Jump to content
Twins Daily
  • Create Account
  • entries
    891
  • comments
    3,675
  • views
    1,591,227

Setting The 2017 Twins Lineup


Ted Schwerzler

2,211 views

 Share

Twins Video

Last winter, I tried my hand at projecting the upcoming lineup right around this same timeframe. With Paul Molitor back as manager of the Minnesota Twins for 2017, much of the same can be expected lineup wise, but he'll need to make some adjustments if he's going to overcome his own deficiencies from a season ago. There's no doubt that Derek Falvey and Thad Levine want to turn this thing around, but it'll be a process.

 

Right now, we know that the Twins have lost a couple of pieces from 2016, and there could be a few more changes along the way. I wouldn't expect them to make many waves in terms of offensive additions, so now seems as good of a time as any to set the lineup. With that out of the way, let's get into it.

 

1. Joe Mauer 1B

 

The unfortunate reality with Mauer is that his defense is Gold Glove caliber but the bat and offensive production is just a shell of what it once was. Recently I touched on the blueprint to get the best out of Mauer. Play him sparingly, split time with Park and Kennys Vargas, and even look at platooning him to remove some at bats against lefties. If Molitor can wrap his head around Mauer being what he is, rather than what he wants him to be, the Twins will be better for it. He's not going to bat .300, but hitting .280 using a similarly structured plan seems like a good bet. If you're not going to bat him leadoff, hitting him sixth or seventh makes a lot of sense.

 

2. Brian Dozier 2B

 

There's really no reason to be disappointed about being able to keep your best player. In not dealing Dozier, the Twins did just that this offseason. He's not going to hit 40 homers again in 2017, but settling in somewhere between his 2015 and 2016 season is a realistic ask. He should be a 3.0+ fWAR player, and will once again drive the Twins. He can allow Mauer's on base skills to add to his RBI total as well.

 

3. Max Kepler RF

 

At points during the 2016 campaign, it appeared that Max Kepler might run away with the Rookie of the Year award. In 31 games from the middle of July through the middle of August, Kepler posted a .912 OPS and cracked seven homers. His smooth swing and quick trigger through the zone should continue to allow him the ability to succeed at the plate. There may be less highs and lows for Kepler in 2017, but a year of consistency would be more than welcomed. He's got a realistic shot at 20 longballs this year and can be among the Twins best hitters.

 

4. Miguel Sano 3B

 

With the Twins non-tendering Trevor Plouffe, it's become time that Sano slots in as the full time third basemen. Realistically, he isn't a great fit there as the accuracy issues with his arm remain a real concern. Until things sort themselves out though, a move to full time DH or first base just doesn't appear in the cards. After a strong rookie year, Sano took steps backwards in 2016. The hope should be that his OPS rests somewhere in the mid .800 range and he can push towards 30 homers. Having played just 116 games a season ago, remaining in shape and healthy will be contributing factors towards Minnesota getting the most out of their young slugger.

 

5. Byungho Park DH

 

Brought over from the KBO as one of the best players that league has ever seen, Park's rookie year in the big leagues didn't go well. The Twins got just 62 games from Park and he was sent to Triple-A for the remainder of the year. Posting just 21 walks with 80 strikeouts, the swing and miss issues were definitely there for the Korean slugger. I believe that the wrist injury that eventually required surgery was a bigger deal than he let on, and if healthy, a big bounce back in 2017 is very plausible. Wipe the slate clean and give me at least 20 bombs in 130 games for the Twins from Park in the year ahead.

 

6. Byron Buxton CF

 

A year ago I found myself making excuses to try and get by Buxton's disappointing debut season. While he's still young, his 92 games in 2016 weren't great either. What Buxton did do though was bolster expectations for 2017 with a strong finish to the season. From August 5 through the end of the year, Buxton had a 30 game sample size in which he posted a .992 OPS while slugging an incredible .641. He's not going to hit nine home runs in a month all too often, but betting against baseball's former top prospect isn't something I want to do. Let him start in the middle, with a move to the top of the lineup being a quick possibility.

 

7. Jason Castro C

 

Signed to a three year deal this offseason by the Twins, Castro is being brought in first and foremost for his defensive acumen. Despite posting just a .684 OPS with the Astros last season, it was his best mark since his .835 OPS All Star season in 2013. If he can trend towards a .700 OPS for Minnesota as a defense first backstop, Molitor will have to be happy. Castro has totaled double-digit homers each year since 2012, and getting some pop from the catching position is something the Twins will welcome. His floor shouldn't be too low, and Castro's ceiling is probably the best the Twins have seen at catcher since Joe Mauer.

 

8. Eddie Rosario LF

 

If there was someone that did themselves no favors in 2016 it was Rosario. Not only did he take steps backwards defensively, but his approach at the plate looked awful far too often. A free swinger that chases out of the zone, Rosario shaved nearly 30 points off of his OPS and again posted an ugly K/BB (91/12) ratio. He needs to be more patient at the dish and come up with a better plan. In the field, Minnesota needs the guy that was worth 10 DRS in 2015, not the one that was worth zero last season. This spot also gets interesting if the Twins do in fact pull off a Brian Dozier trade. If Yasiel Puig is a part of the return, Rosario could find himself as the odd man out.

 

9. Jorge Polanco SS

 

With Brian Dozier remaining a member of the Twins for the 2017 big league season, Polanco is destined to stay at shortstop. It's not an ideal spot for him defensively, but the Twins frankly don't have another option. His bat should help to alleviate some of the defensive gaffes, and expecting him to tote the lumber is a good bet.

For more from Off The Baggy, click here. Follow @tlschwerz

 Share

8 Comments


Recommended Comments

 

Thanks for taking the shot. Unfortunately, it just shows how much work is left to be done. Buxton is nowhere near ready to lead off, nor can Kepler hit third at this point. In fact, hitting both of them that far up might retard their development because of the additional pressure. As I have mentioned on other threads, I think the thing to do is to sign Ben Revere, putting him in left field with Rosario at the fourth outfielder or in a dogfight with Buxton and Kepler for the other two starting spots, and lead Revere off since before his injury field 2016 season he was a fairly consistent .325 to .350 OPB guy. you could also move Sano to the third spot. With that, the lineup would look like this:

 

Revere  LF

Polanco 2B

Sano     3B

Vargas/Park  DH

Kepler   RF

Mauer   1B

Castro   C

Escobar SS

Buxton   CF

 

You would then have Rosario bat in the spot of the guys he's replacing. He might have to lead off a few games,, but assumedly Revere would be the centerfielder a few games with Buxton sitting and Rosario playing left.

I'll disagree with Kepler's capability, I think he's flashed plenty to be relied upon. Buxton leading off is out of necessity, and belief that the end of the year meant things clicked.

 

I am with you in that I'm in favor of the Twins bringing in Revere. Definitely would be contingent upon what the return is in any potential Dozier trade though. If Puig comes here, Revere doesn't fit.

Link to comment

With any kind of rebound and playing to his potential, I'd have Risario in the 7 spot and Castro plus his platoon mate at 8. Otherwise, we are in agreement.

 

I do sometimes wonder though about Polanci leading off and Buxton hitting second.

 

Winder what the lineup would be like if Mayer suffers another injury and Park and Vargas were both in the lineup?

Link to comment

I more or less agree with the lineup. At this time, only one of two things is going to happen, a lineup similar to this is either going to be pretty decent once we hit 2018, or this team will continue to be a disaster far longer than I care to think about. I opt for the former. But it's going to take time. Kepler isn't a MLB 3 hitter now, but could be. Mauer certainly isn't anymore, and won't be again. I am not as onboard with Park as you are. 20 HR's is ok, but not if he doesn't cut down the K's. His SO history is long and well documented, and it happened in a league with AA pitching. Your statement about Molitor was spot on, if he doesn't quit thinking its 2009 as far as Mauer is concerned, then the whole order is bleeped up. It's going to be interesting to see if he can start managing this team like a young team with a future, instead of a team that is supposed to win big right now. He didn't do that last year, and set the orginisation back another year in the process.

Link to comment

Agreed that experience vs talent determines how truly effective this lineup will be. But...and I hate to say this but it's mostly true...with the exception of Mauer the pieces are there and in the mostly right places.

 

Mauer dies provide some value if used properly, though I think we're all crossing our fingers and hoping for more and more Park and Vargas.

 

I really like the potential of this lineup overall. I just hope potential reaches production levels sooner rather than later.

Link to comment

I think that Buxton is actually better batting third.  He showed power in September when they stopped trying to have him bunt every other at bat.  Move Polanco and Kepler to 1 and 2.  The lower half of the lineup is not inspiring. 

Link to comment
Guest
Add a comment...

×   Pasted as rich text.   Paste as plain text instead

  Only 75 emoji are allowed.

×   Your link has been automatically embedded.   Display as a link instead

×   Your previous content has been restored.   Clear editor

×   You cannot paste images directly. Upload or insert images from URL.

Loading...
×
×
  • Create New...