogs.twincities.com/twins/2014/07/31/twinsights-twins-sign-kurt-suzuki-to-two-year-contract-extension/

Edited by JB_Iowa

"The Twins weren't trying to trade" doesn't equal "shouldn't have traded." For all we know, someone did make a firm offer, or at least expressed serious interest. Why else would the extension coincide with the trade deadline?

Except, there is no evidence that Suzuki does that. Not in MN, not in he previous jobs (where you can better compare pitcher outcomes with different catchers). There just is zero actual evidence in outcomes produced he does that well. And, there is evidence he doesn't do it well (see other teams' results with and without him). All the positives are anecdotes, right?

 

Mike, is it possible that everything is baseball isn't quantifiable?

 

What about a pitcher's confidence in a particular pitch? What is our stat for that? Or a catcher's ability to settle down a pitcher that is rattled?

 

I appreciate your point of view, but I believe it ignores a lot of the elements that are present in human endeavors.

Edited by Monkeypaws

. People talk about Mitch Garver. Garver is 23 and hits like Pinto but is still at A, so maybe they don't think much of Garver catching skills either?

 

If Garver were any higher than A, he would have been moved faster that pretty much everyone but Mauer in this organization :)   He was just drafted last season.   To tell you the truth (and this comes from someone who has Garver as his top catching prospect in the organization and a pretty plush 17th overall) he was under the radar last season because of a poor transition to the wooden bat and lack of stamina after a full college season.   He did put a long of work this off-season and this really showed in Spring Training as far as I am concerned and caught my eye there.  Thankfully, it continued through the season.  He should probably finish at Fort Myers, but the longer the Twins are holding Pinto down, the more congested the Catching jobs are.

 

Not bad for a second year pro, really; because this is what he just is. 

Edited by Thrylos

Mike, is it possible that everything is baseball isn't quantifiable?

 

What about a pitcher's confidence in a particular pitch? What is our stat for that? Or a catcher's ability to settle down a pitcher that is rattled?

 

I appreciate your point of view, but I believe it ignores a lot of the elements that are present in human endeavors.

Shouldn't those things manifest themselves in better results on the field, and thus better stats?

Shouldn't those things manifest themselves in better results on the field, and thus better stats?

How do we know they aren't?

How do we know they aren't?

 

I think that the bottom line (2014 record) says that they aren't ;)

How do we know they aren't?

Well, if the stats suggest that pitchers don't perform better with Suzuki...

If Garver were any higher than A, he would have been moved faster that pretty much everyone but Mauer in this organization :)   He was just drafted last season.   To tell you the truth (and this comes from someone who has Garver as his top catching prospect in the organization and a pretty plush 17th overall) he was under the radar last season because of a poor transition to the wooden bat and lack of stamina after a full college season.   He did put a long of work this off-season and this really showed in Spring Training as far as I am concerned and caught my eye there.  Thankfully, it continued through the season.  He should probably finish at Fort Myers, but the longer the Twins are holding Pinto down, the more congested the Catching jobs are.

 

Not bad for a second year pro, really; because this is what he just is.

 

Glad to hear it - thanks

It's pretty hard to argue that he hasn't. He has posted a total of 1.8 WAR for roughly $9m at this point.

 

Kevin Correia and his contract isn't a problem. The problem is all the guys they didn't sign to pitch in front of Kevin Correia.

 

His WAR ranking is 13th for catchers and it's his career year, so it's likely to drop.  Kind of hard to believe we had to pay him the 6th highest contract for catcher in 2015.  Just because they have money to spend, doesn't require them to waste money. 

The money is not an issue. They are swimming in money.

Create an account or sign in to comment

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.